Forum VI (based on Forum III) any interest?

Started by mike in lytle, May 07, 2021, 11:22:39 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 5 Guests are viewing this topic.

Quote from: mike in lytle on May 12, 2021, 11:45:43 AM
The last forum guitar was the failed VI, a 00v-03 MT guitar that was discussed back in 2012 and 2013.
The name VI has already been used, and though the effort fell short, the threads are all here, the discussions recorded, the specs known, the potential dealer identified.
We cannot erase that history. The Forum VI was an idea that failed to make it to production. That doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
In addition, the Forum VI is documented on the wiki site. You can't make that go away.
Mike
Well that's one interpretation - however the generally accepted interpretation would name to  a guitar actually built - not a thread started looking for interest. There have been more than one "failed" attempts at generating Forum Guitars between some of the ones actually built and also subsequent (like this one) to Forum V. As an example I believe there were two or three between IV and V before the V was actually brought to fruition.

Wiki is wrong - it should go away.
Larrivee Electrics - My Dream then and Now!!!!!<br /><br />Forum IV     00-03MT       #4      (Treasured)

Wait, what??  :?
I didn't know about the 6 never coming into existence. Admittedly, math was never my best subject. But, I'm certain 6 comes after 5. How is this being called 7 if there is no Forum 6? That would look really awkward to an outside observer. Were we talking about a concept like literature, art, etc, there's room for that. But, this is strictly a product. Apologies again for sticking my nose in this, it's the management side of me coming out, but if there is no actual Forum 6 in existence, this would naturally be #6.

Quote from: B0WIE on May 12, 2021, 12:49:33 PM
Wait, what??  :?
I didn't know about the 6 never coming into existence. Admittedly, math was never my best subject. But, I'm certain 6 comes after 5. How is this being called 7 if there is no Forum 6? That would look really awkward to an outside observer. Were we talking about a concept like literature, art, etc, there's room for that. But, this is strictly a product. Apologies again for sticking my nose in this, it's the management side of me coming out, but if there is no actual Forum 6 in existence, this would naturally be #6.
Quote from: JOYCEfromNS on May 12, 2021, 11:55:58 AM
Well that's one interpretation - however the generally accepted interpretation would name to  a guitar actually built - not a thread started looking for interest. There have been more than one "failed" attempts at generating Forum Guitars between some of the ones actually built and also subsequent (like this one) to Forum V. As an example I believe there were two or three between IV and V before the V was actually brought to fruition.

Wiki is wrong - it should go away.
I'm good with it. You supported your position. I am happy with VI.
And you guys know more about past efforts than I do.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Good to see a few more folks expressing interest in a Maple-bodied LS!

Also - I'm open to short scale - I can go either way on the scale length.

:thumb
1999 D-02 Left-handed
2002 L-05 Left-handed
Larrivee owner since 1992

I'm cool with an LS BODY without a cutaway and 12 fret

I prefer a slot head which will scare some people off but I could live with a solid headstock. Since I have a maple parlor, I would prefer an All mahogany or walnut back/sides under spruce.  Leave the clear pickguard off of mine. I'll take black or tortoise guard and binding.

It would also be cool to inlay the Roman numeral VII at the 12th fret. Again, this may scare some off but not me and it would denote this guitar in a special way and be worth paying for.

I am retiring in March 2022 and I'll weigh this against other options instead of a gold watch.


Quote from: teh on May 12, 2021, 09:52:09 PM
I'm cool with an LS BODY without a cutaway and 12 fret

I prefer a slot head which will scare some people off but I could live with a solid headstock. Since I have a maple parlor, I would prefer an All mahogany or walnut back/sides under spruce.  Leave the clear pickguard off of mine. I'll take black or tortoise guard and binding.

It would also be cool to inlay the Roman numeral VII at the 12th fret. Again, this may scare some off but not me and it would denote this guitar in a special way and be worth paying for.

I am retiring in March 2022 and I'll weigh this against other options instead of a gold watch.
Got it. And wrote in the spreadsheet.
You may have other opportunities to add/change.
Gold watch? I guess your primary interest may not be affordability (just kidding). Maybe you can get both.
One of my oldest friends got himself a Martin D-41 for his retirement gift to himself.
I wish you well between now and then!
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Quote from: Mikeymac on May 12, 2021, 06:19:41 PM
Good to see a few more folks expressing interest in a Maple-bodied LS!

I asked John about the maple, cause it is listed "at market price" in the custom pricing sheet and that caused me concern.
Here is the reply and I take the liberty of quoting John directly.....
"There is a maple shortage now believe it or not. COVID shutdowns at mill combined with the fact cutting maple onto backs & sides for guitars is not as profitable as making other things. I would not advise maple to be the VI option."

Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Quote from: mike in lytle on May 13, 2021, 01:41:15 PM
I asked John about the maple, cause it is listed "at market price" in the custom pricing sheet and that caused me concern.
Here is the reply and I take the liberty of quoting John directly.....
"There is a maple shortage now believe it or not. COVID shutdowns at mill combined with the fact cutting maple onto backs & sides for guitars is not as profitable as making other things. I would not advise maple to be the VI option."

Mike

Oh, ........ does that mean my L body Sitka/Flamed Maple Custom shop is worth MORE ????  :roll :guitar
I'd like to get involved in this venture providing I could afford it, Walnut back would be my choice, already have Rosewood, Mahogany & Maple.
Also, thought it interesting about using a roman numeral VII ( or whatever this issue would be) had thought the same myself.
We need to get together sometime Mike.

After I received the reply from John about maple (not advised), I went back to my thoughts about the tonewoods and other options.
I have the custom pricing list and Larrivee has MSRP pricing on the website, and dealer MAP pricing is easy to get, so it really isn't tough to ballpark a guitar price, before Larrivee and a potential dealer do their magic.
My gut originally told we could possibly get this Forum guitar done for about the same as a dealer price on a plain-jane OM-03 or L-03 (priced the same) whether in mahogany or rosewood (or walnut). I still feel that way. The cutaway would be an extra expense.
Inlays have been mentioned a couple times, what we might could do is get an inlayed bridge. The Deluxe (the top one in the pic) has the same pattern that is used on the Larrivee Forum index page, and is the standard 10 series bridge. It just screams "Forum guitar", and along with the 3-dot 12th fret marker, might be a good option to differentiate the Forum III vs VI.

Now, I have not played a walnut Larrivee, but maybe someone here can describe the sound of walnut vs rosewood.
That's it for now.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Quote from: Rockysdad on May 13, 2021, 02:01:53 PM
Oh, ........ does that mean my L body Sitka/Flamed Maple Custom shop is worth MORE ????  :roll :guitar
I'd like to get involved in this venture providing I could afford it, Walnut back would be my choice, already have Rosewood, Mahogany & Maple.
Also, thought it interesting about using a roman numeral VII ( or whatever this issue would be) had thought the same myself.
We need to get together sometime Mike.
Herman,
Your custom may well be worth a nice price as scarcity drives prices and maple is very popular.
Pretty sure you don't want to test the waters on that tho!
I have added your info to the sheet, spruce/walnut, just determining interest and keeping the conversation going.
Yes, we are due for a visit. It will happen.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

I'd be interested, spruce/rosewood.

Sent from my SM-G986U using Tapatalk
Remember when the music came from wooden boxes strung with silver wires...

OM-40 SB
Forum VI - LS-03 Moonwood/Walnut
Seagull S6

Quote from: Hooked on May 13, 2021, 08:46:03 PM
I'd be interested, spruce/rosewood.
Hey Lou,
Nice OM-40. Still jealous over the Larrivee stein. Unobtainium.
I hope things are going well with you.
Thanks for your interest in the hopefully new Forum guitar, and I have added your info.
Gonna see where it goes. Hopefully, all the way!
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Quote from: mike in lytle on May 13, 2021, 02:29:53 PM
Now, I have not played a walnut Larrivee, but maybe someone here can describe the sound of walnut vs rosewood.

Walnut can vary as there are several types with varying densities and different parts of the tree can be used for a variety of visual effects. But, let's say we're talking about the straight-grained Peruvian Walnut Larrivee uses compared to the East Indian Rosewood, which is really the only affordable rosewood right now.
EIR tends to be on the darker side, tonally. It produces a lot of harmonic overtones in the upper-bass and low-midrange, so it creates what most hear as a "warm" tone. As you add warmth, there can be a perceived loss of clarity for some users as the high frequencies take a back seat. This is magnified with bigger instruments. Some describe the dense midrange overtones as sounding 'metallic' because they are essentially reproducing the midrange frequencies in different orders, making them more dense and complex. Generally speaking, it's considered to be a warm and complex sound. The L is a mid-sized guitar but LS, being more compact, isn't one that's particularly susceptible to sounding "muddy" from rosewood. So, I consider it a good choice when it comes to versatility here.

Walnut is often described as a blend of rosewood and mahogany, but I think that's a cheap way of explaining it's tone. Walnut is somewhat 'dry' in the midrange, meaning it doesn't stack overtones in that region like rosewood does. There's an immediacy to walnut that is very satisfying to the player. A 'touch response' that feels great to both fingers and pick. I think this would play well with LS design. Notes are very well-defined and tight, without lacking body. Maple fans would likely appreciate this quality of walnut. Walnut is not devoid of overtones though. The high frequencies have a distinct 'sparkle' that's reminiscent of Koa, but higher in frequency, more like Brazilian rosewood's high frequency qualities. The tight mids and bass with a high frequency sparkle gives an energetic feel. This is why walnut is probably my favorite tonewood, along side Brazilian rosewood.

I found it interesting that there were a few votes for maple. I like it and think it can be an excellent back wood. Maple is probably the most 'dry' of the common tone woods. It doesn't really have much of a sound in and of itself as it's not adding significant overtones. It's very good for dampening overtones and allowing the fundamentals to speak more clearly. Nice in larger instruments, or for getting a more fundamental, 'bluesy'/traditional sound out of smaller ones. The issues with Maple is that they are slower to sell, and everyone wants the curly maple, which is much more expensive. For Larrivee to come up with a few dozen curly maple backs that are equal in quality would probably be either difficult, or expensive, or both.

I'd be remiss to discuss back woods without mentioning tops, as they are far more impactful than the back. Sitka balances out EIR well as Sitka is dry in the mids, responsive, and has a high frequency peak that ensures you always get clarity. This is why it's such a popular combo, though it might seem a bit boring for a special build since this wood pairing is so prevalent. European (Alpine, Moon, etc) spruce is heavier in overtones. You can sometimes end up with a darker/warmer sounding instrument with EIR and Euro spruce, depending on the samples and the build. Walnut works extremely well with the more colorful sounding spruces as it's essentially projecting back what you feed it, with a little enhancement in the highs. Walnut and Sitka have some qualities in common and the walnut/sitka L-body I had featured a distinct crispness and high frequency clarity to it. Walnut and Red/Adirondack spruce together have an amazing energy and clarity, with just the right amount of color.  

In choosing woods, I'd decide what purpose this instrument has and go from there. With an LS 12-fret, you're working with a mid-sized guitar (neutral) that is a 12-fret (warm) but compact in depth (dry) so there are several factors coming into play there. In terms of direction, you can play to the LS form and go with more dry sounding woods. Or, play to the 12 fret aspect and go with warmer sounding woods that offer more overtones. Either way, you have balances in place (the 12 fret design and the LS depth) that should help keep it a reasonably versatile instrument. Going short-scale is somewhat dicey as the results are less predictable and there's not much you can do to compensate (strings, set-up, etc) for someone who doesn't like a short-scale on a mid-sized guitar. It's never going to have the tight, responsive feel of a standard scale. Doesn't mean it won't be nice, but for a group buy it seems a little risky.

We have not done a Walnut Forum Guitar before.
We have not done a cedar top, or Engelmann top before either.

Jean hates cedar though, which is a shame, because a Cedar/Walnut  LS would be right up my alley.

Hmmn....  we haven't done a 12-string either, though I suspect interest would be low.


My biggest issue with my Forum-III was the lack of overtones, for which I mostly blame the European Spruce top.


Edit to add:  I despise the Martin style pickguards, and would want a clear PG or no PG.  Put the pepperoni monstrosity in the case like the Forum-III would please most folks.

I've been reluctant to pipe up because I'm in reverse GAS mode right now. Had this idea come up 4-5 years ago I'd have been up for it, but in the last few years I've tried out several LS and different woods OO's and have decided to settle in on just two of the seven acoustics (yikes!) I have now.

As a form of apology I offer this chart from Breedlove on body woods. It may or may not be accurate but it's from Breedlove so . . .

One of the guitars I binged is a Spruce/Rosewood OO-40 and I am really enjoying it's lush sound. It's a pretty far distance from Maple and Walnut so I'd be out on those, and I'd rule out Koa and Lacewood as well. I've unsuccessfully tried out the LS 12 fret body size as they sound less focused to my poor ears and if it comes down to a Spruce/Rosewood Forum VII in an OO, well, I already have one . . . Maybe an Italian Spruce/Ebony OO would be interesting? As a slothead that just might make me slap down the amex.

Sorry to be a bummer, but best of luck to you guys!

PS Kudos' to Bowie for that recent amazing post above- I actually understood and agreed with his tone descriptions which is a tremendously hard thing to communicate. :+1:

Larrivee OO-05 • Larrivee OOV-03 SS • Larrivee OO-44  • Taylor 322ce • Strat • Soundcloud https://soundcloud.com/jpmist

Quote from: jpmist on May 14, 2021, 08:04:05 PM
I've been reluctant to pipe up because I'm in reverse GAS mode right now. Had this idea come up 4-5 years ago I'd have been up for it, but in the last few years I've tried out several LS and different woods OO's and have decided to settle in on just two of the seven acoustics (yikes!) I have now.

As a form of apology I offer this chart from Breedlove on body woods. It may or may not be accurate but it's from Breedlove so . . .

One of the guitars I binged is a Spruce/Rosewood OO-40 and I am really enjoying it's lush sound. It's a pretty far distance from Maple and Walnut so I'd be out on those, and I'd rule out Koa and Lacewood as well. I've unsuccessfully tried out the LS 12 fret body size as they sound less focused to my poor ears and if it comes down to a Spruce/Rosewood Forum VII in an OO, well, I already have one . . . Maybe an Italian Spruce/Ebony OO would be interesting? As a slothead that just might make me slap down the amex.
Sorry to be a bummer, but best of luck to you guys!
PS Kudos' to Bowie for that recent amazing post above- I actually understood and agreed with his tone descriptions which is a tremendously hard thing to communicate.
John,
Thanks for the chart. It adds to what I have been looking up today.
Agree, Bowie's post was great. Am not going to respond to it just now. Good stuff tho.
I guess I could ask you to confirm, but looks pretty clear you have no interest in the current effort.
Mike
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

This has had my interest and every time I read a new post or three I slip closer to the edge. Although I'd be more inclined towards a small bodied 000-60, as my Reverb searches would tell, I'd at least be interested in considering a forum VI. 12 fret, no scale preference at this point, slotted head stock perhaps, spruce on EIR. Maybe 50/50 at this point in all fairness.
Larrivee 000-03 Forum VII
Larrivee LS-03WL Forum VI Limited
Larrivee OM-40M
Larrivee O-01W
Taylor AD12E
Martin 000-16 (gone for now)
Epiphone Olympic Solid Body Electric (1967)
Larrivee F-33 Mandolin (8/1/2008)
Larrivee A-33 (8/21/2009)
Kawalek Octave Mandolin
Eastman MOD 305 Octave Mandolin

Quote from: Riverbend on May 15, 2021, 07:50:55 AM
This has had my interest and every time I read a new post or three I slip closer to the edge. Although I'd be more inclined towards a small bodied 000-60, as my Reverb searches would tell, I'd at least be interested in considering a forum VI. 12 fret, no scale preference at this point, slotted head stock perhaps, spruce on EIR. Maybe 50/50 at this point in all fairness.
I have added your info.
Probably a good time to mention that my original thought was another run of the Forum III, which would be updated with the 16 inch fretboard radius, the easier truss rod access, and a modified bridge plate to facilitate the installation of the Pure Mini pickup. I'm still focused on that concept, although maybe I incautiously mentioned that if we were to have two tonewoods for the body of the guitar, maybe we could look at something besides EIR. But that was personal opinion is all.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Hi, all.

I updated the wiki page to clearly indicate there was a discussion of a Forum VI guitar but no Forum VI series was built.

Cheers.

ST

Back when the Forum III was delivered the bridge plate was talked about, based on two things.
1. Why was it so large?
2. The bridge plate did not extend completely under the saddle, so installation of the K&K Pure Mini could not be properly accomplished.

See the pics, supplied by Roger (Mr_LV19E). These were posted at one time, but due to picture hosting issues beyond our control, nearly all the pics from the Forum III discussions are gone.

The solution to the Pure Mini installation is the addition of a separate extension. Roger did this, others did too. I think the solution was provided by Jim Holler of Trinity Guitars.
I think the bridge plate for the Forum VI should be reconfigured to add this extension.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Powered by EzPortal