What does the 00 and LS bracing look like?

Started by gitnoob, June 13, 2010, 01:06:40 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Great thread. Roger Simonoff book on tap tuning is an excellent source for those interested in techno dynamic's of acoustic stringed instruments .

    Thanks Jeremy, as usual all this information is more than my mind can hold. But the diagrams really help.

      I was wondering what you think the luthiers understood about all the science behind the bracing. Martin came up with this basic X bracing pattern only a short time ago in relation to how long man has been making fine stringed instruments.
      I guess my simple question is "Did Martin know these things when he designed the X pattern?" Or where they all just working by experience and the "master-apprentice"passing on of design and build techniques?

       Until the modern age with computers and the internet not much was shared among luthiers. Yet they managed to build the best instruments we have ever seen, or I should say "heard". Of course Stradivari is implied here as well. His guitars were not so great, but in the early 1700's is when he produced the violins.

       I know this deviated a bit from bracing alone but the question is relevant I believe.

   Jeremy, I think what was explained to me was more reflective on how the braces are scalloped. The bracing pattern is similar to the one shown in your colored diagram, after I looked in the guitar with a mirror. The "T" bracing is a type used on these guitars, which was explained further when I dug into the internet & found a description of this, developed by Crafter. The bracing pattern is different than the normal scalloped, "A", or square type.
   Here is what I found & sorry if it deviates from the your explanation a little.
   "For the past 100 years, the most commonly used types of braces were square or A-shaped. Both of these brace types are sufficiently rigid to retain the shape of the top, but then to top loses resonance due this stiffness. Another alternative is the use of "scalloped bracing", which does allow greater sound top resonance. But, because the braces are less rigid, the string tension sometimes allows the top to bow upwards. This can raise the action & cause playing difficulties.
    The T-brace is similar to the shape of an A-brace, except with narrower sides pared down to a square bottom, looking like an inverted capital "T". This reduces the overall weight of the guitar, as wood is removed from BOTH sides of the brace. The lighter T-brace makes the sound louder & better balanced, while still allowing rigidity to maintain the shape of the top. The T-brace is installed @ a right angle to the top for strength, but offers more resonance than the traditional A-brace."
   
   Makes sense, esp. in the weight to rigidity sense. Lighter top, but still rigid & responsive.
   Also, I can see from your diagram how the bridge acts as another axis. On a 12 fret guitar, how does the new placement (lower) of the bridge explain, in terms of your diagram, why it seems to be more responsive & louder? Is what I've found, & many, to be the norm for guitars of this type? Can you explain this further?
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true

Quote from: dependan on July 27, 2010, 11:07:52 AM
    Thanks Jeremy, as usual all this information is more than my mind can hold. But the diagrams really help.

      I was wondering what you think the luthiers understood about all the science behind the bracing. Martin came up with this basic X bracing pattern only a short time ago in relation to how long man has been making fine stringed instruments.
      I guess my simple question is "Did Martin know these things when he designed the X pattern?" Or where they all just working by experience and the "master-apprentice"passing on of design and build techniques?

It's hard to say what they did and didn't know. I'd guess the X brace was designed not arbitrarily but from recognizing an issue with ladder braced guitar tops rolling forward. Other aspects like scalloping I'm not sure. I wouldn't be surprised if they knew things like how the guitar acts as an air pump and how certain changes to the design would effect that. They did some really smart things back then.


Quote from: BluesMan1 on July 27, 2010, 02:58:45 PM
     "For the past 100 years, the most commonly used types of braces were square or A-shaped. Both of these brace types are sufficiently rigid to retain the shape of the top, but then to top loses resonance due this stiffness. Another alternative is the use of "scalloped bracing", which does allow greater sound top resonance. But, because the braces are less rigid, the string tension sometimes allows the top to bow upwards. This can raise the action & cause playing difficulties.
    The T-brace is similar to the shape of an A-brace, except with narrower sides pared down to a square bottom, looking like an inverted capital "T". This reduces the overall weight of the guitar, as wood is removed from BOTH sides of the brace. The lighter T-brace makes the sound louder & better balanced, while still allowing rigidity to maintain the shape of the top. The T-brace is installed @ a right angle to the top for strength, but offers more resonance than the traditional A-brace."
   
   Makes sense, esp. in the weight to rigidity sense. Lighter top, but still rigid & responsive.
   Also, I can see from your diagram how the bridge acts as another axis. On a 12 fret guitar, how does the new placement (lower) of the bridge explain, in terms of your diagram, why it seems to be more responsive & louder? Is what I've found, & many, to be the norm for guitars of this type? Can you explain this further?

Well I'm pretty sure the A shape profile still has a slightly higher stiffness to weight ratio than the T shape. The tops with A shaped braces don't really inherently lose resonance due to stiffness because one can always just make the brace shorter. Also, the A profiled brace once glued to the top forms a T anyway. However my guess is that there isn't a great deal of difference between the two in practicality.

As for 12 fret guitars: Most 12 fret guitars have bodies designed for 12 frets (unlike the Norman Blake Martin's and the Larrivee forum guitars) and the placement isn't significantly lower. The forum guitars if they're louder(I've never played one) is probably in part due to the bridge being more toward the center of the lower bout. This means it's further away from the sides (which act as a very stiff brace) and more movement can take place. Think about pressing down on a slat of wood with the two ends across a saw horse, the more toward the center you press the easier it is to deflect.

Quote from: jeremy3220 on July 27, 2010, 11:31:03 PM
I'd guess the X brace was designed not arbitrarily but from recognizing an issue with ladder braced guitar tops rolling forward.

On second thought... although the X brace does address the issues prone to ladder braced steel strings, Martin came out with the X brace about 80 years before steel strings. So I'm not sure what system it replaced. I still imagine it was done with a structural purpose in mind. One doesn't need computer generated models of chladni patterns to realize the structural effects of the X bracing.

   Thanks, Mr.J. It's like having a book of guitar knowledge & history when asking you something. Makes some of my questions seem too simple. I'll have to think of some hard ones before my head bursts from all of this!  :bowdown: :humour:
     JP (so there's no confusion, like there would be?)
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true

Quote from: BluesMan1 on July 28, 2010, 02:19:40 PM
   Thanks, Mr.J. It's like having a book of guitar knowledge & history when asking you something. Makes some of my questions seem too simple. I'll have to think of some hard ones before my head bursts from all of this!  :bowdown: :humour:
     JP (so there's no confusion, like there would be?)

Thanks. The questions are good, they make me think.

Powered by EzPortal