Is adding an SD50 one guitar too many?

Started by Jetstar7, March 26, 2007, 03:45:17 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Quote from: PortHueneme on March 26, 2007, 11:33:21 AM
I have an SD-60. While I can see Jeremy's point about too many Larrivee's. The SD is the best sounding guitar and is surprisingly versatile.
I also have an OM-3 koa, great sounding, well balanced, versatile, but totally different then the SD. My suggestion, play one of the SD's, see what you think, if you like it and can afford it, buy it.

After you have played it awhile then make the decision to sell one off. My opinion is you will find it a different sound the the "L" and will most likely decide to keep them both.
The parlor is of course a unique little guitar, that in my view only should count as a 1/2 guitar. I have an "O" and a "Baby T" they count as one when I tell someone how many guitars I have.
Someday I will list them all in my signature, but it would be longer than most of my posts.



So I really have only 1.5 guitars... Keep all three? I mean 2.5? Oh the indulgence!!!
L-03RE (2005)
P-09M  (24th December 2006)
SD-50  (7th May 2007)
RS-4    (15th October 2009)

Quote from: tuffythepug on March 26, 2007, 01:35:43 PM
Jetstar

Have you been following the discussion about the proposed new "Larrivee Forum Guitar" ?   If you can hold off for a while you might want to give this some consiideration.  It would be much easier to convince yourself and your girlfriend that a new guitar purchase was necessary if it was a "one-of-a-kind-chance-of-a-lifetime-not-to-be-missed-collector's-item-investment opportunity.
That's my plan, anyway.

tuffythepug

That's quite a plan tuffythepug. I've yet to check out the Forum Guitar threads. Maybe I shouldn't, just to keep me sane.
L-03RE (2005)
P-09M  (24th December 2006)
SD-50  (7th May 2007)
RS-4    (15th October 2009)

Quote from: jeremy3220 on March 26, 2007, 06:11:28 PM
Glad you like it, but the point is there are alot of nice options in that price range; J-45 , AJ, D-18, D-18V and Dermot recently got an amazingl looking 12fret D slot head Martin that I believe was well under 2 grand. Jetstar might think the SD's sound mediocre after he plays one.

There will never be a shortage of people who prefer their guitar over high end Martins.

jeremy,
Dermot is a place, a brand or a shop? And I believe all these model numbers are from Martin's lineup?
L-03RE (2005)
P-09M  (24th December 2006)
SD-50  (7th May 2007)
RS-4    (15th October 2009)

Quote from: Jetstar7 on March 26, 2007, 10:36:53 PM
jeremy,
Dermot is a place, a brand or a shop? And I believe all these model numbers are from Martin's lineup?

Dermot is a member of the forum. The J-45 and AJ are Gibsons, the rest were Martins.

Quote from: Novalis on March 26, 2007, 08:59:22 PM
These are good points to consider. If you wait to buy an SD, then you will have to wait even longer for it to open up. If you buy one soon, you won't have to wait as long.

I have an SD-50 and it gets more play than any of my other instruments. I've gotten spoiled by the 1 7/8" neck for fingerpicking and it's a real canon when I put a flatpick to it. Lot's of things have come and gone in my music room, but my SD-50 is a real keeper. Go ahead and get you one, you won't regret it.

So this thing about wood opening up, I've never really understood it. What exactly happens? The grains loosen, the stars align and the sound rings in syrupy harmony? The the spruce on my L-03RE has somewhat darken to a duller reddish tint of spruce yellow. Is that effects of opening up or just tan lines? It's never in direct sun if I recall correctly.
L-03RE (2005)
P-09M  (24th December 2006)
SD-50  (7th May 2007)
RS-4    (15th October 2009)

Back to the original poster.  He has a maple and a rosewood.  The SD-50 would put mahagony in his stable.  But does he need another guitar?  Just as much as any of us need another...

The SD-50 really IS a special Larrivee.  I knew that the first two of them I played which made "winning" one on ebay a no-risk buy.  Wow what a superb guitar!  But its only one of many superb guitars out there.

So my advice is to find one and play it before ordering it. 

But my real advice is to chill out with getting another and getting to know the two guitars you have now. 

Play it daily for best results.

Quote from: prof_stack on March 26, 2007, 11:29:44 PM
Back to the original poster.  He has a maple and a rosewood.  The SD-50 would put mahagony in his stable.  But does he need another guitar?  Just as much as any of us need another...

The SD-50 really IS a special Larrivee.  I knew that the first two of them I played which made "winning" one on ebay a no-risk buy.  Wow what a superb guitar!  But its only one of many superb guitars out there.

So my advice is to find one and play it before ordering it. 

But my real advice is to chill out with getting another and getting to know the two guitars you have now. 


Unfortunately, there is no SD50 in my country, at least as far as I know. So I'll never be able to try one, unless I find one during my travels. And yes, adding an SD-50 will make it a diverse and potent line-up.

But I really should take your real advice and learn to appreciate what I already have.
L-03RE (2005)
P-09M  (24th December 2006)
SD-50  (7th May 2007)
RS-4    (15th October 2009)

Quote from: prof_stack on March 26, 2007, 11:29:44 PM
But my real advice is to chill out with getting another and getting to know the two guitars you have now. 
That advice is WAY too practical.

I spent nearly four hours today (quite a bit of time for me) playing my SD-50 and would encourage anybody to get one. For some reason it's really hard to put down today, learning some Mississippi John Hurt songs. Even after five months, I'm still amazed at the sound each time I pick it up. One interesting thing: On my ladder-braced 000, fingerpicking sounds better with dampening, but on the SD-50, it sounds better without dampening the strings. Anybody else here find that the SD-50 sounds best without dampening the bass strings?
Guitars: Larrivee P-05; National Resphonic Style 2 Squareneck;      National Resophonic 12-fret "B"; Dupont MD-50;
Lazy River Weissenborn; Robert Sayers custom flat-top;
Cervantes Crossover; Todd Korup banjo-uke; McSpadden dulcimer;
PRS 22 semi-hollow ltd.; PRS DC3
Amplification: RA-400; Rivera Venus 3

I think you have to really be a bad player to make an SD sound bad.
Last night I was playing my SD-60, one of my playing buddies had his SD-50.
They were the two best sounding guitars in the room. There were a couple of old Martin D-28's (pre 69 Braziian).
The Martins seemed a tad louder, but the SD's were much more balanced.
One of the group has an older Gibson AJ, I have always loved his guitar, but after hearing the SD then AJ seemed very bright.
There was also a Taylor (7 something or other) in the room that could barely be heard, no volume, no tone, no nothing. Sounded like a solid body electric with no amp.

The SD-50 & SD-60 sound much the same to me, the 60 seems to have just a bit more sustain. The 50 is about a year older than the 60 so it may have opened up a bit more.
My 60 is strung with Mediums and the 50 with Lights so that may account for the sustain.

I would be happy with either guitar, I like the looks of the dark rosewood with the flame maple binding and the sunburst top,
Larrivee does a great job with mahogany, the 50 with it's natural top is also a real beauty.
SD-60 SBT
O-50 TSB
OM-03 Koa
D-09 12 string
Gibson-J50
Gibson Blues King
A gaggle of ukes

Quote from: prof_stack on March 26, 2007, 11:29:44 PM
Back to the original poster... the SD-50 really IS a special Larrivee.  I knew that the first two of them I played which made "winning" one on ebay a no-risk buy.  Wow what a superb guitar!"


I couldn't agree more.  In fact, I listened to the SD50 again today from the Larrivee clips sticky.   It is a special guitar.


:donut
p.

"those who danced were thought to be quite insane by those who could not hear the music."


larrivee sd-50 sbt
larrivee parlours:  p01 satin mahogany; p09 walnut
bourgeois omv european
doolin 'sarah'
gibson j45 vine
godin steel multiac duet
takamine ltd98; ef341sc; f400
martin d18 ge; d40; 000 Ltd Ed.Hippie

1. Get it

2. Play it

3. love it

Seems pretty straight-forward....my .02 cents.

I was trying to find a SD-50 at the right price but stumbled onto a 000-50 at an incredible price.  I went for it and am glad that I did.  It's so versatile that I would gladly exchange two other guitars to get one.  The SD-50 is in that same vein; an incredible guitar with volume and tone to spare.  I'll bet the girlfriend would be pleased to see your guitar collection reduced to one.  She would see you as the responsible man that you are.

Perhaps you can learn from my experience:  

When my SD-50 arrived from Jim Holler at TrinityGuitars, I owned two other Larrivees:  L-03MT and JV-05E.  Within two months only the SD-50 remained.  To my ears it was (and is) head and (slope) shoulders above the others!!
Play it daily for best results.

It seems clear to me from the replies above that an SD is a complementary guitar.  i.e. it brings something different to your guitar collection; adds something the others don't have; always gives you a reason to come back and play it.   :cheers
Andy Perkins banjo
Epiphone Bluesmaster Sb
Gold Tone PBR Deluxe
Larrivee SD-50 MT TSb

my SD(60) is the best sounding guitar I own, but I wish I could describe it as the most comfortable. any time I ever think about selling it, just picking it up and listening to it and I know its not going anywhere.

Interesting question......    I have an epiphone Masterbuilt dr500m that is so close in sound and feel to my d03 that it's almost a tossup, however the wood and finish is nicer on the larrivee.  I also have an aspen that I have had for 29 years and it has mellowed and aged well so it also has a beautiful tone.   No, I don't NEED 3 guitars.  Which would I grab if the house caught on fire? probably the Larivee.  Which one would I get rid of?  I can't part with any of the three, so here I am with 3 guitars.  I hope I don't fall in love with a 4th one somewhere down the road.  I could be living in my car. :nana_guitar
Gary

Larrivee L-03 MT 
Martin J 40
Epiphone DR500M
Aspen AD-38 (1978)

Quote from: PortHueneme on March 28, 2007, 12:00:15 PM
I think you have to really be a bad player to make an SD sound bad.
Maybe my bad playing warrants an SD50 even more(!) Or I'm just overcompensating, hahaha!  :bgrin:
L-03RE (2005)
P-09M  (24th December 2006)
SD-50  (7th May 2007)
RS-4    (15th October 2009)

Quote from: prof_stack on March 30, 2007, 08:26:47 PM
Perhaps you can learn from my experience: 

When my SD-50 arrived from Jim Holler at TrinityGuitars, I owned two other Larrivees:  L-03MT and JV-05E.  Within two months only the SD-50 remained.  To my ears it was (and is) head and (slope) shoulders above the others!!

In fact, I'm trying to get an SD50 from Jim as well. Regarding the part about turning three guitars into one, I'm not all that sure. Especially since the spruce on the L03RE has been blushing in a peachy red shade. And the Parlor is quite the darling, and we've just met so she's not going anywhere as well. However, reality bites and the L might have to go to make room for the SD50.
L-03RE (2005)
P-09M  (24th December 2006)
SD-50  (7th May 2007)
RS-4    (15th October 2009)

Quote from: On The Grass on March 30, 2007, 05:25:03 PM
1. Get it

2. Play it

3. love it

Seems pretty straight-forward....my .02 cents.
If I had NBA money, yeah, it will be that straight forward. :smile: But I think I'm just trying, it's hard, to be better with my money when it comes to GAS.
L-03RE (2005)
P-09M  (24th December 2006)
SD-50  (7th May 2007)
RS-4    (15th October 2009)

Quote from: gsammy52 on April 03, 2007, 05:03:38 PM
Interesting question......    I have an epiphone Masterbuilt dr500m that is so close in sound and feel to my d03 that it's almost a tossup, however the wood and finish is nicer on the larrivee.  I also have an aspen that I have had for 29 years and it has mellowed and aged well so it also has a beautiful tone.   No, I don't NEED 3 guitars.  Which would I grab if the house caught on fire? probably the Larivee.  Which one would I get rid of?  I can't part with any of the three, so here I am with 3 guitars.  I hope I don't fall in love with a 4th one somewhere down the road.  I could be living in my car. :nana_guitar
They grow on you don't they? If I could help it, I would've kept my three other guitars which I have either sold or given away. And if my house burns, I'm grabbing both Larrivees. But you'll be better off as I don't even have a car. I might have to curl up in the warmth of the L03 case on a cold, lonely night. :laughin:
L-03RE (2005)
P-09M  (24th December 2006)
SD-50  (7th May 2007)
RS-4    (15th October 2009)

Powered by EzPortal