Is adding an SD50 one guitar too many?

Started by Jetstar7, March 26, 2007, 03:45:17 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

I have an L-03RE and a P-09FM which I got just last Christmas. I am seriously thinking about adding an SD-50. But it's definitely one more guitar too soon, if you know what I mean.

My neighbour at work tells me, "But you've only got one pair of hands." To which I replied, "And how many pairs of shoes have you got?" She had no reply and just muttered something about how it's a four-digit purchase...

So, should I sell off my L-03RE to offset the SD50 to make me feel better? Or is it wiser to look away, move on, and go into the sunset with the Trusty Two that I already have? I do kinda know what you guys will say already :smile:

Views? Comments? Cheers. :coffee :donut
L-03RE (2005)
P-09M  (24th December 2006)
SD-50  (7th May 2007)
RS-4    (15th October 2009)

1.  How bad do you want it?

2.  Can  you afford it?

3.  Are you going to really piss off the wife?

SD-50s are very nice.

2006 Larrivee P-05
1971 Guild D-50
1972 Yamaha FG180

What do you feel the SD-50 will do that the guitars you have now won't do?

Have you played a SD-50?

These are just some questions I think you should ask yourself.

I don't even know if this applies to you at all but...
I think a lot of people who get a Larrivee, that don't get to play (try out) very many other makers, tend to start ordering up more Larrivees. I see it on other forums too. I'll see a post that says like "I just ordered a 000-18GE and a D-6SGT to go along" and the person already has 3 or more Martins in their sig, probably all of which were ordered. I imagine it happens but I don't recall seeing many post where people who have tried the guitars before they buy end up with 4,5,6 or more of the only one brand. It seems to me if you get out and play a variety of high end makers you are going to want more diversity than just one brand. After my first Larrivee it happened to me. I ordered another one, then I had two guitars that I liked but I stilled wanted a rosewood Martinish OM sound, so I ordered an OM-03R. Long story short, the OM-03R sounded nothing like I hoped it would and I had three guitars that sounded too similar.

It's kind of like ice cream, sure the different woods and sizes will give you different flavors but in the end it's still ice cream and it would be nice to have some apple pie to go with your ice cream.

So my opinion is, I can see(maybe) having only two guitars as Larrivees, but I would think long and hard before adding another. If you feel you are going to explode with gas go try out some different guitars. If you haven't done this, it may save you the trouble of buying and trading half a dozen more Larrivees.

Jetstar-I have both an SD-50 and and OMV-60.  I also have very very large hands.  The SD is the most comfortable guitar that I play, especially for finger picking, and I have trouble at times playing the OMV "cleanly."  I often go back and forth with selling the OMV but it is one of the best looking guitars that I have seen and it "spoke" to me when I bought it.  That said, I have cut down to just there two but if push came to shove, I would grab the SD if the house caught fire.  Great guitars, is the perfect "all around' guitar for me given my meat hooks but the sounds, to get to the root question, arent that much different.  Buy what makes you smile and enjoy playing.

I have an SD-60. While I can see Jeremy's point about too many Larrivee's. The SD is the best sounding guitar and is surprisingly versatile.
I also have an OM-3 koa, great sounding, well balanced, versatile, but totally different then the SD. My suggestion, play one of the SD's, see what you think, if you like it and can afford it, buy it.

After you have played it awhile then make the decision to sell one off. My opinion is you will find it a different sound the the "L" and will most likely decide to keep them both.
The parlor is of course a unique little guitar, that in my view only should count as a 1/2 guitar. I have an "O" and a "Baby T" they count as one when I tell someone how many guitars I have.
Someday I will list them all in my signature, but it would be longer than most of my posts.

SD-60 SBT
O-50 TSB
OM-03 Koa
D-09 12 string
Gibson-J50
Gibson Blues King
A gaggle of ukes

I would think that adding two SD-50's might be one too many. But I don't see the harm in adding only one.
Phil

Jetstar7
Yes, it's defiinitely too soon to add the SD-50 right now.
I'd wait until April.




tuffythepug

Quote from: inspector13 on March 26, 2007, 06:52:25 AM
1.  How bad do you want it?

2.  Can  you afford it?

3.  Are you going to really piss off the wife?

SD-50s are very nice.


Inspector 13:
1. After reading these flurry of posts, maybe I'm really just having a huge crush.
2. I can.
3. Don't have a wife. But a girlfriend of many years has been bugging about what's up. Swinging the deal might set her off in a boiling fit.
L-03RE (2005)
P-09M  (24th December 2006)
SD-50  (7th May 2007)
RS-4    (15th October 2009)

Quote from: jeremy3220 on March 26, 2007, 07:04:27 AM
What do you feel the SD-50 will do that the guitars you have now won't do?

Have you played a SD-50?

These are just some questions I think you should ask yourself.

I don't even know if this applies to you at all but...
I think a lot of people who get a Larrivee, that don't get to play (try out) very many other makers, tend to start ordering up more Larrivees. I see it on other forums too. I'll see a post that says like "I just ordered a 000-18GE and a D-6SGT to go along" and the person already has 3 or more Martins in their sig, probably all of which were ordered. I imagine it happens but I don't recall seeing many post where people who have tried the guitars before they buy end up with 4,5,6 or more of the only one brand. It seems to me if you get out and play a variety of high end makers you are going to want more diversity than just one brand. After my first Larrivee it happened to me. I ordered another one, then I had two guitars that I liked but I stilled wanted a rosewood Martinish OM sound, so I ordered an OM-03R. Long story short, the OM-03R sounded nothing like I hoped it would and I had three guitars that sounded too similar.

It's kind of like ice cream, sure the different woods and sizes will give you different flavors but in the end it's still ice cream and it would be nice to have some apple pie to go with your ice cream.

So my opinion is, I can see(maybe) having only two guitars as Larrivees, but I would think long and hard before adding another. If you feel you are going to explode with gas go try out some different guitars. If you haven't done this, it may save you the trouble of buying and trading half a dozen more Larrivees.

Hey Jeremy,

Thanks for knocking some sense into me. But here are my responses to your questions.
In truth, I really just think that the SD50 is one badass looking guitar. And that I like the wide neck idea as I grew up playing a classical guitar. Does that count? From the comments I've read about the SD50, it seems to be a good compliment with the bass that it brings to the team. I like me some bass.

But no, I've never had the chance to see, let alone play one in person.

I see your point with the dessert analogy, good point. But here's why I'm sticking with my guns with Larrivee. Taylors and Martins will require way more cash to get the same amount of guitar I get from a Larrivee. I've done my fair share of research and trials but was pleasantly rewarded by getting to know Larrivee guitars. I think it's this reward of value/great craftmanship/made with love that brings me back to them. This reward that breeds loyalty.

But you're right, I should think long and hard about adding another one. It's probably a terrible crush. But not getting it is probably always the wiser thing to do. And I only have two arms after all.  :bgrin:
L-03RE (2005)
P-09M  (24th December 2006)
SD-50  (7th May 2007)
RS-4    (15th October 2009)

Sorry Can't Resist  :humour:

Remember Guitars get better with age.
They sound better after they open up.

Nuff said, probably why I am single. (but I have a great guitar collection).
SD-60 SBT
O-50 TSB
OM-03 Koa
D-09 12 string
Gibson-J50
Gibson Blues King
A gaggle of ukes

Quote from: spenser on March 26, 2007, 09:05:38 AM
Jetstar-I have both an SD-50 and and OMV-60.  I also have very very large hands.  The SD is the most comfortable guitar that I play, especially for finger picking, and I have trouble at times playing the OMV "cleanly."  I often go back and forth with selling the OMV but it is one of the best looking guitars that I have seen and it "spoke" to me when I bought it.  That said, I have cut down to just there two but if push came to shove, I would grab the SD if the house caught fire.  Great guitars, is the perfect "all around' guitar for me given my meat hooks but the sounds, to get to the root question, arent that much different.  Buy what makes you smile and enjoy playing.

I really don't want to go on a buy/sell/buy/sell gas trip. And you know what, what I already have in my possession do make me smile.
L-03RE (2005)
P-09M  (24th December 2006)
SD-50  (7th May 2007)
RS-4    (15th October 2009)

Thanks for all the replies guys. Made a lot of sense. And love your sense of humour. We really need a prescription for the cure-prevention-suppression-recovery of G.A.S. So here's what I'm thinking, I really should back off and save up for that you-know-what of a lifetime. Or just relook the situation in 5 years when I have money to burn.
L-03RE (2005)
P-09M  (24th December 2006)
SD-50  (7th May 2007)
RS-4    (15th October 2009)

Quote from: jeremy3220 on March 26, 2007, 07:04:27 AM
I don't even know if this applies to you at all but...
I think a lot of people who get a Larrivee, that don't get to play (try out) very many other makers, tend to start ordering up more Larrivees. I see it on other forums too. I'll see a post that says like "I just ordered a 000-18GE and a D-6SGT to go along" and the person already has 3 or more Martins in their sig, probably all of which were ordered. I imagine it happens but I don't recall seeing many post where people who have tried the guitars before they buy end up with 4,5,6 or more of the only one brand. It seems to me if you get out and play a variety of high end makers you are going to want more diversity than just one brand. After my first Larrivee it happened to me. I ordered another one, then I had two guitars that I liked but I stilled wanted a rosewood Martinish OM sound, so I ordered an OM-03R. Long story short, the OM-03R sounded nothing like I hoped it would and I had three guitars that sounded too similar.

Wow. What a great point. This seems all too true. I am going to try to keep this in mind.

The Larrivee -03 series hits a price point that most of the other manufacturers don't. At least not for a guitar of that quality. But if you're  looking at -50 -60 -09 -10 guitars, there are a lot of other kinds of guitars out there. A Gibson is a completely different animal than a Larrivee. As are Taylors, Martins, etc.....

Uh oh...Now I want a J45...
Phil

Quote from: Jetstar7 on March 26, 2007, 12:43:06 PM
Thanks for all the replies guys. Made a lot of sense. And love your sense of humour. We really need a prescription for the cure-prevention-suppression-recovery of G.A.S. So here's what I'm thinking, I really should back off and save up for that you-know-what of a lifetime. Or just relook the situation in 5 years when I have money to burn.

That's a good idea. But I doubt you'll last 5 years  :winkin:

QuoteI see your point with the dessert analogy, good point. But here's why I'm sticking with my guns with Larrivee. Taylors and Martins will require way more cash to get the same amount of guitar I get from a Larrivee. I've done my fair share of research and trials but was pleasantly rewarded by getting to know Larrivee guitars. I think it's this reward of value/great craftmanship/made with love that brings me back to them. This reward that breeds loyalty.

It isn't always about the feature to cost ratio. Tone and playability are not specs you can compare on paper.

Jetstar

Have you been following the discussion about the proposed new "Larrivee Forum Guitar" ?   If you can hold off for a while you might want to give this some consiideration.  It would be much easier to convince yourself and your girlfriend that a new guitar purchase was necessary if it was a "one-of-a-kind-chance-of-a-lifetime-not-to-be-missed-collector's-item-investment opportunity.
That's my plan, anyway.

tuffythepug

Quote from: phil on March 26, 2007, 01:16:55 PM
Wow. What a great point. This seems all too true. I am going to try to keep this in mind.

The Larrivee -03 series hits a price point that most of the other manufacturers don't. At least not for a guitar of that quality. But if you're  looking at -50 -60 -09 -10 guitars, there are a lot of other kinds of guitars out there. A Gibson is a completely different animal than a Larrivee. As are Taylors, Martins, etc.....

Uh oh...Now I want a J45...

I have a J-50 (J-45 with a natural top). We have been together 40 years. It is a beautiful guitar with a deep rich sound, and there is NO WAY I can part with all our memories, but my SD-60 blows it away. I have a few friends with Martin D-45's I prefer the SD-60. I have yet to hear a guitar that compares to the SD anywhere near the price.
SD-60 SBT
O-50 TSB
OM-03 Koa
D-09 12 string
Gibson-J50
Gibson Blues King
A gaggle of ukes

Sometimes it's good to look at the object of your desires just to remind yourself ..... to go for it!

Andy Perkins banjo
Epiphone Bluesmaster Sb
Gold Tone PBR Deluxe
Larrivee SD-50 MT TSb

Quote from: PortHueneme on March 26, 2007, 02:37:34 PM
I have a J-50 (J-45 with a natural top). We have been together 40 years. It is a beautiful guitar with a deep rich sound, and there is NO WAY I can part with all our memories, but my SD-60 blows it away. I have a few friends with Martin D-45's I prefer the SD-60. I have yet to hear a guitar that compares to the SD anywhere near the price.

Glad you like it, but the point is there are alot of nice options in that price range; J-45 , AJ, D-18, D-18V and Dermot recently got an amazingl looking 12fret D slot head Martin that I believe was well under 2 grand. Jetstar might think the SD's sound mediocre after he plays one.

There will never be a shortage of people who prefer their guitar over high end Martins.

Quote from: PortHueneme on March 26, 2007, 12:32:56 PM
Remember Guitars get better with age.
They sound better after they open up.

These are good points to consider. If you wait to buy an SD, then you will have to wait even longer for it to open up. If you buy one soon, you won't have to wait as long.

I have an SD-50 and it gets more play than any of my other instruments. I've gotten spoiled by the 1 7/8" neck for fingerpicking and it's a real canon when I put a flatpick to it. Lot's of things have come and gone in my music room, but my SD-50 is a real keeper. Go ahead and get you one, you won't regret it.
Guitars: Larrivee P-05; National Resphonic Style 2 Squareneck;      National Resophonic 12-fret "B"; Dupont MD-50;
Lazy River Weissenborn; Robert Sayers custom flat-top;
Cervantes Crossover; Todd Korup banjo-uke; McSpadden dulcimer;
PRS 22 semi-hollow ltd.; PRS DC3
Amplification: RA-400; Rivera Venus 3

Quote from: hal537 on March 26, 2007, 03:40:04 PM
Sometimes it's good to look at the object of your desires just to remind yourself ..... to go for it!



We need to see that one again.   :+1: :+1:
http://community.webshots.com/user/fng45

Life is too short to drink cheap beer.

Powered by EzPortal