How do Larrivee do it?

Started by PCT57, December 08, 2006, 12:09:36 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Quote from: Bruce Chiriani on December 09, 2006, 06:47:39 PM
No need to apologize, but I think we're sort-of splitting hairs here, so I'll try to keep it short and sweet: in spite of the list of guitars owned below, I happen to like the vintage look. However, vintage guitars (whether from the 30s or re-creations) have always fallen short of handling all the various types of music I like to play/perform. Larrivee's vintage series provides the vintage look with a more modern tone and feel that I happen to prefer. Jean Larrivee has created an attactive alternative to Martin, Santa Cruz and Collings for some (but apparently not all) folks, and, like it or not, that puts these guitars in direct competition with the aforementioned makers. By the way, I'm not knocking these other fine guitar brands. If you prefer them and are willing to pay the price, that's all that should matter to you.

Ok I gotta ya. I agree a modern sounding guitar with traditional looks is a good idea. Usually a modern sound means you're stuck with modern looks. I do think perhaps you ought to clarify that next time. It would save alot of confusion ,since I think most people will be thinking in terms of sound when talking about a guitar being a rival/alternative to another guitar. I would agree the Larrivee traditional series makes a great alternative to the others as far as looks goes.

Quote from: Stringdancer on December 09, 2006, 04:20:07 AM
I love the sound of Martins and Larrivees and appreciate the tonal differences between the two.

Says a person with 2 of each!  :bgrin: You should know!

I wish i had the money to be able to "appreciate the tonal differences" Haha.  :humour:
'06 Larrivee LV-03E
'03 Art & Lutherie Cherrywood

How to make such a quality instrument for much less than others currently on the market? This is actually a question I asked myself recently when looking for my latest guitar. Let me say first off that I have a great appreciation for other makes (Martin, Taylor, etc..) and can understand why those guitars have the great reputation that they have earned (lots of friends have Martins and Taylors and most of them sound fantastic). That being said, for the money I spent on my SD-50, there isn't another brand even close in quality, craftsmanship, or sound.

I didn't buy the SD-50 hoping it would sound or look like a Martin. I bought it because it was the very best 12 fret dreadnought within my price range. In fact, there wasn't ANY other guitar even REMOTELY close to the quality of my SD-50 at the price I paid. I'm a bargain hunter and I'm glad I bought my Larrivee before they get to be more well-known and the price goes up. And no, my Larrivee SD-50 does not sound like a Martin or Santa Cruz. It sounds like a Larrivee SD-50, just like it should.
Guitars: Larrivee P-05; National Resphonic Style 2 Squareneck;      National Resophonic 12-fret "B"; Dupont MD-50;
Lazy River Weissenborn; Robert Sayers custom flat-top;
Cervantes Crossover; Todd Korup banjo-uke; McSpadden dulcimer;
PRS 22 semi-hollow ltd.; PRS DC3
Amplification: RA-400; Rivera Venus 3

First Act guitars get my vote! :thumb :niceguitar:
bluesman67
HOGTOP CHARLOTTE

www.reverbnation.com/hogtopcharlotte

How does Larrivee do it?

I just wanted to pipe in...  BTW since I'm new here I'll say "HELLO"!

Congrats on your New Larrivee!!!!!!

And I just wanted to add...If you think it sounds good now, wait till it ages and opens up.  It will blow your mind !   :bgrin:

I have a D02 I purchased like 5 -8 years ago and as its ages it just keeps sounding better and better. 

But keep playing it...alot.  not only time (as the wood ages) but also playing the guitar makes them open up .  I cant prove this but I find that guitars that arent played but every "so often" do not open up as well as ones that are played often.

And for a side note....  After having my D02 for about three months I sent a letter to Larrivee basically thanking them for building such a wonderful instrument (that I could actually afford. Payed about $450 I think).  The last lines of my letter said...

Thank you...Thank you...Thank you...

Thier responce was a simple as thier approach to guitar making...the letter simply said ...


Your welcome...Your welcome...Your welcome! 

I thought that was cute!






People will always argue that different is better. Whatever. I look at it as, GUITAR MAKING IS NOT MAGIC. If you have a proven design, similar top grade materials and the skill to build a flawless box, you'll probably do alright. You could be the flavour of the week. Does Kevin Ryan build a better guitar than Jean Larrivée? Jean Larrivée WAS Kevin Ryan before Kevin Ryan. Only he was in Toronto influencing Bruce Cockburn instead of in L.A. having Jackson Browne et al buy one. Kismet.
How does JCL do it? Design improvements. CNC. His own sawmill or just plain ... wood! Martin still putting plastic fingerboards on fairly expensive guitars? Gee! What's this? My all solid wood $600.00 Larrivée has an ebony fingerboard? Hmmm.   
As for Martin? There's 100+ years of loyalty that I'm not going to argue against. Unfortunately, I find that the Martins I like tend to already belong to someone or have a price tag that just does not compute. YMMV.     

Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 09, 2006, 09:14:15 PM
I think most people will be thinking in terms of sound when talking about a guitar being a rival/alternative to another guitar. I would agree the Larrivee traditional series makes a great alternative to the others as far as looks goes.

The only other thing you must consider is that an OM-60 does not sound like an OM-10 (although the same woods are used). While I would not imply that an OM-60 sounds just like a Santa Cruz, Martin or Collings OM (as it shouldn't , by the way), I would say that it has a decidedly drier, more vintage sound than its standard series counterpart. Wouldn't you agree?
Singin' Fool

1997 Taylor Cujo 14
1999 Larrivee OM-10 reserve koa
2003 Taylor PG LTD
2006  Fender GDO500
2008  Taylor GC7

Quote from: Bruce Chiriani on December 13, 2006, 07:42:31 AM
The only other thing you must consider is that an OM-60 does not sound like an OM-10 (although the same woods are used). While I would not imply that an OM-60 sounds just like a Santa Cruz, Martin or Collings OM (as it shouldn't , by the way), I would say that it has a decidedly drier, more vintage sound than its standard series counterpart. Wouldn't you agree?

Yes I think the differences between the standard and traditional series moves the traditional models more toward a vintage sound. Still they sound way more Larrivee like that vintage. If Larrivee standards were on one side of a football field (American) and Martin, Cruz, Bourgeois vintage Martin style models on the other, the Larrivee traditionals only made it to their 20 yard line (In my scientific opinion  :winkin: ) So if we are only talking about sound, I still say a OM-60 is not an alternative to a Martin OM-28V/SCGC OM/PW / Bourgeois Vintage OM.

Fortunately, at Larrivée they are playing hockey not American football.  See all those little guys skating circles around the big lugs? That's the future you're looking at.  :beer

Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 13, 2006, 10:06:26 AM
Still they sound way more Larrivee like that vintage.

Gee.....could that be because they ARE Larrivees?


Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 13, 2006, 10:06:26 AMSo if we are only talking about sound, I still say a OM-60 is not an alternative to a Martin OM-28V/SCGC OM/PW / Bourgeois Vintage OM.

Sure it is...if you prefer the Larrivee sound.

Every time a thread like this starts, the thing that annoys me is the insistence by some people that everything must be compared to the "Martin sound" as if the Martin sound is a standard set in stone. It isn't.

The Martin sound, whatever it is, is only one tone among a variety of sounds available in the marketplace. If you like it, fine. If you prefer Larrivee, fine. If you prefer Collings, that's fine too.

Judge each guitar on its own and how pleasing the sound is to your ears.

Jim   

Quote from: jwsamuel on December 13, 2006, 11:00:46 AM
Gee.....could that be because they ARE Larrivees?


Sure it is...if you prefer the Larrivee sound.

Every time a thread like this starts, the thing that annoys me is the insistence by some people that everything must be compared to the "Martin sound" as if the Martin sound is a standard set in stone. It isn't.

The Martin sound, whatever it is, is only one tone among a variety of sounds available in the marketplace. If you like it, fine. If you prefer Larrivee, fine. If you prefer Collings, that's fine too.

Judge each guitar on its own and how pleasing the sound is to your ears.

Jim   


:doh

Your all up in the Kool-aid and don't even know the flavor. Please do not quote me and make irrelevant statements as if you are being informative. Bruce and I were having a discussion an a certain topic, not related to whatever point you are making.

Yes Jeremy! We have all drank the Kool Aid. I'm biting my tongue here, dood.  :tongue:
Btw if you want a private conversation, this isn't the place for it. 

Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 13, 2006, 12:38:51 PM
Your all up in the Kool-aid and don't even know the flavor. Please do not quote me and make irrelevant statements as if you are being informative. Bruce and I were having a discussion an a certain topic, not related to whatever point you are making.

Jeremy, all you are doing is trying to measure everything against martin and yet you accuse me of Kool-Aid?

The fact is that I own two Martins and a Larrivee, so don't tell me I am getting caught up in anything. My two Martins -- a D-28 and an 000-18 - sound different from one another. And they both sound different from my Larrivee. That's why I have them all.

All you are doing is holding "the Martin sound" as if it is the end all and be all of everything. The fact is, there IS NO Martin sound. Different models of Martin sound different from one another. Yet, you keep talking about it as if there is one sound. That's being irrelevant.

The fact is that if all guitars sounded alike, there would be no need for different brands. Yet, having eveything sound like a Martin seems to be you misguided ideal.

So Jeremy, you get off the Kool-Aid. Stop being so single minded that guitars from Nazareth are the standard against which all should be judged. They aren't.

As for you and Bruce having a discussion, take it private if you don't want others joining in.

Jim

I like all acoustics for what they are.   I love my Taylors and my Larrivee.  Each has their own sound and they are both good.  I like Martins too, but just haven't owned one, but I would like to someday.  I think what makes a guitar line great is how different they are for one another.  Same goes for electrics.

Quote from: jwsamuel on December 13, 2006, 02:14:04 PM
Jeremy, all you are doing is trying to measure everything against martin and yet you accuse me of Kool-Aid?

The fact is that I own two Martins and a Larrivee, so don't tell me I am getting caught up in anything. My two Martins -- a D-28 and an 000-18 - sound different from one another. And they both sound different from my Larrivee. That's why I have them all.

All you are doing is holding "the Martin sound" as if it is the end all and be all of everything. The fact is, there IS NO Martin sound. Different models of Martin sound different from one another. Yet, you keep talking about it as if there is one sound. That's being irrelevant.

The fact is that if all guitars sounded alike, there would be no need for different brands. Yet, having eveything sound like a Martin seems to be you misguided ideal.
So Jeremy, you get off the Kool-Aid. Stop being so single minded that guitars from Nazareth are the standard against which all should be judged. They aren't.

As for you and Bruce having a discussion, take it private if you don't want others joining in.

Jim

Quote from: ducktrapper on December 13, 2006, 01:05:53 PM
Yes Jeremy! We have all drank the Kool Aid. I'm biting my tongue here, dood.  :tongue:
Btw if you want a private conversation, this isn't the place for it. 

:laughin: You both didn't get the kool-aid remark. It has nothing to do with forum lingo(meaning blind brand loyalty or whatever). All up in the kool-aid and not knowing the flavor means you're all up in the conversation not knowing what it is about. I didn't say I wanted the conversation to be private, but it would be nice before you jump in the middle of it, to know what it was about. Go back and read(maybe multiple times) all of mine and Bruce's conversation and maybe you'll see that the only point I was getting at is that  the Larrivee traditional models are not based on the same design philosophy(Martin) as the builders he mentioned(more specifically those builder's models designed after vintage Martin's).

The post of mine you quoted first had nothing to do with Martins being better or that Larrivee should sound like Martins.
"Gee.....could that be because they ARE Larrivees?"
No -CENSORED-.

"Sure it is...if you prefer the Larrivee sound."
No, the others having something in common... the Larrivee doesn't have that thing in common.

Oh in that case I have to say, " Well no kidding!"  I thought it rather obvious that the Larrivée traditional series were trying to visually offer a guitar that didn't immediately turn off bluegrassers etc. They might actually pick one up. Other than that, I believe Jean L. had no intention of them feeling and sounding like anything other than Larrivées. Some of us here actually prefer them. If a bluegrasser picks one up, he might too. It's not all about Martin. Hasn't been for a long time.
Personally, I generally like the Larrivée style Larrivées over the traditional series anyway.  The OOO-50 being my one exception so far.

Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 13, 2006, 04:28:00 PMGo back and read(maybe multiple times) all of mine and Bruce's conversation and maybe you'll see that the only point I was getting at is that  the Larrivee traditional models are not based on the same design philosophy(Martin) as the builders he mentioned(more specifically those builder's models designed after vintage Martin's).

No, that is not the only point you made because you followed that up by saying that Larrivees were only on the 20 yeard line.

"Sure it is...if you prefer the Larrivee sound."

Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 13, 2006, 04:28:00 PMNo, the others having something in common... the Larrivee doesn't have that thing in common.

And perhaps Larrivees don;t have anything in common because they are Larrivees. As for the other brands you mention, they have as much in common with Martin as Larrivee's Traditional series does. They are all variations on a theme and they all have their differences.

Jim

Quote from: ducktrapper on December 13, 2006, 05:21:15 PM
Personally, I generally like the Larrivée style Larrivées over the traditional series anyway.

Me too. To get to your other point, I do know a guy who is a flatpicker with all Martins. He recently tried a Larrivee D-50 after being insistent that he did not like Larrivees. And, he liked it.

Jim

Quote from: jwsamuel on December 13, 2006, 07:01:46 PM
No, that is not the only point you made because you followed that up by saying that Larrivees were only on the 20 yeard line.

"Sure it is...if you prefer the Larrivee sound."

And perhaps Larrivees don;t have anything in common because they are Larrivees. As for the other brands you mention, they have as much in common with Martin as Larrivee's Traditional series does. They are all variations on a theme and they all have their differences.

Jim

Ok fine you're right. I think Larrivees suck I would never buy one.  you  didn't miss the point, Larrivees are only 20% as good as a Martin. Thats why all my guitars are Martins.

and yes those other manufacture's guitar based on Martins are no closer than Larrivee; despite having very similar bracing patterns unlike Larrivee.


Why does anyone else bother to build a guitar, I ask you?  :?

Powered by EzPortal