Is quality control slipping?

Started by guzzipete, August 08, 2005, 08:11:34 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Being a recent fan of the L shape, I'm wondering if my experiences of quality control problems are widespread.  The first purchase was an L-09 which needed to be refinished, lots of lumps in the gloss on back and sides.  Instead of waiting, I traded up to an L-19, which also has finish problems.  Last week I took delivery of an L-03MT which needed a complete fret dress from new, had a series of high frets especially no. 3, creating all sorts of buzz problems.  A new L-03K had protruding frets which were dangerously sharp, and all needed to be filed.
If Larrivee wants to become more 'mainstream' in the guitar world, the quality control issues need attention, from my limited experience...
L-09 and L-19 were made in California, the two -03 models were made in Canada

I've notice the sharp fret ends from california but have never had a problem from Canada.Sometime's the way a guitar gets set up for some player's style's I've had to do some dressing but in the 300 or so Larrivee's that have gone thru my hands my only problem has been sharp fret ends.As for finishes the store I have my shop in has had some seconds that had finish issue's but they were bought knowing this at an additional discount and the discount and disclosure of the defect was told up front.
A REPAIRPERSON,Barefoot Rob gone to a better place
OM03PA
Favorite saying
 OB LA DE OB LA DA,LIFE GOES ON---BRA,It is what it is,You just gotta deal it,
One By One The Penguins Steal My Sanity, Keith and Barefoot Rob on youtube
Still unclrob
#19
12 people ignoring me,so cool
rpjguitarworks
Call PM me I may be able to help

When I bought Brad166's sweet '03 JV-05E last February, there were some problems with sharp fret ends.  I wonder if different climates cause the ebony fingerboards to swell and/or contract.  I sanded them round and smooth and now all is well.

Also, the bridge pin holes were drilled slightly off vertical.  So strange, but its not noticeable after I enlarged the holes a little so the pins fit snugly.

My feeling is that the Canadian plant (where the 03's and customs are made) has better QC. 
Play it daily for best results.

All I own are 03's and I've never had a problem! -_-
#113
2004 Larrivee Parlor BW
2003 Larrivee L-03 BW
2002 Larrivee D-03 BW x 2

I found the fret ends to be a little sharp on the D05 I bought a while back, but when I was in to see Dave at the 12th Fret recently he took care of it for me. I have a couple of light marks on the side of mine where the stain didn't seem to penetrate (Dave said it looked as if some glue or paste got left on during refinishing). It's actually under where your arm rests so no one can see it (even myself) when playing, it doesn't affect the sound at all, adds a bit of character, and I got a very nice discount on the guitar as well. I played it before I bought it and kept coming back to it after trying out the Taylors and the Martins so I guess it was the sound that hooked me more than the overall look. I beleive my D05 was made over a year ago.
On the other hand I was in the same store last week where I bought my Larrivee, and I was looking at a Taylor 800 series flame maple (beautiful wood). I had a close look at the top of the guitar because something caught my eye. The finish had pin holes right across the top in the laquer. It must have had a lot of bubbles in it when it was drying.
Brian M.

Sharp fret ends aren't necessarily a QC problem.  After the guitar leaves the factory, any dry conditions can cause a slight shrinkage in the fretboard with the result that the fret ends protrude slightly.  This can (and does) happen on any brand of guitar.  Its part of owning an item made of wood.

E. Shoaf

Sharp fret ends come up often on this forum.  I don't hang out at other forums so I was wondering...is this an issue that is unique to Larrivée?

By the way, when I got my used D-09, the fret ends were also sharp.  I basically ignored it and after a while, they were no longer a problem.  My theory is similar to Ratishna's...once I had it in a good climate-controlled setting, the wood expanded to its original state and this concealed the sharp ends.  Of course, I guess it could also be that I just got used to it and don't notice it anymore, but I don't think so.  -_-
Jerry  #698

2001 Larrivee D-09
2001 Seagull M-6
1992 Alvarez 5040
c. 1995 Yamaha CG-150CA
1998 A&L Ami

Quote from: jmhyer on August 09, 2005, 08:43:32 AM
Sharp fret ends come up often on this forum.  I don't hang out at other forums so I was wondering...is this an issue that is unique to Larrivée?

By the way, when I got my used D-09, the fret ends were also sharp.  I basically ignored it and after a while, they were no longer a problem.  My theory is similar to Ratishna's...once I had it in a good climate-controlled setting, the wood expanded to its original state and this concealed the sharp ends.  Of course, I guess it could also be that I just got used to it and don't notice it anymore, but I don't think so.  -_-

As mentioned in Ratishna's post just before yours, this is a common occurrence.  Wood is wood and if it dries, even just a little bit, it will shrink while the metal frets stay the same size.  I worked as a part-time teacher in a store not long ago, not exactly a good store either, and every guitar was dried out and had sharp fret ends sticking out.   

Square fret ends with no bevel means sharp fret ends in any climate.

I agree about the drying wood and shrinkage but ebony doesn't shrink that much,and I've NEVER had this problem with the 03's out of Canada.I'm not trying to make any trouble just stating the facts as they pertain to me,in my shop.The store in which my shop is in now mostly carries the 03's.Never a problem.I know I'm not "towing the line" here but my responcability{sp} is to the end user namely the player.If I'm not happy,why would anybody think the player would be.
A REPAIRPERSON,Barefoot Rob gone to a better place
OM03PA
Favorite saying
 OB LA DE OB LA DA,LIFE GOES ON---BRA,It is what it is,You just gotta deal it,
One By One The Penguins Steal My Sanity, Keith and Barefoot Rob on youtube
Still unclrob
#19
12 people ignoring me,so cool
rpjguitarworks
Call PM me I may be able to help

Fret boards shrink a fair amount especially here in this climate.  Larri's are made in a pretty wet place, and i'd think it impossible not to have these fret problems.  a smalll file easily cures it and the boards stabilize.  As long as the neck remains straight or adjustable then there's no real problem.
Peter
creestudios.com
Art Guitars and more

When I read Guzzipete's post, I wondered if the long trip to Oz might have had something to do with the fret problem.

I have a cheapo Martin (DXB) that I don't bother humidifying because the body is made of HPL.  However, the fretboard is wood (can't remember what kind) and the fret ends have gotten  somewhat sharp over the years, due to winter dryness, I assume. 
D-03RE
D-03-12
00-50 TSB
OM-02

...and several other guitars.  Former Larrivees: P-01, OM-03R SH (Twelfth Fret special edition), P-01 Chris Hadfield special edition

I've owned as many as 4 Larrivees at one time and seems I buy one at least once a year. No issues to speak of. Sure I can take a magnifying glass and find some tiny things occassionally that you might get picky about if it were a 5K guitar but for the typical 1-2K price I have paid the quality has been beyond acceptable. In fact impressive. I check all of mine for proper neck angle and a lot of saddle when I buy them. No sharp fret ends on any Larrivee I have recieved either direct from Larrivee or through the better dealers. I have absolutely seen sharp fret ends on a Larrivee before but it was also in a store where I see sharp fret ends on 2-3 other brands too. The store is dry and they do not humidify yet they run heater in the winter and AC in the summer both can dry out guitars regardless of the outside RH%. On the occassions where I have needed help with small issues Larrivee seems to always help me so the support has been good on my end. I've also helped about a dozen people resolve various issues over the years as a friend and advisor and those cases all worked out fine. One guitar was sent back to Larrivee and they even documented with photos all the damage caused by lack of humidity, dipping top, rotating bridge, shrinking fretboard binding, a crack in the top, sharp frets.

I also know some other high end builders on a personal friend basis and you would not believe how many guitars are overheated and dried out in shipment and before the buyer sees them. Even see some get overheated and the neck set slip and other pretty ugly things. Bridges popping off etc. This is not a Larrivee specific issue in my opinion and I really kinda chuckle at the concept that USA factory is less quality than Canada. Maybe I am wrong but with my understanding of the operation I dont see how there is a quality degradation in the USA. If there is ever a problem you should very politely contact Larrivee and I bet they will always fix the problem. In the end a good dealer should prevent you from ever seeing problems like you described. Sometimes I wonder. I also believe all blem or flawed guitars should be stamped by Larrivee or sent back from the dealer and stamped and redistributed. Plus the serial should be recorded so there is NO way someone can have a dealer sell them a blem as a new guitar.



Check out my new blues site WEB SITE with free acoustic blues lesson videos and more.

As far as I know the factory blems sr #'s are recorded before shipping.I never understood way they weren't marked.Everyone that sold out of the store the customer was told what and were the defect was,it was also noted in the shop log.
A REPAIRPERSON,Barefoot Rob gone to a better place
OM03PA
Favorite saying
 OB LA DE OB LA DA,LIFE GOES ON---BRA,It is what it is,You just gotta deal it,
One By One The Penguins Steal My Sanity, Keith and Barefoot Rob on youtube
Still unclrob
#19
12 people ignoring me,so cool
rpjguitarworks
Call PM me I may be able to help

I had some sharp fret ends on one of my Larrivees. I know one other person who had some high fret problems on an L body. I have also seen some sloppy glue-gobs and drips.
I guess it points out the importance of the dealer in the whole picture. I have heard of one dealer who returns Taylors back to the factory if he isn't happy with a guitar. But, I have never heard of the Larrivee dealer sending anything back from the showroom.

--Fred


I had an LV-05mt with the sharp ends as well. Didnt bother me too much because I was still able to play though :mellow:

Edited:
Dont suffer and dont waste money going to a repair shop. Take a hard sanding block and buy a grade of ultra fine or emery sandpaper. Mask off the back of the neck and body join area with blue painter masking tape old the block at a 45 degree angle and run it up and down that sharp edge of the fretboard once or twice on the sides of the neck. Feel between every stroke or two until the little foil ends vanish. It's really more like a buffing them away than a real sanding. People will drive 20 miles in traffic and pay someone to do it but this fret edge problem is faster to fix than logging into the forum. Paying to have this done or opening a huge customer service can of worms is a lot like going to the hospital emergency room to clip a fingernail. I am not so amazed this happens to guitars but I am amazed that it causes much stress. The only concern I have is looking at the entire instrument for any signs of drying just in case it needs some care.
Check out my new blues site WEB SITE with free acoustic blues lesson videos and more.

Just in case someone does get brave. I sure don't recommend someone doing this if you can bring it back to a local dealer but if you buy used or need to save some money this might be easier than you thought. I just masked off my parlor and shot an example photo of how you might do it. Frets.com might even have a better way. I know this is safe and I have done this on Martins, Santa Cruz and countless Gibsons. Usually once this is done you will never have it again. Again, the sandpaper is so fine it's almost smooth like buffing paper.
Check out my new blues site WEB SITE with free acoustic blues lesson videos and more.

It looks like the canine in charge of quality control is fullfilling his/her duties of overseeing your work!

Powered by EzPortal