Forum VI (based on Forum III) any interest?

Started by mike in lytle, May 07, 2021, 11:22:39 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 4 Guests are viewing this topic.

Quote from: Frasier1 on June 01, 2021, 08:16:08 PM
I have #1/10 and to me it is absolutely phenomenal.  It was because of the Forum III that piqued my interest in the LS body and because of the one I have that has interested me in the F-VI, especially with walnut and cutaway.  If this build was to go the way of the -40 bracing I would probably still be on board,  although I'm still in favor of the standard bracing - only because I have the -40. 
I should have snapped to this when you said you have one of the Notable LS-03.
On your Notable LS-03, what is the depth of the body at the lower bout?
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

I can go either way on the bracing - if John Jr. says it's a good idea, I trust his first hand experience.

I'd still want to stick with the traditional curved Larrivee headstock - I just think a Martin-style headstock on a Larrivee body looks odd. It's fine on a Larrivee 40 Series OM or dread, but on the L - it's just wrong.

:wacko:
1999 D-02 Left-handed
2002 L-05 Left-handed
Larrivee owner since 1992

I have an OM-40, so the traditional Larrivee bracing would be my preference, just to hear the difference. But not a deal-breaker in any case. Looking forward to hearing ballpark pricing. :whistling:
Remember when the music came from wooden boxes strung with silver wires...

OM-40 SB
Forum VI - LS-03 Moonwood/Walnut
Seagull S6

Quote from: Mikeymac on June 02, 2021, 10:39:45 AM
I can go either way on the bracing - if John Jr. says it's a good idea, I trust his first hand experience.

I'd still want to stick with the traditional curved Larrivee headstock - I just think a Martin-style headstock on a Larrivee body looks odd. It's fine on a Larrivee 40 Series OM or dread, but on the L - it's just wrong.
I could not say myself from any kind of experience what 40 series bracing would do to the Forum VI.
The Notable LS was different enough in woods and scale that the 40 series bracing might have made sense.
Also, that is why I asked Cliff for the body depth of his Notable. The Forum VI will be 4 inches.

The 40 bracing idea is intriguing, but it really would be sort of an experiment, in my humble opinion.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

John just replied about this, verbatim and total.
40 series bracing....You guys are looking for something special and unique. Adding the scalloped hybrid bracing to an LS-03 makes it that much more unique. Therefore I think it is a great idea. Besides, adding a little extra low end (40 bracing) to a smaller body is also a great idea.

Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Reading John's comments on the scalloped hybrid bracing has me hoping this is the route we end up taking. I understand the sentiment for "traditional", and I'll only add that the first time I played one of the OM-40 series, and after owning a traditional L, my first response was "WOW!". It was, and still is, a Larrivee immediately. The balanced sound is still there and remarkable, as of course is the build quality. To my ears, at least, it was like a bit of an acoustical awakening. Almost like a measurable refinement. Love them both. If I could only have one, it'd probably be the scalloped hybrid based only on my limited experience.
Larrivee 000-03 Forum VII
Larrivee LS-03WL Forum VI Limited
Larrivee OM-40M
Larrivee O-01W
Taylor AD12E
Martin 000-16 (gone for now)
Epiphone Olympic Solid Body Electric (1967)
Larrivee F-33 Mandolin (8/1/2008)
Larrivee A-33 (8/21/2009)
Kawalek Octave Mandolin
Eastman MOD 305 Octave Mandolin

I'd vote for the new bracing. The traditioal Larrivee bracing is what I have on my current Larrivees, and it's all I've ever known on a Larrivee. That's not a bad thing at all, but I'm for making this guitar something different and taking John's advice in this regard.
2002 L-10
2006 LV-10QM
2010 OMV-03

Formerly: O-01 Koa Parlor, L-03

Bracing....
Ok, I have added another column on the spreadsheet.
So far, we have two votes for hybrid (40 series), the other I will call standard (X bracing)
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

40 series bracing sounds nice to me.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Quote from: mike in lytle on June 02, 2021, 11:13:37 AM

John just replied about this, verbatim and total.
40 series bracing....You guys are looking for something special and unique. Adding the scalloped hybrid bracing to an LS-03 makes it that much more unique. Therefore I think it is a great idea. Besides, adding a little extra low end (40 bracing) to a smaller body is also a great idea.



I trust John Jr's judgment and experience. The only thing NOT addressed is the fact that the 12-fret neck will also likely add some low end (unless I'm totally out to lunch!); or at least more resonance because the bridge has been moved to the center of the lower bout.

One reason the combination of these two elements *could be* a good thing on an LS is that Walnut, in my experience, is not a very "bassy" wood; it is more transparent, like Maple. So *my assumption* is that the 40 Series bracing/12-fret neck combination will be a strong compliment to the smaller LS body made of Walnut.

How am I doing so far?  :rolleye:

IOW, I'm good with 40 Series bracing (but still would like a traditional Larrivee rounded headstock on a Larrivee LS body...but I won't let this be a deal breaker).
1999 D-02 Left-handed
2002 L-05 Left-handed
Larrivee owner since 1992

 :crying: :crying:  My head hurts.  :? :? Decisions, decisions.  :wacko: :wacko:

Quote from: Mikeymac on June 02, 2021, 03:10:20 PM
I trust John Jr's judgment and experience. The only thing NOT addressed is the fact that the 12-fret neck will also likely add some low end (unless I'm totally out to lunch!); or at least more resonance because the bridge has been moved to the center of the lower bout.

One reason the combination of these two elements *could be* a good thing on an LS is that Walnut, in my experience, is not a very "bassy" wood; it is more transparent, like Maple. So *my assumption* is that the 40 Series bracing/12-fret neck combination will be a strong compliment to the smaller LS body made of Walnut.

How am I doing so far?  :rolleye:

IOW, I'm good with 40 Series bracing (but still would like a traditional Larrivee rounded headstock on a Larrivee LS body...but I won't let this be a deal breaker).
You are at least trying to sort it out, which is good. Preference noted.
I am really happy this came up now rather than later. I would have felt really bad if anyone made a decision based on incomplete information.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Quote from: Rockysdad on June 02, 2021, 04:23:46 PM
:crying: :crying:  My head hurts.  :? :? Decisions, decisions.  :wacko: :wacko:
Herman,
Take your time.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

It seem like this is really coming together.  I would take the comments of the builder, John in this case, when it comes to the bracing.  I don't have any experience with the different styles, so, yes, go with the hybrid for a special and unique guitar.  That's what we are after, isn't it?


I like special and unique!



:winkin:
1977 Classical
2015 OO-40
2017 LV-10 50th Annniversary #2/50
2021 LSV-03 Forum VI
2023 Hatfield BJG Strong Tenor low G Ukulele #003

Quote from: markj on June 02, 2021, 07:05:05 PM
I like special and unique!
:winkin:
Mark,
You need to say specifically what you prefer, and not make me sort of follow the gingerbread trail.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Quote from: jazzereh on June 02, 2021, 06:58:06 PM
It seem like this is really coming together.  I would take the comments of the builder, John in this case, when it comes to the bracing.  I don't have any experience with the different styles, so, yes, go with the hybrid for a special and unique guitar.  That's what we are after, isn't it?
I am glad you popped up. I noted the preference.
However I do see you have not yet weighed in on the sitka vs moonwood, or the solid wood vs herringbone rosette.
Critical stuff here!
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Quote from: mike in lytle on June 02, 2021, 09:37:50 AM
I should have snapped to this when you said you have one of the Notable LS-03.
On your Notable LS-03, what is the depth of the body at the lower bout?
Mike


Mike,

I just measured and it is 4.25 inches measured from the bottom and 15 1/8 across the lower bout.

I initially was interested due to the traditional parallel bracing being that I have an LS with -40 bracing, but knowing
what I know, if I didn't have a -40 braced guitar that is definitely what I would be looking for, especially in an LS body.
I actually wanted to state this earlier but didn't want to sound arrogant, and still don't!

I'm looking forward to this still!



Quote from: Riverbend on June 02, 2021, 11:41:25 AM
Reading John's comments on the scalloped hybrid bracing has me hoping this is the route we end up taking. I understand the sentiment for "traditional", and I'll only add that the first time I played one of the OM-40 series, and after owning a traditional L, my first response was "WOW!". It was, and still is, a Larrivee immediately. The balanced sound is still there and remarkable, as of course is the build quality. To my ears, at least, it was like a bit of an acoustical awakening. Almost like a measurable refinement. Love them both. If I could only have one, it'd probably be the scalloped hybrid based only on my limited experience.


So very well said Riverbend!



My preference is for the 40 series bracing as I have a couple with the standard bracing.  I will say that the standard bracing still has a lot of bass response on my C-03R TE which I think is due to it being a 12 fret guitar.

Quote from: mike in lytle on June 02, 2021, 07:25:23 PM
I am glad you popped up. I noted the preference.
However I do see you have not yet weighed in on the sitka vs moonwood, or the solid wood vs herringbone rosette.
Critical stuff here!
Mike

Sorry, figured that was somewhat worked out as well but I'm in for the moonwood, again given what John Jr had to say, and the solid wood rosette.

Powered by EzPortal