Strings suggestion - for a newbie

Started by Deliberate1, March 15, 2019, 08:40:54 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Friends, many of you contributed very kindly to my posts last month as I added a lovely 00040RE custom to sit along side my woodwinds. It could not have been a better choice. It is a beautiful piece of work that makes even more beautiful sounds.
The fellow I bought it from is a pro, in fact a Larrivee sponsored artist. The guitar came strung with Elixer Nanoweb's in medium (13-56). He suggested that this set up would be a bit rugged for virgin fingers. And he was right. He suggested that i replace them with Polyweb in 11-52. Well I absolutely love the way the guitar sounds with the medium strings - punchy, full-throated and resonant with great projection. But they have been tough on the digits. I can play for about 15 minutes, then rest and come back for diminishing spans of time, until they are toast.
So I bought a set of the 11-52 Polywebs. I had a local luthier install them and adjust the action to what he said was an "electric guitar" standard. If I recall correctly, he said it was 1/16 and 5/64, E to E. I cracked open the case, and sounded my first chord and wondered where the sound went. The thinner strings sound, for lack of a better term, thinner - less robust with considerably less projection. Frankly, it sounds like a different guitar, and not for the better.
To be sure, it does play a bit easier, but that could be due to the lower action. As I think about it, I probably should have had the action adjusted with the medium strings rather than change two variables simultaneously. Had a good lesson - strings matter.
I am resigned to play the new strings. They probably are what I should be using now anyway, to toughen my fingers and facilitate chord-making in these early days. I can live with the diluted sound for a while.
But as some point, in the not so distant future when my fingers get beat into shape, I am going to want something else that would get me closer to the sound of the mediums. And hence, my question. I know strings are personal. That said, any and all suggestions for different ones to try would be appreciated. Finally, do you have to adjust the saddle or nut if I go from these 11-52 strings to something more robust, like the 12-53 that came with the guitar. It makes sense that a thicker diameter would lessen the fret-string tolerance.
Again, many thanks for the help.
David

The 11s do not vibrate the top the same way as 13s do.  I'd not worry about the sound for the moment....work on learning to play and strengthening your fingers for now.  12s sound great on every Larrivée I've played.  I personally would not play 13s.  11s are very muted on my guitar.  I'd guess that playability has more to do with your string gauge change than the setup.

Just one more thought.... my guitar arrived (used) with elixirs on it.  I hated the sound and feel and immediately swapped them out for D'Addario EJ16, which are plain phosphor bronze 12s.  Huge sound improvement.
2010 LSV-11e
2002 4E Jose Ramirez
1998 S6+folk Seagull
1986 Charvel Model 3A
2001 Fender Jazz bass
1935 A-OO Gibson mandolin
1815 JG Hamm violin

Congrats on your OOO-40RE, sorry the strings didn't work out.

Everyone is going to recommend their own favorite strings so I may as well get that ball rolling. On my spruce topped guitars I like John Pearce strings quite a lot. I had been using Elixirs Phos Bronze for several years and while I liked how long they lasted I was thinking the coating they put on the strings dampens their tone a bit but that's just my opinion and is open for debate. Pearce has a light gauge set of 12's to 53 which might be a good compromise from the 13s you had and the 11s you have now. I strongly prefer the Phosphor Bronze which has a deeper rich tone to the 80/20s which have more treble and sound a bit sterile to me.

With a change of gauges that slight you don't have to worry about the nut or the saddle. But I'm a tad concerned that your lowered saddle is more the reason you've lost your original tone than the lighter string gauge.

As far as playing comfort, perhaps your luthier got it right but here's a web site that shows you how to check that your nut is adjusted ideally. http://www.frets.com/FretsPages/Musician/GenSetup/NutAction/nutaction.html
It's my opinion that a proper nut slot depth has a lot to do with playing comfort. Another thing you might consider just for practicing is playing with a capo on F or F# as that will also make the strings easier to fret.

Hopefully you'll take a crack at putting on your own strings from here on out. It's not unusual to go thru a few sets on a new guitar as it can make a surprising difference, life is too short to put up with strings you don't like the sound of . . .

Best of luck with your OOO, I had one once, loved the tone, but I like smaller guitars more and didn't want to adjust to the 1 13/16" width neck it had.
Larrivee OO-05 • Larrivee OOV-03 SS • Larrivee OO-44  • Taylor 322ce • Strat • Soundcloud https://soundcloud.com/jpmist

Well, I hate to sound contrary here, but I personally think the sound degradation has less to do with the strings and more to do with the low set up as JPMIST pointed out in his response.  11's, 12's, or 13's really don't matter all that much especially when it comes to a small bodied guitar.  Different story for a full sized dreadnaught.  I know this may draw the ere of some folks, but the string gauge is less of a factor with sound than most people think.  But is sure does affect how easy or hard it is to play the guitar.  Just last week, I had to adjust the truss rod on my LV=03RE, not so much as I found the action a bit to low for my taste and style of playing, but for sound.  It has lost a fair degree of it's volume and low end boom and it only took an 1/8th of a turn to bring it back to life. 

If I may make a suggestion, you might want to purchase one of these at StewMac:   It is the best tool I have ever bought, easy to use and essential in keeping your guitar set up to the proper height that meets yours needs and taste.

Changing strings yourself is not a difficult task, there are many Youtube videos out there that will provide excellent instruction.  For me, I love to change strings, it becomes a sort of zen time with me a my guitars.  A bonding thing sort off.  Anyway, congrats on you new Larrivee and enjoy the heck out it!!!!
Lord of the STRINGS * Kronbauer TDK *  Taylor 614ce  *  Larrivee LV-03RE  *  Taylor 810ce  *  Martin D-18 Custom  *  Gibson ES - Les Paul  *  Gibson J-45  *  Fender Telecaster  *  Jason Romero banjo  *   National Estralita Resonator * Muth mandolin

He suggested that i replace them with Polyweb in 11-52.

Was reading up more on Polywebs. I thought that I once tried them and immediately took them off, but I could be misremembering. In any event I've been reading up on them and the consensus is that they tend to suck the treble out of your tone. Not a popular set unless you have a really bright guitar that needs taming. So with any luck, any set you change to might be an improvement. https://www.acousticguitarforum.com/forums/showthread.php?t=541038

While it was probably not a bad idea from the luthier as the strings have a slick feel, fretting callouses are simply the price of admission to the guitar player guys & gals group, so just keep playing and mother nature will eventually fix the issue.

@NewStrings, buying my string gauge from Stew-Mac was the end of my love affair with their site. I know it's a business but charging $7 to mail me a 3X5 piece of thin metal was hard to stomach. I like it and use it often, but there are tons of alternatives on eBay and Amazon. . .
Larrivee OO-05 • Larrivee OOV-03 SS • Larrivee OO-44  • Taylor 322ce • Strat • Soundcloud https://soundcloud.com/jpmist



@NewStrings, buying my string gauge from Stew-Mac was the end of my love affair with their site. I know it's a business but charging $7 to mail me a 3X5 piece of thin metal was hard to stomach. I like it and use it often, but there are tons of alternatives on eBay and Amazon. . .
[/quote]
If you think paying $7. is bad, try paying $15 (USD which would be over $20 Canadian!!!) to ship to Canada.  Unfortunately, at the time I bought mine there were not a lot of alternatives.  I still order from Stewmac, but I wait until I place a large order, then grit my teeth when i comes time to pay.  But, they have many unique high quality items that are hard to find elsewhere. 
Lord of the STRINGS * Kronbauer TDK *  Taylor 614ce  *  Larrivee LV-03RE  *  Taylor 810ce  *  Martin D-18 Custom  *  Gibson ES - Les Paul  *  Gibson J-45  *  Fender Telecaster  *  Jason Romero banjo  *   National Estralita Resonator * Muth mandolin

I'm not a string geek, myself. D'addario EJ16s were always plenty good enough for me on almost any guitar, but a couple things jumped out at me on this thread.
First off, I don't want my acoustic guitar set up like an electric. It won't perform like either if you do this.
(Although, curiously, I'm perfectly OK with electrics being set up this way.)  :winkin:
Secondly, truss rods are not installed in the neck to adjust the action.
The truss rod serves only to adjust "relief" (the "bow" in the neck)
I know no one specifically said that's what it's for, although it certainly means get be inferred from the reference, but consider this post just to clarify that point once again since not everyone has been here for years and not everyone has years of experience messing around with guitars so perhaps it bears repeating.

I remember Polywebs.  Larrivee used to ship with them in the late 90's.

They sound... not good.
Also, they shred and grow mange, even worse than the nano-webs.


If you like a coated string, I think the D'Addario EXPs are much better than Elixirs.
If you play with bare fingers, I recommend standard Light Gauge (.012-53)  like EXP-16 or EJ-16.
If you play with a flat pick, then I'd go up one gauge to Mediums like EXP-17 or EJ-17

I also suspect the action is now too low for good sound.

If you think that lights still lack sustain, you could try a hybrid set like the EXP-19 which combines light trebles with medium bass strings.

My 1998 OM-03R is strung with EXP-16 strings (probably).  They might be EJ-16 or the last of the old Martin PB SP lights.  Either way, they are a 12-53 or 12-54 set in phosphor bronze.

Quote from: Queequeg on March 16, 2019, 12:29:39 PM
I'm not a string geek, myself. D'addario EJ16s were always plenty good enough for me on almost any guitar, but a couple things jumped out at me on this thread.
First off, I don't want my acoustic guitar set up like an electric. It won't perform like either if you do this.
(Although, curiously, I'm perfectly OK with electrics being set up this way.)  :winkin:
Secondly, truss rods are not installed in the neck to adjust the action.
The truss rod serves only to adjust "relief" (the "bow" in the neck)
I know no one specifically said that's what it's for, although it certainly means get be inferred from the reference, but consider this post just to clarify that point once again since not everyone has been here for years and not everyone has years of experience messing around with guitars so perhaps it bears repeating.

All very good points Queequeg, I probably should have clarified my point on the adjusting the truss rod a bit more.  You are so correct, the truss rod is not used to adjust the action, but a good set up begins with making sure the relief set correctly before any other adjustments are made.  Then the saddle becomes the next key component in setting up the string height.  I have been setting up guitars for about 30 years now and have spent considerable time doing adjustment so that my guitars (and for others) are set up exactly the way the player likes them.  Of course, every player has a different style, attack and preference so that becomes the biggest challenge.  When done right, it is very rewarding and makes playing so much more enjoyable and sound better.
Lord of the STRINGS * Kronbauer TDK *  Taylor 614ce  *  Larrivee LV-03RE  *  Taylor 810ce  *  Martin D-18 Custom  *  Gibson ES - Les Paul  *  Gibson J-45  *  Fender Telecaster  *  Jason Romero banjo  *   National Estralita Resonator * Muth mandolin

In 50 odd years of playing, I've never actually encountered a bad new string.   :beer

OP here. Many thanks for all your observations.
So I if I were to make a change to get back some of the magic, should I start with new strings (perhaps those mentioned above) or have the luthier elevate the saddle. Again, now I will do just one variable at a time. Luthier stands behind his work and said he will make whatever adjustments I want.

Quote from: Deliberate1 on March 16, 2019, 09:21:07 PM
OP here. Many thanks for all your observations.
So I if I were to make a change to get back some of the magic, should I start with new strings (perhaps those mentioned above) or have the luthier elevate the saddle. Again, now I will do just one variable at a time. Luthier stands behind his work and said he will make whatever adjustments I want.

Simplest thing would be to shim the saddle higher first while you're there to hear how the strings sound with more room to vibrate. I'd shoot for 5/64ths to 3/32nd inch at the 12th fret and if that doesn't improve the tone then change strings. (Said the amateur home guitar tech to 6 guitars. . . )
Larrivee OO-05 • Larrivee OOV-03 SS • Larrivee OO-44  • Taylor 322ce • Strat • Soundcloud https://soundcloud.com/jpmist

Change strings to lights. I just never understood how lowering the saddle a few thousands could impact the tone.
A Hebrew, under the Spell
Pain is a good thing

As others have said, try swapping the strings for a set of 12-53 lights first.  It won't require a visit to you luthier. The additional tension will probably raise your action slightly, and you should notice more robust tone/volume, and slightly more demanding playability.  Your hand and fingers will soon gain strength and toughen.  I inquired  from Larrivee as to the recommended gauge for a recently acquired LSV-11, and was told that all their instruments leave their factory set up for mediums, but that most owners soon swap them out for lights.

Eventually you will realize that tone/volume and playability is a compromise, and you will find the set up that best suits your needs.
Gary
'76 L-11
'10 LSV-11
'03 D-03
'86 Flatiron A5-JR

Quote from: Ggsanders on March 17, 2019, 10:08:36 PM
As others have said, try swapping the strings for a set of 12-53 lights first.  It won't require a visit to you luthier. The additional tension will probably raise your action slightly, and you should notice more robust tone/volume, and slightly more demanding playability.  Your hand and fingers will soon gain strength and toughen.  I inquired  from Larrivee as to the recommended gauge for a recently acquired LSV-11, and was told that all their instruments leave their factory set up for mediums, but that most owners soon swap them out for lights.

Eventually you will realize that tone/volume and playability is a compromise, and you will find the set up that best suits your needs.

Very interesting observation - that larger gauge strings, with more tension than lighter, would raise the action. So is it safe to say that going from one gauge to another, at least typically, should not require saddle adjustment? Thanks.
D

Going from one gauge to another won't necessarily require a saddle adjustment, but it might.  For instance, if you take your saddle down a bit too far for the extra lights or maybe, custom lights, you'd strung up, and you were disappointed with the tone/volume, that saddle adjustment might be perfect for the slight increase in tension light gauge strings might have.  Lights, then, might provide the sound and playability you're looking for without a saddle adjustment.

However, if you're disappointed with the tone/volume of extra, or custom lights, and your saddle height/action is set perfectly where you like it, then moving up the higher tension of light or medium gauge strings might raise your action to the point where you're unhappy with the playability.  Then a saddle adjustment would be necessary to bring the action down to where you like it.



Gary
'76 L-11
'10 LSV-11
'03 D-03
'86 Flatiron A5-JR

Changing sting gauge will not change string height. String action is dependent on three things; nut slot height, saddle height and neck relief.  I prefer medium gauge strings 13/56 but whatever you like is what you should get, just have your luthier or tech set the guitar up for that gauge.  I find if a guitar is set up for mediums and you go to lights you'll need to loosen the truss rod for lighter strings so you don't end up with back bow, it doesn't require much adjustment just enough so the strings don't buzz. You can sight down the neck to look for relief or you can measure it by putting a capo on the first fret then pressing the string down at the 12th fret and measuring the space between the bottom of the string and the top of the 6th or 7th fret,  specs are available online.
Roger


"Live simply so that others may simply live"

I respectfully disagree.  Without making any other adjustments, when changing from extra lights to lights, or lights to mediums, the increased tension pulling on the neck of your guitar will definitely resulting in raising your action.  I've kept my '76 L-11 strung with lights for years, with low E 12th fret action a shade under 6/64.  I thought I'd try mediums, just for a look/see.  While I definitely liked the increased volume, the increase in tension raised the 12 fret action to 7/64.  It was not unplayable, but it did fatigue my left hand, and I decided the trade off in volume was not worth it so I put lights back on.

I could have adjusted the action by taking some off the saddle, but I don't want to make the saddle any lower.
Gary
'76 L-11
'10 LSV-11
'03 D-03
'86 Flatiron A5-JR

Well, if I may, let me throw another observation into the fray......you may be both right.   You size string "gauge" may not necessarily change the string height (increased relief) but string "tension" will.  Just because you have selected a medium gauge string string, it doesn't necessarily mean you have increased the tension enough to raise the action.  Point and case, look at the odd string gauges of Thomastik-Infeld strings and if you've ever played them, you know they are not a high tension string.  If you do a little bit of research, you can find what the tension is for each brand of string. Below, I am provide 2 examples of what I mean, comparing 2 very common brands of strings, Elixir Nanoweb's and D'Addario EJ-16's both are 12-53 light gauge strings.


Acoustic Phosphor Bronze with NANOWEB® Coating   


Tension Chart
           Diameter             Tension        
Item #   Note   Inches   mm   lbs   kg   
PL012   E   0.0120   0.3000   23.360   10.600   
PL016   B   0.0160   0.4060   23.310   10.570   
PB024   G   0.0240   0.6096   30.030   13.630   
PB032   D   0.0320   0.8128   29.930   13.580   
PB042   A   0.0420   1.0668   28.930   13.120   
PB053   E   0.0530   1.3462   24.950   11.320   


If you check Elixir's Nanoweb's in the same size
12-53, there is a significant difference in the tension.


 Acoustic Phosphor Bronze with NANOWEB® Coating

String tension shown below is an approximation. Guitar string tension is based upon a 25.5" guitar scale length and standard tuning.

Total Tension

Light Strings
Diameter (in) / Tension (lbs) .012 / 23 .016 / 23 .024 / 30 .032 / 30 .042 / 30 .053 / 26 162


I apologize for the "eye hurting charts" it a tough one to copy and paste to get everything to line up.  But, if you look closely, you will see that the Elixir's are higher tension on the bass strings (primarily, the D, A, & E) over the D'Addario. 

So, bottom line, it's not always the gauge that will create the necessary pull on the neck to increase the string height.   At my age (63) string tension is everything to me as my old hands struggle greatly and every little bit of help I can get, I take it!!!
Lord of the STRINGS * Kronbauer TDK *  Taylor 614ce  *  Larrivee LV-03RE  *  Taylor 810ce  *  Martin D-18 Custom  *  Gibson ES - Les Paul  *  Gibson J-45  *  Fender Telecaster  *  Jason Romero banjo  *   National Estralita Resonator * Muth mandolin

You were correct in that I was not considering those strings designed specifically as low tension strings, and did not consider that medium gauge low tension strings might not raise a guitars action.  Like you, my aging hands are sensitive to any increase in tension.  I tried low tension Newtone Heritage strings, and they were real nice for a light touch, but they just didn't have enough guts when I wanted it. 

Anyway, I was really just comparing the effect different gauge D'Addario strings had on my guitar's action.  EJ16's 12-53 have
160.5 lbs of tension, and give me 5.7/64 in. low E 12th fret action.  When I tried EJ19's, their bluegrass set w/light trebles and medium wounds, and a rated tension of 175.8 lbs., action at 12th fret increased to 7/64 in.  Not outrageous, but more than my left hand likes. 

Just a simple observation, generally, an increase in gauge parallels an increase in tension, which, without making adjustments to a guitars saddle or truss rod, will raise the guitars action and affect its playability.
Gary
'76 L-11
'10 LSV-11
'03 D-03
'86 Flatiron A5-JR

Powered by EzPortal