Comparing 00's, Martin 12 or 14 fret and Larrivee

Started by guitone, May 23, 2010, 02:40:10 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Can anyone tell me their perceptions of the differences in tone? I am not as concerned about woods in a small body as general observations.

Thanks

A real quick observation:  the smaller-sized guitars (i.e. parlor and OO's) are gaining in popularity--a resurgence, if you will.  I am newer to 12-fret guitars.  For me, the size is easier to handle.  My 2 cents  :smile:

Yes, I am trying to get feedback on the two different manufacturers 00's.....

I am very interested in this question as well.
Larrivee P-03R Limited, Italian Alpine Spruce
Yamaha AC1R

I've always been sweet on Martin's 00-15.  14-fet paddlehead with 1 5/8" nut, that guitar would probably be in my house if not for the F-IV.  Sapele is a great tonewood and I'd welcome that one as well as mahogany.  Too bad Martin uses wings (extra wood strips on the paddle) on most of their guitars these days, but that doesn't hurt the sound.

This new 00-03MT is really something special and although I said it was open sounding when I got it, it is even more open after two weeks of almost daily playing. 

Both guitars have a sweet balanced sound.  The characteristic Martin sound is there in the 00-15, but in a smaller package, so it is subdued somewhat.  The 00-03MT sounds nothing like my F-III LS-03R and resonates like nobody's business.  I'd really like to try out a Larrivee 00-03 with sitka over mahogany.  That one could be a real keeper, too.

Oh, while playing the F-III today, I noticed how big and bulky it feels.   :tongue:
Play it daily for best results.

As I wrote elsewhere, The Podium have their own custom shop version which is glossy. They sounded much more lively an interesting to me than the regular ones. That goes both for the slothead and the paddle.

Quote from: prof_stack on May 24, 2010, 01:22:00 AM
The 00-03MT sounds nothing like my F-III LS-03R and resonates like nobody's business.  I'd really like to try out a Larrivee 00-03 with sitka over mahogany.  That one could be a real keeper, too.

Oh, while playing the F-III today, I noticed how big and bulky it feels.   :tongue:

Prof... how does your FIII compare with your FIV when it comes to moderate to aggressive strumming. I realize the OO-03MT may not have the same real estate sizewise so does it "fall apart" when strummed aggressively? Does your FIV have the same bottom end, deep sound as the F-III?

Just curious because I'm seriously considering a OO-03 hog/spruce myself. I was not too happy with my OO-09.

ricky

Quote from: rpm60912 on May 24, 2010, 03:31:33 AM
Prof... how does your FIII compare with your FIV when it comes to moderate to aggressive strumming. I realize the OO-03MT may not have the same real estate sizewise so does it "fall apart" when strummed aggressively? Does your FIV have the same bottom end, deep sound as the F-III?

Just curious because I'm seriously considering a OO-03 hog/spruce myself. I was not too happy with my OO-09.ricky
Ricky, I don't strum much at all since (1) I primarily fingerpick, and (2) there are no pickguards on my III and IV.  But the III is better to my ears for strumming.

My F-IV is so lively and resonant that the bottom end is really nice without very much boxy-ness.  But the III (mine is IRW under Italian spruce) has more depth, even though it doesn't vibrate as much as the IV.
Play it daily for best results.

So this brings me to another important for me question, how will a larrivee 00-12 fret, short scale be for strumming? I know they are wonderful fingerpicking guitars but I do like to dig in at times, maybe a lot of the time.

Quote from: guitone on May 24, 2010, 05:19:43 PM
So this brings me to another important for me question, how will a larrivee 00-12 fret, short scale be for strumming? I know they are wonderful fingerpicking guitars but I do like to dig in at times, maybe a lot of the time.
I can't see why not, my P-09FM short scale holds herself pretty well, I wouldn't compare to a L or D model, but she's pretty loud for a small git. Look, you got to remember these are made for fingerpicking, so don't expect to much. Probably a longer scale is what is needed or a bigger body. But as I mentioned, my parlor sure does the job. I bought a Martin 0-16NY recently and comparing to my P, I think the P still sounds better.
cheers
fongie

Powered by EzPortal