satin v. gloss

Started by Blue Light, April 27, 2010, 01:14:39 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Quote from: ffinke on April 28, 2010, 11:50:20 AM
I don't think you can compare and -09 to an -03 as you are talking about Rosewood vs. Mahogany (Sapele). Your observations of the sound is completely consistent with all the tone wood discussions I've seen. The true test is to play the 000-15 satin against the 000-15 gloss. If there is a difference I would be surprised.

f

And yes, I did A/B the 000-15 satin vs 000-15 gloss, they have both at the podium. There is a difference, I would say the glossy one had more high overtones which makes it sound more complex and "brighter".

Quote from: Blue Light on April 27, 2010, 01:14:39 PM
I recently purchased a satin P-03 and have read several posts about the acoustic differences between satin and gloss finishes.  I am curious as to whether satin finish is as durable as gloss.  If I keep my guitars on a stand, say, and one of my cats was to spray on it... would I be better off with a high-gloss finish?  PURELY hypothetical...  any thoughts?  experiences? 

MY cats would NEVER be so rude!. But I do have an impression on the top of my 00-03 from a DOG claw (She's lucky to be alive!!  :angry:) The satin finish was not broken. (Yay?)

I ran a poll asking if players preferred satin or gloss for looks (only). Gloss won, but the satin have a passionate following. Then there are those who think they sound different...
:wacko:

Same stuff slightly different thickness; satin is thinner, but has an inclusion in the final coat.  I prefer gloss, but I am now in love with the simple look of my 00-03. Or the fantastic tone makes me love it for what it is?
Chris
Larrivee's '07  L-09 (40th Commemorative); '09 00-03 S.E; '08 P-09
Eastman '07 AC 650-12 Jumbo (NAMM)
Martin   '11 D Mahogany (FSC Golden Era type)
Voyage-Air '10 VAOM-06
-the nylon string-
Goya (Levin) '58 G-30
-dulcimer-
'11 McSpadden

Quote from: frankhond on April 28, 2010, 02:48:12 PM
And yes, I did A/B the 000-15 satin vs 000-15 gloss, they have both at the podium. There is a difference, I would say the glossy one had more high overtones which makes it sound more complex and "brighter".

Well, there you go. Answered that question.

:bgrin:
Larrivee L-03 w/Gotoh 381 tuners (African Mahogany/Sitka)
Collings OM2Hc (EIR/Sitka)
Schenk Ophirio (Sapele/Cedar)
Bourgeois 00 Custom (Mahogany/It. Spruce)

   Frank, were they both 14 fret models? The "S" ones are 12 to the body, giving a much better sound, IMO. As you know, the bridge placement also gives more volume & projection. Like mine, the one listed on my sig. Just got it, the day before the F-IV arrived. Slot-head also, so have to watch the fingers when changing strings? :humour:
   Have a good way of doing it w/o poking the fingers. Have had both gloss & matte guitars, the gloss having a little more "shimmer" than the matte. Like them both & can't really give a definitive opinion about them. You like your F-IV? I love my F-III, both being satin finished. And, both little cannons. I went with the Podium gloss -15S, which are custom shop builds. Have some mojo already going on? Like a -17 series, but not glossed as much. The whole idea behind the build. Honduran HOG on all, bone nut & saddles, Martin Schaller Gold M12P with pearloid buttons (nice ones!).
  Ask Frank @ the Podium about them. Don't know if any are left, as he only had one left last week. Will place another order sometime soon, trying to get Waverlys on the next ones. Too late to put them on mine, as Martin had already done the Schallars.
   My F-IV sounds more open out of the case, but these Podium Specials are something you should check out. I don't have the luxury of going there ( :crying:), but did research on them before talking to Frank. All worked out really well. BTW, what's your opinion on how the Martin pins sit in the bridge holes? A little funky looking, but they are seated fully against the plate under the bridge. Martin told me to take it to an authorized repair shop if I wanted them "fixed", under warranty. Don't know why Martin suddenly did this? :?
   Here's a few pics of my "Special". Sweet!
     Jeff
     

[attachment deleted by admin]
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true

Yeah, I'm here for only a short time. And I seriously got into these mahogany guitars.
Podium have 000-15 satin / 000-15 glossy podium special and *also* 000-15S satin / 000-15S glossy podium special. So anyone who wants to compare, go knock yourself out.  :winkin:

I played all of them and I really fell for the 14 fret glossy one, BUT the nutwidth is no good, I need 1&3/4inch.
I'm gonna go there again and doublecheck the glossy slothead. We'll see.

My daughter's Walden has glossed up considerably in the "high traffic" areas, and I attribute it to the type of finish nl. Nitro cellulose - it seems the UV cured poly finish on the 03-series stands up more to use over time. Any takers on that statement?
"To me...music exists to elevate us as far as possible above everyday life." ~ Gabriel Faure

Quote from: frankhond on April 28, 2010, 02:46:39 PM
The LV_03RE is a rosewood model. The R=rosewood, the E means it has a Baggs pickup installed.

Oops, sorry. Didn't see the 'other' R.
Larrivee L-03 w/Gotoh 381 tuners (African Mahogany/Sitka)
Collings OM2Hc (EIR/Sitka)
Schenk Ophirio (Sapele/Cedar)
Bourgeois 00 Custom (Mahogany/It. Spruce)

I believe the original poster asked which finish was more durable (gloss or satin) and hypothetically if said guitar was kept on a stand and something happened (i.e. Tabby decided to mark her territory while the guitar was on the stand), which finish would hold up better. I like everything I have but I am glad I opted for the satin finish on my two Larrivees. They are an exceptional value and have held up well with no noticable wear other than a nice patina of playability. 

P.S. Sonically as well as overall balance and playability, both my parlor and my 12 string sound great. I played a Taylor 855 and Larrivee L-05 12 string Tuesday night that were both over double the price of my Larrivee. I would have been happy with any of these guitars but the 12 string Larrivee was such a good price I was able to buy my Martin OM-35 the next year with the money I saved by not opting for a high end Larrivee or Taylor 12 string at the time.


'The true test is to play the 000-15 satin against the 000-15 gloss. If there is a difference I would be surprised.'
Me too (I think those 2 guitars are braced differently, which accounts for the brighter sound.)
 
I've got 2 all mahogany guitars, a martin 00 15 (14 frets) and a Santa Cruz 00 1929 (12frets). One has a satin finish (martin) and the SC has a gloss finish.
If the santa Cruz is brighter sounding than the martin (beside being a SC), it is due to the scalloped bracing and the lightness of the top as opposed to the A framed non scalloped bracing of the 00 15.
I very much doubt that if the cruz was satin and the martin glossed, the sound would change accordingly.
One more thing: If  I compare the SC to my other gloss finished martin (000 28vs, sitka rosewood, 12 frets), it is still brighter. This time because of mahogany,  which is known for its brightness and woody sound.
(the 28 has a darker tone, more warmth  and fat trebles)
The finish doesn't have much to do with it, my 2 cents...
laurent.

PS: I am waiting for my PO3 long scale, hopes it proves me right... :smile:

Quote from: gibus on May 06, 2010, 11:09:23 AM
'The true test is to play the 000-15 satin against the 000-15 gloss. If there is a difference I would be surprised.'
Me too (I think those 2 guitars are braced differently, which accounts for the brighter sound.)
 
I've got 2 all mahogany guitars, a martin 00 15 (14 frets) and a Santa Cruz 00 1929 (12frets). One has a satin finish (martin) and the SC has a gloss finish.
If the santa Cruz is brighter sounding than the martin (beside being a SC), it is due to the scalloped bracing and the lightness of the top as opposed to the A framed non scalloped bracing of the 00 15.
I very much doubt that if the cruz was satin and the martin glossed, the sound would change accordingly.
One more thing: If  I compare the SC to my other gloss finished martin (000 28vs, sitka rosewood, 12 frets), it is still brighter. This time because of mahogany,  which is known for its brightness and woody sound.
(the 28 has a darker tone, more warmth  and fat trebles)
The finish doesn't have much to do with it, my 2 cents...
laurent.

PS: I am waiting for my PO3 long scale, hopes it proves me right... :smile:


They real difference among brands and models is the design, build and wood. Not the finish. Finish makes only small differences - maybe. Unless it is glob-on thick!
Chris
Larrivee's '07  L-09 (40th Commemorative); '09 00-03 S.E; '08 P-09
Eastman '07 AC 650-12 Jumbo (NAMM)
Martin   '11 D Mahogany (FSC Golden Era type)
Voyage-Air '10 VAOM-06
-the nylon string-
Goya (Levin) '58 G-30
-dulcimer-
'11 McSpadden

If a cat sprayed one of  my guitars the only finishing going on would be me finishing off the cat.
Steve ....aka the SMan

I like the gloss finish on my 90s D-50, but if I were buying a new Larrivee I'd buy an 03 with a satin finish. Not because I prefer it necessarily, but the lack of time spent on the gloss finish is the reason the 03s are the bargain they are. Money is an object with me, and I like a bargain. Larrivee's competitive with any company in any price range, but I don't think anyone can compete with the 03s in their price range. Purely for sound, I'd take a D-03R over far more expensive Martins. At the 03s price, there's no contest.

Quote from: gibus on May 06, 2010, 11:09:23 AM

The finish doesn't have much to do with it, my 2 cents...
laurent.


I'm not good enough guitar tech to say, but I did hear a difference between two pairs of guitars. The guy at podium told me the difference between regular satin and custom gloss was (1) the finish (2) 30% longer build time mainly because of the finish. The bracing etc was "identical".

But of course there is some difference between a regular and a custom shop guitar - that 30% longer build time. That, and the fact that satin guitars are most often the ones with 30% less, implies that finish does have a difference, part due to finish physics, and part due to manufacturing logistics. That's all I can say about this, maybe someone here is an experienced luthier, if so, speak up, shed light on this subject  :smile:

Quote from: frankhond on May 07, 2010, 12:03:30 AM
I'm not good enough guitar tech to say, but I did hear a difference between two pairs of guitars. The guy at podium told me the difference between regular satin and custom gloss was (1) the finish (2) 30% longer build time mainly because of the finish. The bracing etc was "identical".

But of course there is some difference between a regular and a custom shop guitar - that 30% longer build time. That, and the fact that satin guitars are most often the ones with 30% less, implies that finish does have a difference, part due to finish physics, and part due to manufacturing logistics. That's all I can say about this, maybe someone here is an experienced luthier, if so, speak up, shed light on this subject  :smile:
That's a great suggestion, but it will still get arguments here on both sides. " The sun is bright!" ":No the sun is dark!!"
:humour: :roll
Chris
Larrivee's '07  L-09 (40th Commemorative); '09 00-03 S.E; '08 P-09
Eastman '07 AC 650-12 Jumbo (NAMM)
Martin   '11 D Mahogany (FSC Golden Era type)
Voyage-Air '10 VAOM-06
-the nylon string-
Goya (Levin) '58 G-30
-dulcimer-
'11 McSpadden

Good points,all the way around.....Leftync especially nails it,imo......In my case I "was" hot for a gloss finished hog dread,already owning 2 RW's(still,very different guitars though).....Looking closely at how I should "go",I happily decided to keep my D-O3R....It is just too good to move away from!

  I spent many weekends scoping a few local guitar stores,and played a load of gits.New and vintage.....Though I do have a few superb boutique gits,every time I came away from an afternoon with other very pricey guitars,and held & played my D-O3R,I was simply in awe of this guitars overall quality.This with "it" being far less expensive than my other 3 superb gits.

  I now realize one can become GAS free.I "think" I am :winkin:

  Best to all

Howdy, y'all. This is my first post. I am new to Larrivee and just bought my first on line today. An LV-03RE in satin. I come from a woodworking supplies background and have dealt with alot of cabinet makers who do alot of finishing. Most home owners like "shiney". To them, shiney looks "nicer" or "more expensive" or simply more durable perhaps. It's perception.
Maybe we have some of that going on with guitars as well. I play electric guitar mostly and know that the satin finishes (typically nitro vs Larrivee's Urethane type finish though) allow for a more woody/open tone. I chose the satin for that reason and the price was great . I am sooo looking forward to becoming more musically organic and chatting with you fine Larrivee fans   :bowdown:  . Peace.
Larrivee LV-03RE
Yamaha FG-160 ('73- my first acoustic)
McInturff Royal
Melancon Pro Artist "S"
G&L ASAT Classic
Hamer USA Daytona
Fender Princeton Reverb II
Fender Concert II
Vox Pathfinder 15R
Assorted Fulltone, Buddha & Boss  Effects Pedals

Michael

Congrats on your guitar and welcome qcsmitty  :+1:
"To me...music exists to elevate us as far as possible above everyday life." ~ Gabriel Faure

qcsmitty,  :welcome: ,  :gotpics: I love pics of guitars, show us yours (gotta get 10 posts) but I am looking forward to it. If you pose it well (especially outdoors, Larrivees  seem to make any setting look good  :winkin: ) it may well end up a GOTM and we can all admire it all month. They are outstanding instruments! Got any doughnuts for us?
08 Larrivee L05-12
02 Larrivee DV-09
73 Granada Custom
Kids got the others  :)

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/default.cfm?bandID=797065


Enjoy The Breakfast of Champs:
:donut :donut2 :donut :donut :donut2 :donut :donut2 :donut2
I will have the LV-03RE by weekend and will post pics. Thanks folks!
Larrivee LV-03RE
Yamaha FG-160 ('73- my first acoustic)
McInturff Royal
Melancon Pro Artist "S"
G&L ASAT Classic
Hamer USA Daytona
Fender Princeton Reverb II
Fender Concert II
Vox Pathfinder 15R
Assorted Fulltone, Buddha & Boss  Effects Pedals

Michael

Some folks love gloss and hate satin.  I have to say I love them both!  I read somewhere from either John Jr. or Jean that the satin finish is as durable as gloss.

Hey Duck!  Drunk cats don't bounce!

Disclaimer - no cats were injured or intoxicated.  Do not try this at home.

bluesman67
HOGTOP CHARLOTTE

www.reverbnation.com/hogtopcharlotte

Powered by EzPortal