Playing the snot out of your guit

Started by jshowyin, July 29, 2009, 05:30:13 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Quote from: jshowyin on July 29, 2009, 05:30:13 PM

I'm not seeing any mucus coming out of my guits, but then maybe I haven't played them enough yet.  :smile: When can I expect to see it?



Depends on you and your beliefs. We see threads all the time about how someone bought a new guitar and wished it was brighter, darker, punchier, etc. Of course the guitar will open up in months, weeks, days or even hours, depending on who's doing the wishing, and sound however they hoped it would. I'm sure if you believe in it enough you'll see a little snot seeping out of that soundhole.

Quote from: Lawn Jockey on July 29, 2009, 05:32:56 PM
If "playing the snot out of it" isn't cutting it.....perhaps you should "beat it like it owes you money".

:cheers

Where would this sayin' comes from "playin' the snort out of the guitar" I didn't know guitars have snort   :?  :whistling:
cheers
fongie

Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 06, 2009, 10:29:19 PM
Depends on you and your beliefs. We see threads all the time about how someone bought a new guitar and wished it was brighter, darker, punchier, etc. Of course the guitar will open up in months, weeks, days or even hours, depending on who's doing the wishing, and sound however they hoped it would. I'm sure if you believe in it enough you'll see a little snot seeping out of that soundhole.
:yawn 
10-1614 more than a number, it's body and soul.

Quote from: flatlander on August 08, 2009, 12:18:11 AM
:yawn 

Wow, thanks for the emotional feedback. I'm always interested in how my readers feel about my posts. It's ok if you can't comment on the actual subject matter, it means a lot just to share your feelings.

Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 08, 2009, 10:21:45 AM
Wow, thanks for the emotional feedback. I'm always interested in how my readers feel about my posts. It's ok if you can't comment on the actual subject matter, it means a lot just to share your feelings.
I thought you would catch on that I was just letting you know that your little jabs don't go unnoticed. If you want full response I can certainly give it to you.  Gotta go to son's soccer game now though.
10-1614 more than a number, it's body and soul.

   fongie, the expression refers to "snot", as in "bugers", the mucous, sometimes hard things that work well as projectiles that come out of your nose! :humour:  What you're thinking of is the word "snort", which is a sound or a noun, such as a pig makes, or some disgrunted & doesn't agree with you would make. What was that? Thought I heard one coming from around Tennessee? Snort can also be a sound that comes out, through the nostrils, as a part of a laugh. Or referring to drugs through the nose. Or, even, doing a shot of alcohol. Snot is something your brother, when sharing a room, throws on you when the lights go out! Yes, from experience!
   You can always say "playing the heck out of your guitar", or something meaning the same. We'll get the idea! But then, is it meant as "beating your guitar so hard" or " playing it for a long time"? Is a subjective phrase, meaning something different to many. Most just think of the length of playing, not try to put words in people's mouths.
   One thing to always remember is to keep the snot OFF your guitar, or yourself! :humour:
    Cheers, mate!
     Jeff   :guitar
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true

Quote from: flatlander on August 08, 2009, 11:00:26 AM
I thought you would catch on that I was just letting you know that your little jabs don't go unnoticed. If you want full response I can certainly give it to you.  Gotta go to son's soccer game now though.

They weren't jabs but rather crucial points in my statement. Are you really going to tell me it doesn't matter what someone believes in regards to how they perceive their guitar opening up?

  I don't think Matt was focused on perception or belief regarding guitars, but rather the "perception" that could result from such statements. ie. ''condescending'' for one thing could be construed by a gentle person,who lacks the boldness for a retort.

   Jeremy, I think you said it right, as Dan seconded. It seems to be a subjective thing & all don't get the concept of "opening up" or perceive it the same. Now I'll get some backlash from flatlander, but we also all have a way of replying to posts sometimes, some in your face & others tiptoeing. I don't think either of you tiptoe around here & are always ready to defend what you say, as I've found out in the past. I'm not trying to start something here, FL, just seeing things as I do.
   FL, I hope you had a good time @ your son's soccer game. And I'm not being sarcastic. I'm just kicking back more on the Forum, tyring not to get into arguments & just enjoying it a little more. No harm meant. This appears to be between you & Jeremy. As I said, I think alot of things people say are subjective. Yes, I get the sarcasm from Jeremy sometimes, but it's just part of him & I still like him for who he is & respect what he says, as he's expressing his opinion. As you are. It's like a medieval jousting match. Who's will break first? :cheers
     Jeff   :guitar
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true

Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 06, 2009, 10:29:19 PM
Depends on you and your beliefs. We see threads all the time about how someone bought a new guitar and wished it was brighter, darker, punchier, etc. Of course the guitar will open up in months, weeks, days or even hours, depending on who's doing the wishing, and sound however they hoped it would. I'm sure if you believe in it enough you'll see a little snot seeping out of that soundhole.
"How come I keep wishing I didn't hear the sound of you saying quick break in periods are in peoples heads but I'm still hearing it?"  That's how I was going to start last night but decided it really just made me tired. Hence the yawn
  1st Bluesman I don't think you get the point of mine or Danny's post, so let me spell it out since inquiring minds want to know. (I am having jousting fun BTW)
  Jeremy, 1st if you don't see above quote as a jab, call me crazy and drop off now. Over the years you have made it quite clear that you believe people's perceived breakin are in thier head. You've always been a "fact" guy, which is good, and the fact is that often you have outright said, or over the last year insinuated, that these changes in tone are in peoples head. There is/was a clear deliniation between perceived change in tone and real. People presented it as real change, you dismissed it as in thier head, just as you did above.
Of course I'm sure you remember your replies concerning me reporting changes happening with my 000-60
within 6 weeks of "playing the snot" out of it. And how my L-10 didn't change much even as I was activly looking for it and leaving it in front of speakers ect.
No one has presented facts on breaking in guitars. In this day and age with spectrum analyzers very accessable and reasonable, I'm not sure why. But anyway there are many bonified builders and musicians who have a different opinion on this than you do. Are some peoples break ins, in thier head or in how they adjust to guitar? Certainly. I really don't think mine was. I'm not gonna go thru the individual, obvious to me changes that happened. But even if it was in MY head, it doesn't matter. I'll readily admit I don't have the best ears.
Physically or mentally. My right ears highs are fried and volume about half of lefts.
  Most really good musicians have good ears. I have a friend who I would call great. Plays everything electric and acoustic great. He never says anything about it but he has perfect pitch. I've seen him restring instruments with out a tuner or reference and tune them right into 440 with the tweaks that make his tuning sound better than yours. Everyone loves playing with him because he makes everyone sound better.  He just instinctively and sublimely fillls in the sonic spaces. I trust his ears. He believes some instruments break in much quicker that others. In fact he said he's heard a big and very quick change in Banjo's when you pick them up after not having played them for a while. He mentioned in particular his early 30's RB and how he had to "wake it up" after being in for maintenence for a long time. Where was it? It was at Snuffy Smiths who also has similar belief. Snuffy works on some of the very top musicians instruments. J.D. Crowes man. Remember when someone posted about Clarences D-28 and there was a reference to Tony Rice saying he had just gotten it back out, literally from a vault? That was at Snuffy's. He let my friend look at it, but not touch!
There could be more, like violin makers applying high frequency sine waves to instruments to straighten out  fibers in wood................. but the point is that you dismiiss reports of quick break-in times as in someones head, on instruments you haven't even heard? To me dismissing someones opinion outright because it differs from your own limited experience with breaking in new guitars,and your understanding of wood and glue is closed minded even for your own sake. More importantly I think it comes off dismissive of other forum members opinions.  Lastly, when you act like you are so sure about a subject that it is impossile to be sure of.
(especially when you've never heard the guitar in question) it cast doubt for me on other things you may present in full confidence. That's a shame because I know that you contain a wealth of info. Much more than me. Well there's the rest of the story. Always appreciate the things I learn from your posts. Matt
 
10-1614 more than a number, it's body and soul.

   Matt, I think I get the point of both of your points, Jeremy & I not agreeing on things constantly, & I can see how you feel the way you do about the "jabs". Sometimes Jeremy just comes off as "in your face" sometimes, seems like he's always right, & I kid him, which he understands, sometimes. I don't see you as someone that "lacks the boldness of a retort", as Danny said. I've done this dance with Jeremy before &, in the end, it's almost like butting heads! As far as he's concerned, I've learned to ask questions, if I don't agree say so, then let it be. He's helped me alot on tech questions & seems to know alot of what he's talking about. Not saying you don't. Alot of these posts are subjective, not factual. I, as you, have placed my L-10 in front of my massive speakers (years ago) & played the snot out of my speakers. Heard it made the break-in period less time, esp. with the bass turned up & really getting the top vibrating! Might have worked, as my L-10 is just an incredible guitar. To say that I, or others, don't learn from what you've had to say isn't true.. You always have good input. I try to have good input & share my years of knowledge, but always still learning.
   If I got the answer you got, I'd have to give a full answer also, as you did. I get it. Maybe didn't phrase it as such, but I get Jeremy & his personality. Have emailed each other, me mainly asking for advice, & his tone is totally different in that world. I haven't been around as long as you & heard all of his quotes, but the break-in comment was kinda sarcastic, or I perceived it as such. As I said, I'm trying not to react to things like that, knowing that he's half kidding? I think? :?
   Know what the funny thing is, my F-III has taken half the time to break in as sounding as good as my L-10. Something I realized the other day!
     Jeff 
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true

Quote from: flatlander on August 08, 2009, 06:39:49 PM
Are some peoples break ins, in thier head or in how they adjust to guitar? Certainly.

:ohmy: Oh come on, you are basically saying the same thing I did in the post you have a problem with. You don't even disagree with what I actually said.

Quotebut the point is that you dismiiss reports of quick break-in times as in someones head, on instruments you haven't even heard? To me dismissing someones opinion outright because it differs from your own limited experience with breaking in new guitars,and your understanding of wood and glue is closed minded even for your own sake. More importantly I think it comes off dismissive of other forum members opinions.  Lastly, when you act like you are so sure about a subject that it is impossile to be sure of.
(especially when you've never heard the guitar in question) it cast doubt for me on other things you may present in full confidence.

I wasn't dismissive of anyone in this thread, the person I quoted didn't even claim their guitar opened up. There is no 'guitar in question'. Nor were any opinions dismissed simply because they differ from my own 'limited experience'. My beliefs are based on some small part to your experience with your 000-60.  If you have an issue with something specific I said then you are welcome to bring that up but don't try to pin me for a crime with no victim. The conversations will be much more fruitful if you stick to the words on the page rather than pretend you know what I believe and why.

Also, If I believe that guitars breaking in is only in one's head, it wouldn't make any difference if I heard the guitar or not would it? Unless you are claiming I have would be immune from the effect you claim I believe in.


Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 08, 2009, 07:52:36 PM
   but the break-in comment was kinda sarcastic, or I perceived it as such.

Well yes to some degree. However it does depend on who is perceiving this changing(breaking in/opening up) and that includes what they believe. That idea doesn't exclude the possibility that the change could be real.

Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 06, 2009, 10:29:19 PM
Depends on you and your beliefs. We see threads all the time about how someone bought a new guitar and wished it was brighter, darker, punchier, etc. Of course the guitar will open up in months, weeks, days or even hours, depending on who's doing the wishing, and sound however they hoped it would. I'm sure if you believe in it enough you'll see a little snot seeping out of that soundhole.
Jeremy, I kinda wish the  :yawn would have been the end. But I appreciate deserving a more specific post. So this is last of this. Like I said in last post, if you don't think that was a jab, call me crazy and move on. I don't need to go any further than this post to be specific and make point.
   I realize that it was just kidding but I also know that it something you have brought up a lot and slipped into threads. The overall theme of the above post seems to me to be
that break in time is determined by "you and your beliefs" and what the individual is expecting or wishing for. "depends on who's doing the wishing" I don't know how that can be interpreted any differently.  I'll try to address the points you made in counter.
  "I wasn't dismissive of anyone in this thread"
Perhaps not but I wasn't speaking of only this thread. I don't need to look up old threads because you said it right here. "We see threads all the time about how someone bought a new guitar and wished it was brighter, darker, punchier, etc. Of course the guitar will open up in months, weeks, days or even hours, depending on who's doing the wishing, and sound however they hoped it would."
This is your own comment about past threads. Lets break it down to be sure. We see threads all time. (commenting on real, threads) about how someone (a forum member) or even hours, depending on who's doing the wishing, and sound however they hoped it would." (dismissive) The guitars in question would be the one's spoken of in these past threads you refer to.

"Also, If I believe that guitars breaking in is only in one's head, it wouldn't make any difference if I heard the guitar or not would it?"  I know you have acknowledged changes over time. It's the dismissing of someone's opinion outright because you don't think the time frame is plausable. I don't think it's fair or logical, to do that without hearing the guitar over that time frame yourself.

"Oh come on, you are basically saying the same thing I did in the post you have a problem with. You don't even disagree with what I actually said." Your right. I don't disagree that it is probably sometimes, maybe a lot of the times, the case. But I'd still want to hear guitars myself before deciding. I hate explaining something like this, it's like having to explain a joke, but the main purpose of that statement was to acknowledge common ground. It tends to make discussion more civil in cases like this.

That idea doesn't exclude the possibility that the change could be real."  Just say that a little more often or throw it in if you want, when inferring that changes in a guitars sound are in owners head.
That's really all it would take to fit my idea of a less dismissive attitude. Otherwise carry on.
Bluesman, yes, yes I get or think I get Jeremy. I like in your face straight talking people. I'll take that to fluffy B.S. anyday. Of course with that comes some blow back, which I don't think he gets bent out of shape about from past experiences. I also know how much he brings to forum on the wood and strings side and I've commented on that several times before. I certainly look forward to
the many things we'll agree on in future post and don't think I'll stay on his shix list longer than today, Ok well may tommorrow. :beer





10-1614 more than a number, it's body and soul.

QuoteThe overall theme of the above post seems to me to be
that break in time is determined by "you and your beliefs" and what the individual is expecting or wishing for.

That isn't the theme. I didn't address 'break in time' at all. Go back and read the question I responded to initially. The OP didn't ask when the guitar would break in, he asked when he would perceive it. It was a theoretical question. I think I was right on the money, that how and when one perceives a guitar opening up depends on who they(the perceiver) are and what they believe. I think that's true and that concerns me more than if the idea is dismissive or not. If you have issue with an old post then you've already had your chance to address it, certainly don't get it confused with this one.

   I had the snot knocked outta me once.
This plain clothes detective got out of his car in my suburban Detroit  neighborhood and asked me a bunch of dumb questions and I must have done something "perceived" by him to be a threatening gesture caused he popped me a good one upside the head. I was about 145 lbs, pimpled faced and 16 years old.
                                    I also had a cold.   I think he had to lend me his handkerchief.

                   My "perception" of cops changed right then and there. (my house was just across the street)

                             My mom was pretty angry with that "tough cop"

   Let's see... what were we talking about? Snot, perception, guitars? Not really.  :blush:

The actual time period when one "perceives" that a guitar's tone has changed will vary hugely. There are just so many factors involved, not the least of which is that when you own a guitar and play it every day, the change on a day by day basis is imperceptible. It's like living with your kids and not noticing that they are getting taller and taller whereas someone who has not seen them for a year will say "Wow, how they've grown!". But the fact that tonal changes do occur is surely undisputed. However the latter part of this thread is a bit confusing to me. Jeremy states that the opening up time depends on "who they (the perceiver) are and what they believe". But what do those two concepts mean, Jeremy? Who I am and what I believe has nothing to do with whether I perceive a change in sonic properties (unless I were hearing impaired).  How I judge those changes will be due to subjective factors (my own tastes) but the fact that I do perceive changes is an objective fact, assuming that I am speaking with honesty. In just such a way, I perceived changes in the colour of the top of my year old L03 R as UV darkened the spruce - indisputable and in this case, verifiable by photograph - but whether I liked the changes (I did) is a subjective response based on who I am ie my personal tastes and thus, "in the head". Is this what you are saying? Because if you are saying that any PERCEPTION of change is subjective, then I  disagree strongly. And I would really like you to explain how you see it that who they...are and what they believe influences the time it takes to perceive tonal change in a guitar. Regards, Lee.

Oh heck - why not throw some more fuel on the fire -

The "perceived" change in a new guitar has 2 other parts in my estimation. One is the "honeymoon" period that I think everyone goes through with a new (or used) guitar. When you finally get that guitar into your living room, and sit in your favorite chair, and play some of the songs you really know the sound of from other guitars, you start to hear things that are different. How long the honeymoon lasts varies from guitar to guitar - reading some of the For Sale ads, you would think its over within days for some people. I have found I need to play a guitar for months before I start to feel like I understand my feelings about it.

The other part is the change and adaptation of playing style on a new instrument. This is especially true if there are some physical differences between the new guitar and the ones you are used to  - neck size/shape, body size/shape, etc. - the physical differences I think you actually adapt to, and change the way you hold the instrument and play it. And some of that may even be subconcious.

And the "structural" changes to a new guitar must be real - there is a company that makes a vibrator kinda device that you attach to the instrument and turn on, and it claims to stimulate the changes in the instrument that take much longer to happen just by playing -  http://www.tonerite.com/

SO there you go - a bunch of stuff happens when you "play the snot out of your guit". Some are physical changes to the guitar, some are possible physical changes from the player, and some are purely perception based on the expectations the owner has from the purchase. Plus you usually end up with your first scratch or ding, getting that change out of the way too -

Asbestos suit on  -  Fire away!

Tad
Bunch of Larrivees - all good -
and a wife that still puts up with me, which is the best -

The prices of those Tonerites seem to have fallen. I might get one. I remember them being much more. Still a lot for a vibrator. If Wallmart were selling them they'd be $19.99
L-03 Italian Spruce

Tone is much more complex than simply observing a soundboard getting darker in color. We also don't have photographs to compare. 'Who they are' involves factors such as how sensitive their hearing is. That doesn't just mean their physical hearing. When I was in the recording program at MTSU there was a class called 'Critical Listening', because understanding what you are hearing is very much a skill.

I already addressed the beliefs part. Like I said in past threads we have people who complain their guitar is lacking something and sometime later the guitar 'opens up' and is no longer lacking. That would be fine if these guitars weren't all opening up in different ways that happen to coincide with how the owner wished they sound. Someone reports their guitar getting brighter while another reports theirs getting more bass.




http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deutsch's_scale_illusion

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_fundamental

http://www.cog.brown.edu/~slomanlab/Fernbach/Assets/op264-fernbach.pdf

Powered by EzPortal