who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?

Started by Johnny Canso, June 16, 2008, 08:37:27 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Quoteanalogy, what looks better - primer or paint??   

Johnny,  does primer have a beautiful grain to be seen if no paint is applied ?

- Larry
PLAY SONG , LIVE LONG !

Larrivee OOO-60 - Lady Rose
Pavan TP-30 classical - nylon
Takamine 132s classical -nylon
former Larrivees  L-03R  SD-50

Before buying my Larrivée L-03, I owned a Seagull S6+ Cedar and a La Patrie Etude.  They both had satin finishes and I really liked their look.

I traded them in to get my Larrivée and I wanted an L-03 (mahogany back and sides, not sapele) for the satin finish, rather than buy a L-05 with the gloss finish.

And, I have never liked the look of a gloss body and a satin neck.    :tongue:
:guitar

2006 Larrivée L-03
2006 Martin Backpacker

"The best things in life aren't things."

Quotewhat looks better - primer or paint
What are we talking about...finish on a 56 Chevy or guitars.... :?
Guys what happened since i've been gone???  The question was "who prefers satin finish to gloss"...i see there are a few glossy guys chimeing in on the topic who want to tell us why gloss is the better of the two....read the subject again guys...just a thread for us satin lovers here. :wink:



1948 Gibson LG-2
1970 Martin D-18
1971 Martin 000-18
1974 Larrivee 12-String
1978 Larrivee L09-R

Quoteguys...just a thread for us satin lovers here

:thumb

yea, wha da ya think this is...an open mike ?    :humour:
PLAY SONG , LIVE LONG !

Larrivee OOO-60 - Lady Rose
Pavan TP-30 classical - nylon
Takamine 132s classical -nylon
former Larrivees  L-03R  SD-50

 :doh
Quote from: Johnny Canso on June 18, 2008, 07:14:42 PM
What are we talking about...finish on a 56 Chevy or guitars.... :?
Guys what happened since i've been gone???  The question was "who prefers satin finish to gloss"...i see there are a few glossy guys chimeing in on the topic who want to tell us why gloss is the better of the two....read the subject again guys...just a thread for us satin lovers here. :wink:





Quote from: Johnny Canso on June 18, 2008, 07:14:42 PM
just a thread for us satin lovers here. :wink:





Proof positive I've stayed up too late reading this forum:  I thought that said "Satan lovers" the first time I read it. 
Larrivee D-03R "Marie"
www.joereitzphoto.com

In my experience, satin-finished guitars are louder and sound more open from the get-go.  I have always liked them for that reason.  But... I also really like the combination of a gloss top and satin back and sides.  Best of both worlds. 

I like satin finish - for the sound I perceive. Gloss usually looks nicer, but I hear something I like in satin.
No problem with me for the "swooshing" some people have trouble with - I think it's a matter of adjusting playing style.

For me, it depends on the guitar.

My OM-03MT Forum is satin and I think it's just the right finish.....it kind of matches the tone. On the other hand I think my LSV-11 would look terrible with a satin finish..........too much bling for satin. I would have preferred my OMV-03 to be gloss, (then it would have been an OMV-05, I know), but couldn't find an OMV of any sort when I was looking.

I guess, over all, I like gloss on rosewood, but go either way on mahogany.

Gary
Taylor Custom GC all mahogany
Tayor 812c (1997)
Taylor 612c (1994)
Yamaha FG730S
Yamaha CGX 171 SCF Flamenco
Samick Greg Bennett OM-08CE

Quote from: the creature on June 19, 2008, 10:56:07 AM
In my experience, satin-finished guitars are louder and sound more open from the get-go.  I have always liked them for that reason.  But... I also really like the combination of a gloss top and satin back and sides.  Best of both worlds. 
YEP...

My Seagull M6, which I really enjoy, has a nice, thin gloss finish. I bought the equivalent Simon & Patrick for my son with a satin finish, and damn if it didn't sound better (it doesn't hurt that he's a better player) and it's not easy to improve on a good Seagull. I'd been saving for a better guitar, and once I realized how much I liked satin, it didn't make sense to go higher than a Larrivee 03, so I bought the D-03R.
Of course, it helps if the satin finish has a well-made guitar underneath.

Lefty...i have Seagulls also & they were my first real guitar & i've always said that bang for the buck, Seagulls are the tops but the Larrivee 03 series is right there with them  :bowdown:, & now that the all solid wood Seagulls are selling well over $1000 these days!!!!
1948 Gibson LG-2
1970 Martin D-18
1971 Martin 000-18
1974 Larrivee 12-String
1978 Larrivee L09-R

I agree that the Seagull quality stands out among guitars in the $500 or so and under range. So does S&P, btw, another Godin company. But my Larrivee sounds as good as anything I've heard, and better than just about all of them.

       I just bought a used Grand S parlor, and after a major clean up, sanding and shaping the saddle properly and putting on new strings. I got to say it is a keeper. Very loud and clear. About as bright as maple.
       The satin finish must be the thinnest I've ever seen. I got a high quality OHSC also. pretty sweet deal.

I definitely prefer gloss asthetically, but I will admit that the 03 models that I have played do have an edge in raw, open tones & sustain, IMO.  :drool:  But I also tend to get the "swooshing" effect on the satin finish that I dislike.  :mad:
Larrivee L-05
Gibson R8 Historic Les Paul
Gibson SG Std
Fender '69 CS Relic Strat

Quote from: dependan on June 17, 2008, 10:37:42 PM
The gloss can take a punch like a drunken Irishman. The satin has a glass jaw, so to speak.

Well said.  :+1:
Larrivee D-03R "Marie"
www.joereitzphoto.com

I really enjoy the look and feel of the satin finish.
Pleased to meet you, hope you guessed my name ...

I've always liked mine too, but I've always been curious to ask..  there are two small "rougher" spots on the back of my D-03R.. is the finish just thin there or is it just worn?
Larrivee D-03R "Marie"
www.joereitzphoto.com

      JCL responded to the question of gloss and satin finish on the "musicrowshow". He said the satin is 1/2 the finish of the gloss. I also believe the gloss gets a finer preparation on the wood before and during finishing. The satin is thus rougher by comparison. Danny

QuoteJCL responded to the question of gloss and satin finish on the "musicrowshow". He said the satin is 1/2 the finish of the gloss 

Danny, tks so much for this quote. I missed the show.   :donut :coffee

This shines a lot of light on my previous posts about satin vs gloss.
I maintained that satin sounded better and showed pictures and quoted George Harrison who told of how he and John Lennon removed the finish on some of their guitars to get a better sound.

I remember at least one person saying in my post, that the amount of finish on satin and gloss were the same and the only difference being that the gloss was buffed. I found that hard to believe but had no facts to refute it.

When I bought my L-03R the smell of the rosewood was so strong (and wonderful). I mentioned this to the store owner and she said,
"It's because of the satin finish. The gloss finish on other guitars covers up a lot of the fragrance of the wood"
She is around guitars all the time and certainly can tell the difference.

JCL's statement confirms what the store owner said and what I from the beginning suspected to be true.
The scientist in me is restless until a mystery is solved.   :thumb

....just wish my SD-50 had a satin finish.

- Larry
PLAY SONG , LIVE LONG !

Larrivee OOO-60 - Lady Rose
Pavan TP-30 classical - nylon
Takamine 132s classical -nylon
former Larrivees  L-03R  SD-50

Powered by EzPortal