Parlor Dilemma

Started by Fingers, May 03, 2008, 05:23:31 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Hello  :beer

I want a parlor (for a long long time) and have the opportunity to acquire either of these 2:  Sitka/Mahogany or Sitka/Bubinga

Can I have some input on which I should get and why?  How different will they sound?  Played the mahogany and sounded nice, but don't know much about bubinga.  I have toiled with this for a month and I know I should just pull the trigger by now :ohmy:

Thanks

Never tried bubinga but sure love my hog parlor.  Bubinga has a very pretty grain but I've never heard much about the tone compared to other tone woods.  You'll have a blast with one either way I bet! :nana_guitar
1986 Larrivee L-05

 I think in a parlor the sound doesn't vary as much as the larger bodied models. I would say pick the one that looks the best to you. Danny

I played a mahogany, rosewood and fortunately a rather unique Flame Maple Parlor which came home with me. What a great sound from a little guitar. These were all satin finish and this one is currently at my son's house playing the blues

teh,

Nice decision on the maple parlor... I saw your interest in a bubinga larrivee.  It is a great tonewood and very beautiful.  My brother has one of the L-10s in bubinga and it is one of my favorite Larrivees.  It has really opened up in the past year of being played.  It has a warm tone with the midrange punch of mahogany but with overtones like koa.  IMO it would make a killer dreadnaught.  Dave at guitar adoptions still has one, and man do I want that guitar.  There is not much talk about the bubinga Larrivees and its unfortunate because they are very nice...the wood used in those guitars was special.  Get one!

Justin
OM-03 MT Custom (Cree Studios "Fish Guitar")

There's a koa one on ebay. :)

I love my maple parlor.  Enjoy.

jeff
Santa Cruz PJ
Martin om28v
Martin 0018vs
Bourgeois 'Alan Simpson' Slope Dread
Martin LXM (on loan)

Neither, parlour doesn't sound good if you ask me.  Even after all these years, I dont see the appeal other than the beautiful build quality.  (I did play a maple O - extra tone bar compared to the P - that was an amazing exception though).

If you want a small body guitar, the martin LX-1 (solid) top is a better guitar that is easier to play and much cheaper.  Not to mention sounds far better than a parlour.  I am not saying that parlours are bad guitars or anything, but they dont sound that good for the money.  Yes I realize that they are small guitars, and not supposed to sound like big guitars.  But the LX-1 is also a smaller guitar that really sounds great.

If you must get a parlour, I would say get a maple back and side one.
Larrivee LSV-05
Larrivee LV-09FM
Larrivee CS-30
Yamaha Chronos LL-16
Yamaha Pacifica 112J
Martin LX-1
Fender American Stratocaster Delux
Fender Mexican Stratocaster
Fender Mexican Telecaster
Rivera Sedon

I just had a little debate in my head about whether to reply to Calvin's post and as you can see the left part of my head won (I think it's the left,or maybe it's the right...oh well anyway one side gave up).
                     Having had some recent experience with parlors and other smaller sized guitars I have to say I agree at least in part that they don't have the same sonic range of any (take your pick) other Larrivee. And the price of the high end P series can be steep, if you consider what else could be had in that price range.
                     I found that for me the L sized Gibson is small enough yet still with a lot of warm full tone range (never boxy) I also like playing my classical, again size is not too large but sweet tones easily coaxed out of it.
                     I may own a Larri parlor again someday, But I would look for a good used one (it seems a lot of players try them out and put them back on the market in short order)
                     Maple is the prettiest I've seen and the tone should be a bit brighter, though I can't really say, I've never heard one live. But An older P0-1 (I think that's right) came up for sale, well used with dings and such but under $400. That was here locally. That's a fraction of what I paid for a new one. Of course the new one has a warranty and a nice case. Which is why I didn't buy the used one.
                     The end of the parlor story for me was that I just didn't feel like it had what I really wanted a new Larrivee for. My LSV-11 has exactly what I want in a Larrivee. Except the Lower bout is a bit too large. But it is narrower and has a very tight waist with a small upper bout. Plus the short scale. So my shoulder problems (which are what caused me to pursue the parlors) are not as big a deal. If need be I adjust the waist to my left leg or drop my right arm over the lower bout (since it's narrower I can do this,long arms help too) And since I'm mostly finger pickin with light strumming it works for me.
                             O.K. I am high jacking your thread to say this stuff that I really should post else where; Some of it applies though and maybe it will be helpful.
                             SO get a nice MAPLE one "flamed" or not. Danny  :blush:

Hi,

Having had the LX-1...I returned it (it did sound ok but just felt like a toy...good cheap price and you don't have to worry about humidity...then ok)....then I got my hog top Larrivee parlor....NO comparison in my opinion. The Larrivee is a very well made, beautiful wood instrument, the LX-1.....a laminated toy....remember, this is my opinion. I got the LX-1 to learn on but it in no way inspired me to actually get going with playing. The hog top....I love her and just looking at her makes me want to make her sing. I can't play her at all now due to shoulder problems but hope to again one day. But I won't sell her. I guess it just depends on what you want in a small guitar if you want one at all. Some people just don't like the size or the way they feel. For me, having originally gotten an OMV-03 that I did not get attached to and felt too large for me, the parlor is perfect. I am not a loud person so having a guitar that is not loud works very well for me.

Tammy

I love my P-05MT, it's great for sitting around by myself playing. Easy on my shoulder and sweet to my ears. That being said, if you plan on playing with others you will get drowned out.
And, it was worth every penny I paid for it.

:coffee  :donut2  :donut
Roger


"Live simply so that others may simply live"

I love my maple parlor too.  The pic in my sig. is the back of it...
00-05 SH, '73 Hernandez Classical, Taylor 314

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/default.cfm?bandID=770687

I have a Baby T and a Larrivee "O" (fancy parlor) . I have played and heard many Larrivee parlors and IMHO there is no comparison to the Baby T or Baby M.
The Larrivee are real instruments with a quality sound. The mistake I often made when my "O" was new is I just played it too hard. The softer I play the louder and better it sounds. Bare fingers and small venues are the only place I play it unless I am plugged in. I have to be careful not to get caught up in the heat of the moment on a loud/fast song and start over powering the top.

The Baby T is as good as any Baby Martin I have heard. It is also a joy to play and it is an easy guitar to tote around and not worry about. It too can easily get overdriven and while I like it it is not a quality instrument like the Larrivee. If you want a small guitar to dabble with and knock around go the Baby route. If you want a quality finger picking machine I don't think you can do better than the Larrivee. For most jams I really like my OM, it can hold its own in a crowd and comfortable to sit with for several hours.
SD-60 SBT
O-50 TSB
OM-03 Koa
D-09 12 string
Gibson-J50
Gibson Blues King
A gaggle of ukes

I agree with dependan.  Again I am not saying the parlour is a bad guitar, just that it's a bit much - cost wise - for what it is.  The reason I like maple version was probably because it acted like a niche type of guitar that was just so different from all others I've played.  I just cant justify paying 600 dollars for a used one when I can get a used OM03.

As for the LX-1.  Again, I think it's better sounding than the parlour, each to his own.  LX-1 has a solid top by the way.  The LX-M's are laminates (do not confuse).  That being said, I played 5 different LX-1's before settling on mine.  So I admit they are not very consistent.  Thus you must play to decide.

FYI the O and the P are slightly different in that the O has an extra tone bar.  Also, if you must have a small guitar, there is also the OO, which actually sounds like a big guitar.
Larrivee LSV-05
Larrivee LV-09FM
Larrivee CS-30
Yamaha Chronos LL-16
Yamaha Pacifica 112J
Martin LX-1
Fender American Stratocaster Delux
Fender Mexican Stratocaster
Fender Mexican Telecaster
Rivera Sedon

Check out this hog-top Larrivee parlor (doesn't really answer your question but I just love this guy's playing):

http://youtube.com/watch?v=KSouq4E5bxk&feature=related
2008 Larrivée L-03SO (Grevillea Robusta)
2008 Art & Lutherie Ami Almond
2000 Larrivée OM-02

OK - Here's my two cents worth - it's worth probably less......

To me a parlour guitar has the compact sound for personal playing - hence the name.  I searched for a performance instrument for about three months when I finally settled on the 03E (certainly would have gone to the higher models if $$$ were there) - It seems to have combined smaller size, but still the performace volume and sound.  To me it's the best of both worlds.....

At the parlour guitar level - it seems to me that tone woods would have a large effect on their sound.  Maple, Bubinga, Hog - each would have their own sounds... 

Good luck on your search... I hope you'll keep us informed on the outcome!

Regards,

Russ
06' Larrivee LV-03E
89' Fender Strat Custom Shop
85' Zion Electric
Carvin all tube vintage amps
And a lot of other junk!

Quote from: Yoyodyne on May 22, 2008, 04:39:43 PM
Check out this hog-top Larrivee parlor (doesn't really answer your question but I just love this guy's playing):

http://youtube.com/watch?v=KSouq4E5bxk&feature=related

That's Denis from this Forum.
Larrivée Limited Edition Rosewood Parlor (2003)
plus various other acoustic guitars and one ukulele

I know I just love to say ... bubinga!

Quote from: Parlor Picker on May 23, 2008, 07:15:34 AM
That's Denis from this Forum.

Wow, I never made that connection.  :blush: Denis is an absolutely remarkable player, his touch and tone just amaze me.
2008 Larrivée L-03SO (Grevillea Robusta)
2008 Art & Lutherie Ami Almond
2000 Larrivée OM-02

Quote from: russski1 on May 22, 2008, 07:33:02 PM

At the parlour guitar level - it seems to me that tone woods would have a large effect on their sound.  Maple, Bubinga, Hog - each would have their own sounds... 


I'd heard the opposite i.e. the smaller the guitar the less effect the back/sides have on tone. Which was part of the reason why I just opted for the cheapest (and I love Mahogany!). That said I've never been able to do a side by side compaison so I know nothing!

I do know I love me P-05!

Paul
Larrivee P-05
Brook Taw

Powered by EzPortal