Larrivee bone saddle

Started by pehabe, April 16, 2008, 04:57:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Hi all,
I know that this topic has been discussed in detail many times, but I have a curious question.
From forum search for bone saddle I had found that many of forum fellowers suggest Collosi bone saddle rather than Larrivee.
Flat radius, porous, etc etc etc...
If Larrivee bone saddle is so inferior then what happend to the one that come with the guitar, espesially Larrivee high end series.
Do you replace them with Bobs saddle?  Do these saddles have porous problem? Too Flat?
Or these saddle have different qualitiy than the one offerd from Larriveewearables?

Just curious since I want to upgrade my L-03R saddle to bone...

Any opinions would be highly appreciated.

cheers,
Peter

Peter,

Read This. Bob goes into detail about all the various materials used in common applications. I don't know if I would say that any are "better" than any others. Just different. I have a Larrivee bone in my LV10 and don't have a problem with it at all.
"The barrier to knowledge is the belief that you have it"

2006 Larrivee LV-10 MR   1980 Les Paul Custom Natural   2008 Larrivee LV-03-12   1998 Carvin LB75 Koa Bass

My L 09 and L05 have the older type saddle and are great. The L05MT has the new saddle. Its awesome. OK a lot may be down to a certain Mr Holler, but Jim set up the L05 too. I reckon the new saddle is a major step forward. Just MHO.
God is Good
Larrivee L09, L05, L05 MT, P 09, OM 03 MT 12 string
Hofner Committe Thin 1962
Musicman Albert Lee (blue)
ditto in red but hard tail
Silhouette Special

Quote from: pehabe on April 16, 2008, 04:57:56 PM

If Larrivee bone saddle is so inferior then what happend to the one that come with the guitar, espesially Larrivee high end series.


what happened is they got 'upgraded' to the super duper triple compensated turbo charged Tusq saddle - Larrivee no longer ships their guitars with bone saddles.

My opinion is, there's no reason for me to get the Larrivee saddle instead of the Colosi saddle. Actually there's no way I'd buy a Larrivee bone saddle, I got two in a row that had almost no radius. Do they even still sell them since they made the switch? I'd be surprised if they don't stop selling them soon.

       I did get a new bone saddle from Larri a few weeks ago that I put on my D-09 and it was fine, good quality bone. But it wasn't the Super dooper pooper scooper triple combobulated type...just a regular compensated one. The bone saddle on my LSV-11 that came with it new is also a high quality saddle, but I guess they have started shipping them with Tusq :? Doesn't make any sense to me...oh well. I think the only ones getting that new type triple comp..whatever, are the 12 fret short scale models...but I'm not sure of that. Danny

Thanks for your comments,
so it seems we... the upgraders... has more choice and also more problem than the people with on board bone saddle, right?
From the commenrts here I could take a summary that the bone saddle from Larriveewearable is totally different quality with the one they ship with the guitar.
Or not?
If they are same quality than I believe the hig end user will buy Bobs saddle immidiately.

cheers,
Peter

   Not everyone is as picky as some of us are. You could probably get a good bone saddle from Larrivee Wearables. Like I said the one I got from Larrivee for my D-09 was fine. Danny  :donut :donut2

I doubt Larrivee would go through the trouble to make different saddles one for their guitars and another to sell as an accessory. Larrivee may have fixed their radius problem and you may not be able to hear a difference in poreus, but why bother, Colosi's even look better and have great instructions. It sounds like you are over analyzing this, you don't need to conduct a sociological study, give yourself 3 seconds to decide then buy one.

Quote from: jeremy3220 on April 17, 2008, 07:10:30 AM
It sounds like you are over analyzing this, you don't need to conduct a sociological study, give yourself 3 seconds to decide then buy one.

1... 2... 3...
Jawohl, Kommandant!  :bowdown:

:humour:

cheers,
Peter

Quote from: jeremy3220 on April 17, 2008, 07:10:30 AM
I doubt Larrivee would go through the trouble to make different saddles one for their guitars and another to sell as an accessory. Larrivee may have fixed their radius problem and you may not be able to hear a difference in poreus, but why bother, Colosi's even look better and have great instructions. It sounds like you are over analyzing this, you don't need to conduct a sociological study, give yourself 3 seconds to decide then buy one.
:laughin:
           I'll take that advice on future saddle orders myself. Danny

Hi All,
just updated my post...
Yesterday I received Larrivee bone saddle (uh, oh... not Collosi?... hmmm another story).
I looked at it carefully, measured it and compared with the original plastic saddle.
Result:
- it had the same radius with the plastic saddle
- it was a little bit thicker (0.08mm)
- it was bit taller (2.5mm difference)
- it had no strange spot

Point 2 and 3 are 'normal'. It should be taller and thicker since no saddle is same, right.

After sanding it and put into my L-03R... wow... I noticed the different. Even my Taylor friend had noticed that it has more sustain and better tone separation.  haha
I love it... :nana_guitar

Thanks for everyone and all good advices that you bring here.

Maybe... just maybe if I had some spare I would buy Collosi Walrus Ivory...
Question: Is it worth it to change bone saddle to ivory?

cheers,
Peter

I think to do that on an 03 is "over the top". Maybe if you had a 1927 0-45 Martin that your Great grandfather passed down it would be worth it. Danny


QuoteQuestion: Is it worth it to change bone saddle to ivory?

I changed my vintage Martin's from EI to bone because bone clearly sounded better.. maybe the Elephants in 1949, 54 & 61 had inferior tusks?

For me.. the answer was nope... caveat being they are all sitka/mahog and Martin's... i have a custom "vintage" bone saddle on my OM19 from LMI, and the same on all of my Martin's... my Webber has the stock saddle, it's bone as well.

And there are several options for saddle material beyond the one guy you are talking about... cheaper & very professional options, well worth checking out for a number of reasons;
LMI
StewMac

d.


I've been lookin at the beef bones my dogs have been chewin on and one of them is very hard and good size. I have considered cutting some blanks from it and making some dog bone saddles and nuts. Danny

Quote from: dependan on April 28, 2008, 11:52:14 AM
I've been lookin at the beef bones my dogs have been chewin on and one of them is very hard and good size. I have considered cutting some blanks from it and making some dog bone saddles and nuts. Danny
Then you could play "You ain't nothin' but a hound dog". Then again your dog may try to gnaw on your guitar.
Roger


"Live simply so that others may simply live"


Quote from: Mr_LV19E on April 28, 2008, 01:25:50 PM
Then you could play "You ain't nothin' but a hound dog". Then again your dog may try to gnaw on your guitar.

                         I've got an Idea for a new variation on GOTM. How about BLOTM or FPOTM. Best laugh or funniest post  that was a great comeback, I laughed pretty loud and my wife asked why, so I read your post to her and she started laughing.    We truly need as much of this as can be dished out to lighten us all up now and then. Danny

I have experience with Larrivee bone saddles, Bob's bone saddles and saddles I made myself from bone blanks.

There is no big difference between the three. Saddles are not very complicated.
I used to be "edman" here......

Oh Yea! Try making a super duper pooper scooper triple combobulated one  :humour:

Powered by EzPortal