L05 -> D50?

Started by Dude Dad, December 24, 2007, 08:45:10 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Hi all

I've been stopping by here often for several years now to read your comments, consider your advice and to enjoy the friendliness of the members. This is by far my favorite forum and the one I visit the most often. I would like to get some input from an expectation or comparison view. I am considering trading in my L05 for a D05 or D50. I don't have a dealer near by so I must rely on personal testimony & experience. I even considered a D03R but figured I might be spoiled by the 05 appointments. I value your opinions  - please comment freely.

Merry Christmas to all - be safe!

Larrivee RS-4 GoldTop
G&L S-500 BlueBurst

I can not speak to the D05 as I have not played one. I own a D50 and these guitars are built to compete directly with the Martin D-18. The Larrivee is a much better built guitar and offers way more bang for the buck. The D50 is currently and under rated guitar on the market and therefore can be had for  around $1000. The appointments are similar except that the Larrivee offers some upgrades in that it features maple binding, custom engraved tuners, bone nut and saddle, Abalone rosette, pearl logo and diamond fret inlays. In addition, the Larrivee has a slightly enlarged sound hole. Tone is subjective; however, I feel that the tone of the Larrivee rivals the d-18. The Larrivee produces a loud, dry sound that is suitable for bluegrass. However, it also can be complex and deliver plenty of sustain and balance for fingerstyle. For utilitarian purposes, the d50 is a steal.

QuoteI own a D50 and these guitars are built to compete directly with the Martin D-18. The Larrivee is a much better built guitar

Don't know if i could agree with that statment... Martin's fret ends don't rip yer hand open, and their tuners work....

my take is that they are both are good factory guitars, but build quality is about on par, and if anything the Martin's Qc is a bit better, esp with the Larrivee's crude fret ends that would never exit Naz, and Larrivee has just switched to the same tuners that are on the D18.

A friend who is a bluegrasser and owns a small fleet of vintage Martin's was raveing about a D50 at a store near me, and that is high praise from someone who gig's reguarly with a 50's D18 & 60's D28.

If my old D18 (i own a '54) is ever lost i would be looking at the D50... they are that good, but i don't think they are built better than Naz's offerings..... but the weak points are addressable (fret ends + tuners)

d.

Hello,

What would a D-05 be built to compete against if the D-50 competes against the D-18? How much difference is there really between  the D-05 and D-50 (other than cosmetic)? And whilst on this subject, I have a D-04 that appears "identical" to the D-05 except for the abalone inlay. Just wondering. I won't mention that the D-03 appears to be an un-glossed D-04...  :winkin:

Thank you,

Will
Cheers,

Will

Acoustic, Electric & Air guitars

QuoteHow much difference is there really between  the D-05 and D-50 (other than cosmetic)?

Will;

There's two large differences between the 50/60 & the 01/2/3/4/5/9/10/19/72.... the braceing is forward shifted, closer to the sound hole, and the center of the "X" is further from the bridge... and the sound hole is enlarged.

No D50 is directly comparable to any D18 on paper due to diffrences in braceing design, in reality let your ears tell you.. i think the one's i have played are very close to my rear shifted/straight braced giged for decades sitka topped D18....

Let YOUR ears tell you.. esp if you can find an older D18 to compare it to.. these still are the things that all others must be judged by.

Ta,

d.

ps. the build quality on my D18 is stunning... including rolled fingerboard edges......

QuoteThere's two large differences between the 50/60 & the 01/2/3/4/5/9/10/19/72.... the braceing is forward shifted, closer to the sound hole, and the center of the "X" is further from the bridge... and the sound hole is enlarged.

INterresting, and what are the differences for ears?

thanxs

It becomes a matter of looks. I prefer the D-05 because it looks like a Larrivée to me. Others prefer the "traditional" look. Inside they are all Larrivées. My D05 is a killer dread.

Quote from: jeremyl on January 08, 2008, 05:01:10 PM
INterresting, and what are the differences for ears?

thanxs

The forward shifted braces loosen up the top a little and add bass. the larger soundhole increases the resonant frequency and I think it makes the guitar sound more airy and less focused.

L-05 or D50 Not D50 or Martin D-18

I just got an L09 I love it.

It sounds much more subtle than my older D shaped Grammer G10. I also love the Grammer I've had it since 77 I think.

I wouldn't trade the L09. It's what Larrys are supposed to be. :donut2 :coffee :donut2 :donut :coffee

Allow me to share my experience.  I thought a D-50 might be a great 3rd guitar, so I went and played an D-50 and a D-60.  I had previously played a D-03 which I loved (and I ended up buying an L-03 that I loved).

I braced myself for the D-50 magic on the first strum.....

:yak:

Darn.  No magic.  It was too thick and dead... as if it had Elixer POLYWEB 13's on it or something..
Either of them, the D-50 or the D-60.

I hope it was the strings.  I love my L-03, now that is a good sounding guitar to my ears.

Just an experience with many variables including my day to day perception.  I have gotten used to Elixer nano 80/20 custom lights on my L-03.  Maybe I just like a more airy sound.

  Dude Dad, By design I have 1 electric guitar, and 1 acoustic guitar, a D05 bearclaw. I love this guitar for it's playability, looks, and mostly it's voice. IMO it's hard to beat that big dread sound. I'm 6'2'' and have arms like an ape so "cuddling up" to my guitar isn't a consideration for me, and the neck is comfortable and fast. When I play it's a very even ratio of  strumming/ finger picking/ flat picking. I'd like to, but haven't yet played a D50. I have played a L05 next to this D05, and it was a very difficult decision, but as I said, I'm a sucker for a dread. My best friend has in the last 3 years had 6 or 7 custom Martins, 2 Gibsons, and a Collings. All BEAUTIFL guitars  :bowdown:, different voices, playability, and levels of bling, but I can honestly say that the D05 held it's own against these beautifully crafted instruments. I lust after  :crying:,  and can appreciate, lots of different makes and models of guitars, but my D05 covers all my needs very nicely. IMO the 5 series has the right level of cosmetic appointments that makes them pretty good looking. Good luck, and enjoy the process!

Powered by EzPortal