How do Larrivee do it?

Started by PCT57, December 08, 2006, 12:09:36 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Its three weeks now since I got the OM-50 and I just can't get over the quality of this thing particularly when compared to the cost.

If this was a Martin it would have cost at least twice as much and I a/b'd it with many high end Martins and with regard to the sound it was different, brighter somehow, but now way inferior in my opinion.

I have a fairly plain 00016 (from new) which is a good guitar with a lovely sound but when you compare it to the Larrivee the is a massive difference in value for money. The Martin cost me in 1991 the same as the OM !! The quality of the materials and 'bling' (awful term) on this guitar is nothing other than stunning - good enough just to sit and look at.

Can anyone explain how Larrivee can do it or is it just that Martin guitars are very overpriced and you pay for the 'history' etc?

I think that its a matter of pride on the part of Jean Larrivee. He believes in a no-nonsense approach to guitar making and marketing. He vowed a few years back to make high-quality vintage style guitars that would rival Martin, Santa Cruz and Collings at a much lower cost. I'd say that he's made good on his promise, wouldn't you?
Singin' Fool

1997 Taylor Cujo 14
1999 Larrivee OM-10 reserve koa
2003 Taylor PG LTD
2006  Fender GDO500
2008  Taylor GC7

I think it's a matter of opinion. It's possible the Martin name adds to the price. Of course Martin produces alot of models, with lots of variation between models which I'm sure adds to cost. Personally if I were going to spend over 1K on guitar, it probably wouldn't be a Larrivee. I don't think Larrivee produces anything that competes with Martin's standard line. A Martin OM-21 weighs alot less than a OM-09, and I think it sounds alot better too. Of course if you like a more modern sound you will probably like the Larrivee better, or maybe a Taylor.

I know how you feel PCT57.  I look at my new L-03 and wonder how can such a nice guitar cost so little.

I recently played a Martin D-28 Marquis, OM-28 Marquis and a D-18GE.  They were all in the $4000 to $5000CDN price range.  Beautiful, well made, quality instruments all of them.  But later, after the boys were in bed, I took out the L-03 and started playing.  I smiled thinking, I paid less than $1000CDN for this guitar including shipping, taxes, brokerage fees, duty...etc everything!!!  And in no way did those three Martins sound $3000 to $4000 "better" than my L-03.  Don't get me wrong, I would buy any, maybe even all, of those Martins if I had the money.  But when you can't afford or don't want to spend $4-5k for a guitar, it's nice to know you can buy a high quality guitar without having to spend the big bucks.  

Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 12:55:28 PM
I think it's a matter of opinion.   I don't think Larrivee produces anything that competes with Martin's standard line.
Those are TROLLING words, mister!   :laughin:
You haven't played my SD-50!! Larrivee traditional > Martin standard.  :nana_guitar
Play it daily for best results.

Quote from: Bruce Chiriani on December 08, 2006, 12:45:59 PM
I think that its a matter of pride on the part of Jean Larrivee. He believes in a no-nonsense approach to guitar making and marketing. He vowed a few years back to make high-quality vintage style guitars that would rival Martin, Santa Cruz and Collings at a much lower cost. I'd say that he's made good on his promise, wouldn't you?

I'm sorry, I've said before, but no. No Larrivee sounds anything like a Martin or the boutique builders who make guitars modelled after Martins. The only thing they have in common are looks and forward shifted X braces. Larrivee's have symmetrical parabolic bracing (very modern). Martins have scalloped asymmetrical bracing. Also the enlarged soundhole is not traditionally a feature on Martin style guitars. The X braces inside a Santa Cruz OM/PW are about a third as thick as Larrivee's braces. Larrivees are great guitars, but they have nothing in common soundwise with the builders you mentioned.

Quote from: prof_stack on December 08, 2006, 01:07:12 PM
Those are TROLLING words, mister!   :laughin:
You haven't played my SD-50!! Larrivee traditional > Martin standard.  :nana_guitar

I meant in the Larrivees in the price range of the Martin standard line, when compared to the Martin standard line. In other words if I were going to buy a guitar in that price range, I probably would go with Martin over Larrivee. However I could totally understand someone liking any Larrive over any Martin, its just that if I were to spend that kind of money it probably wouldn't be on a Larrivee.

and actually I haven't played any of the SDs, yet.

Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 01:07:35 PM
No Larrivee sounds anything like a Martin or the boutique builders who make guitars modelled after Martins.

You're absolutely right. Larrivee guitars sound way better than similar style/price martins  :laughin:

...but clearly thats a matter of personal preference. To each his own.  :cheers

Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 01:07:35 PM
Larrivees are great guitars, but they have nothing in common soundwise with the builders you mentioned.

Here, however, I am afraid you are very, very wrong. Every single one of them sounds like a guitar to me!  :humour:

Aboss  :guitar
'06 Larrivee LV-03E
'03 Art & Lutherie Cherrywood

Quoteand actually I haven't played any of the SDs, yet.

I agree with prof_stack, you need to play an SD.
I don't believe any of the Martin D-45's I've played or heard sound any better than my SD-60 which cost much less.
I might add I did not buy the SD-60 because of price, I just like its looks and the sound is incredible.
SD-60 SBT
O-50 TSB
OM-03 Koa
D-09 12 string
Gibson-J50
Gibson Blues King
A gaggle of ukes

Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 01:07:35 PM
I'm sorry, I've said before, but no. No Larrivee sounds anything like a Martin or the boutique builders who make guitars modelled after Martins.

Why should they? Larrivees are Larrivees and Martins are Martins. If you prefer the sound of a Larrivee get one. If you prefer the sound of a Martin, get one. Neither sound is the Holy Grail. In fact, even within the Martin and Larrivee lines, there are different tones....one is not better than the other.

That aside, Larrivee guitars are well made and are often a greater value than Martins of the same price...but only if you prefer the Larrivee tone.

Jim

The higher end martins do "tend" to sound better than Larrivee... ...slightly.  But at what cost?  I've played a few that actually sounded pretty bad, so there is also the consistency issue.  That being said, I've also played absolutely amazing larrivees (much better than average).

I will probably never buy a highend martin.  For that kidn of money, I'd go on to something like Bourgeois or Collings.
Larrivee LSV-05
Larrivee LV-09FM
Larrivee CS-30
Yamaha Chronos LL-16
Yamaha Pacifica 112J
Martin LX-1
Fender American Stratocaster Delux
Fender Mexican Stratocaster
Fender Mexican Telecaster
Rivera Sedon

As far as comparing Martin to Larrivee... that is really a personal opinion. I played a d09 and a d05 and thought they were both great guitars. I think they were around a thousand dollars at the time. I didn't buy a Larrivee. I played a D41 that touched me. It feels right, sounds right and looks the way I want it. Personal preference. BTW.... when you are buying a guitar that you know is a keeper, price plays no part in it.  :thumb
Larrivee OM-03BW
Martin D-41 Special
Gibson Les Paul
Gibson Flying V
Fender Jimmie Vaughan strat
Recording King RK-80 Banjo
Mid seventies Marshall amps
Peavey 5150

Quote from: Calvin on December 08, 2006, 04:11:10 PM
The higher end martins do "tend" to sound better than Larrivee... ...slightly. 

Only to people who prefer that sound.

The higher end Martins are a lot more expensive than higher end Larrivees.

Jim

Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 01:07:35 PM
I'm sorry, I've said before, but no. No Larrivee sounds anything like a Martin or the boutique builders who make guitars modelled after Martins. The only thing they have in common are looks and forward shifted X braces. Larrivee's have symmetrical parabolic bracing (very modern). Martins have scalloped asymmetrical bracing. Also the enlarged soundhole is not traditionally a feature on Martin style guitars. The X braces inside a Santa Cruz OM/PW are about a third as thick as Larrivee's braces. Larrivees are great guitars, but they have nothing in common soundwise with the builders you mentioned.

It's just another opinion (like yours), but I've owned 12 Martins over the years, all high-end instruments- I've also owned and played several Santa Cruz's and Collings, and you're right. The vintage line of Larrivees doesn't sound like them. But these guitars do sound and feel great. Better? It's just a matter of opinion, but having owned many Martins including some true vintage models (from the 1930s) I can honestly say that Larrivees do it for me, while the others have all been sold off along with their various and sundry shortcomings...
Singin' Fool

1997 Taylor Cujo 14
1999 Larrivee OM-10 reserve koa
2003 Taylor PG LTD
2006  Fender GDO500
2008  Taylor GC7

Quote from: Bruce Chiriani on December 08, 2006, 06:54:16 PM
It's just another opinion (like yours), but I've owned 12 Martins over the years, all high-end instruments- I've also owned and played several Santa Cruz's and Collings, and you're right. The vintage line of Larrivees doesn't sound like them. But these guitars do sound and feel great. Better? It's just a matter of opinion, but having owned many Martins including some true vintage models (from the 1930s) I can honestly say that Larrivees do it for me, while the others have all been sold off along with their various and sundry shortcomings...

You said "He vowed a few years back to make high-quality vintage style guitars that would rival Martin, Santa Cruz and Collings at a much lower cost. I'd say that he's made good on his promise, wouldn't you?"
The idea that they successfully built something that rivals those guitars but sounds nothing like them doesn't exactly make sense.

You've said before Jean was looking at those boutique builders "building guitars that pay tribute the golden age of luthiery (1930s and 40s), and believed that he could build guitars in that same tradition at a much lower cost to the consumer. The vintage series has proven him correct." (I assumed that you were keeping with this same line of thought in your reply to this thread)

So he makes a supposed traditional style series thats look's is obvioulsy Martin, except the guitars don't sound like traditional Martins or traditional anythings, but you say he's made good on his promise  :?  I'm sorry but I don't know why you keep bringing those builders up in reference to the traditional series. The traditional series isn't competing with those companies anymore than a OM-03.

Quote from: jwsamuel on December 08, 2006, 03:05:22 PM
Why should they? Larrivees are Larrivees and Martins are Martins. If you prefer the sound of a Larrivee get one. If you prefer the sound of a Martin, get one. Neither sound is the Holy Grail. In fact, even within the Martin and Larrivee lines, there are different tones....one is not better than the other.

That aside, Larrivee guitars are well made and are often a greater value than Martins of the same price...but only if you prefer the Larrivee tone.

Jim
I agree with everything you said.

Quote from: Calvin on December 08, 2006, 04:11:10 PM
I will probably never buy a highend martin.  For that kidn of money, I'd go on to something like Bourgeois or Collings.

Couldn't have said it better myself.  When I'm inspired to pick up a Martin down at the local shop, I cannot see what the fuss is. Can't see ever getting GASsed from a Martin.   I know several of you have posted about some fine Martins that you own, but I find them too quiet and almost muddy.  That's just me, but I guess that's why we don't all own the same model and brand ...

One thing that we can all agree on is that JCL provides great quality within his price range, regardless of the model.

jimmy

I love the sound of Martins and Larrivees and appreciate the tonal differences between the two. Others may prefer the contrast of say Gibson and Taylor, all personal preferences of course. In my opinion there is no "BEST" guitar...just the guitar or guitars that the particular player likes best
Larrivee D-05
Larrivee L-05MT
Larrivee P-05
Martin D-18GE
Martin 0M-42
Rainsong JM1000
Beard Gold Tone round neck
Ibanez AS 103- NT custom
CA Cargo
Collings 01



What I like to do when I'm not murdering perfectly good guitar tunes.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/shutterdancer/

Seem to have started a good Larrivee v Martin debate here however that was not really the objective.

I said

QuoteIf this was a Martin it would have cost at least twice as much and I a/b'd it with many high end Martins and with regard to the sound it was different, brighter somehow, but now way inferior in my opinion.

I didn't say Larrivee was better than Martin but just different and here is the important bit - no way inferior.

My point was I have got a standard series 00016 (yes they did make them) which is a basically a scalloped braced long scale 00018 but with satin finish and plastic bindings. This guitar, now 16 years old, has what I would call the typical Martin sound which is good. The Larrivee has in addition to the Larrivee sound which is also good - abalone inlay on headstock, open engraved tuners, volute, bound ebony finger board with diamond MOP position markers, ebony bridge, herringbone top, abalone rosette, flamed maple binding with additional black/white/black binding front and back, bone saddle, ebony bridge pins with MOP abalone dots and a high gloss finish.

So, I have two different guitars each having a nice sound, neither being inferior soundwise (in my opinion!)than the other but miles apart in materials and 'bling'. The martin cost me £850 in 1991 and the Larrivee £850.00 in 2006.

So which is the better value for money? well unless the Larrivee falls to bits in 10 years logic seems to say Larrivee. Unless of course you want to pay lots more to have the street cred of having Martin on the headstock?

Regards

Phil

"Sacred cows make great hamburgers."

My Larri 000-50- sounds good to me

Martin D-18GE- sounds good to me

Huss & Dalton T-DM- sounds good to me

Collings CW- sounds good to me

Bourgeois Vintage-D- sounds good to me

Opinions kept in the mind are harmless....when they leave the body by tongue or pen (keyboard), well, you know what happens.  As I am getting older and
much more opinionated, I still try to allow others to have their opinion hoping that will allow me to have mine.

Play on my friends.

Larry

<1 or 2 nice ones>

Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 09:15:51 PM
You said "He vowed a few years back to make high-quality vintage style guitars that would rival Martin, Santa Cruz and Collings I'm sorry but I don't know why you keep bringing those builders up in reference to the traditional series. The traditional series isn't competing with those companies anymore than a OM-03.

No need to apologize, but I think we're sort-of splitting hairs here, so I'll try to keep it short and sweet: in spite of the list of guitars owned below, I happen to like the vintage look. However, vintage guitars (whether from the 30s or re-creations) have always fallen short of handling all the various types of music I like to play/perform. Larrivee's vintage series provides the vintage look with a more modern tone and feel that I happen to prefer. Jean Larrivee has created an attactive alternative to Martin, Santa Cruz and Collings for some (but apparently not all) folks, and, like it or not, that puts these guitars in direct competition with the aforementioned makers. By the way, I'm not knocking these other fine guitar brands. If you prefer them and are willing to pay the price, that's all that should matter to you.
Singin' Fool

1997 Taylor Cujo 14
1999 Larrivee OM-10 reserve koa
2003 Taylor PG LTD
2006  Fender GDO500
2008  Taylor GC7

Powered by EzPortal