Main Forums => Larrivée Guitars => Topic started by: PCT57 on December 08, 2006, 12:09:36 PM

Title: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: PCT57 on December 08, 2006, 12:09:36 PM
Its three weeks now since I got the OM-50 and I just can't get over the quality of this thing particularly when compared to the cost.

If this was a Martin it would have cost at least twice as much and I a/b'd it with many high end Martins and with regard to the sound it was different, brighter somehow, but now way inferior in my opinion.

I have a fairly plain 00016 (from new) which is a good guitar with a lovely sound but when you compare it to the Larrivee the is a massive difference in value for money. The Martin cost me in 1991 the same as the OM !! The quality of the materials and 'bling' (awful term) on this guitar is nothing other than stunning - good enough just to sit and look at.

Can anyone explain how Larrivee can do it or is it just that Martin guitars are very overpriced and you pay for the 'history' etc?
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: Bruce Chiriani on December 08, 2006, 12:45:59 PM
I think that its a matter of pride on the part of Jean Larrivee. He believes in a no-nonsense approach to guitar making and marketing. He vowed a few years back to make high-quality vintage style guitars that would rival Martin, Santa Cruz and Collings at a much lower cost. I'd say that he's made good on his promise, wouldn't you?
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 12:55:28 PM
I think it's a matter of opinion. It's possible the Martin name adds to the price. Of course Martin produces alot of models, with lots of variation between models which I'm sure adds to cost. Personally if I were going to spend over 1K on guitar, it probably wouldn't be a Larrivee. I don't think Larrivee produces anything that competes with Martin's standard line. A Martin OM-21 weighs alot less than a OM-09, and I think it sounds alot better too. Of course if you like a more modern sound you will probably like the Larrivee better, or maybe a Taylor.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: Denis on December 08, 2006, 01:03:10 PM
I know how you feel PCT57.  I look at my new L-03 and wonder how can such a nice guitar cost so little.

I recently played a Martin D-28 Marquis, OM-28 Marquis and a D-18GE.  They were all in the $4000 to $5000CDN price range.  Beautiful, well made, quality instruments all of them.  But later, after the boys were in bed, I took out the L-03 and started playing.  I smiled thinking, I paid less than $1000CDN for this guitar including shipping, taxes, brokerage fees, duty...etc everything!!!  And in no way did those three Martins sound $3000 to $4000 "better" than my L-03.  Don't get me wrong, I would buy any, maybe even all, of those Martins if I had the money.  But when you can't afford or don't want to spend $4-5k for a guitar, it's nice to know you can buy a high quality guitar without having to spend the big bucks.  
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: prof_stack on December 08, 2006, 01:07:12 PM
Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 12:55:28 PM
I think it's a matter of opinion.   I don't think Larrivee produces anything that competes with Martin's standard line.
Those are TROLLING words, mister!   :laughin:
You haven't played my SD-50!! Larrivee traditional > Martin standard.  :nana_guitar
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 01:07:35 PM
Quote from: Bruce Chiriani on December 08, 2006, 12:45:59 PM
I think that its a matter of pride on the part of Jean Larrivee. He believes in a no-nonsense approach to guitar making and marketing. He vowed a few years back to make high-quality vintage style guitars that would rival Martin, Santa Cruz and Collings at a much lower cost. I'd say that he's made good on his promise, wouldn't you?

I'm sorry, I've said before, but no. No Larrivee sounds anything like a Martin or the boutique builders who make guitars modelled after Martins. The only thing they have in common are looks and forward shifted X braces. Larrivee's have symmetrical parabolic bracing (very modern). Martins have scalloped asymmetrical bracing. Also the enlarged soundhole is not traditionally a feature on Martin style guitars. The X braces inside a Santa Cruz OM/PW are about a third as thick as Larrivee's braces. Larrivees are great guitars, but they have nothing in common soundwise with the builders you mentioned.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 01:18:27 PM
Quote from: prof_stack on December 08, 2006, 01:07:12 PM
Those are TROLLING words, mister!   :laughin:
You haven't played my SD-50!! Larrivee traditional > Martin standard.  :nana_guitar

I meant in the Larrivees in the price range of the Martin standard line, when compared to the Martin standard line. In other words if I were going to buy a guitar in that price range, I probably would go with Martin over Larrivee. However I could totally understand someone liking any Larrive over any Martin, its just that if I were to spend that kind of money it probably wouldn't be on a Larrivee.

and actually I haven't played any of the SDs, yet.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: aboss on December 08, 2006, 01:20:26 PM
Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 01:07:35 PM
No Larrivee sounds anything like a Martin or the boutique builders who make guitars modelled after Martins.

You're absolutely right. Larrivee guitars sound way better than similar style/price martins  :laughin:

...but clearly thats a matter of personal preference. To each his own.  :cheers

Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 01:07:35 PM
Larrivees are great guitars, but they have nothing in common soundwise with the builders you mentioned.

Here, however, I am afraid you are very, very wrong. Every single one of them sounds like a guitar to me!  :humour:

Aboss  :guitar
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: PortHueneme on December 08, 2006, 02:45:49 PM
Quoteand actually I haven't played any of the SDs, yet.

I agree with prof_stack, you need to play an SD.
I don't believe any of the Martin D-45's I've played or heard sound any better than my SD-60 which cost much less.
I might add I did not buy the SD-60 because of price, I just like its looks and the sound is incredible.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jwsamuel on December 08, 2006, 03:05:22 PM
Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 01:07:35 PM
I'm sorry, I've said before, but no. No Larrivee sounds anything like a Martin or the boutique builders who make guitars modelled after Martins.

Why should they? Larrivees are Larrivees and Martins are Martins. If you prefer the sound of a Larrivee get one. If you prefer the sound of a Martin, get one. Neither sound is the Holy Grail. In fact, even within the Martin and Larrivee lines, there are different tones....one is not better than the other.

That aside, Larrivee guitars are well made and are often a greater value than Martins of the same price...but only if you prefer the Larrivee tone.

Jim
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: Calvin on December 08, 2006, 04:11:10 PM
The higher end martins do "tend" to sound better than Larrivee... ...slightly.  But at what cost?  I've played a few that actually sounded pretty bad, so there is also the consistency issue.  That being said, I've also played absolutely amazing larrivees (much better than average).

I will probably never buy a highend martin.  For that kidn of money, I'd go on to something like Bourgeois or Collings.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jessz1 on December 08, 2006, 05:20:41 PM
As far as comparing Martin to Larrivee... that is really a personal opinion. I played a d09 and a d05 and thought they were both great guitars. I think they were around a thousand dollars at the time. I didn't buy a Larrivee. I played a D41 that touched me. It feels right, sounds right and looks the way I want it. Personal preference. BTW.... when you are buying a guitar that you know is a keeper, price plays no part in it.  :thumb
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jwsamuel on December 08, 2006, 05:53:15 PM
Quote from: Calvin on December 08, 2006, 04:11:10 PM
The higher end martins do "tend" to sound better than Larrivee... ...slightly. 

Only to people who prefer that sound.

The higher end Martins are a lot more expensive than higher end Larrivees.

Jim
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: Bruce Chiriani on December 08, 2006, 06:54:16 PM
Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 01:07:35 PM
I'm sorry, I've said before, but no. No Larrivee sounds anything like a Martin or the boutique builders who make guitars modelled after Martins. The only thing they have in common are looks and forward shifted X braces. Larrivee's have symmetrical parabolic bracing (very modern). Martins have scalloped asymmetrical bracing. Also the enlarged soundhole is not traditionally a feature on Martin style guitars. The X braces inside a Santa Cruz OM/PW are about a third as thick as Larrivee's braces. Larrivees are great guitars, but they have nothing in common soundwise with the builders you mentioned.

It's just another opinion (like yours), but I've owned 12 Martins over the years, all high-end instruments- I've also owned and played several Santa Cruz's and Collings, and you're right. The vintage line of Larrivees doesn't sound like them. But these guitars do sound and feel great. Better? It's just a matter of opinion, but having owned many Martins including some true vintage models (from the 1930s) I can honestly say that Larrivees do it for me, while the others have all been sold off along with their various and sundry shortcomings...
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 09:15:51 PM
Quote from: Bruce Chiriani on December 08, 2006, 06:54:16 PM
It's just another opinion (like yours), but I've owned 12 Martins over the years, all high-end instruments- I've also owned and played several Santa Cruz's and Collings, and you're right. The vintage line of Larrivees doesn't sound like them. But these guitars do sound and feel great. Better? It's just a matter of opinion, but having owned many Martins including some true vintage models (from the 1930s) I can honestly say that Larrivees do it for me, while the others have all been sold off along with their various and sundry shortcomings...

You said "He vowed a few years back to make high-quality vintage style guitars that would rival Martin, Santa Cruz and Collings at a much lower cost. I'd say that he's made good on his promise, wouldn't you?"
The idea that they successfully built something that rivals those guitars but sounds nothing like them doesn't exactly make sense.

You've said before Jean was looking at those boutique builders "building guitars that pay tribute the golden age of luthiery (1930s and 40s), and believed that he could build guitars in that same tradition at a much lower cost to the consumer. The vintage series has proven him correct." (I assumed that you were keeping with this same line of thought in your reply to this thread)

So he makes a supposed traditional style series thats look's is obvioulsy Martin, except the guitars don't sound like traditional Martins or traditional anythings, but you say he's made good on his promise  :?  I'm sorry but I don't know why you keep bringing those builders up in reference to the traditional series. The traditional series isn't competing with those companies anymore than a OM-03.

Quote from: jwsamuel on December 08, 2006, 03:05:22 PM
Why should they? Larrivees are Larrivees and Martins are Martins. If you prefer the sound of a Larrivee get one. If you prefer the sound of a Martin, get one. Neither sound is the Holy Grail. In fact, even within the Martin and Larrivee lines, there are different tones....one is not better than the other.

That aside, Larrivee guitars are well made and are often a greater value than Martins of the same price...but only if you prefer the Larrivee tone.

Jim
I agree with everything you said.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jimmy buffett on December 08, 2006, 09:58:09 PM
Quote from: Calvin on December 08, 2006, 04:11:10 PM
I will probably never buy a highend martin.  For that kidn of money, I'd go on to something like Bourgeois or Collings.

Couldn't have said it better myself.  When I'm inspired to pick up a Martin down at the local shop, I cannot see what the fuss is. Can't see ever getting GASsed from a Martin.   I know several of you have posted about some fine Martins that you own, but I find them too quiet and almost muddy.  That's just me, but I guess that's why we don't all own the same model and brand ...

One thing that we can all agree on is that JCL provides great quality within his price range, regardless of the model.

jimmy
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: Stringdancer on December 09, 2006, 04:20:07 AM
I love the sound of Martins and Larrivees and appreciate the tonal differences between the two. Others may prefer the contrast of say Gibson and Taylor, all personal preferences of course. In my opinion there is no "BEST" guitar...just the guitar or guitars that the particular player likes best
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: PCT57 on December 09, 2006, 05:11:48 AM
Seem to have started a good Larrivee v Martin debate here however that was not really the objective.

I said

QuoteIf this was a Martin it would have cost at least twice as much and I a/b'd it with many high end Martins and with regard to the sound it was different, brighter somehow, but now way inferior in my opinion.

I didn't say Larrivee was better than Martin but just different and here is the important bit - no way inferior.

My point was I have got a standard series 00016 (yes they did make them) which is a basically a scalloped braced long scale 00018 but with satin finish and plastic bindings. This guitar, now 16 years old, has what I would call the typical Martin sound which is good. The Larrivee has in addition to the Larrivee sound which is also good - abalone inlay on headstock, open engraved tuners, volute, bound ebony finger board with diamond MOP position markers, ebony bridge, herringbone top, abalone rosette, flamed maple binding with additional black/white/black binding front and back, bone saddle, ebony bridge pins with MOP abalone dots and a high gloss finish.

So, I have two different guitars each having a nice sound, neither being inferior soundwise (in my opinion!)than the other but miles apart in materials and 'bling'. The martin cost me £850 in 1991 and the Larrivee £850.00 in 2006.

So which is the better value for money? well unless the Larrivee falls to bits in 10 years logic seems to say Larrivee. Unless of course you want to pay lots more to have the street cred of having Martin on the headstock?

Regards

Phil
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: ElJefe on December 09, 2006, 09:45:05 AM
"Sacred cows make great hamburgers."

My Larri 000-50- sounds good to me

Martin D-18GE- sounds good to me

Huss & Dalton T-DM- sounds good to me

Collings CW- sounds good to me

Bourgeois Vintage-D- sounds good to me

Opinions kept in the mind are harmless....when they leave the body by tongue or pen (keyboard), well, you know what happens.  As I am getting older and
much more opinionated, I still try to allow others to have their opinion hoping that will allow me to have mine.

Play on my friends.

Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: Bruce Chiriani on December 09, 2006, 06:47:39 PM
Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 08, 2006, 09:15:51 PM
You said "He vowed a few years back to make high-quality vintage style guitars that would rival Martin, Santa Cruz and Collings I'm sorry but I don't know why you keep bringing those builders up in reference to the traditional series. The traditional series isn't competing with those companies anymore than a OM-03.

No need to apologize, but I think we're sort-of splitting hairs here, so I'll try to keep it short and sweet: in spite of the list of guitars owned below, I happen to like the vintage look. However, vintage guitars (whether from the 30s or re-creations) have always fallen short of handling all the various types of music I like to play/perform. Larrivee's vintage series provides the vintage look with a more modern tone and feel that I happen to prefer. Jean Larrivee has created an attactive alternative to Martin, Santa Cruz and Collings for some (but apparently not all) folks, and, like it or not, that puts these guitars in direct competition with the aforementioned makers. By the way, I'm not knocking these other fine guitar brands. If you prefer them and are willing to pay the price, that's all that should matter to you.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jeremy3220 on December 09, 2006, 09:14:15 PM
Quote from: Bruce Chiriani on December 09, 2006, 06:47:39 PM
No need to apologize, but I think we're sort-of splitting hairs here, so I'll try to keep it short and sweet: in spite of the list of guitars owned below, I happen to like the vintage look. However, vintage guitars (whether from the 30s or re-creations) have always fallen short of handling all the various types of music I like to play/perform. Larrivee's vintage series provides the vintage look with a more modern tone and feel that I happen to prefer. Jean Larrivee has created an attactive alternative to Martin, Santa Cruz and Collings for some (but apparently not all) folks, and, like it or not, that puts these guitars in direct competition with the aforementioned makers. By the way, I'm not knocking these other fine guitar brands. If you prefer them and are willing to pay the price, that's all that should matter to you.

Ok I gotta ya. I agree a modern sounding guitar with traditional looks is a good idea. Usually a modern sound means you're stuck with modern looks. I do think perhaps you ought to clarify that next time. It would save alot of confusion ,since I think most people will be thinking in terms of sound when talking about a guitar being a rival/alternative to another guitar. I would agree the Larrivee traditional series makes a great alternative to the others as far as looks goes.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: aboss on December 09, 2006, 10:35:29 PM
Quote from: Stringdancer on December 09, 2006, 04:20:07 AM
I love the sound of Martins and Larrivees and appreciate the tonal differences between the two.

Says a person with 2 of each!  :bgrin: You should know!

I wish i had the money to be able to "appreciate the tonal differences" Haha.  :humour:
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: Novalis on December 10, 2006, 12:05:18 AM
How to make such a quality instrument for much less than others currently on the market? This is actually a question I asked myself recently when looking for my latest guitar. Let me say first off that I have a great appreciation for other makes (Martin, Taylor, etc..) and can understand why those guitars have the great reputation that they have earned (lots of friends have Martins and Taylors and most of them sound fantastic). That being said, for the money I spent on my SD-50, there isn't another brand even close in quality, craftsmanship, or sound.

I didn't buy the SD-50 hoping it would sound or look like a Martin. I bought it because it was the very best 12 fret dreadnought within my price range. In fact, there wasn't ANY other guitar even REMOTELY close to the quality of my SD-50 at the price I paid. I'm a bargain hunter and I'm glad I bought my Larrivee before they get to be more well-known and the price goes up. And no, my Larrivee SD-50 does not sound like a Martin or Santa Cruz. It sounds like a Larrivee SD-50, just like it should.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: bluesman67 on December 10, 2006, 11:46:18 AM
First Act guitars get my vote! :thumb :niceguitar:
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: ccarnucci on December 12, 2006, 04:43:02 PM
How does Larrivee do it?

I just wanted to pipe in...  BTW since I'm new here I'll say "HELLO"!

Congrats on your New Larrivee!!!!!!

And I just wanted to add...If you think it sounds good now, wait till it ages and opens up.  It will blow your mind !   :bgrin:

I have a D02 I purchased like 5 -8 years ago and as its ages it just keeps sounding better and better. 

But keep playing it...alot.  not only time (as the wood ages) but also playing the guitar makes them open up .  I cant prove this but I find that guitars that arent played but every "so often" do not open up as well as ones that are played often.

And for a side note....  After having my D02 for about three months I sent a letter to Larrivee basically thanking them for building such a wonderful instrument (that I could actually afford. Payed about $450 I think).  The last lines of my letter said...

Thank you...Thank you...Thank you...

Thier responce was a simple as thier approach to guitar making...the letter simply said ...


Your welcome...Your welcome...Your welcome! 

I thought that was cute!





Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: ducktrapper on December 12, 2006, 05:06:46 PM
People will always argue that different is better. Whatever. I look at it as, GUITAR MAKING IS NOT MAGIC. If you have a proven design, similar top grade materials and the skill to build a flawless box, you'll probably do alright. You could be the flavour of the week. Does Kevin Ryan build a better guitar than Jean Larrivée? Jean Larrivée WAS Kevin Ryan before Kevin Ryan. Only he was in Toronto influencing Bruce Cockburn instead of in L.A. having Jackson Browne et al buy one. Kismet.
How does JCL do it? Design improvements. CNC. His own sawmill or just plain ... wood! Martin still putting plastic fingerboards on fairly expensive guitars? Gee! What's this? My all solid wood $600.00 Larrivée has an ebony fingerboard? Hmmm.   
As for Martin? There's 100+ years of loyalty that I'm not going to argue against. Unfortunately, I find that the Martins I like tend to already belong to someone or have a price tag that just does not compute. YMMV.     
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: Bruce Chiriani on December 13, 2006, 07:42:31 AM
Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 09, 2006, 09:14:15 PM
I think most people will be thinking in terms of sound when talking about a guitar being a rival/alternative to another guitar. I would agree the Larrivee traditional series makes a great alternative to the others as far as looks goes.

The only other thing you must consider is that an OM-60 does not sound like an OM-10 (although the same woods are used). While I would not imply that an OM-60 sounds just like a Santa Cruz, Martin or Collings OM (as it shouldn't , by the way), I would say that it has a decidedly drier, more vintage sound than its standard series counterpart. Wouldn't you agree?
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jeremy3220 on December 13, 2006, 10:06:26 AM
Quote from: Bruce Chiriani on December 13, 2006, 07:42:31 AM
The only other thing you must consider is that an OM-60 does not sound like an OM-10 (although the same woods are used). While I would not imply that an OM-60 sounds just like a Santa Cruz, Martin or Collings OM (as it shouldn't , by the way), I would say that it has a decidedly drier, more vintage sound than its standard series counterpart. Wouldn't you agree?

Yes I think the differences between the standard and traditional series moves the traditional models more toward a vintage sound. Still they sound way more Larrivee like that vintage. If Larrivee standards were on one side of a football field (American) and Martin, Cruz, Bourgeois vintage Martin style models on the other, the Larrivee traditionals only made it to their 20 yard line (In my scientific opinion  :winkin: ) So if we are only talking about sound, I still say a OM-60 is not an alternative to a Martin OM-28V/SCGC OM/PW / Bourgeois Vintage OM.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: ducktrapper on December 13, 2006, 10:54:36 AM
Fortunately, at Larrivée they are playing hockey not American football.  See all those little guys skating circles around the big lugs? That's the future you're looking at.  :beer
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jwsamuel on December 13, 2006, 11:00:46 AM
Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 13, 2006, 10:06:26 AM
Still they sound way more Larrivee like that vintage.

Gee.....could that be because they ARE Larrivees?


Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 13, 2006, 10:06:26 AMSo if we are only talking about sound, I still say a OM-60 is not an alternative to a Martin OM-28V/SCGC OM/PW / Bourgeois Vintage OM.

Sure it is...if you prefer the Larrivee sound.

Every time a thread like this starts, the thing that annoys me is the insistence by some people that everything must be compared to the "Martin sound" as if the Martin sound is a standard set in stone. It isn't.

The Martin sound, whatever it is, is only one tone among a variety of sounds available in the marketplace. If you like it, fine. If you prefer Larrivee, fine. If you prefer Collings, that's fine too.

Judge each guitar on its own and how pleasing the sound is to your ears.

Jim   
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jeremy3220 on December 13, 2006, 12:38:51 PM
Quote from: jwsamuel on December 13, 2006, 11:00:46 AM
Gee.....could that be because they ARE Larrivees?


Sure it is...if you prefer the Larrivee sound.

Every time a thread like this starts, the thing that annoys me is the insistence by some people that everything must be compared to the "Martin sound" as if the Martin sound is a standard set in stone. It isn't.

The Martin sound, whatever it is, is only one tone among a variety of sounds available in the marketplace. If you like it, fine. If you prefer Larrivee, fine. If you prefer Collings, that's fine too.

Judge each guitar on its own and how pleasing the sound is to your ears.

Jim   


:doh

Your all up in the Kool-aid and don't even know the flavor. Please do not quote me and make irrelevant statements as if you are being informative. Bruce and I were having a discussion an a certain topic, not related to whatever point you are making.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: ducktrapper on December 13, 2006, 01:05:53 PM
Yes Jeremy! We have all drank the Kool Aid. I'm biting my tongue here, dood.  :tongue:
Btw if you want a private conversation, this isn't the place for it. 
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jwsamuel on December 13, 2006, 02:14:04 PM
Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 13, 2006, 12:38:51 PM
Your all up in the Kool-aid and don't even know the flavor. Please do not quote me and make irrelevant statements as if you are being informative. Bruce and I were having a discussion an a certain topic, not related to whatever point you are making.

Jeremy, all you are doing is trying to measure everything against martin and yet you accuse me of Kool-Aid?

The fact is that I own two Martins and a Larrivee, so don't tell me I am getting caught up in anything. My two Martins -- a D-28 and an 000-18 - sound different from one another. And they both sound different from my Larrivee. That's why I have them all.

All you are doing is holding "the Martin sound" as if it is the end all and be all of everything. The fact is, there IS NO Martin sound. Different models of Martin sound different from one another. Yet, you keep talking about it as if there is one sound. That's being irrelevant.

The fact is that if all guitars sounded alike, there would be no need for different brands. Yet, having eveything sound like a Martin seems to be you misguided ideal.

So Jeremy, you get off the Kool-Aid. Stop being so single minded that guitars from Nazareth are the standard against which all should be judged. They aren't.

As for you and Bruce having a discussion, take it private if you don't want others joining in.

Jim
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: cowinds on December 13, 2006, 03:56:10 PM
I like all acoustics for what they are.   I love my Taylors and my Larrivee.  Each has their own sound and they are both good.  I like Martins too, but just haven't owned one, but I would like to someday.  I think what makes a guitar line great is how different they are for one another.  Same goes for electrics.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jeremy3220 on December 13, 2006, 04:28:00 PM
Quote from: jwsamuel on December 13, 2006, 02:14:04 PM
Jeremy, all you are doing is trying to measure everything against martin and yet you accuse me of Kool-Aid?

The fact is that I own two Martins and a Larrivee, so don't tell me I am getting caught up in anything. My two Martins -- a D-28 and an 000-18 - sound different from one another. And they both sound different from my Larrivee. That's why I have them all.

All you are doing is holding "the Martin sound" as if it is the end all and be all of everything. The fact is, there IS NO Martin sound. Different models of Martin sound different from one another. Yet, you keep talking about it as if there is one sound. That's being irrelevant.

The fact is that if all guitars sounded alike, there would be no need for different brands. Yet, having eveything sound like a Martin seems to be you misguided ideal.
So Jeremy, you get off the Kool-Aid. Stop being so single minded that guitars from Nazareth are the standard against which all should be judged. They aren't.

As for you and Bruce having a discussion, take it private if you don't want others joining in.

Jim

Quote from: ducktrapper on December 13, 2006, 01:05:53 PM
Yes Jeremy! We have all drank the Kool Aid. I'm biting my tongue here, dood.  :tongue:
Btw if you want a private conversation, this isn't the place for it. 

:laughin: You both didn't get the kool-aid remark. It has nothing to do with forum lingo(meaning blind brand loyalty or whatever). All up in the kool-aid and not knowing the flavor means you're all up in the conversation not knowing what it is about. I didn't say I wanted the conversation to be private, but it would be nice before you jump in the middle of it, to know what it was about. Go back and read(maybe multiple times) all of mine and Bruce's conversation and maybe you'll see that the only point I was getting at is that  the Larrivee traditional models are not based on the same design philosophy(Martin) as the builders he mentioned(more specifically those builder's models designed after vintage Martin's).

The post of mine you quoted first had nothing to do with Martins being better or that Larrivee should sound like Martins.
"Gee.....could that be because they ARE Larrivees?"
No -CENSORED-.

"Sure it is...if you prefer the Larrivee sound."
No, the others having something in common... the Larrivee doesn't have that thing in common.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: ducktrapper on December 13, 2006, 05:21:15 PM
Oh in that case I have to say, " Well no kidding!"  I thought it rather obvious that the Larrivée traditional series were trying to visually offer a guitar that didn't immediately turn off bluegrassers etc. They might actually pick one up. Other than that, I believe Jean L. had no intention of them feeling and sounding like anything other than Larrivées. Some of us here actually prefer them. If a bluegrasser picks one up, he might too. It's not all about Martin. Hasn't been for a long time.
Personally, I generally like the Larrivée style Larrivées over the traditional series anyway.  The OOO-50 being my one exception so far.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jwsamuel on December 13, 2006, 07:01:46 PM
Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 13, 2006, 04:28:00 PMGo back and read(maybe multiple times) all of mine and Bruce's conversation and maybe you'll see that the only point I was getting at is that  the Larrivee traditional models are not based on the same design philosophy(Martin) as the builders he mentioned(more specifically those builder's models designed after vintage Martin's).

No, that is not the only point you made because you followed that up by saying that Larrivees were only on the 20 yeard line.

"Sure it is...if you prefer the Larrivee sound."

Quote from: jeremy3220 on December 13, 2006, 04:28:00 PMNo, the others having something in common... the Larrivee doesn't have that thing in common.

And perhaps Larrivees don;t have anything in common because they are Larrivees. As for the other brands you mention, they have as much in common with Martin as Larrivee's Traditional series does. They are all variations on a theme and they all have their differences.

Jim
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jwsamuel on December 13, 2006, 07:03:29 PM
Quote from: ducktrapper on December 13, 2006, 05:21:15 PM
Personally, I generally like the Larrivée style Larrivées over the traditional series anyway.

Me too. To get to your other point, I do know a guy who is a flatpicker with all Martins. He recently tried a Larrivee D-50 after being insistent that he did not like Larrivees. And, he liked it.

Jim
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jeremy3220 on December 13, 2006, 07:15:33 PM
Quote from: jwsamuel on December 13, 2006, 07:01:46 PM
No, that is not the only point you made because you followed that up by saying that Larrivees were only on the 20 yeard line.

"Sure it is...if you prefer the Larrivee sound."

And perhaps Larrivees don;t have anything in common because they are Larrivees. As for the other brands you mention, they have as much in common with Martin as Larrivee's Traditional series does. They are all variations on a theme and they all have their differences.

Jim

Ok fine you're right. I think Larrivees suck I would never buy one.  you  didn't miss the point, Larrivees are only 20% as good as a Martin. Thats why all my guitars are Martins.

and yes those other manufacture's guitar based on Martins are no closer than Larrivee; despite having very similar bracing patterns unlike Larrivee.

Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: ducktrapper on December 13, 2006, 07:45:15 PM
Why does anyone else bother to build a guitar, I ask you?  :?
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: tuffythepug on December 13, 2006, 09:05:29 PM
Excuse me for intruding on this argument but am I missing something here ?   The original thread started by Phil last week was simply asking how Larrivee can make the caliber of guitars that they make (apparently up and down their impressive line of products) and offer them at prices far below many other "top name" brands.  Yes he used Martin as a measurement of price comparison between two very fine guitar manufacturers.  To those who have said that all guitars sound different I say amen and thank God.  If they all sounded the same I would not be able to get the sounds I get out of my Guild Maple Jumbo, Gibson Hummingbird, and Larrivvee OM-03.
Does one sound "better" than the other ?  No.   Different ? abosultely.

I've only been a Larrivee owner for a couple of weeks but I can already see that when compared to other top name production guitar builders Larrivee gives you more bang for your buck.  That's just my opinion but I think most would agree.  They wil never take the place of Martin and I really don't believe that is their goal.
So, back to the original question:   HOW DOES LARRIVEE DO IT ?

Thanks for letting me chime in.

Lynn
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: Caleb on December 13, 2006, 09:12:56 PM
(http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/f/ff/Kool-AidMan.jpg)
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: tuffythepug on December 13, 2006, 10:01:40 PM
I'm new here.  Was that last post a slam at me ?

Lynn
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jwsamuel on December 13, 2006, 10:04:14 PM
Quote from: tuffythepug on December 13, 2006, 09:05:29 PM
So, back to the original question:   HOW DOES LARRIVEE DO IT ?


Well, I think one thing that contributes is the simplicity of the line. Larrivee does not have as many different models to keep track of as other manufacturers. No custom orders, no signature lines. That lets it have a more efficient operation and that means less overhead.

Jim
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: sayheyjeff on December 13, 2006, 10:09:23 PM
Sorry to see an interesting thread go down the tubes like this.  Personally, I think there are a few too many posts here where the objective of discussing guitars and music has been relegated to 2nd tier - if not forgotten altogether -  and its a shame.  While my other favorite forum is posting lessons, music recorded for feedback and everyone's appreciation, discussions of the benefits to be derived from playing this guitar or listening to that musician, raising funds for someone in need, and how nice it was that folks could devote the time and effort to get together and play together at someone's house in another state once or twice a year, a few folks here get off track and focus on "one upping someone in an argument" (and one based on subjective opinion rather than FACT at that).  I hope it ends before moderators have to step in and remind folks we have rules and what they are for.  Otherwise, we will lose folks like Lynn (thanks for your post).

jeff
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: Caleb on December 13, 2006, 10:53:39 PM
Quote from: tuffythepug on December 13, 2006, 10:01:40 PM
I'm new here.  Was that last post a slam at me ?

Lynn
just an attempt at humor. 
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: jimmy buffett on December 14, 2006, 08:47:25 AM
Quote from: sayheyjeff on December 13, 2006, 10:09:23 PM
Sorry to see an interesting thread go down the tubes like this.  Personally, I think there are a few too many posts here where the objective of discussing guitars and music has been relegated to 2nd tier - if not forgotten altogether -  and its a shame...a few folks here get off track and focus on "one upping someone in an argument" I hope it ends before moderators have to step in and remind folks we have rules and what they are for.  Otherwise, we will lose folks like Lynn (thanks for your post).

jeff

Thanks for stating the obvious, Jeff.  It was time that someone stepped up and reminded us that this type of running commentary serves no useful purpose, and in the end will only result in the loss of people who contribute something positive.  People who come here to talk about guitars.  I think that we can share ideas and exchange opinions without turning this into a free for all. What purpose do these remarks serve?

jimmy
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: ducktrapper on December 14, 2006, 09:39:18 AM
I believe most of us were actually trying to address the original question. It sounded like a bunch of Koolaid drinkers? Well, this IS the Larrivée Forum. Many of us love our guitars. Surprise! Except in die hard minds, Martin has not been the sine que non of guitars for several years now. Whatever that means. I knew the minute I played a chord on my 1975 L09 that my Martin obsession was over. Perhaps this is unsettling for some. The world turned upside down. Change is good. 
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: Peter Cree on December 14, 2006, 10:07:02 AM
I love my Martins.

I love my Om-03mt and my parlor.

And I don't know how Larrivee does it and still make money.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: inspector13 on December 14, 2006, 10:45:42 AM
Diversity is what makes the music and guitar industries go round and thrive. If the Martins, Taylors and Larrivees of the world all sounded alike there would anly be one brand ( I think we can agree on that ). WE are fortunate there are so many qualities guitars made and we have found the ones that we enjoy playing.

For the most part this forum is a very friendly place so lets all join together around the campfire and sing Kumbaya while Unclrob plays for us.

(http://i139.photobucket.com/albums/q282/inspecter13/campfire.jpg)
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: PCT57 on December 14, 2006, 03:48:04 PM
Tuffy said:

QuoteExcuse me for intruding on this argument but am I missing something here ?   The original thread started by Phil last week was simply asking how Larrivee can make the caliber of guitars that they make (apparently up and down their impressive line of products) and offer them at prices far below many other "top name" brands.

Quite correct and thanks for the informative answers.

I am amazed at how this thread has carried on. Perhaps we can put it to bed now. :wave

Also still amazed at my Larrivee :thumbsup
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: Bruce Chiriani on December 14, 2006, 06:54:50 PM
I just want to apologize to everyone for my part in this discussion, which I thought was a good one until things got nasty. I guess I'll just end with my own stated opinion: I think that Larrivee's traditional series compares quite favorably with Martin, Santa Cruz, Collings and Bourgois (sp?) in the A/B tests that I've personally performed in the past couple of years. Having said that, I'm always pleasantly surprised by the Larrivee's pricing, which is considerably lower than comparable models in the aforementioned brands. For me, that's a wonderful thing, but for those who disagree, I guess it's not so wonderful...

Again, sorry this thread got out of hand...
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: Novalis on December 14, 2006, 08:39:39 PM
Quote from: Bruce Chiriani on December 14, 2006, 06:54:50 PM
Again, sorry this thread got out of hand...
Maybe I've been missing something. I don't see anything wrong here, just lively debate. Isn't that part of what we look for in a forum? :?
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: bluesman67 on December 14, 2006, 08:46:33 PM
Overhead.  Overhead.  Overhead.  The bigger the overhead, the bigger the price to the consumer.

In the 90's, I worked for Canon's largest distributor in North America (the copier company).  Canon didn't care if you sold a $1000 copier or a $100,000 copier.  The dealership did, but Canon didn't.  They only cared about how many unit (of anything) that were sold, because they made the same profit on each and every single unit that left the production floor.

If Martin could lower the cost of their guitars, they would, to take marketshare from Taylor, Guild, etc.  But they are locked into their overhead, from the cost per square foot of factory space, to labor, marketing, etc.  I doubt that they even make more profit per guitar than Larrivee.  
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: ducktrapper on December 15, 2006, 11:00:48 AM
I agree. No one's giving away guitars. But who wants to pay a lot more for something other than the guitar?
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: gtrplayer on December 15, 2006, 04:37:07 PM
my 2 cents worth

IMO Larrivee guitars, as most here will agree, are the "best bang for the buck" out there. And personally I love the sound of them. I own a 000-50, 00-50 and an OM-50 and think they're excellent guitars. I also own an old Gibson J-40 and a Martin D-35 that get very little playing time. I'm primarily a fingerpicker which probably explains why the dreads don't get much use.

With respect to the initial query as to how does Larrivee does it, I suspect lower profit margins with the hopes of eventually capturing a bigger slice of the market.  Martin, Taylor, Collings, etc., have established credentials, name recognition, client loyalty, gravitas, yadda, yadda, which affords them the ability to charge more. It doesn't mean there product is superior nor inferior, it's just what the market supports.

To me Larrivees are a great deal for IMO a great sounding instrument.

gtrplayer :bgrin:
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: Gemnoc on December 17, 2006, 02:05:45 PM
Quote from: bluesman67 on December 14, 2006, 08:46:33 PM
Overhead.  Overhead.  Overhead.  The bigger the overhead, the bigger the price to the consumer.
I believe you've nailed it. The Larrivées (Jean, Wendy, John, Matthew) do their share of work on the guitars, they work on weekends... No big marketing department and a small budget, the mere fact that you are one person away from talking over the phone to Brian at customer service (I would be intrigued to know if you can get a human being that fast through Martin or Taylor CS?), all this makes up for the lower prices.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: oczad on December 17, 2006, 06:03:38 PM
I think it just boils down to sheer talent in design and pride. Tone depends on quality of materials and design. I don't think Larrivee has better material quality than the other high end builders. So that leaves design. We know bracing for example is a huge contributor to tone.  Jean's design from what i have read is unique and may well be a big prt of why they can build guitars that are so good and sell the cheaper. The others may have to spend more time and money to find ways of getting the same degree of tone from lesser bracing designs. just a thought and i may be wrong. But that bracing design really is a huge bonus because whatever degree to which it is responsible for tone, the advantage it has over other designs in holding the top flat is in itself a monumental advance. It's one of the reasons Larrivees keep such a consstant action during seasonal changes.  But back to the subject, i think one definate reason for the bang for the buck of thier line is a real simple one.......they are not a huge company with a bunch of suits at the top living in huge mansions with fleets of Jags and mercededs in the garage. It appears that Jean and family are one of those rare small companies where the owners get thier hands dirty and care deeply about thier art. Theres a lot to be said for that besides being partly if not wholy responsible for the excellent value.  Surely you'll not find such a situation at martin. Maybe in years past but not today. If i had to guess i'd say those 2 factors are the reason......a unique and toneful design and a tight knit family who don't put the almighty dollar before thier pride. Gotta love them ! Speaking of bang for the buck, seagulls are another one that gives you more tone for the money in thier lower end market than anyone lese. And also a canadian builder.....must be something in the air up there !
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: sdelsolray on December 17, 2006, 08:06:20 PM
Yeah, this thread certainly did get off track from the usual Larrivee owners' self-love fest.  Glad to see it getting back on track.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: rrgguitarman on December 18, 2006, 03:05:07 AM
QuoteSpeaking of bang for the buck, seagulls are another one that gives you more tone for the money in thier lower end market than anyone lese. And also a canadian builder.....must be something in the air up there ! 

:+1:
I've purchased Larrivees and Seagulls not because I couldn't afford brand X but, because I love the sound and value you get for your hard earned money.
Title: Re: How do Larrivee do it?
Post by: Queequeg on December 18, 2006, 08:34:28 AM
Quote from: Stringdancer on December 09, 2006, 04:20:07 AM
I love the sound of Martins and Larrivees and appreciate the tonal differences between the two. Others may prefer the contrast of say Gibson and Taylor, all personal preferences of course. In my opinion there is no "BEST" guitar...just the guitar or guitars that the particular player likes best
So true, and yet apparently such a difficult concept for some...

my father, now years long dead and gone used to have a real conversation stopper, when someone, often myself, would profer an opinion, and Dad would aver, "You're wrong!"


You can get your facts or statistcs wrong.

You can make a wrong turn.

And maybe even "you mighta did somebody wrong"


But, remember this: Your feelings and opinions can never be wrong.