What humidification system do you use?

Started by mikey007, September 22, 2024, 12:23:21 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

We're living in a condo for a few months so I can't use my whole room humidifier this winter. Previously I used oasis but I just switched over to Boveda. We'll see how they do in the dead of the Canadian Winter.
Larrivee LV03R
Larrivee OO-40 Pearl Edition
Larrivee OM-40WL JCL
Taylor 426CE Spring Limited

In my guitar room, I use a Levoit humidifier that costs about $70 through Amazon. The room temperature is currently 73 degrees and the RH is 48%. With the AC running, I fill it every 2-3 days.

My guitars stay in their cases when they're not being played and I have experienced zero humidity related issues. Most of my guitars are acoustics and range between 2 and 48 years of age. I also have a new Larrivee Electric BAKER-T Pro that is three months old,

I have Venta and Vornado humidifiers. It used to be for the guitar room but I have a couple and they do the whole house now. I also use boveda packs (similar to the Daddario things) but not for my guitars.

I've always had good luck with Boveda and I'm currently using it now. I usually rehydrate them from time to time to get more life out of them.
2004 Larrivee OM-03R
2018 Larrivee D-40 SOLD
2004 Larrivee D-03R SOLD

I actually went with the Boveda/Daddario 2-way system. Just seemed like the best for me now until our house is built. Once it's built, I can go back to the evap40.
Larrivee LV03R
Larrivee OO-40 Pearl Edition
Larrivee OM-40WL JCL
Taylor 426CE Spring Limited

Quote from: mikey007 on October 20, 2024, 01:03:26 PMI actually went with the Boveda/Daddario 2-way system. Just seemed like the best for me now until our house is built. Once it's built, I can go back to the evap40.
Probably not on the dryness level of Canada in OK, but still wouldn't mind that Evap40 in the bedroom at night, and it sounds like it's fairly easy to clean too!
2004 Larrivee OM-03R
2018 Larrivee D-40 SOLD
2004 Larrivee D-03R SOLD

In S.E PA (mid- Atlantic area) have have found the Music Nomad humidifier (suspended in the sound hole) combined with the Herco humidifier maintains the proper relative humidity pretty effectively. The wetness has to be checked every couple of weeks, which is no big deal with a hygrometer in the case and I'm playing the guitar regularly. One concern I've read is the reluctance to put moisture inside the guitar in case of leakage.

For in case humidification, I've always used the sponge in a perforated baggie method.  However, finding an ideal place to put it has been a challenge depending on the case you use.  My question for you all is:  have any of you ever tried placing your humidifier in the compartment box?  A guy on the AGF suggested this, but I wonder if enough moisture will escape to make this effective.  I like the concept of storing in the compartment box where it is physically separated from the instrument.

Would think being contained in such a small enclosed area would impede the effectiveness. Curious to hear if anyone has tried this and how it worked out.

Humidity spreads via pressure (I think it's technically molecular collision) so it doesn't need air movement to move. However, it also escapes via this method so you lose more before it gets to the guitar body. You can place a hygrometer inside the soundhole, attached to a string to see if enough moisture is making it to your guitar. It will vary from case to case (had to really resist putting a joke in there).

I've had lots of success with the d'addrio humidipack system. Larrivee sells them on their website in the pro shop, so that convinced me. I considered the humidification case closed.
Larrivee P-03
Larrivee Forum VII
Larrivée OM-03R maple leaf inlay

Well played Bowie & SP6!   :nana_guitar (pardon my PUNishment)


Quote from: Silence Dogood on October 24, 2024, 11:06:13 AMNone (and never any issues).

    Wow, that would be nice! With my first Larrivee years ago, I didn't know anything about humidification and used nothing as well. After a while, I dropped it off with a good guitar tech in OKC because I was getting some string buzz. He said my humidification was lower than he would like to see it (39%), and that was the main problem. I believe 42% is ideal so not too far off, but apparently enough to cause the bridge to sink a little. That's when I was educated on humidification.
    I would love to have a system that keeps the home around 45% year round!  When we briefly lived in CO, the home we lived in had a humidification system that was part of the HVAC, but never got to experience it since the job there was short-lived. How are you able to get away with none?
2004 Larrivee OM-03R
2018 Larrivee D-40 SOLD
2004 Larrivee D-03R SOLD

Quote from: jweave69 on October 26, 2024, 09:50:18 AMHow are you able to get away with none?
No idea. It's just something I've never paid any attention to or fussed over (FWIW, neither did anyone back in the day either).  I know "it's a thing" because builders talk about it and stress it so heavily, but it's never been a thing for me.  Maybe where I live the conditions are ideal?  I don't know.  I'm in North Texas and we run the A/C most months out of the year.  When the heater is on (which isn't very often) the house gets dry but I guess not enough to affect my guitar.  I keep it in the case when I'm not playing it, but for years I kept it on a stand in my living room. 

Yeah sounds like N. Texas must be the ideal spot for guitar humidity lol! SW OK is pretty close, but I suspect a little drier, especially in the winter. Lived in NW NM for 9 months, and my throat and guitar needed constant humidity!
2004 Larrivee OM-03R
2018 Larrivee D-40 SOLD
2004 Larrivee D-03R SOLD

Unless you go without air conditioning, few places are actually ideal for guitars. Many people get away without humidity control though. The woods and finish still go through stress from expansion and contraction. They've just been fortunate that it was never enough to form a crack. There's a lot of people who do it for years with no problem, then their luck runs out. In nitro finished guitars you can often see witness lines (like a ripple around the center seam) from the wood movement.

 I kept my first two acoustics for 15 years (in Arizona) with no humidification and didn't get a crack, though wood movement did cause a finish crack in one of them. Then, after seeing my father in law's Gibson, I decided not to gamble anymore.

Quote from: Silence Dogood on October 24, 2024, 11:06:13 AMNone (and never any issues).
I talked to unclrob the other day. He's in north Florida and he told me that he doesn't have to humidify or dehumidify there.

Quote from: B0WIE on September 22, 2024, 02:08:29 PMI have Venta and Vornado humidifiers. It used to be for the guitar room but I have a couple and they do the whole house now. I also use boveda packs (similar to the Daddario things) but not for my guitars.

Used to keep the doors to the room closed, then I got a second Venta. I've tried every type and many brands in many different spaces - nothing comes close to the Ventas. Very quiet, no filters, no wicks, no dust (actually takes a fair bit of dust out of the air), uses plain tap water.

All guitars are hanging or on stands - nothing in cases (because I don't have a case for the piano  :guitar )

I leave my guitar in the case with a dampit in the soundhole and a sponge in a modified travel soap bar container in the case up by the headstock.  I live up here in Minnesota.
Larrivee SD 40r

Powered by EzPortal