Change to For Sale Board Rules

[Queequeg]

After some discussion, the mods have reached agreement regarding eBay listings.
Effective immediately:
Links to eBay are not to be posted here on the For Sale board. No eBay links on the For Sale Board.

It is in keeping with a pre-existing rule which states:
All items for sale must have a price.  No best offers, etc.  This is not the place for an auction.

Thank you all for you attention to this change.

[ducktrapper]

After some discussion, the mods have reached agreement regarding eBay listings.
Effective immediately:
Links to eBay are not to be posted here on the For Sale board. No eBay links on the For Sale Board.

It is in keeping with a pre-existing rule which states:
All items for sale must have a price.  No best offers, etc.  This is not the place for an auction.

Thank you all for you attention to this change.

So what's the best way to direct forumites to a possible good deal or particularly nice guitar on eBay? If I see a guitar on eBay that may be interesting, can I notify the forum and arrange another method, ie. pm, to point someone in the right direction or is any directing to eBay verboten? 

[Queequeg]

So what's the best way to direct forumites to a possible good deal or particularly nice guitar on eBay? If I see a guitar on eBay that may be interesting, can I notify the forum and arrange another method, ie. pm, to point someone in the right direction or is any directing to eBay verboten?  

Good question, duck.
If it is a Larrivee guitar and you are not the seller, you can post an "interesting eBay item" on the Larrivee board. If it is a non-Larrivee guitar, post a link on the Other Guitar Makers board.
If you are selling a guitar, you can start a thread with a new post on the For Sale board here, with a sale price.
The word "auction" is where we ran aground here recently.

[ducktrapper]

I've never linked to eBay, myself, but I was trying to get things straight for those who might. 

[cke]

Hey Mods!
I for one think this is a good move.

[eded]

Same here.  This is appreciated. 

Ed

[rockstar_not]

Seems like you could put a simple statement like 'no reasonable offers refused' or something similar at the end of your axe list and if another forumite was interested in purchasing, they could PM you.

Would that violate the rules?

[Queequeg]

Seems like you could put a simple statement like 'no reasonable offers refused' or something similar at the end of your axe list and if another forumite was interested in purchasing, they could PM you.

Would that violate the rules?

yes, in fact that would violate the rules.

[Mikeymac]

Know what I think?

This should be a sticky thread that stay's up top.

[Queequeg]

Know what I think?

This should be a sticky thread that stay's up top.

Agreed.
Thank you for suggesting this, Mikeymac.

[ST]

Thanks for the clarity and I appreciate the decision.

I'd be happier if you banned links to sales on eBay ... period.  No public service announcements, or gee ain't that in'neresting. If I want to look a eBay, I'll look at eBay.   

[L07 Shooting Star]

Thanks for the clarity and I appreciate the decision.

I'd be happier if you banned links to sales on eBay ... period.  No public service announcements, or gee ain't that in'neresting. If I want to look a eBay, I'll look at eBay.   

I disagree with banning those kind of links altogether.  I think the right decision was made.  Let's just eliminate them as part of any for sale or for trade thread, as has been done.  The "gee ain't that interesting" threads are an entirely different thing and are often, in fact, interesting.  Those posts often generate good discussion on the finer points of Larrivee guitars,  the variations in appointments, their value, etc.

A good example is Tuba Mikes topic about a supposed OM-03 for sale on ebay that he linked us to today.  I learned something from that thread.  I recently posted a link to an ad on Kijiji for an OM-03 that I was considering buying.  I did it to solicit advice and comments on whether I should go ahead with the purchase.  I would not have been able to do that if such links were banned altogether.

Kurt

[headsup]

The mods have come to this conclusion for their own reason and we respect that.

this issue is not solely eBay based.
it's Craigs list, & kijiji ( Canada) and in fact any and all sites where Larrivee owners might be looking for interesting Larrivee guitars (as I do).

I have been guilty (as have others) of seeing something interesting that I thought I would share for anyone else to see if they might be looking for such a guitar.
so is the rule just eBay or ALL links to ALL listings out side of the forum?

could one say "saw a very lovely, unique JCL instrument on a Seattle site yesterday"?

or "somebody is selling a 1967 JCL Classical guitar in Toronto for $500"?

(you get the drift...)

might a "survey" asking forum members about this topic have been an option?

Sorry if I've missed something obvious here....

[JOYCEfromNS]

The mods have come to this conclusion for their own reason and we respect that.

this issue is not solely eBay based.
it's Craigs list, & kijiji ( Canada) and in fact any and all sites where Larrivee owners might be looking for interesting Larrivee guitars (as I do).

I have been guilty (as have others) of seeing something interesting that I thought I would share for anyone else to see if they might be looking for such a guitar.
so is the rule just eBay or ALL links to ALL listings out side of the forum?

could one say "saw a very lovely, unique JCL instrument on a Seattle site yesterday"?

or "somebody is selling a 1967 JCL Classical guitar in Toronto for $500"?

(you get the drift...)

might a "survey" asking forum members about this topic have been an option?

Sorry if I've missed something obvious here....

Hi Kevin not sure what prompted your post to a topic that is 3 years old.

For some clarity, seems you might be confusing the For Sale Board with other boards. The ban is only to the For Sale Board (as title indicates).

For example if you see an interesting Larrivee somewhere else  Ebay, Kijiji etc nothing is stopping anyone from creating a link in Larrivee Guitars for discussions as many have done in the last 3 years - its just not appropriate in the For Sale Section

[headsup]

just in from splitting firewood, I guess my brain had a freeze up.
thanks.

[Mikeymac]

To the Mods:

Should this also include no links to Reverb sales? They aren't auctions - a price is always listed (and buyers are free to make lower offers).

Just curious if there should be some clarity about this in the original (four year old!) post, since Reverb has become so popular for musicians (I've bought and sold more gear there than on e-bay/craigslist/etc.).

Thank you!

[JOYCEfromNS]

To the Mods:

Should this also include no links to Reverb sales? They aren't auctions - a price is always listed (and buyers are free to make lower offers).

Just curious if there should be some clarity about this in the original (four year old!) post, since Reverb has become so popular for musicians (I've bought and sold more gear there than on e-bay/craigslist/etc.).

Hi Mike - you may be over thinking this. To essentially steal Queequeg words above and add a little of my own:

If it is a Larrivee guitar and you are not the seller, you can post an "interesting eBay/Reverb item" on the Larrivee board. If it is a non-Larrivee guitar, post a link on the Other Guitar Makers board.
If you are selling a guitar, you can start a thread with a new post on the For Sale board here, with a sale price and link anywhere you like be it Reverb or EBay so long as your post has met the rules highlighted in the previous sentence.

Clear as mud  

[Kohtzy]

If a guitar is listed on the sale site and is listed on Reverb by the owner, can a link to Reverb be included in the post? I read through all the conversation, and I'm still not sure...I don't want to do anything inappropriate. Thanks.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Queequeg]

Is it YOUR guitar?
OK.
But post the price here too, just to be extra nice.

[Kohtzy]

Thank you Queequeg.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk