Larrivee Guitar Forum

Main Forums => Recording, Pickups, Live Sound, etc. => Topic started by: dberch on January 26, 2015, 07:30:50 PM



Title: Need Reso Biscuit pickup
Post by: dberch on January 26, 2015, 07:30:50 PM
Greetings! I just purchased my first resonator, a Whipple Creek copy of a '35 National Trojan. Awesome guitar.

I need to amplify it. I'm interested in the following pickups and would love to hear comments from those who have used them or have heard them in person. Recordings would be most welcome!

K&K Biscuit pickup
Schatten NR-2
Highlander Biscuit pickup
Fishman Nashville for biscuit

Thanks!

David Berchtold
www.davidberchtold.com


Title: Re: Need Reso Biscuit pickup
Post by: Barefoot Rob on January 26, 2015, 07:52:06 PM
A few years back I installed a couple of Fishman pu's.They mounted to the screw on the underside of the resonator,I haven't tried the others.My clients seemed happy and when run thru a pre-amp I thought they sounded pretty good.


Title: Re: Need Reso Biscuit pickup
Post by: dberch on January 26, 2015, 09:06:19 PM
Thanks, Rob!  Did they quack?  Fishman just scares me.  Problaby be oK through my K&K Pre. has lots of head room.


Title: Re: Need Reso Biscuit pickup
Post by: Barefoot Rob on January 27, 2015, 01:50:46 AM
Don't remember any quacking.


Title: Re: Need Reso Biscuit pickup
Post by: flatlander on January 27, 2015, 02:47:36 PM
Congrats on the reso! I wish I would have jumped on that wagon long ago. Love them.
I have a highlander iP-!X inline in my steel biscuit NRP and it sounds great! Balanced, sensitive.
Completely natural?..well I don't know of any pick up that is. I'm not very good at describing tones maybe but
it makes it sound powerful.   Its good and sensitive and picks up any subtle thing you do. Or bash and it responds. The slide sounds great on it as well.
It has a preamp and a special cord, just stereo, that comes with it and a little box that hold battery. Sounds wonderful to me and it when I asked about pickups for this NRP it was the
overwhelming choice, If I get a chance I'll record it, but that will be a few days.
  I had a Shatton on my cheaper Republic and wasn't impressed, of course it wasn't on a National either.
I have a Fishman Nashville but it's for a Spider Bridge. It sounds great as well but a different animal than Biscuit.
Have fun and it looks like a great guitar. I hadn't heard of Whipple Creek so I looked them up. Looks like a nice handmade deal there and I found a story and pics of him making, I guess the first reso of your kind.   (only? The only reso I saw) And story is he took and old National in for repair and did detail spec check on it and replicated. Used a thicker truss rod though which is good. Anyway, cool and have fun!
  


Title: Re: Need Reso Biscuit pickup
Post by: dberch on January 30, 2015, 01:06:45 AM
Thanks, flatlander! Yes, that's the one I have Whipple Reso #001!  Digging it more every day. 

Been investigating that ToneCone at Elderly. Talked with the tech/designer yesterday. Sounds like that's the way to go for me because it should work through my K&K preamp.

I'll keep you posted.
David


Title: Re: Need Reso Biscuit pickup
Post by: flatlander on January 30, 2015, 10:52:22 AM
The Highlander really does sound great to me. Hopefully you can test drive some. I should be able to record mine this weekend, acoustically, then with pick-up. So let me know if you're still shopping or settled in on the tone-cone..


Title: Re: Need Reso Biscuit pickup
Post by: dberch on February 06, 2015, 05:37:33 PM
The Highlander really does sound great to me. Hopefully you can test drive some. I should be able to record mine this weekend, acoustically, then with pick-up. So let me know if you're still shopping or settled in on the tone-cone..
Hey Flatlander! You get a chance to record that NRP ?

Here's a quick and dirty recording of mine: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NG7tX71RVYg
Just used my iPhone.

Cheers!
David


Title: Re: Need Reso Biscuit pickup
Post by: flatlander on February 07, 2015, 03:15:45 AM
Cool! Sounds great. Sorry very hectic week at work. If you haven't gotten a pickup yet, I'll see if I can record sat or sun. Now the steel is a different tone for sure, but it should give good idea of quality of pick up. Nice guitar you got there. I really like it!


Title: Re: Need Reso Biscuit pickup
Post by: dberch on July 06, 2015, 06:13:16 PM
I ended up getting a ConeTone from Elderly. Excellent!

http://www.elderly.com/new_instruments/items/CTONE1.htm