Forum VI (based on Forum III) any interest?

Started by mike in lytle, May 07, 2021, 11:22:39 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 6 Guests are viewing this topic.

Quote from: Hooked on May 16, 2021, 07:31:07 PM
And now, since I decided to weigh in... could someone post sound samples of similar bodied guitars with spruce/walnut, spruce/rosewood, spruce/mahogany combinations? Or point me to a resource that already has those comparisons? Maybe with my good headphones, I could hear something to make a clear choice...

Lou

The trouble with clips is that you'll rarely find acoustic guitar clips that offer direct A/B comparisons. The difference in back woods is small enough that a different room, different mic, or even moving the mic by 2 inches (5cm for my friends up north :winkin:) will have a greater influence than the back wood will. Even if you do find actual A/B comparisons, many factors come into play that make one sound better than another just based on things like mic placement. I am a full-time audio engineer who uses his ears for a living and even I don't trust clips I hear on youtube and such because they rarely reflect what the instrument actually sounds like in-hand. I've made comparison clips of all my guitars at some point but I won't post the clips as the mic-placement wasn't exact and it would give misleading impressions about each instrument.

I will say that the L wears everything pretty well. It's not a big enough body that back wood choice becomes critical. With dreads and jumbos, you can easily end up with sonic mud if you don't choose the right wood combo for your tastes and play style. On an L, the top has a lot of influence and the back offers some flavor that can be balanced with string choice. Just my personal observation there, opinions will vary.

Quote from: Queequeg on May 16, 2021, 09:54:36 PM
Great post, Lou.
It is the antithesis of the cork sniffer. Not to say that we have cork sniffers here.
My ears are 68 years old. They don't differentiate the way they used to, but I know what I like.
And I've been around here quite a while but I still learn a lot from these guys here.
:cheers
Bowie addressed the sound clip issue.
For my own part, I will readily admit that I can be easily influenced sometimes, and I also am older (will be 68 next week).
And as the mods know I can be kind of hyperbolic.
I think I will take a break until Tuesday. I have been too quick to respond to things, and the group needs the space.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Mike, I was a little confused by your private message but I'll address it here since you insisted. I did state that I was initially not too interested, but could be tempted. After people started mentioning features that I like (before I ever mentioned them) my curiosity grew.

I'm mostly just trying to give people food for thought. In addition to objective statements, I've given personal opinions and labeled them as such.

I could actually see myself getting in on this if it included a few specific features. I've intentionally not brought up those features because I don't want this to be "my build". If the group decides upon those things on their own then I may jump in. My posts are mostly to help people understand how different choices affect a guitar build, especially things that many people haven't experienced first hand.

Ok, after reading Bowie's comment on walnut, I am intrigued more than before.  My problem is that I already have the guitars of my dreams (LSV-11 and a cedar/rosewood Ramirez) and it's hard to imagine having another guitar that would keep my attention.  If I get another guitar, it's got to be different in a good way.  So if the price is not unreasonable, I might be convinced.  That would make my preference LS, 12 fret, full scale, non-cutaway, walnut body (whatever top wood works best with that).  I'd kind of prefer a preinstalled pickup (dual source) as long as it is not a barndoor installation.
2010 LSV-11e
2002 4E Jose Ramirez
1998 S6+folk Seagull
1986 Charvel Model 3A
2001 Fender Jazz bass
1935 A-OO Gibson mandolin
1815 JG Hamm violin

Quote from: B0WIE on May 17, 2021, 10:25:37 AM
Mike, I was a little confused by your private message but I'll address it here since you insisted. I did state that I was initially not too interested, but could be tempted. After people started mentioning features that I like (before I ever mentioned them) my curiosity grew.

I'm mostly just trying to give people food for thought. In addition to objective statements, I've given personal opinions and labeled them as such.

I could actually see myself getting in on this if it included a few specific features. I've intentionally not brought up those features because I don't want this to be "my build". If the group decides upon those things on their own then I may jump in. My posts are mostly to help people understand how different choices affect a guitar build, especially things that many people haven't experienced first hand.
Bowie, thanks for this, it is good we know more about where you are at on the guitar.
However, I do think that you should go ahead and let us know what features you would like to see, as you are considered experienced and knowing.
Up till now, I only saw an opinion on walnut/adirondack.
Adding your preferences does not commit you to anything, and may generate additional helpful discussion.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Quote from: Paraclete on May 18, 2021, 11:16:58 AM
Ok, after reading Bowie's comment on walnut, I am intrigued more than before.  My problem is that I already have the guitars of my dreams (LSV-11 and a cedar/rosewood Ramirez) and it's hard to imagine having another guitar that would keep my attention.  If I get another guitar, it's got to be different in a good way.  So if the price is not unreasonable, I might be convinced.  That would make my preference LS, 12 fret, full scale, non-cutaway, walnut body (whatever top wood works best with that).  I'd kind of prefer a preinstalled pickup (dual source) as long as it is not a barndoor installation.
I understand. I have you revised to spruce/walnut, and of course the type of spruce is still up in the air.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Geez, I take one day off from this and we have 200 more reads on the thread.
Maybe that is a signal of momentum, or unspoken interest.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Mike, I've not been keeping track of how many have expressed interest yet but since you note the number of views of this thread without comment, I wonder if pricing would make any difference?  I do know that you've got a lot of different 'wants' for now but what if we were to come up with some kind of ballpark price?  Make an assumption for a few things: 12 fret, adi, walnut, OM/OOO, no pickup.  Is there any way to get a ballpark price?  If people saw it was, say US$1000 as opposed to US$2000, maybe there would be more interest.  Just sayin'

Since we're still kicking the tires on this, I'll add:

I'd be good with any Spruce and Walnut, but I'd also be on board with Hog/Hog ...

an LS 12 fret with H/H would be a good sonic choice (as many Forum III owners have attested).

Just making sure we're keeping all reasonable options on the table.


:coffee :donut :coffee :donut2
1999 D-02 Left-handed
2002 L-05 Left-handed
Larrivee owner since 1992

Quote from: Hooked on May 16, 2021, 07:31:07 PM
And now, since I decided to weigh in... could someone post sound samples of similar bodied guitars with spruce/walnut, spruce/rosewood, spruce/mahogany combinations? Or point me to a resource that already has those comparisons? Maybe with my good headphones, I could hear something to make a clear choice...

Lou

Three guitars, same time, same mic, everything identical except the guitars.

Spruce/Mahogany Larrivee OM
Carbon Fiber Rainsong OM
Spruce/Rosewood Larrivee OM

https://soundcloud.com/rocket_song/3-guitars-sound-samples

Quote from: Mikeymac on May 18, 2021, 06:06:52 PM
Since we're still kicking the tires on this, I'll add:
I'd be good with any Spruce and Walnut, but I'd also be on board with Hog/Hog ...
an LS 12 fret with H/H would be a good sonic choice (as many Forum III owners have attested).
Just making sure we're keeping all reasonable options on the table.

Quote from: jazzereh on May 18, 2021, 03:29:34 PM
Mike, I've not been keeping track of how many have expressed interest yet but since you note the number of views of this thread without comment, I wonder if pricing would make any difference?  I do know that you've got a lot of different 'wants' for now but what if we were to come up with some kind of ballpark price?  Make an assumption for a few things: 12 fret, adi, walnut, OM/OOO, no pickup.  Is there any way to get a ballpark price?  If people saw it was, say US$1000 as opposed to US$2000, maybe there would be more interest.  Just sayin'
Mikey,
Before I saw your post I had sent an inquiry to John about the reasonableness of the spruce/walnut combo.
Also, in the inquiry I re-mentioned our interest in an affordable version, and specifically the spruce/hog and hog/hog.
I am desperately focused on making another version of the Forum III that we can afford.
That was a concern group members have mentioned a lot.
I also inquired if it was too early for us to start talking to dealers.
Altho I have MSRP, and MAP and the Custom Price List here, I can't even begin to say what will happen when Larrivee and a dealer get involved.
I am happy with our current progress tho.
I will let the group know when I get a response from John.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Quote from: AZLiberty on May 18, 2021, 09:07:57 PM
Three guitars, same time, same mic, everything identical except the guitars.

Spruce/Mahogany Larrivee OM
Carbon Fiber Rainsong OM
Spruce/Rosewood Larrivee OM

https://soundcloud.com/rocket_song/3-guitars-sound-samples
Thanks for this!

All three sound great.

I found the Om-03 the warmest, with the most pronounced midrange, perhaps a little muddy in a nice full way.

The Rainsong was clean, less mids and maybe highs, but well balanced. It seemed to lack a little depth and complexity compared with the others. Too clean perhaps?

The Om-03R was crisper and less muddy than the hog, but similar richness and depth. The mids were much less pronounced, so a different feel and less warmth.

I want them all...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Since maple has been all but ruled out at this point, and I was among the people suggesting it from the beginning, I'd like to say that I'm open to different options. I currently have a sitka/rosewood L-10 and sitka/mahogany OMV-03, so my preference would be something that's not one of those. Also, I have a maple guitar incoming that may have been recently posted on the for sale forum, so that will probably scratch my itch for a maple Larrivee.  :guitar
2002 L-10
2006 LV-10QM
2010 OMV-03

Formerly: O-01 Koa Parlor, L-03

Quote from: mike in lytle on May 18, 2021, 01:13:14 PM
Geez, I take one day off from this and we have 200 more reads on the thread.
Maybe that is a signal of momentum, or unspoken interest.
Mike

I'd bet some of those reads are like mine...  I know the excitement of these build threads, through experience.  I read to live it vicariously even though I'm not in the market.

Ed

Regarding the pricing of a new forum guitar:  Forum III was produced in Vancouver in 2009.   Of course any new forum guitars will be produced in California.  There were numerous options.   3 wood combinations, standard or cutaway, & herringbone purfling primarily.  Obviously things have changed in the last 12 years.  I won't say what the pricing was in 2009 but an all hog with herringbone was much, much closer to $1k than 2K.   The pricing seemed to hit the sweet spot for members who were on the fence but couldn't pass up the chance to have something very very special.  I wish I could be a part of this next forum guitar but with 5 already in the house, including my Forum III I can't justify the expense.   I do, however, wish you guys all the luck in the world getting this done.  For what it's worth,  in the past they only needed 12 confirmed orders to proceed with production

I received a reply from John about the walnut guitars..... this is it, verbatim and complete.

"If you were to go the Walnut route then American Walnut is the way to go for cost-efficiency. We have plenty and it is only $300 MSRP. Obviously less when we come up with a final price. The more on board, the greater the savings package I can put together.  As for the dealer to work with, please leave that up to me to sort out. All I want is for you folks to come up with a model.

These will be the only variations... Lefty, cutaway, and pickup options.  Of course, the Larrivée's will throw in a little special touch for the Forum folks. Lets see what you come up with first, and then we'll see about adding a little something special 😉"


John did not address the sitka/hog or hog/hog options. This may be because Larrivee might want us to focus one one model.
I wrote back with a couple of follow up questions regarding pickup options. Will let the group know.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Sooooooo, what will body size do to Spruce/Walnut combo,........ would it make a difference?

I guess I'm trying to see which would optimize utilizing Walnut.

Quote from: Rockysdad on May 19, 2021, 03:17:27 PM
Sooooooo, what will body size do to Spruce/Walnut combo,........ would it make a difference?

I guess I'm trying to see which would optimize utilizing Walnut.

Body size will tend to do the same thing no matter what tone woods are involved: larger bodies will add more bass; small bodies will lose depth and sound more boxy, etc. From there, different woods will move the tone toward the characteristics of that particular wood species...

...sorry this isn't more helpful. I think we're pretty well agreed on the LS (small, 15" wide Larrivee shaped) body for this Forum guitar.
1999 D-02 Left-handed
2002 L-05 Left-handed
Larrivee owner since 1992

Quote from: Mikeymac on May 19, 2021, 04:16:22 PM
Body size will tend to do the same thing no matter what tone woods are involved: larger bodies will add more bass; small bodies will lose depth and sound more boxy, etc. From there, different woods will move the tone toward the characteristics of that particular wood species...
...sorry this isn't more helpful. I think we're pretty well agreed on the LS (small, 15" wide Larrivee shaped) body for this Forum guitar.
Quote from: Rockysdad on May 19, 2021, 03:17:27 PM
Sooooooo, what will body size do to Spruce/Walnut combo,........ would it make a difference?
I guess I'm trying to see which would optimize utilizing Walnut.
If one were to do a search on Larrivee walnut guitars one would find a large number of them are small guitars... parlors.
I would not anyways consider the LS as a small guitar. It is really comparable to an OM, but L-body shaped.
And remember, we are going to have a bridge in the middle of the lower bout.
Like I said, I have not played a walnut guitar, so I have to approach it like that.
It is going to sound good.

Please remember, I asked John about the Walnut cause more forum members listed it as a preference.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Bridge plate stuff here....
Regarding the bridge placement and the Pure Mini installation....
John indicated no structural changes to the guitar would be approved, because they are working with a large backlog.
We do have a way around the problem, as it has been brought to our attention by Roger (MR_LV19E).
I myself have several sound hole pickups begging to be tested in an LS.
Mike
Larrivee OM-03, OM-03 laurel, OM-50, L-03 laurel, LSV-03 Forum VI, 000-01

Powered by EzPortal