Strings suggestion - for a newbie

Started by Deliberate1, March 15, 2019, 08:40:54 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

I have used light gauge strings on every guitar I own since 1972. I tried mediums and medium lights on my D-35 without a noticeable difference in sound.

As Ducktrapper said: He has never encountered a bad new string in 50 years of playing and I would agree with that statement. Unless he had a guitar instead of a rattle in his playpen when he was a baby (Which is entirely possible), both of us must be about the same age (or at least born in the same decade). 

Quote from: Ggsanders on March 22, 2019, 07:32:55 PM
I respectfully disagree.  Without making any other adjustments, when changing from extra lights to lights, or lights to mediums, the increased tension pulling on the neck of your guitar will definitely resulting in raising your action.  I've kept my '76 L-11 strung with lights for years, with low E 12th fret action a shade under 6/64.  I thought I'd try mediums, just for a look/see.  While I definitely liked the increased volume, the increase in tension raised the 12 fret action to 7/64.  It was not unplayable, but it did fatigue my left hand, and I decided the trade off in volume was not worth it so I put lights back on.

I could have adjusted the action by taking some off the saddle, but I don't want to make the saddle any lower.

Its my opinion that action is more than string height, like I said action is a combination of nut slot depth, saddle height and neck relief. Leave one of those out of the equation and you won't get the best sound and the best playability.

In your example above you changed from lights to mediums which increased the tension on the neck and it bowed forward ultimately raising the strings off of the fretboard. Its not necessary to do anything but adjust the truss rod to compensate by tightening the rod to bring the neck back to the position it was in with the lights installed. Having a forward neck bow is going to make it much more difficult to finger clean notes, in other words it reduces the playability of the guitar, same thing for high nut slots or a high saddle, they are all part of a good setup or a bad setup.

My example was just the opposite of yours in that I used going from mediums to lights which created a back bow and string buzz which ruins playability, that requires loosening the truss rod so the lower string tension can pull the neck straight.

I think we are just disagreeing on the definition of action, I think it is all about playability which I think encompasses both ease of playing and good tone.

BTW. my string height at the 12th fret is the same as yours only I use 13/56 gauge and my guitars are very easy to play, but my neck relief is almost flat at the high e side of the neck and just a smidgeon of relief at the low E side of the neck.

One more thing, this is assuming you have level frets which would actually be the first thing to check in a setup. Without level frets you will never be able to get the lowest possible sting height.

Hope I clarified myself.  :donut  :donut2  :coffee
Roger


"Live simply so that others may simply live"

OP here. Very much appreciate all the suggestions and observations. I am now about one month into my guitar experience. And it is going very well. I adore the guitar. The way it looks, sounds and smells. I made a good choice in the 00040RE custom. Whether due to the 11-52 light strings, or neck adjustment, or development of hard won calluses and learning chords that I am trying to lay down with eyes closed, I am pleased with where I am.  I do not plan to make any changes at this time since it is going well. But in the next few months, as the strings wear out and my fingers orient, I will re-string with 12's, perhaps choosing some of the options suggested above. Really enjoying dipping my toe into this stringed world. While my more than 50 years of woodwind experience is not directly applicable, music is music. Intervals are intervals. But dealing with chords is totally new, and will ultimately help me in my sax jazz work, as I improvise mostly by ear.
Again, much obliged for the good help.
Cheers.
David

Quote from: jpmist on March 16, 2019, 01:50:17 AM
Congrats on your OOO-40RE, sorry the strings didn't work out.

On my spruce topped guitars I like John Pearce strings quite a lot. I had been using Elixirs Phos Bronze for several years and while I liked how long they lasted I was thinking the coating they put on the strings dampens their tone a bit but that's just my opinion and is open for debate. Pearce has a light gauge set of 12's to 53 which might be a good compromise from the 13s you had and the 11s you have now.
Obliged for the the advice. I just restrung the box with the Pearce strings you suggest and can appreciate a very substantial improvement in projection and tonal breadth vs. the Elixer Polywebs. Just what I was looking for since I removed the 13-56 the guitar had when it arrived in my hands. They may be a tad more stiff than the Elixers but not dramatically so, and well worth the change. Many thanks.

I also like John Pearse strings on my Larrivees. I usually get the 12 to 53 jpmist mentioned but replace the .012 E string with a .013. That said, for grins I recently tried these: https://www.amazon.com/Martin-MFX740-Bronze-Acoustic-Strings/dp/B0029SYO0S . I've always been disappointed with Martin strings as they seemed to go dead much faster than other strings. They are lower tension strings but sound fine to me and last much longer then the previous Martin strings I've tried. Cheap too!




A question. When you put on strings, do they sound as good as they are going to, or do they become more resonant as they age a bit, only to then deteriorate over time.
Thanks.

"Do they sound as good as they are going to?" Good question.  Depends on what "good" means.  Generally, they will ring the loudest when brand new and in short order, within a week or so if they are uncoated strings, will begin to deteriorate.  Some like the brand new sound, others like them after the initial brashness tempers a bit.  It's really a personal preference.  Some brands and alloys degrade more quickly than others, depends on the guitar and the individual players skin chemistry, as well.

Most will agree, I think, that strings will not become more resonant as they age.
Gary
'76 L-11
'10 LSV-11
'03 D-03
'86 Flatiron A5-JR

Quote from: teh on March 23, 2019, 07:45:40 AM
I have used light gauge strings on every guitar I own since 1972. I tried mediums and medium lights on my D-35 without a noticeable difference in sound.

As Ducktrapper said: He has never encountered a bad new string in 50 years of playing and I would agree with that statement. Unless he had a guitar instead of a rattle in his playpen when he was a baby (Which is entirely possible), both of us must be about the same age (or at least born in the same decade).  

Started when I was 14 in 1965. So not quite 50 years. In that time, I have used a lot of different brands of strings, even the much maligned Black Diamonds (which worked fine) and including most of the fads. Ever bring home strings that have never even been coiled? Anyway, I'd never say there is no difference between strings, obviously there is, and while I've preferred some to others depending on the individual guitar and what I was using it for, it's true I've never encountered a truly bad set of strings. The fun in this game is trying different things and finding out what works best for you. When these string threads get going, almost every brand of strings eventually gets touted. That's why I eventually after many years of participating on forums, when asked the best set of strings, started saying, "Six new ones". I got my head bitten off for saying so but it really is good advice. After all, there's no cheaper way of changing the tone of your guitar than putting new strings on it. And ... I mostly always use light gauge strings. Sometimes extra light.  :cheers    

Quote from: Ggsanders on April 01, 2019, 06:38:49 AM
"Do they sound as good as they are going to?" Good question.  Depends on what "good" means.  Generally, they will ring the loudest when brand new and in short order, within a week or so if they are uncoated strings, will begin to deteriorate.  Some like the brand new sound, others like them after the initial brashness tempers a bit.  It's really a personal preference.  Some brands and alloys degrade more quickly than others, depends on the guitar and the individual players skin chemistry, as well.

Most will agree, I think, that strings will not become more resonant as they age.

OP here. thank you for a helpful answer which is considerably more articulate than my question. Since our playing time differs, could we perhaps talk in terms of the number of hours on strings before they begin to noticeably fail. And is there a discernible difference in the rate of deterioration based on technique - finger strumming vs. plastic picking, etc.

Cheers.
D

Quote from: Deliberate1 on April 01, 2019, 12:15:57 PM
OP here. thank you for a helpful answer which is considerably more articulate than my question. Since our playing time differs, could we perhaps talk in terms of the number of hours on strings before they begin to noticeably fail. And is there a discernible difference in the rate of deterioration based on technique - finger strumming vs. plastic picking, etc.

Cheers.
D

Coated strings will last a long time for most people. Uncoated, if you're playing a lot, will depend on your body's chemistry and how hard you are on them. Some people beat the crap out of their strings, others not so much. Some people have dry hands, others exude Alien like acid. As a rule of thumb, if they sound good, aren't noticeably worn, they are good. Unless you're gigging, then changing them before a gig is usually a good idea. Of course, if money is no object and you're only dealing with one guitar, change them more often.    

Tip? I always keep the cardboard from the new set in my case and write the date on it. That way you'll know what brand and gauge you used and how long they've been on.

Quote from: ducktrapper on April 01, 2019, 12:51:21 PM
Coated strings will last a long time for most people. Uncoated, if you're playing a lot, will depend on your body's chemistry and how hard you are on them. Some people beat the crap out of their strings, others not so much. Some people have dry hands, others exude Alien like acid. As a rule of thumb, if they sound good, aren't noticeably worn, they are good. Unless you're gigging, then changing them before a gig is usually a good idea. Of course, if money is no object and you're only dealing with one guitar, change them more often.    

Tip? I always keep the cardboard from the new set in my case and write the date on it. That way you'll know what brand and gauge you used and how long they've been on.

So, it depends. Fair enough.
Good call on using the package as a reminder.
Best,
D

Quote from: Deliberate1 on April 01, 2019, 12:59:49 PM
So, it depends. Fair enough.
Good call on using the package as a reminder.
Best,
D

Exactly. Also, especially if you have sweaty hands, wiping the strings and neck down after playing will extend the life of the strings. Experiment. Enjoy.  :beer


Powered by EzPortal