Not-so-good vibrations...what's up with this?

Started by Riverbend, June 07, 2013, 11:52:16 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Thanks 3Dz...I did read that post of yours a while ago.
Larrivee 000-03 Forum VII
Larrivee LS-03WL Forum VI Limited
Larrivee OM-40M
Larrivee O-01W
Taylor AD12E
Martin 000-16 (gone for now)
Epiphone Olympic Solid Body Electric (1967)
Larrivee F-33 Mandolin (8/1/2008)
Larrivee A-33 (8/21/2009)
Kawalek Octave Mandolin
Eastman MOD 305 Octave Mandolin

Well, went off to see the "guitar specialist/repair guy" at my local music store today. He fiddled with the truss rod, he unfiddled the truss rod...still the same crazy G# wolf toneishness. New strings (which I thought I'd try but do not like so far...D'Ad's in medium guage PB) made it much worse. He had the guitar instructor listen to it and he was stumped. So down the road I'll go when I can to see the nearest "real" guitar tech, which is about 75 miles away. The funniest thing though, is when we were all done and I found out that the "guitar specialist" doesn't actually play guitar. He's a DRUMMER!
(insert drummer/drool/leveling the stage joke here) He almost tried to pry the first pin out with his side cutters before I whoa-whoa'd him up real quick. I pretty much hovered from that point on. Chalk one up I guess.   
   
Larrivee 000-03 Forum VII
Larrivee LS-03WL Forum VI Limited
Larrivee OM-40M
Larrivee O-01W
Taylor AD12E
Martin 000-16 (gone for now)
Epiphone Olympic Solid Body Electric (1967)
Larrivee F-33 Mandolin (8/1/2008)
Larrivee A-33 (8/21/2009)
Kawalek Octave Mandolin
Eastman MOD 305 Octave Mandolin

Here's an interesting post about wolf tones: link

It might be worthwhile to try the suggestion about changing out the saddle.

Quote from: rockstar_not on June 07, 2013, 03:22:28 PM
You have an 'E'model.  Make sure that whatever spring is used to hold the battery in place is well damped.  These can sing.  Use a piece of sponge or something to make dang sure that nothing in that pre-amp is vibrating.

To rule out sympathetic vibration of the strings between tuners and nut, tie on a section of thick rubber band on each one independently.  If you hear it go away, then you've found your culprit.  Shouldn't happen with the headstock angled back and a properly sized nut slot, but this is another common area of sympathetic vibration showing up in the sound.

-Scott

Did you rule out the pre-amp/battery holder, springs, etc. first?  Then have you tried to make sure no sympathetic string vibration is happening via the rubber band method I described above?

I had a 9v battery holder 'sing' in a previous guitar.  Rule that out first before you make your trek.
2000 L-03-E
2012 Epiphone Nighthawk Custom Reissue
1985 Peavey Milestone
2004 SX SPJ-62 Bass
2008 Valencia Solid Cedar Top Classical
2015 Taylor 414ce - won in drawing
2016 Ibanez SR655BBF
???? Mitchell MDJ-10 3/4 scale
???? Squier Danocaster
1981 G&L El Toro
My Sound Cloud

Quote from: rockstar_not on June 25, 2013, 07:47:51 PM
Did you rule out the pre-amp/battery holder, springs, etc. first?  Then have you tried to make sure no sympathetic string vibration is happening via the rubber band method I described above?

I had a 9v battery holder 'sing' in a previous guitar.  Rule that out first before you make your trek.
Yep...thanks, I did all that stuff. This has stumped a few folks. I've never heard anything like this before from any guitar. The medium gauge strings made it even worse, too. Much more noticable, in fact, sometimes when I'm playing it, it sounds like a whole series of ringing noises that live somewhere between the notes. Crazy stuff...I'm starting to think it's possessed!?
Larrivee 000-03 Forum VII
Larrivee LS-03WL Forum VI Limited
Larrivee OM-40M
Larrivee O-01W
Taylor AD12E
Martin 000-16 (gone for now)
Epiphone Olympic Solid Body Electric (1967)
Larrivee F-33 Mandolin (8/1/2008)
Larrivee A-33 (8/21/2009)
Kawalek Octave Mandolin
Eastman MOD 305 Octave Mandolin

Update...sort of at least. Pretty much convinced that my guitar just has a "dead spot" if I had to choose a term. Perhaps a "phase cancelling harmonic" might be applied descriptively, as well. On the D string at G#, where the woo-woo-woo-ing of the sickly sandhill crane/rusty barn door is first noticeable, and then when combined with the open G string below, the harmonics are a total train wreck. Several dampening techniques, string changes, truss rod tweaks, nut and saddle examinations later, I'm left wondering if I'm at a point where nothing can be done. I've read so much about wolf tones that I hear them in my sleep (might be the coyotes across the river...). I've been offered a new saddle in my choice of tusq or bone and been advised by a well respected forum member to avoid bone due to potential conflicts with my under-saddle pick-up. If I do try a new saddle, it seems that I'd also be responsible for any costs involved in fitting related work for the new saddle, plus there's no guarantee that it would change anything . I wish I had a good way to record the noise and post it here. I assure you it would make most of you cringe and at least some of you cry...it's not a pleasant sound coming from what is otherwise a beautiful guitar. I have other guitars ranging from expensive to lower end and none of them have this issue. An interesting side note is that while in a local guitar shop last week I picked a lower end Taylor off the wall, didn't notice the model but it retailed just under $800, and it seemed to have the same issue. I've sampled about a dozen guitars of various brands others in stores and haven't heard anything similar until the Taylor. I'm pretty much at a loss right now as far as what, if anything, to do.     
Larrivee 000-03 Forum VII
Larrivee LS-03WL Forum VI Limited
Larrivee OM-40M
Larrivee O-01W
Taylor AD12E
Martin 000-16 (gone for now)
Epiphone Olympic Solid Body Electric (1967)
Larrivee F-33 Mandolin (8/1/2008)
Larrivee A-33 (8/21/2009)
Kawalek Octave Mandolin
Eastman MOD 305 Octave Mandolin

Stewart-MacDonald sells a tool for checking fret level as compared to the fret before and the after it may be a low spot and the string rotation could be effected.
A REPAIRPERSON,Barefoot Rob gone to a better place
OM03PA
Favorite saying
 OB LA DE OB LA DA,LIFE GOES ON---BRA,It is what it is,You just gotta deal it,
One By One The Penguins Steal My Sanity, Keith and Barefoot Rob on youtube
Still unclrob
#19
12 people ignoring me,so cool
rpjguitarworks
Call PM me I may be able to help

A saddle swap is a cheap investment. I am not aware of any potential conflicts with my under-saddle pick-up and a bone saddle unless it isn't fitted properly. Keep the old saddle, of course.
A brace may have to be filed down to change the harmonics of the top.

Quote from: Queequeg on July 16, 2013, 10:24:25 AM
A saddle swap is a cheap investment. I am not aware of any potential conflicts with my under-saddle pick-up and a bone saddle unless it isn't fitted properly. Keep the old saddle, of course.
A brace may have to be filed down to change the harmonics of the top.
Maybe "conflict" wasn't the right word choice on my part...it was mentioned that the amplified sound of under-saddle bone has been less than stellar in that person's opinion...I can't remember verbatim...and it was offered very generously and as simply their opinion. All I know is that I wish my guitar sounded somewhat "normal" in that relatively high traffic area of the neck. And by the way, the "noise"...or whatever describes it, has been verified by dozens of other ears and fingers...virtually everyone who has heard or fingered the guitar.   
 
Larrivee 000-03 Forum VII
Larrivee LS-03WL Forum VI Limited
Larrivee OM-40M
Larrivee O-01W
Taylor AD12E
Martin 000-16 (gone for now)
Epiphone Olympic Solid Body Electric (1967)
Larrivee F-33 Mandolin (8/1/2008)
Larrivee A-33 (8/21/2009)
Kawalek Octave Mandolin
Eastman MOD 305 Octave Mandolin

Broken truss rod perhaps?  In order to do what you describe, my opinion is that somewhere on your guitar, something is loose that shouldn't be loose.  Finding it has eluded you so far.
2000 L-03-E
2012 Epiphone Nighthawk Custom Reissue
1985 Peavey Milestone
2004 SX SPJ-62 Bass
2008 Valencia Solid Cedar Top Classical
2015 Taylor 414ce - won in drawing
2016 Ibanez SR655BBF
???? Mitchell MDJ-10 3/4 scale
???? Squier Danocaster
1981 G&L El Toro
My Sound Cloud

I've heard of wolf notes but not sure I have heard one. Just for the sake of experiment, try muting all other strings but that one note and hear what happens. Or capo at that particular fret and play normally to hear what happens. Maybe expose the guitar to higher humidity for some time to see how it affects the sound. Tune up or down a half step or whole step and see if the wolf note changes or disappears. Just thinking....
I had a Simon & Patrick parlor for a while that had a buzz at a certain frequency that I could not figure out. One day I had it outdoors for a while in warm humid weather and the buzz began to lessen.
Hope you get it figured out.
A Hebrew, under the Spell
Pain is a good thing

Quote from: broKen on July 16, 2013, 01:42:50 PM
I've heard of wolf notes but not sure I have heard one. Just for the sake of experiment, try muting all other strings but that one note and hear what happens. Or capo at that particular fret and play normally to hear what happens. Maybe expose the guitar to higher humidity for some time to see how it affects the sound. Tune up or down a half step or whole step and see if the wolf note changes or disappears. Just thinking....
I had a Simon & Patrick parlor for a while that had a buzz at a certain frequency that I could not figure out. One day I had it outdoors for a while in warm humid weather and the buzz began to lessen.
Hope you get it figured out.
Thanks for the suggestions...tried all of the muting/tunings/capo here capo there stuff. Tried truss rod adjustments, vibration dampening, about everything short of replacing the nut or saddle and they've both been inspected and seem fine. We'll see what happens tonight playing outside in very high humidity...but I don't think that's going to do anything because it's already been exposed to higher than average humidity playing outside on several occasions. Nothing is loose internally. Just seems to crash tonally at that particular frequency, though with a capo on, the D string seems pretty dead everywhere up the neck. What should be sustain is instead just a slightly off-key, chiming vibrating crash. It's an otherwise beautiful sounding guitar. I'm going to pay to have the saddle changed and hope that that and some more time might lead me to a happy conclusion. Other than that, I'm stumped.   
Larrivee 000-03 Forum VII
Larrivee LS-03WL Forum VI Limited
Larrivee OM-40M
Larrivee O-01W
Taylor AD12E
Martin 000-16 (gone for now)
Epiphone Olympic Solid Body Electric (1967)
Larrivee F-33 Mandolin (8/1/2008)
Larrivee A-33 (8/21/2009)
Kawalek Octave Mandolin
Eastman MOD 305 Octave Mandolin

Did I read something wrong? The noise is coming off the 6th fret? And when you're hammering on the pinky it's only up to 5th fret? And 6th never really fretted? Sorry if I misread something.  I just got excited for a minute when you said 6th string cause I thought it had just settled in and needed frets dressed a little, or 6th had lifted or whatever.
10-1614 more than a number, it's body and soul.

Quote from: flatlander on July 16, 2013, 07:52:51 PM
Did I read something wrong? The noise is coming off the 6th fret? And when you're hammering on the pinky it's only up to 5th fret? And 6th never really fretted? Sorry if I misread something.  I just got excited for a minute when you said 6th string cause I thought it had just settled in and needed frets dressed a little, or 6th had lifted or whatever.
D string 4th fret, but it's not fret buzz at all, it's a dead chiming sound that comes from somewhere. Accentuated even more if the note is hammered. Also has a weird mutual non-sustain when played with the open G string below. Sounds similar to a string picked above the nut...got that dead sound.
Larrivee 000-03 Forum VII
Larrivee LS-03WL Forum VI Limited
Larrivee OM-40M
Larrivee O-01W
Taylor AD12E
Martin 000-16 (gone for now)
Epiphone Olympic Solid Body Electric (1967)
Larrivee F-33 Mandolin (8/1/2008)
Larrivee A-33 (8/21/2009)
Kawalek Octave Mandolin
Eastman MOD 305 Octave Mandolin

OK, That G# thing, which would be 6th fret, threw me off. And as for that matter adjacent 1/2 step notes always sound bad when played together. G# against G. Well good luck. Those things can be weird and frustrating but I wouldn't give up that someone good can find cause. As far as bone vs synthetic saddle I think problems usually arise if bone in not consistant in make up, which synthetic usually is, and can cause inbalance in volume across strings. Good quality bone is not a problem for me. I prefer bone as much as anything because they last longer. I don't like any buzzing but want to get as low as possible. If I put synthetic on the hairy edge like that doesn't last as long before 1st and 2nd string in particular notch themselves in and buzz.
10-1614 more than a number, it's body and soul.

I've not been too clear on this at all...sorry...but it actually starts at F# and pretty much heard through the whole step to G#. I've been thinking F# some of the times I've been writing G#. I don't normally read what I type and I type poorly and those keys are right next to each other. I also often play the wrong notes, too, not just type them...
Larrivee 000-03 Forum VII
Larrivee LS-03WL Forum VI Limited
Larrivee OM-40M
Larrivee O-01W
Taylor AD12E
Martin 000-16 (gone for now)
Epiphone Olympic Solid Body Electric (1967)
Larrivee F-33 Mandolin (8/1/2008)
Larrivee A-33 (8/21/2009)
Kawalek Octave Mandolin
Eastman MOD 305 Octave Mandolin

Quote from: unclrob on July 16, 2013, 10:14:47 AM
Stewart-MacDonald sells a tool for checking fret level as compared to the fret before and the after it may be a low spot and the string rotation could be effected.

This is my guess.

Powered by EzPortal