Science Experiment: What's the Helmholtz Frequency of your Parlor?

Started by gitnoob, June 02, 2010, 04:34:54 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Anybody game for a science experiment?

Sing into the soundhole of your Parlor, and report the frequency where it resonates the most.    Mine resonates loudly at B.   Maybe a little sharp of B.

(Yes, there's a reason I'm asking.)
Gits: 2004 P-01K, 2005 OM-03MT
Uke: Kala KA-ASKS with Larrivee Flamed Koa
Chops: fingerstyle noob

 Yeah, roughly 'B'.  So? Come on. Give!!  :blush: :? Is this some sort of social experiment?  Oh geez, now I feel like a fool!! Everybody is laughing at me  :crying: I didn't do it. I just pretended, really!! :wacko:
Chris
Larrivee's '07  L-09 (40th Commemorative); '09 00-03 S.E; '08 P-09
Eastman '07 AC 650-12 Jumbo (NAMM)
Martin   '11 D Mahogany (FSC Golden Era type)
Voyage-Air '10 VAOM-06
-the nylon string-
Goya (Levin) '58 G-30
-dulcimer-
'11 McSpadden

OK, I guess two data points are enough.    :smile:

It's the tone.   Something has always bugged me about the tone of the Parlor.    I've got mediums on mine, and I finally realized I like the tone of just about all the notes except for the open B.

I think the sound hole is too small, and it causes that hollow resonance at B that sounds almost like blowing on the top of a bottle.   The Helmholtz resonance.

You can lower the frequency by covering up with hole, but I think the hole should probably be a little bigger -- get that resonance closer to B#, and I think the Parlor would sound better.

(Hopefully Jean is reading this and experimenting with the LSH Parlor right about now.   :bgrin:)
Gits: 2004 P-01K, 2005 OM-03MT
Uke: Kala KA-ASKS with Larrivee Flamed Koa
Chops: fingerstyle noob

 :guitar  "Too much time on my hands... da da da da  Too much time on my hands... "

Well, I can't say that I hear the issue on my EIR  version. But every git has a resonance frequency. Way back I was taught to tune  a classical by tapping on the bridge to grab an A.  'corse, Parlors do have a characteristic sound. Maybe it contributes to that 'boxiness?'  I believe the 0-50, -60 had enlarged soundholes.
Chris
Larrivee's '07  L-09 (40th Commemorative); '09 00-03 S.E; '08 P-09
Eastman '07 AC 650-12 Jumbo (NAMM)
Martin   '11 D Mahogany (FSC Golden Era type)
Voyage-Air '10 VAOM-06
-the nylon string-
Goya (Levin) '58 G-30
-dulcimer-
'11 McSpadden

Quote from: cke on June 02, 2010, 05:25:44 PM
But every git has a resonance frequency. Way back I was taught to tune  a classical by tapping on the bridge to grab an A.  'corse, Parlors do have a characteristic sound. Maybe it contributes to that 'boxiness?'  I believe the 0-50, -60 had enlarged soundholes.

Yes, I think that what I've been calling "boxiness" is mostly the sound of that open B.

My understanding is that custom builders try to tune the top, back, and air cavity such that it doesn't resonate exactly with any fretted or open notes.    You want a resonant contribution, but not an unbalanced response specific to certain notes.

FWIW, I was A/B'ing two guitars trying to decide which to sell.    That's how I came up with "I really love this Parlor except for the open-B" bit.     Since I mostly love the Parlor, I think I may just live with it and play tunes that don't include the B.   :smile:
Gits: 2004 P-01K, 2005 OM-03MT
Uke: Kala KA-ASKS with Larrivee Flamed Koa
Chops: fingerstyle noob

Here's an experiment to try. De-tune your guitar slightly (in either direction) and see if you still get the same results with the B string.
Ron


Quote from: gitnoob on June 02, 2010, 05:17:35 PM
OK, I guess two data points are enough.    :smile:

It's the tone.   Something has always bugged me about the tone of the Parlor.    I've got mediums on mine, and I finally realized I like the tone of just about all the notes except for the open B.

I think the sound hole is too small, and it causes that hollow resonance at B that sounds almost like blowing on the top of a bottle.   The Helmholtz resonance.

You can lower the frequency by covering up with hole, but I think the hole should probably be a little bigger -- get that resonance closer to B#, and I think the Parlor would sound better.

(Hopefully Jean is reading this and experimenting with the LSH Parlor right about now.   :bgrin:)

Wow...  Helmholtz?  Last I heard, and it was a LONG time ago, it didn't really apply in a predictable enough fashion to apply to guitar design.  Something about the reaction of the flexible guitar body to vibrations and the changes in air pressure insided the guitar...  Something about you'd have to extrapolate from a non-compressible in the guitar body or some such thing...  It was complicated   :wacko:, and I pretty much don't remember :roll  I don't remember a lot of things from the 70's and 80's.  Nature's way of keeping us sane I suppose.

For the record, the voice of the parlor is probably much more affected by the size of the top.  As I recall there was much excitement over tap testing vintage Martin Dreads in the '70s.  They all seemed in the same neighborhood when tap tested.  Not the same tone (which I can't remember), but within a step or so either direction.  Much excitement ensued.  If you could tune the top to the same tone as those guitars you'd have a monster!  Well turned out that when spruce was shaved and cut to be useable as a top in the dread shape, it just kind of is in the neighborhood of that tone :roll  Sort of like a drum head.  Bigger drums are probably going to have a lower tone all things being equal.

But if you really believe in this stuff, a luthier can enlarge your soundhole.  The legendary Clarence White dread has it's equally legendary enlarged soundhole as the result of a repair.  I would think it wouldn't be that expensive.

Even cheaper solution.  Tune a quarter tone up or down from standard.  You'll only hit the B when bending notes :winkin:


Good point -- probably easier to change the string tuning than resize the sound hole.   :smile:

I detuned both flat and sharp, and it may just be my imagination, but I think the string formerly known as B did sound more balanced and less "hollow" when I did.   I liked the sharp tuning best.
Gits: 2004 P-01K, 2005 OM-03MT
Uke: Kala KA-ASKS with Larrivee Flamed Koa
Chops: fingerstyle noob

I'm not blowing into my parlor without an audio mic hooked up to a O-scope.

I think the parlor does sound a bit better with the b string tuned about 2 cents sharp though.

I have the same issue but not open B, instead it's the G string about three frets up. And it doesnt sound hollow, rather "too full" and the sustain is shorter, like a "thonk". On both my LV's.

But all guitars have this, with different frequencies. It was explained to me that the compromise is to make a responsive guitar with a stronger "wolftone", or a guitar with harder bracing (Taylor for example) which will have more even tone but be less responsive. The tone which the guitar is tuned to is something less likely to interfere, different luthiers use different frequencies.


I think this would be an appropriate time to ask, "Whachoo talkin' 'bout Willis?"

Quote from: ducktrapper on June 03, 2010, 08:27:58 AM
I think this would be an appropriate time to ask, "Whachoo talkin' 'bout Willis?"

Better watch out. GC estate may sue you for infringement on artistic property Duck!

Quote from: frankhond on June 03, 2010, 07:41:17 AM
I have the same issue but not open B, instead it's the G string about three frets up. And it doesnt sound hollow, rather "too full" and the sustain is shorter, like a "thonk". On both my LV's.

But all guitars have this, with different frequencies. It was explained to me that the compromise is to make a responsive guitar with a stronger "wolftone", or a guitar with harder bracing (Taylor for example) which will have more even tone but be less responsive. The tone which the guitar is tuned to is something less likely to interfere, different luthiers use different frequencies.



Well G and B have always been my most problematic strings.  Have you tried a plain 3rd string, just for schnitzengrins?

Quote from: gitnoob on June 02, 2010, 05:17:35 PM

You can lower the frequency by covering up with hole, but I think the hole should probably be a little bigger -- get that resonance closer to B#, and I think the Parlor would sound better.

You DO realize that a "B#" is also known as a "C"...?   :wink:
1999 D-02 Left-handed
2002 L-05 Left-handed
Larrivee owner since 1992

I'm busted.    Haven't practiced my scales in a while.    :ohmy:
Gits: 2004 P-01K, 2005 OM-03MT
Uke: Kala KA-ASKS with Larrivee Flamed Koa
Chops: fingerstyle noob

Quote from: Mikeymac on June 04, 2010, 06:31:51 PM
You DO realize that a "B#" is also known as a "C"...?   :wink:
Actually, this only true in well-tempered (piano) tuning.   :arrow
Chris
Larrivee's '07  L-09 (40th Commemorative); '09 00-03 S.E; '08 P-09
Eastman '07 AC 650-12 Jumbo (NAMM)
Martin   '11 D Mahogany (FSC Golden Era type)
Voyage-Air '10 VAOM-06
-the nylon string-
Goya (Levin) '58 G-30
-dulcimer-
'11 McSpadden

Quote from: blue on June 03, 2010, 12:19:19 PM
Well G and B have always been my most problematic strings.  Have you tried a plain 3rd string, just for schnitzengrins?

Nah. All guitars I owned had some weird spot somewhere. I just try to avoid that particular note in that place, or cover it up by wrapping it in other notes...  :nana_guitar

Once I had the privilege to jam with a pro classical virtuoso. He was playing a Yamaha borrowed from another guy who apologetically said "it has a buzz". The virtuoso replied "I know, I'm working around it". That attitude stuck with me ever since.

Powered by EzPortal