are other brands worth the extra.

Started by sniggs, May 26, 2010, 11:42:58 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

I'm not meaning to slag other makers off here but are they really worth $$$$ more than Larrivee,I was looking at getting a Collings just to add something extra to the mix but was a bit taken aback at all the extra charges for things that on Larrivee I have taken for granted, case was an extra $300 ,fingerboard binding was only on the higher models,wood body binding $600 extra etc I was very close to buying one but just couldn't justify the cost,just makes me realise I have a  :nice guitar:

To some yes to others no.
A REPAIRPERSON,Barefoot Rob gone to a better place
OM03PA
Favorite saying
 OB LA DE OB LA DA,LIFE GOES ON---BRA,It is what it is,You just gotta deal it,
One By One The Penguins Steal My Sanity, Keith and Barefoot Rob on youtube
Still unclrob
#19
12 people ignoring me,so cool
rpjguitarworks
Call PM me I may be able to help

I did a 'poll' a month ago asking more or less the same question. Larrivee's are really high end guitars. Others are ofter more hand finished, but often you are paying for cache or the name rather than value.

http://www.larriveeforum.com/smf/index.php?topic=32210.0

My opinion is most other guitar brands at this strata are relatively over-priced. But that doesn't stop me from wanting some of them  :drool:
Chris
Larrivee's '07  L-09 (40th Commemorative); '09 00-03 S.E; '08 P-09
Eastman '07 AC 650-12 Jumbo (NAMM)
Martin   '11 D Mahogany (FSC Golden Era type)
Voyage-Air '10 VAOM-06
-the nylon string-
Goya (Levin) '58 G-30
-dulcimer-
'11 McSpadden

They're worth whatever the buyer thinks they're worth, aren't they?

Quote from: sniggs on May 26, 2010, 11:42:58 AM
I'm not meaning to slag other makers off here but are they really worth $$$$ more than Larrivee,

Best way to tell is to sit down and play the Collings and see the difference for yourself. There is a Collings dealer around the corner and I check them out from time to time. They make a fine guitar...

One day i wanted to audition a Martin 000-28VS (some guys I trust say this is martin's "best" guitar model). I loved it. Then the sales guy at the shop showed me a Collings version of the same guitar and the Collings tone was obviously bigger, louder...just more there. The Martin sells for about $3K and the Collings was $4K. Obviously a better guitar.

But I didn't have half of that to spend so it didn't matter. I still like my Larrivees even though I could spend more $$ and get something I might like even better.

I've actually liked some Santa Cruz guitars more than Collings when I had them both side by side. But which is the better buy? A more expensive better guitar or a more affordable perfectly fine guitar? We each have to decide for ourselves....
Larrivee 00-70 
Gibson Advanced Jumbo  - J-185 - J200 Jr.
 National Resophonics  M1 Tricone
 Eastman MD-904 - DGM-1

Collings is a special case.  There is as much myth and hyperbole surrounding them as Pre-War Martins.  One writer, 20 years ago just throws out "This is the kind of guitar that's going to take 5 years to open up before you even hear its real voice" to make it to 650 words in his review, and now it's taken as gospel with Collings.  And the thing is that on average they are amazing guitars.  But they were also the first kind of small scale company to send you pictures during the build.  Custom folks did it first, but Collings was the first "Big" to do it.  Kind of gave you the sense that "gee look!  They're building it just for me!"  

For a classic, old timey style guitar, you'd have a hard time finding better.  They do sound a little "tight" regardless of whether or not you've waited 5 years.  Because they are supposed to  :thumb

Now is one worth it?  I think a used one is.  I got a slope shouldered dread that was the main touring instrument of one of the Dixie Chicks backup players maybe 9, 10 years ago.  I think I paid $2,000.  It was beat as you'd expect, but it was awesome.  A used one can be had for Martin prices if you're patient and lucky.  

Quote from: Dotneck on May 26, 2010, 03:03:40 PM
Best way to tell is to sit down and play the Collings and see the difference for yourself. There is a Collings dealer around the corner and I check them out from time to time. They make a fine guitar...

I still like my Larrivees even though I could spend more $$ and get something I might like even better.

I But which is the better buy? A more expensive better guitar or a more affordable perfectly fine guitar? We each have to decide for ourselves....

We are conditioned to believe if it costs more it is better. But "It Ain't Necessarily So."  When I discovered Larrivee (my L-09), I  went to a famous high end store and played Martin's, Goodall's, Froggy Bottoms, Santa Cruz's, Lowden's and  Collings'. They were all really good guitars.  I ended up swapping among a Martin 00-28EC, a OM -28 Marquis, a Froggy Bottom H ,and a Collings OM 2H deep body. My favorite was the FB, but it  was over $10k, and not in my league financially, but I liked the Collings almost as much. It reminded me of the Larrivee I played the day before. And it cost 3X more. I went back and played the Larrivee and committed to it without a single look back.

Someone else might have a different idea of how a guitar should sound. I fell in love with the Larrivee sound. I could have paid more than I did, but there was no reason for me to do so.

Pricing is  then result of a lot of considerations. A smaller shop like SCGC or Collings need to make a lot more of their nut on each guitar
Chris
Larrivee's '07  L-09 (40th Commemorative); '09 00-03 S.E; '08 P-09
Eastman '07 AC 650-12 Jumbo (NAMM)
Martin   '11 D Mahogany (FSC Golden Era type)
Voyage-Air '10 VAOM-06
-the nylon string-
Goya (Levin) '58 G-30
-dulcimer-
'11 McSpadden

Quote from: cke on May 26, 2010, 03:25:05 PM
Someone else might have a different idea of how a guitar should sound. I fell in love with the Larrivee sound. I could have paid more than I did, but there was no reason for me to do so.

That's why I said the best way to tell is to sit down and play them. Compare them.

I was surprised in the difference between the Martin and the Collings. I've never compared the Collings to any of my Larrivees since I am not seriously shopping in that price range...so need to go through the exercise.
Larrivee 00-70 
Gibson Advanced Jumbo  - J-185 - J200 Jr.
 National Resophonics  M1 Tricone
 Eastman MD-904 - DGM-1

Quote from: ducktrapper on May 26, 2010, 02:52:14 PM
They're worth whatever the buyer thinks they're worth, aren't they?

Amen!

...and if you can't play them well, does it matter?

To me it's variety. I'm looking into another guitar on a different forum and have basically asked this same question. There are guitars known for their quality, price, market share (visibility), uniqueness, and a lot of other criteria but I'm of the camp: "It doesn't need to COST an arm and a leg to SOUND like it cost an arm and a leg".


f
Larrivee L-03 w/Gotoh 381 tuners (African Mahogany/Sitka)
Collings OM2Hc (EIR/Sitka)
Schenk Ophirio (Sapele/Cedar)
Bourgeois 00 Custom (Mahogany/It. Spruce)

The more you spend the more paranoid you get over dings. I MHO, bang for buck, you can not beat a Larrivee.
Larrivee:
P09
OM03
OMO3R
OMO5
LO2
LO3R
LO3W
LO3K

I understand they charge what they can get and good look to them,and the tone and quality is not in question,the thing that surprised me was that what I would call standard on a high priced guitar were charged as extras,end pin-fingerboard bindings-body binding and a case etc,I can understand people wanting a high price guitar but lets not bleed them dry.I'm just glad that I took a closer look at what others offer and know that if ever I do buy a higher price guitar, that it better offer the same level of "extras" as standard as Larrivee or I'll be looking elsewhere.

I'm sure some of the high end guitars are worth the extra money but you almost have to be Howard Hughes to afford them. I'm so glad Larrivee has made such great guitars for prices that anyone with a job can afford. Dollar for dollar......the 03 series are the best guitars on the planet.   


Recently got GAS for a 00 with koa body so I contacted a Martin dealer and priced a custom 00-28VS with koa back and sides. Few weeks later I get an email from a local Larrivee dealer that they just ordered a small run of Larri 00's with you guessed it, koa back and sides and even a slot head just like the Martin for $2000 less than what I was quoted for the custom 00-28. Both the Martin dealer and the Larrivee dealer are known for low prices so most of the extra two grand would have gone to Martin.

So...my very long answer is NO..

It's in the ears and pocket book.  I have played Collings, Martin , Taylors and as mentioined before Larrivee is just as close to those at less money.  I could have had a Collings, but I got two Larrivees for less than the collings.  The Collings sound great, but so do the Larrivees.  I have not been impressed with the newer Martins and have never been impressed with Taylor's.  If I played pofessionally I might opt for a Collings, but that being said I have a vareity of sounds from my 3 Larrivees that I could not afford, much less get from the other 3.  Lots of great guitars out there now that did not exists 20 years ago.  Just my opinion. :donut :donut :donut
Larrivee C-09 (Small Flying Eagle)
Larrivee D-03

Quote from: sniggs on May 26, 2010, 05:27:33 PM
the thing that surprised me was that what I would call standard on a high priced guitar were charged as extras,end pin-fingerboard bindings-body binding and a case etc,

I do actually understand the case thing.  If I paid $4000 for a guitar, I'm not putting it in an off the shelf case that's $300 retail, that probably doesn't protect it any more than a $100 Larrivee case (no offense).  I'd actually appreciate being given the choice on picking out my own case.

Yes. SCGC's and H&D's are the cheapest I've found that have the sound and feel I want.

are other brands worth the extra.

As you go up the price ladder with different brands the law of diminishing returns rears it's ugly head.  To some they are certainly worth it and to others not.   Larrivees are an under-rated guitar, which is reasonably priced, that stacks up well against a lot of brands.  A fine guitar certainly at my skill level.   To me it's all about playing.  I've seen some fine players make  some cheesy guitars sound like a million bucks.

Quote from: gtrplayer on May 26, 2010, 07:36:12 PM
To me it's all about playing.  I've seen some fine players make  some cheesy guitars sound like a million bucks.

:+1:  No doubt there are better guitars out there than my humble L-03 -- although I'm not sure there are any better for within 500 bucks of the price I paid.  Still, I'm constantly reminding myself that what I need is not a better (or more expensive guitar) but better skills on the one I'm lucky enough to own already.  Put a $10,000 guitar in my hands and it's still me playing . . . put my guitar is the hands of someone with "the gift" and it'll sound priceless. 

But ain't it great that all these amazing guitars are out there . . . calling out to us . . . tempting us with their siren songs . . . (time to go tie myself to the mast before I end up giving out my credit card number to some little gal called froggy bottom or a temptress with SCGC for initials)
". . . if I only had a brain . . ."
___________________________
'08 L-03 Silver Oak

Are other brands worth the extra?  It depends.

Until my Forum-IV arrived I would have said yes.  The wonderful SD-50 I used to own got trounced by the Martin D-18GE and so it went away.  The new GE costs twice what the used SD cost me.  That SD was the best Larrivee I ever played, until the F-IV came.

BUT, I have this haunting siren that keeps calling me back to the vintage sound of a 40's or earlier D-18.  My GE and F-III might make way for an old D-18 or a recent D-18A.  For me it would be worth it.  YMMV.
Play it daily for best results.

They are all so different.... How do you compare a Porsche to a Honda or a BMW to a VW?  You can't because they are so different.  I said this in another thread not because I have something to prove...If you go into a higher end shop and try to throw out those terms or comparisons, they are gong to ask you the same thing or tell you the same thing. Its logic. I own more than my share of Larrivee's  and they are great all on their own.  I'm just not sure why I would compare them to something else which is totally different in every way other than the fact they are both guitars. I'm just saying...
A bunch of great guitars I don't deserve and a gaggle of fly rods.... Aint life grand?

Powered by EzPortal