Forum IV owners have you compared with SC 1929?

Started by mannish, May 24, 2010, 08:07:55 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

This past weekend I was near Madison for my son's soccer tournament.  In between games I stopped at Madison Music and played a few guitars.  I played a Collings OM1 A SS Cutaway (mahogany/adirondack), a Huss & Dalton FS (Rosewood and Spruce), a used Huss & Dalton OM-C (Rosewood/Spruce), a used Larrivee LSV-11, a Santa Cruz H-13 (mahogany/spruce), a Santa Cruz 1929 OO (mahogany/mahogany) and a Santa Cruz OM/PW Ltd (rosewood/spruce). 

All were nice guitars, but I really enjoyed the SC's more than the others.  Although I really liked the OM/PW, I was really intrigued by the 1929 OO.  For a new guitar it was very resonant, was excellent for both fingerstyle and strumming, the size was extremely comfortable.  The string spacing by the saddle seemed wider than on my F-III (I haven't bothered to check the specs, but it seemed that it was).  I love the look of this guitar as well, the mahogany was beautiful (and Larrivee all-hogs look great too, this just had a different kind of look to it).  Oh yeah, loved the vintage style headstock too. 

Just curious if any FIV owners have played an SC 1929 OO since size seems quite similar.  How would you compare the two?  Any feedback would be appreciated.  Here are links to pictures of the guitar I played: s

http://www.madisonmusic.com/inventory/guitarpix/SantaCruz1929-FullView.jpg
http://www.madisonmusic.com/inventory/guitarpix/SantaCruz1929-Front.jpg
http://www.madisonmusic.com/inventory/guitarpix/SantaCruz1929-Back.jpg
http://www.madisonmusic.com/inventory/guitarpix/SantaCruz1929-Headstock.jpg

Thanks, Dan
Webber Roundbody Rosewood/Englemann 2001
Martin OO-15c Custom  Mahogany/Sitka 2014

I don't fully qualify according to your criteria, but I am close.  I have played the SC 001929 several times and I recently was able to compare it to a Larrivee 00 body style.  Without causing too much controversy they are just 2 different guitars from 2 different makers.  The Cruz's are built lighter than the Larrivee's which makes a big difference all the way around in more areas than I care to mention.  You are also comparing a $1K guitar to a $3K guitar.  Also not to mention a hand made guitar vs. a factory cnc cut and made guitar.  Danny gets pissed every time I bring up SCGC and compare, but there is a difference.  You guys got a steal of a deal on those forum guitars hands down...  I can't compare exactly what you are asking, but it would be hard to compare he two.  I am a Cruz and Larrivee owner and have owned several Larrivee's and Cruz's in years past both being great guitars, but hard to compare.  I hope you guys enjoy those new little guitars!!!!

:guitar :nana_guitar :cheers :beer :guitar
A bunch of great guitars I don't deserve and a gaggle of fly rods.... Aint life grand?

Nailed it -  You can only compare them in the fact that they both use mahogany, they are both approximately the same shape and size, but beyond that, they are very different - built with different approaches for different markets.

I love my Larrivees, and I love my Cruzes, but I wouldn't try to replace one with the other. If you are in the market for one of these, you really should play them both, and judge them based on your own criteria.
Bunch of Larrivees - all good -
and a wife that still puts up with me, which is the best -

Below are some pix I took in Eugene, OR a month or so back.  I'll be down there in mid June and will surely play the 1929 and compare it to my Forum-IV.

But I have to tell you that the resonance of the Forum-IV has really caught me off-guard.  I was not expecting it to be so lively.  That's what I remember about the 1929.  For sure the $1K F-IV dominates the $3K 1929 on quality sound vs price but I don't want to say more than that.  The 1929 is a very nice guitar.


That's a new Collings 0 hog top to the right.  I liked the 1929 better.




Nice retro looking headstock.  Good marketing to call it "1929".




Meticulous build quality.


Slotted bridge.  Great break angle over the saddle.
Play it daily for best results.

Doubt I'll get the chance to try the Santa Cruz...no one stocks them around here...

I would love to try it though.  I'm sure that 1929 is amazing but the FIV is more than just "good enough" for me 

Quote from: Denis on May 25, 2010, 08:25:03 AM
Doubt I'll get the chance to try the Santa Cruz...no one stocks them around here...

I would love to try it though.  I'm sure that 1929 is amazing but the FIV is more than just "good enough" for me 

Denis, if you're ever in Toronto, the Twelfth Fret stocks SCGC, as does Folkway in Guelph, about 50 km west.  And in Montreal, Boutique Tone stocks SCGC -- although that's more of an electric store, so I think they only have a couple at any given time.  (I haven't been there since they moved, though, so I could be wrong.)
D-03RE
D-03-12
00-50 TSB
OM-02

...and several other guitars.  Former Larrivees: P-01, OM-03R SH (Twelfth Fret special edition), P-01 Chris Hadfield special edition

Quote from: Tycho on May 25, 2010, 09:03:55 AM
Denis, if you're ever in Toronto, the Twelfth Fret stocks SCGC, as does Folkway in Guelph, about 50 km west.  And in Montreal, Boutique Tone stocks SCGC -- although that's more of an electric store, so I think they only have a couple at any given time.  (I haven't been there since they moved, though, so I could be wrong.)

Tycho...there is no way I will step foot in Toronto again without a trip to the 12th Fret.  My girlfriend has been warned.  Her twin sister now lives  a bit closer having left her fiance...they lived way out in Brampton.  I think she's in Etobicoke now.  And we have a friend that lives in the Danforth area....so, no two ways about it...

   The review in AG mag of the "1929" was a good one & made them sound like a steal. For $3,000? Our F-IVs are what I would expect the "1929" to sound like, right out of the case. Was an unexpected surprise. Two different companies, 2 different guitars, all with their own unique sound.
   Have never played the "1929" series, but have owned S.C. guitars before, being great guitars. Can't wait to hear what some that compare the two have to say. Never expected this sound from the F-IV right off the bat, & getting better everytime it's played. The wife is going to Florida for a week, so will use my ToneRite on it while she's gone. Not much space in my place! Would then like to bring it to my local "boutique" shop to compare. The "1929" is a little high, as far as money, for me.
   Hard to compare w/o having A/B'd them. Will be interesting? Think the comparison (tonal) will be closer than expected, as these Larrivees are just amazing. The S.C.'s are really nice guitars, as far as I can tell from the review. The salesman @ my shop gets a little pissy if you're not buying a $5,000 guitar from him, but always leave with something. Sales are his life. Will try to bring in my F-IV to have the luthier put my clear p/g on, getting my foot in the door. Good friend & honest, so might be able to bypass the sales thing?
   Plus, it's the store that originally turned me onto Larrivees, so I know that George (owner,luthier) will be interested. As many of us doing this as possible will give the best rounded opinion?
   
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true

The 1929 00-17 is a tribute/remake of a "1929 00-17 Martin".  It has a vintage voice to it right out of the box.  Theses SC 00's have a different voice with different style bracing, lighter built like a "1929 00-17 Martin did" than the Larrivee which makes it a TOTALLY different guitar from a totally different era.  Even if I had chosen to purchase one of the last 2 forum guitars, I would have never tried to compare it to a SC because they are 2 totally different concepts of a 00 guitar. There are no posts on the SCGC players forum wondering or comparing the 1929 to the Larrivee forum guitar because you really can't.  Two different guitars at 2 different price points... Not really A competition.  I Know the OP was just trying to start a conversation and not a shooting match. Like I said before... You guys got a bargain and I think it would be awesome to have one, but I don't as I have others I like to play.  If you played the 1929 00 you would agree.  They have sold more than they can make of those guitars at $3K without question or quibble about price.  Artisan started the whole idea in partner with SCGC.  Now they are available to all SCGC dealers.  If you like high end guitars... the 1929 00 is a bargain!
A bunch of great guitars I don't deserve and a gaggle of fly rods.... Aint life grand?

      I have played the Collings all Mahogany a little but not the SCGC.


Quote from: Bltprf502 on May 24, 2010, 09:46:15 PM
I don't fully qualify according to your criteria, but I am close.  I have played the SC 001929 several times and I recently was able to compare it to a Larrivee 00 body style.  Without causing too much controversy they are just 2 different guitars from 2 different makers.  The Cruz's are built lighter than the Larrivee's which makes a big difference all the way around in more areas than I care to mention.  You are also comparing a $1K guitar to a $3K guitar.  Also not to mention a hand made guitar vs. a factory cnc cut and made guitar.  Danny gets pissed every time I bring up SCGC and compare, but there is a difference.  You guys got a steal of a deal on those forum guitars hands down...  I can't compare exactly what you are asking, but it would be hard to compare he two.  I am a Cruz and Larrivee owner and have owned several Larrivee's and Cruz's in years past both being great guitars, but hard to compare.  I hope you guys enjoy those new little guitars!!!!

:guitar :nana_guitar :cheers :beer :guitar
Man, I am truly sorry if I came across that way to your posts. I am a bit moody at times. But I would think the SCGC 1929 would be a fantastic 00.

Quote from: dependan on May 25, 2010, 11:37:07 AM
      I have played the Collings all Mahogany a little but not the SCGC.

   
                 Man, I am truly sorry if I came across that way to your posts. I am a bit moody at times. But I would think the SCGC 1929 would be a fantastic 00.

Its all good Danny... I was just hoping you would join in on his one.   :bgrin: :thumbsup

  :winkin:
A bunch of great guitars I don't deserve and a gaggle of fly rods.... Aint life grand?

Quote from: Bltprf502 on May 25, 2010, 11:26:15 AM
... There are no posts on the SCGC players forum wondering or comparing the 1929 to the Larrivee forum guitar because you really can't.  Two different guitars at 2 different price points... Not really a competition.  ...
Of course there are no comparisons there.  Why would a high-end forum like SC entertain such thoughts?    :winkin:

Of course its not a competition.  There are so many really great guitars being made now.  There are bargains galore.  Pick your price point and play!

Having played the 1929 I can say that the F-IV also has that old-wood vibe.  Which sounds better?  Don't know if one does.  I'll find out in June.
Play it daily for best results.

Since were talking Hogtops, let's not forgot about this little builder up here in New England.

I'll be heading up to see Dana Bourgeois at Pantheon in July to try out/pick up the left hand version of this:





[attachment deleted by admin]
jeff

Larrivee 00-03MT Forum IV  #30 of 29

Oh, one thing about the Martin 1929 00-17, the inspiration for the SC model(s):

With the Great (American) Depression under way in 1929, Martin quickly produced some low cost (compared to their normal guitars of the time) all-hog guitars to help keep sales moving along and their name alive.  Martin still does that with their 15 and 15M series guitars.  Larrivee does it as well with the 03MT models. 

Santa Clara, Collings, and others spared no expense to do their versions and are doing a fabulous job, albeit at a much higher price point.
Play it daily for best results.

Quote from: prof_stack on May 25, 2010, 02:55:44 PM
Oh, one thing about the Martin 1929 00-17, the inspiration for the SC model(s):

With the Great (American) Depression under way in 1929, Martin quickly produced some low cost (compared to their normal guitars of the time) all-hog guitars to help keep sales moving along and their name alive.  Martin still does that with their 15 and 15M series guitars.  Larrivee does it as well with the 03MT models. 

Santa Clara, Collings, and others spared no expense to do their versions and are doing a fabulous job, albeit at a much higher price point.

Made in the USA by hand in a totally different economy... Of course there will be a much higher price point.  :winkin:
A bunch of great guitars I don't deserve and a gaggle of fly rods.... Aint life grand?

Quote from: bhika on May 25, 2010, 02:33:08 PM
Since were talking Hogtops, let's not forgot about this little builder up here in New England.

I'll be heading up to see Dana Bourgeois at Pantheon in July to try out/pick up the left hand version of this:





....and yes I know this would be a fantastic guitar as well.  I have one of Dana's Slope D's in flamed Maple and bearclaw spruce.  An amazing playing, sounding guitar for sure.  Thanks for sharing the pics.  I bet this one was more $ than the 00-17 1929.  Very nice in deed!
A bunch of great guitars I don't deserve and a gaggle of fly rods.... Aint life grand?

Quote from: Bltprf502 on May 25, 2010, 03:40:51 PM
....and yes I know this would be a fantastic guitar as well.  I have one of Dana's Slope D's in flamed Maple and bearclaw spruce.  An amazing playing, sounding guitar for sure.  Thanks for sharing the pics.  I bet this one was more $ than the 00-17 1929.  Very nice in deed!

Yes, but less then the Santa Cruz.
jeff

Larrivee 00-03MT Forum IV  #30 of 29

What dealer did you find that one at in the pic?
A bunch of great guitars I don't deserve and a gaggle of fly rods.... Aint life grand?

Quote from: Bltprf502 on May 25, 2010, 05:22:01 PM
What dealer did you find that one at in the pic?

I got the pictures from the Pantheon site, but it was made for AcousticMusic.org in Conn.
jeff

Larrivee 00-03MT Forum IV  #30 of 29

   That's the store about 10 minutes from me that I was talking about. Lots of stuff, no prices posted. Have to email, call, or go in. Bought ALL of my boutique guitars there for years, plus Larrivees. Is now a "high-end" shop that feels Larrivee isn't worthy of selling there? The ones they have are from the collection of the salesman, who was a Larrivee fanatic for years. Then Taylor. Now, whatever expensive, sweet sounding ones he plays?
   Is a really nice shop, like stepping back 100 years when you walk in. That's about how old the house is? Just has a great smell & feeling there. Bought Santa Cruz's, Bourgeois, Flammang, & others there. Takes me back to when I could afford them, as they were much cheaper?
   Here's the site: acousticmusic.org. I have no affiliation with them other than being friends with the owner/luthier, getting many things answered by him. When he's not busy?
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true

Powered by EzPortal