Indecision: OM-05 MT, OM-05, or OM-09?

Started by Ngerty, April 21, 2010, 08:15:57 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

TOPIC HAS CHANGED SLIGHTLY. PLEASE SCROLL DOWN THE PAGE AND HELP ME DECIDE BETWEEN THE OM-05MT, OM-05, and OM-09. THANKS!

For those who know I've been searching for my first quality guitar, well, I'm still searching. As of now, I'm down to the Larrivee OM-05 MT and the Taylor GC5. I finger-pick a lot, strum some. I originally was set on getting a mahogany-topped guitar, but western red cedar is interesting (GC5 has mahogany back and sides and a cedar top). Here are things I like and dislike about each guitar.

OM-05 MT Like: All Mahogany. Maple Binding. Wider string spacing. It's a Larrivee and that apparently means it is high-quality (So I've read...never played one and doubt I will be able to).

Dislike: OM size is a bit big, I think. Not exactly built for fingerpicking. Pick-guard (or else tan-line).

GC5 Like: Really attractive guitar. Comes without a pick-guard. Small, Grand Concert body shape. Short-scale. Slotted headstock is pretty cool (I like it more and more). Wider string spacing.

Dislike: Not a mahogany-topped guitar (Although I've been thinking lately: "Who cares? What's wrong with cedar?).

I've been leaning in the direction of the Taylor, however I've read that Taylor guitars are merely flashy and do not compare with Larrivees when it comes to sound. Hopefully I'll play a GC5 soon, but in the meantime, I'm interested in what this community has to say. Thanks!
:donut :donut :ph34r: :donut2 :donut2 :ph34r: :donut :donut
Martin HD-28
Martin DX1

OM-05  :+1: Finger picking OM-05  :+1: Strumming OM-05  :+1:
Don't know where you got your info, OM's are fantastic for finger picking  :+1:
cheers
fongie

let's see...
Taylor  :yak: or
Larrivee :bowdown:

Well I say Larrivee, It is not that different in size. It has a wonderful tone. It is as consummate finger-style guitar.

Larrivee stopped using cedar. It does have a warm mellow tone, breaks in quickly, but it is oily and the layers tend to flake which means bridge glue problems are much more likely.

Taylor's are fine instruments with fast action and a great neck. I just don't like the house sound. But Taylor and Larrivee are friends and Taylor buys his wood from JCL.
Chris
Larrivee's '07  L-09 (40th Commemorative); '09 00-03 S.E; '08 P-09
Eastman '07 AC 650-12 Jumbo (NAMM)
Martin   '11 D Mahogany (FSC Golden Era type)
Voyage-Air '10 VAOM-06
-the nylon string-
Goya (Levin) '58 G-30
-dulcimer-
'11 McSpadden

Both are wonderful Gits for fingerpicking. Personally I prefer the Larrivee feel and tone BUT that is an individual preference.

I realize you said you couldn't BUT really you should attempt to try the Larrivee somewhere
Larrivee Electrics - My Dream then and Now!!!!!<br /><br />Forum IV     00-03MT       #4      (Treasured)

Buy the Taylor. It will leave one more Larrivee available to the rest of us that know Larrivees' are a better constructed guitar.
Larrivee:
P09
OM03
OMO3R
OMO5
LO2
LO3R
LO3W
LO3K

The Taylor looks really nice, but it is more expensive. I also get the feeling that Larrivee's are much nicer despite the fact that they are less well known than Taylor Guitars. And in a sudden change I have almost definitely eliminated the Taylor from consideration and am considering the OM-05 MT and the OM-05. This, I'm sure, is something more people can help me out with. The spruce-topped guitar sounds very nice and dynamic in the youtube videos I've seen, while there are no videos of the MT being played. Can someone compare these guitars or describe what they know about them and their sound?

Thank you, your help is greatly appreciated!
:donut :donut :donut :donut2 :donut2 :donut2 :coffee :donut2 :donut2 :donut2 :donut :donut :donut
Martin HD-28
Martin DX1

Maybe I just happened upon a great little OM-05E, but I have a plethora of other gits costing 2-3 times as much as my
Larrivee(s)  and every night when I walk into the guitar room I'm always excited to reach for the OM-05.  Having said that, I will find me an OM-05MT one of these days - but only after I receive my F-IV soon!

Taylors and Larrivees both produce excellent products, but I'd suggest you for the Larrivee and if it doesn't become your best friend then try a Taylor.  JMO!

Good Luck


Quote from: Ngerty on April 21, 2010, 11:14:14 PM
The Taylor looks really nice, but it is more expensive. I also get the feeling that Larrivee's are much nicer despite the fact that they are less well known than Taylor Guitars.

Taylor is very good at marketing.  They are also good at making a consistent guitar with more emphasis on "plugged in" sound than pure acoustic sound. In general I think Larrivee makes a much better sounding guitar.

On the other hand, the Cedar topped models really are the under-appreciated Gems in the Taylor line, and sound substantively different than their spruced topped models.

Ceder sounds amazing but I'm sure it is a lighter wood then hog or spruce. There for it absorbs the sound more then it's heavier counterparts like hog and spruce who reflects and throws out more.
cheers
fongie

I am not interested in getting into the Taylor vs Larrivee; which is better debate, however an OM is a great guitar for fingerstyle. Definitely not too big (as Ngerty says above). I have two OMs (Martin & Larrivee) and I only play fingerstyle.

Quote from: Ngerty on April 21, 2010, 11:14:14 PM
...while there are no videos of the MT being played.

Ask and ye shall receive...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x5MijjRwoGw


I'll be getting more tunes with Mary Helen up on youtube in the coming weeks...keep your eyes peeled.

Blue
OM-05MT "Mary Helen"
Silvercreek T-170
Harmony Herd (1203, 162, 165, 6362)

Thanks Blue! Nice playing on a nice guitar. I would love a link to anything you post.

Could owners of either an OM-05MT, OM-05 or 0M-09 describe as best they can the guitar's sound? This would be enormously helpful. I've read that Larrivee does mahogany really well. Better than Rosewood? I've played one hog-top guitar (a 70's Guild D-15) which has a very interesting tone. I really like it for fingerpicking and alternate tunings. My Martin DX1 is spruce topped, but doesn't really handle different (lower) tunings all that well. Is this becuase it is spruce-topped, or is it because it cost $500 (and has high pressure laminate back and sides. I think Formica...)?

Anyway, what can I expect from each guitar in terms of its sound and tone and playability in alt. tunings?

Thanks.
Martin HD-28
Martin DX1

Blue in VT is a great player with a steady thumb for impeccable timing and a deep appreciation and understanding of the blues for that special mojo sound.
I have an OM-50TSB (traditional series so it has the enlarged soundhole)
Here's a youtube although I am capoed up at the 7th fret and I included some clams at the end just so you would know it was me.

I haven't played a 'hog version, but I did spend some time with an OM-09. Wow! One of the remarkable guitars. If I didn't already own a remarkable L-09...

It compared nicely with a Froggy Bottom and a Martin OM-28 Marquis I played. I am confidrnt that the -05's will be the same withe the 'hog sound.
Chris
Larrivee's '07  L-09 (40th Commemorative); '09 00-03 S.E; '08 P-09
Eastman '07 AC 650-12 Jumbo (NAMM)
Martin   '11 D Mahogany (FSC Golden Era type)
Voyage-Air '10 VAOM-06
-the nylon string-
Goya (Levin) '58 G-30
-dulcimer-
'11 McSpadden

Quote from: Queequeg on April 22, 2010, 10:23:23 AM
Blue in VT is a great player with a steady thumb for impeccable timing and a deep appreciation and understanding of the blues for that special mojo sound.

:blush: :blush: :blush:  aaawww shucks....thanks Q... :wink: (your check is in the mail... :tongue:)  

I didn't even know you were on youtube...you've got some great tunes up there...thanks for the link!

Ngerty...I'll let you know when I get more up...I'm sure I'll do some filming this weekend.

Blue
OM-05MT "Mary Helen"
Silvercreek T-170
Harmony Herd (1203, 162, 165, 6362)

Thanks Blue, and by the way, if you record anything else on the MT, could it possibly be in DADGAD tuning, or standard (or standard with low E down to a D)? I only ask this because it would help to hear the guitar played in a tuning that I would use. I don't want to inconvenience you or ask too much, but if you happen to know a tune in one of these tunings, I'd love to hear it!

Do you think Jim Holler would make a recording of the MT if I were to ask? I'm just a little unsure about the MT because I don't have the option to return it. Being a custom model, I'd only be able to try it if I went to his shop, but that's a ways away.

Still, any description of the tone of one of these guitars is greatly appreciated. Thanks.

:donut :donut :donut2 :donut2 :donut :donut :donut2 :donut2 :donut :donut :donut2 :donut2 :donut :donut :donut2 :donut2 :donut :donut :donut2 :donut2 :donut :donut
Martin HD-28
Martin DX1

I don't want to get into a debate about guitars or their sound (that's all subjective anyway). I will say however that I always wanted a Taylor since I first saw one in the early 90s. I played strictly classical and, in fact, gave up guitar for quite a few years. 2 years ago the bug bit again and I went out and bought a Taylor 214. THEN I bought a Larrivee L-03. I know the 214 with its laminated sides and back is inferior to the solid wood used in Larrivees and that should be a comparison but I still have the Larri and not the Taylor.

Then I decided I wanted a playmate for my L-03. I had owned a Martin D-18 many years ago and thought that would be a good compliment to the -03. I went to a large, nationally recognized store and began the search. That store just happened to have an OM-09 that blew the strings off any Martin in the place. I also played Collings, Santa Cruz, Lowden, and Bourgeois that trip and quickly forgot about any Martin.

I've since added a Collings and a Huss and Dalton to my herd but that OM-09's sound still haunts me.

I'd say get the -09... or the -05... or the MT. Well, you get the point.

f
Larrivee L-03 w/Gotoh 381 tuners (African Mahogany/Sitka)
Collings OM2Hc (EIR/Sitka)
Schenk Ophirio (Sapele/Cedar)
Bourgeois 00 Custom (Mahogany/It. Spruce)

Blue, Queequeg, nice playing  :+1: Enjoyed very much
Queequeg enjoyed your other clips as well  :thumb
cheers
fongie

Om 09, I played on recently and was totaly in guitar lust.
beautiful guitar ,good looking and played so wonderfully.
dave

Quote from: fongie on April 22, 2010, 06:41:57 PM
Blue, Queequeg, nice playing  :+1: Enjoyed very much
Queequeg enjoyed your other clips as well  :thumb
cheers
fongie
much obliged for your kind words of encouragement, fongie.  :wave

Powered by EzPortal