Searching for Ivory Bridepins and Saddle

Started by gregor, August 06, 2009, 03:51:28 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Here´s a pic from my saddle and nut (nut is the same material like the saddle)... i think it´s plastic but it´s not good to see on this bad pictures...

Greg

[attachment deleted by admin]

   gregor, I think you're making the right move by doing the bone or ivory nut, bone a cheaper alternative & still adds nice sound. Some prefer or don't notice a big difference with the nut change, but most will tell you it's worth it & make sure you have a good luthier do it. Should really have a beautiful sounding guitar when all is done. Good luck & keep us posted with the results!
     Jeff   :guitar
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true

That looks like Tusq. It's doubtful someone would go through the trouble of making that 90 degree angle that runs parrallel with the saddle under the b string.

Thank you BluesMan! Jeremy what do you mean (sorry, my english is not good enough)? Do i need this thing with the B-String on my new bone saddle too? Why i have this on my saddle now? What make this thing with my b-string?

Thanks, Greg

Greg - what he is refering to is the top of your saddle looks like it has been cast or machined very exactly. Usually with a hand fit saddle, the top edge is more "sinuous", since it is hand filed and polished.

When your tech fits your saddle, they need to compensate the top of it to make the intonation more accurate. The default shaping is to have all but the B string break at the leading edge,  and to have the B break at the trailing edge. If you have the guitar hand-compensated, you may see the break point vary from string to string, but it will depend on the thickness of the strings, and the type of compensation you like. It all gets ridiculously complicated, and for 90+% of players, myself included, the very small distinctions almost need to be pointed out -

After its done, and you look at the old and new, it will all be very obvious - And you should really enjoy it.

Tad
Bunch of Larrivees - all good -
and a wife that still puts up with me, which is the best -

   Tad, I've had Tusq compensated saddles replaced with bone ones, many being not compensated on the bone ones. Have only had one bone one, actually, that was compensated on the B string. All of the others, I guess if done right, as I questioned this as I watched one luthier doing it, don't have to be compensated. I couldn't figure it out, ending up with an uncompensated bone saddle & the original Tusq compensated one. And the intonation is dead on. I know for a fact that that the F-III Tusq saddles were compensated, as yours is, but Jim's bone one is not. One luthier of mine broke the saddle twice when compensating it, so put one on that wasn't. It also was dead on, as far as intonation. I don't have one Larrivee or my Baden that has a compensated saddle now. Can you or someone explain this? I was given 2 answers, one the "if done right" & the other saying "he just did it another way". Jim's first uncompensated saddle was off, but since doing the new saddle & nut, all if perfect. My Epi AJ-500M had the same thing done to it, me being told that it was actually off (the B string) with the original saddle.
   Anyone know the reason why this works the way it does? As I said, all of the bone ones made are now uncompensated, 2 being compensated to start (Tusq). Tad, Jeremy, Rob, all else, an explanation?
     Jeff   :guitar
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true

Alot of it has to do with your ear, and what you find as the "sweet" spot when playing. From a little bit of reading I've done so far on the subject, the style of playing you do can affect what you hear as "tuned". If you play mostly in major chords, you may adjust your tuning one way, and if you play in diminished, maybe tweak it a little differently - open tunings, slightly different another way. It also matters if you play with other instruments, or just solo.

What that means to me, is that since I play a little in alot of different ways, I want a very generic compensation.

The thickness of a Tusq saddle seems to be .120". In that thickness, you can get at most maybe 8+ cents of adjustment for a string. That is not huge, but you can definitely hear it if you try.

When I took my F3 to my tech, I had him check and adjust each string using his tuner. Most digital tuners are accurate to maybe 1 cent ( they say 1 cent, but . . ).  He played the 12th fret octave, and compared it to the 12th fret harmonic. The harmonic divides the string exactly in half - and the twelth fret should do the same ( differences in action, string guage, etc, not being taken into account here ). If the string frets a bit sharp or flat, the break point on the saddle can be moved ever so slightly to compensate. When it is very, very close, the harmonic and octave should be identical. But you also have to fret up each string as well to check individual notes.

So when he did this with my F3, the top of the saddle ended up with the E 2/3 back from the leading edge, A 9/10 back, D 1/2, G 1/8 back, B 9+/10 , and e about 1/8 back. The intonation is as perfect as I could ever hear it, and registers on the tuner near perfect. That is just this one guitar - it could be very off if you slipped this into another F3. But it would probably be close, since it isn't very different from the original TUSQ saddle.

BUT - if I were to change the string weight, tweak the truss rod 1/8 turn, or even an extended change in local humidity, would throw it all off. Not by very much, but enough that on the tuner you would definitely see it.

If everything sounds great to you, then it is great - that's the wonderful thing about all this.

Hope that isn't too confusing - As I said at the beginning, I'm just reading up on all this as I'm trying to understand it better myself, since it is part of the process of setting up a guitar -

If you get a chance, look at how it all works on an electric guitar - the bridge is designed to be easily and rapidly adjusted in height, and in compensation for each string - makes set-up a LOT easier -

Tad
Bunch of Larrivees - all good -
and a wife that still puts up with me, which is the best -

Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 08, 2009, 03:00:20 PM
   Tad, I've had Tusq compensated saddles replaced with bone ones, many being not compensated on the bone ones. Have only had one bone one, actually, that was compensated on the B string. All of the others, I guess if done right, as I questioned this as I watched one luthier doing it, don't have to be compensated.

All else equal, if it has to be compensated on the tusq then it has to be compensated on the bone. The bone saddle in my Santa Cruz and my D-18LO are both fully compensated. It's not hard to do.

Actually, here is a much better explanation for anyone who wants to read through it -

http://www.guyguitars.com/eng/handbook/Tuning/temperament.html

Tad
Bunch of Larrivees - all good -
and a wife that still puts up with me, which is the best -

   Guys, I have near perfect pitch, play by ear, can pick up a tune quickly just by listening. What it sounds like your explanation implies, Tad, is I am a simpleton? :humour: As far as my ears? Really these luthiers are the best in the state, & no one come back with there must not be many here, & how do you also explain Jim doing uncompensated saddles? He's a master builder, builds classicals for many great players, but did our F-III saddles uncompensated bone. The guitars might leave the factory flat, as I know one did, & therefore didn't need to be compensated, as it was. Doing a straight saddle corrected the fact that the B was flat. The two main guys I use, one being a former apprentice of the other, have worked on MANY famous people's guitars. When Steven Stills would come into our state to play, he would always have one of these luthiers do the setup prior to his shows. If you know his history, he's about as anal as they come to having a perfect guitar. Still don't but the fact that if it's Tusq compensated, it has to be bone the same way. Have 3 examples here @ home to the contrary. Larrivee just throws them on, probably having a dozen or so to chose from, & is done by ear. I know what it says on paper & Jeremy your S.C. & fake Martin (you'll love that one!), but maybe your ears are off? Question oneself, then question others! :humour:
     Jeff   :guitar
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true

Jeff, I'm not sure what you are getting at.

Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 08, 2009, 05:59:58 PM
     how do you also explain Jim doing uncompensated saddles?

Maybe they didn't need to be compensated, who knows  :?


If the guitar is going sharp or flat up the neck then, assuming there are no other problems, you move the contact point on the saddle back or forward accordingly. It's that simple. I had to have the uncompensated bone saddle on my OM/PW replaced because the B was going sharp. 



Sorry Jeff, but all Jims initial bone saddles had basic compensation on them. I know, I had 4 go through my hands -

And it has alot less to do with your quality of hearing as with the style of your playing, and maybe your expectations. If it sounds good to you, then it is, and conversely, if it doesn't sound good to you, then it isn't. Ask one of your luthier friends if they ever had to set a guitar up in a way they thought was bad, but the customer loved it.

Its like fine cooking - Theres nothing better in this world than when my mom cooks a birthday dinner, but she'd never be hired by Chez Panisse -

Tad
Bunch of Larrivees - all good -
and a wife that still puts up with me, which is the best -

  Tad, not to be augmentative, but Jim gave me back both the Tusq saddle & the first bone one he made, which isn't compensated. Nor the second. I'll accept your comments on the rest as it's as you said, like fine cooking! We'll let it rest for now. Until I really research it & find an answer that i can accept as a physics reason. I just can't get over thinking in a scientific way. Has been pounded into me!
     Jeff   :guitar
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true


   Jeremy, thanks. Interesting reading, but now I'm more confused about the uncompensated bone saddles I have. I get the idea that it all comes down to point of contact, thus resulting in a different breaking point. I wish there was another view other than from the top (the others don't address the B string compensation). I just don't get how twice, a compensated saddle was taken (actually 3) & made in one that wasn't, the intonation still being dead-on. I know, nothing's dead-on, but using my Boss TU-12 & Crafter clip-on, the intonation is on the money (we'll use that phrase instead). What am I missing here?
   Think I just found the thing I missed, which would have helped if the was an angled diagram in that article. I looked @ both of Jim's saddles & what I didn't notice before I see now. He ANGLED the saddle where the B makes contact, ever so slightly & not as much as the Larrivee one. This changed the contact point of the B string, thus making it compensated. Had to look real close to notice the difference in the width of the top of the saddle, but upon close inspection of his old one & the one that's on my F-III now, I can see the contact point is set back a hair from the E, being the string that was easiest to compare to.
   I stand corrected on this one, defer to the master, & thanks for the enlightening article. Without it, I don't think I'd have gotten up to really inspect the saddle so closely. Now I see that it is compensated, but the Larrivee one looks alot more! :?
   Thanks again & now I not only get it, but can see it, helping my scientific mind! :thumb
     Jeff   :guitar
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true

   Jeremy & Tad, here are a couple of poor pics, but showing how the contact point on the bone saddle IS shifted on the point where the B string contacts it, towards the bridge.. If you follow the line of light, it is visible, besides the narrowing of the top of the saddle. Just to show you were right, & I wasn't looking closely enough! :doh
    Jeff   :guitar

[attachment deleted by admin]
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true

I can see it in the pics. That's another nice thing about not using a Tusq saddle, it looks better than that angled B string box.

Now you know what to look for - on the Tusq, the casting process makes it very clear, probably so they don't accidentally put it in backwards at the factory -  :humour: - On the handmade one, the break point is less obvious, until you really look.

Tad
Bunch of Larrivees - all good -
and a wife that still puts up with me, which is the best -

   Here's a few more I took, making it more noticeable. It also looks like the low E string is slightly compensated, also. The contact point on the bone saddle for the B string is towards to Tusq saddle. The line is a little long, so it might be hard to tell.
     Jeff   :guitar

[attachment deleted by admin]
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true

Powered by EzPortal