Odd observation with string change.....

Started by Blueser, August 03, 2009, 02:01:34 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

So I have two Larrivee Dreads.....A D-10 with rosewood back and sides and sitka top, and a D05 custom, which is basically a mahogany D-05 with sitka top and a D-50 neck (square headstock and engraved chrome tuners).  They are definitely different sounding (as you would expect).  The R/W bodied D-10 has a bit more low end and upper-mid metallic jangle and chime, while the Mahogany D-05 has a more balanced tone across the spectrum, and just a bit less of that jangle on the top end.  I recently brought my D-05 to have a K&K mini western pickup system installed, and while I was at it, I had a set of John Pierce Bluegrass strings put on, as I wanted to try them to get that little bit extra top end jangle out of the guitar.  Prior to that, both guitars were strung with D'Dario EJ116's, and now only the D-10 has them still on it. 

I noticed that the D-05 with the Pierce Bluegrass strings now has significantly less volume than the D-10, which is still strung with the EJ116's.  This was not the case prior to the change, and I was wondering if a string change could have made this much of a difference.  I know I can always put another set of EJ116's on the D-05 to check, but I just had these installed, and truth be told, while they are not as loud, the guitar sounds sweet, and seems to be easier to play with these strings.  I also have a set of Pierce 80/20's that I will try as well, as I wanted to see if there was anything that was better than the EJ's that I was playing ( I am open to suggestions), but it just seems odd to me, that strings of the same gauge would have that much of a volume difference!

Any information or feedback would be appreciated.  I have played electric guitar for close to 20 years, and have recently been bitten by the acoustic bug over the past two years, and just trying to get my preferences settled.

Thanks,
Dave

There shouldn't be that much volume difference between JP's and D'addario.

yep - strings can make a huge difference in the sound of a guitar. Volume, feel, tone - alot of variables. The pickup shouldn't have had any effect, but I would have probably suggested only making one change at a time to get a better feel for each one.

You'll find that there isn't a brand of strings out there that someone on the Forum won't feel is the best sounding, while someone else may hate them. The EJs are a standard, and I am happy with them on my OMs and LSs, but I don't play a Dread -  I tried some JPs on an OM and didn't care for them myself, but had some on my baritone, and they sounded good on it -

Tad
Bunch of Larrivees - all good -
and a wife that still puts up with me, which is the best -

Quote from: tadol on August 03, 2009, 03:21:28 PM
yep - strings can make a huge difference in the sound of a guitar. Volume, feel, tone - alot of variables. The pickup shouldn't have had any effect, but I would have probably suggested only making one change at a time to get a better feel for each one.

You'll find that there isn't a brand of strings out there that someone on the Forum won't feel is the best sounding, while someone else may hate them. The EJs are a standard, and I am happy with them on my OMs and LSs, but I don't play a Dread -  I tried some JPs on an OM and didn't care for them myself, but had some on my baritone, and they sounded good on it -

Tad

Thanks for your responses thus far.  I agree, that the pickup would/should not have affected anything, but when he took the strings off to install the pickup, this was the opportunity to change them, so in essence, I did only change one thing that made any real difference.   On the next string change, I will go back to the EJ's to see if the strings are the culprit. 

Thanks,
B




Strings can, and do, have a large impact on both tonal qualities and volume projection.
"The barrier to knowledge is the belief that you have it"

2006 Larrivee LV-10 MR   1980 Les Paul Custom Natural   2008 Larrivee LV-03-12   1998 Carvin LB75 Koa Bass

Is it possible you just happend to get a bad set of strings ?
Maybe they had been on the shelf forever.    - Larry
PLAY SONG , LIVE LONG !

Larrivee OOO-60 - Lady Rose
Pavan TP-30 classical - nylon
Takamine 132s classical -nylon
former Larrivees  L-03R  SD-50

I have no proof, but it was told to me by an authoritative source (a N. American professional guitarist) that John Pearse, Martin and various other brands of strings are all manufactured by D'Addario (to the particular specifications of the brand holders of course).  Interesting.
Larrivée Limited Edition Rosewood Parlor (2003)
plus various other acoustic guitars and one ukulele

I have used both EJ-16 and John Pearse for years with not much difference..except the JP's haveing much more longevity.

However..if the install of your undersaddle pick up was botched...that  my friend would make a huge difference in sound!

Every time anything is added between the saddle and the bridge a change in sound will occur.....ususally not a positive one!


Good luck!



Quote from: Bubblemaker on August 09, 2009, 07:17:47 PM


However..if the install of your undersaddle pick up was botched...that  my friend would make a huge difference in sound!



K&K mini's stick to the bridgeplate, not under saddle.
10-1614 more than a number, it's body and soul.

Powered by EzPortal