Traditional series?

Started by BenF, August 03, 2009, 11:12:53 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

From reading previous threads, I understand that many people acknowledge that the only things traditional about the traditional series are the external looks and the name.  Underneath they are modern day Larrivees, with larger soundholes and slightly adjusted bracing patterns.

Whilst the L body is the Larrivee trademark shape, why is there no L-50 or L-60 in the lineup.  A uniquely Larrivee guitar with a traditional look? 

Thoughts?
Ben
2009 FIII LS-03RHB #5

http://www.youtube.com/user/1978BenF

Ben, I'd venture the guess that the L is uniquely Larrivee and the Trad Series was designed to mimic the look of, well, Traditional Martin design.

But the D already mimics the Martin Dread shape, as the OM mimics the Martin OM, even without the 'traditional' tag.  They are only traditional in that their appointments are more common with early 20th century and before guitars, i.e. open back tuners, some with slot heads, herrinbone purfling, sunburst finishes, squared paddle headstocks.  Surely these items are at least in part cosmetic preferences, and for that reason why should there not be an L with these options?

This crossed my mind recently when a thread about sunburst finishes was on the AGF, and a number of people praised JCLs sunburst skills.   It seems odd that this 'traditional' feature is available (or has at some stage) on everything except his trademark guitar.

Maybe I am missing the point.
Ben
2009 FIII LS-03RHB #5

http://www.youtube.com/user/1978BenF

You have to recognize what this series is 'traditional' to. They are styled after pre-war Martins, there's no question this is what they are meant to look like. To use the term 'traditional' in a general way is inaccurate because this look didn't exist outside of Martin for the most part. The reason there is no L in the lineup is because Martin didn't make an L body.

Over the last few years or so there has been a large market for guitars based on pre-war Martin designs. Manufactures have been offering open geared tuners, 'forward shifted' and 'scalloped' bracing, herringbone, etc. Larrivee followed with their own guitars that looked like Martins and put 'shifted bracing' in the description, which wasn't worth mentioning except that it's a phrase that helps sell guitars.

If you want a L with a traditional Larrivee look get one of those JCL 40th Anniversary guitars. If you want an L that looks like a traditional Martin I guess you're out of luck.

EDIT: The reason Larrivee doesn't make a L that looks like a traditional Martin is probably because they don't think there is a market for it. People wanting these pre-war Martin style guitars are going for Martin body shapes not Larrivee.

Fair enough.  I guess it undermines the unique Larrivee shape by making an old looking one.  I was thinking of these details as a cosmetic preference rather than defining an era.  I hadn't really thought of them as 'exclusively Martinlike', but I guess you are quite right when I think about it. 

Ben
2009 FIII LS-03RHB #5

http://www.youtube.com/user/1978BenF

I think that it is worth noting that at least in the case of the the SDs, traditional is more than simply visual.
With the 12-fret design, the bridge is shifted to the center of the lower bout and this has a significant impact on the sound of the guitar.

Quote from: Queequeg on August 03, 2009, 11:51:27 AM
I think that it is worth noting that at least in the case of the the SDs, traditional is more than simply visual.


No more than the other guitars in the traditional line up that are also based on Martin body styles. The bridge isn't 'shifted' on the SD because that is how they were designed(ie it isn't an alteration).

The 000 also isn't in the regular line up.

Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 03, 2009, 12:01:52 PM
No more than the other guitars in the traditional line up that are also based on Martin body styles. The bridge isn't 'shifted' on the SD because that is how they were designed(ie it isn't an alteration).

The 000 also isn't in the regular line up.
Indeed. My point is that this traditional appointment is not merely visual. (That was the OP's original point.)

Quote from: Queequeg on August 03, 2009, 12:15:54 PM
Indeed. My point is that this traditional appointment is not merely visual. (That was the OP's original point.)

It's not an appointment, it's an overall body design based on Martin's just like the 14 fret OM, 12 fret 000 and 14fret dread. On the inside it's a modern day Larrivee.

My last try, Jeremy:
The overall body design of the SD which is a slope-shouldered dred, has among such "traditional" features as  (1.) a pyramid bridge and (2.) a slothead, some of which one might say (as the original poster did) that "the only things traditional about the traditional series are the external looks".
The point I was trying to make (although obviously and hugely unsuccessfully on my part, as witness your responses) was that it isn't all merely for appearances. Some are structural and functional to the sound of the guitar.
That is all.

 
Quote from: Queequeg on August 03, 2009, 01:09:07 PM
The point I was trying to make was that it isn't all merely for appearances.

I'm aware they don't make an SD in anything other than the traditional series, I got that. My point was that compared to the rest of the 'traditional' line up the SD is no more traditional in tonal or aesthetic features. You don't have to keep responding telling me the SD has traditional features that are more than aesthetic; I understand that and was only adding that while the SD does have traditional features the rest of the line up is just as traditional (for their respective body style) in those areas like the bridge and headstock. For instance the OM-50 and even the OM-03 have a belly bridge and solid headstock (features traditional to an OM) so there is nothing note worthy about the features of the SD other than they don't make it in the standard series.


Let me open another can of worms.  I would actually dispute even the appearance part of the "Traditional" series.  To my eyes, the enlarged soundhole makes the guitar look significantly different from the pre-war Martins and the recent clones thereof.  I don't know what's so "traditional" about that at all.

The bottom line: it's too easy to get caught up with the interpretation of the label "Traditional" here.  (I personally think it's a misnomer, intentional or otherwise on Larrivee's part.)  FWIW, I own one because it has the tone that I want, not because it looks like a "pre-war Martin."  The alleged resemblance to the vintage guitars played absolutely no part in my decision to purchase the OM-50.  In fact, if I had my way, I'd ditch the open-back tuners on it for a nice set of Gotohs.   :tongue:
'07 Larrivée OM-50 (Bone Nut/Saddle, K&K Pure Mini Pickup)
'09 Composite Acoustics OX Raw

Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 03, 2009, 02:54:00 PM

I'm aware they don't make an SD in anything other than the traditional series, I got that. My point was that compared to the rest of the 'traditional' line up the SD is no more traditional in tonal or aesthetic features. You don't have to keep responding telling me the SD has traditional features that are more than aesthetic; I understand that and was only adding that while the SD does have traditional features the rest of the line up is just as traditional (for their respective body style) in those areas like the bridge and headstock. For instance the OM-50 and even the OM-03 have a belly bridge and solid headstock (features traditional to an OM) so there is nothing note worthy about the features of the SD other than they don't make it in the standard series.
OK, right. I think that we understand each other then (at last). Sorry, I wasn't trying to be argumentative.

Quote from: BenF on August 03, 2009, 03:29:38 PM
I never started this  :wacko:
Hey Ben! - some things  :wacko: my mind too, and it seems we need to get through this once again  :yawn.
I could with the best intentions perhaps just add that in Larrivee's case, the "advanced X" seems to be rather a case of the perimeter of the enlarged sound hole moving closer to the relative stationary X brace. The way I see the traditional series, is a culmination of some popular traditional appointments into a standard Larrivee-voiced guitar.
"To me...music exists to elevate us as far as possible above everyday life." ~ Gabriel Faure

Quote from: BenF on August 03, 2009, 11:12:53 AM
From reading previous threads, I understand that many people acknowledge that the only things traditional about the traditional series are the external looks and the name.  Underneath they are modern day Larrivees, with larger soundholes and slightly adjusted bracing patterns.

Whilst the L body is the Larrivee trademark shape, why is there no L-50 or L-60 in the lineup.  A uniquely Larrivee guitar with a traditional look?  

Thoughts?
Remember that we have an L series guitar that has a Herringbone rosette and trim on the body, with a 12fret neck and Jeremy even said in response to Denis playing his that it sounded like a pre-war Martin.
                 That of course is the guitar in my signature.    But I know, I know ...it's not a Martin. No one needs to remind me. ( I have one) :donut

Quote from: Zohn on August 04, 2009, 02:30:03 AM

I could with the best intentions perhaps just add that in Larrivee's case, the "advanced X" seems to be rather a case of the perimeter of the enlarged sound hole moving closer to the relative stationary X brace.

Larrivee doesn't call it "advanced X" as far as I know. The description on their site says "Shifted Symmetrical Parabolic X-Bracing" because they probably want you to think 'Forward Shifted' or 'Advanced X'. It's actually shifted backwards an amount that is probably negligible.

Quote from: dependan on August 04, 2009, 03:07:38 AM
     Remember that we have an L series guitar that has a Herringbone rosette and trim on the body, with a 12fret neck and Jeremy even said in response to Denis playing his that it sounded like a pre-war Martin.
                 

For the record, I said "It actually sounds kinda like a vintage Martin small body, like a 0-18 or 00-18, but more upfront."



Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 04, 2009, 09:35:38 AM
Larrivee doesn't call it "advanced X" as far as I know. The description on their site says "Shifted Symmetrical Parabolic X-Bracing" because they probably want you to think 'Forward Shifted' or 'Advanced X'. It's actually shifted backwards an amount that is probably negligible.
There you go... :+1:
"To me...music exists to elevate us as far as possible above everyday life." ~ Gabriel Faure

Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 04, 2009, 09:35:38 AM
Larrivee doesn't call it "advanced X" as far as I know. The description on their site says "Shifted Symmetrical Parabolic X-Bracing" because they probably want you to think 'Forward Shifted' or 'Advanced X'. It's actually shifted backwards an amount that is probably negligible.

For the record, I said "It actually sounds kinda like a vintage Martin small body, like a 0-18 or 00-18, but more upfront."



Thanks Jeremy, I forgot what you had said exactly.

  I will add this thought here. I think that the Forum III design with a slothead, pyramid bridge and a few more ''Traditional" style add ons would be a wonderful little guitar for Larrivee to produce. Especially now that Martin has dropped the 000-15 and 17S from there line. Larrivee could use this size and do some all Mahogany runs with it.      
               I would like it, or something similar in a 12 fret, smaller body depth, all hog.

   Jeremy, sounds like you didn't have your coffee today! :humour: I have to agree about the LOOKS of the SD's trying to have that vintage look, as Q is saying. But I agree with Jeremy that they don't have the same build or sound of a Martin vintage guitar. Personally, I just thuink they have thier own, awesome sound. I know from owning & playing my SD-50 that it is unique to itself. Might have some cool vintage appointments (slot-head, HB, etc.) & because it's 12 to the body the bridge is shifted lower, but these things aren't what gives it its sound. The bracing, which IS different than a Martin, plays a major factor in the sound. Not saying it's better, just different. As I said in my for sale thread, a friend recently played mine & said it sounded better than his slope Collings, which surprised me. Told him what I paid & he didn't believe me. The collings was 3-4 times as much.
   I will say one thing, you play a "normal" SD-50 & you'll realize how they are powerful, balanced, but have a sound projection that knocks your socks off. Some might have played a clunker. They're out there. Q has a monster on a leash, as I do. I'm not saying these things to promote the sale of my SD, but just stating things the way I see & hear them. My SD-50 is simply an awesome guitar, 'nough said. It speaks for its self. Listen & let me know if you can hear me playing it! It's so loud, you probably could. And that's playing @ a normal strum. Everybody loves to pull quotes from others, but I'm telling you, in the Traditional Series, the SD-50 is a different guitar than the others. Would love to get my hands on a OOO-50, just to play, but for my style, the SD fits all styles of music. I wanted to throw light strings on mine, but Jeremy suggested that I stick with the recommended mediums, which I think give it alot of its power. I'm learning to stop arguing about crap & start listening & learning, @ the ripe old age of 52! As of Thursday! Just another day, another year, but I talked my wife into that high-end case on Ebay for my F-III! Happy bithday to me! :bgrin:
     Jeff   :guitar
'11 Martin OM18V Engelmann Custom
'11 Martin D-18 Adirondack Custom
'12 Martin MFG OM-35 Custom
'07 Larrivee OOO-60(Trinity Guitars)
'13 Larrivee OM-03 "Exotic"RW Custom(Oxnard C.S.)
'10 L.Canteri OO1JP Custom(IS/IT.WALNUT)


So it seems I have come to doubt, all that I once held as true

Powered by EzPortal