Should I buy a cracked D-03?

Started by JohnnyB, May 25, 2008, 02:51:49 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.


Hey folks -

I am new to guitars, and was hoping that you could give me a little advice.  I went to the store to purchase my first guitar (looking at Seagull S06s), but the salesman found a used Larrivee D-03 with a center seam split (and a pickup) for about $500.  He indicated that some humidity may close the gap, or the split could be repaired and that there should be no adverse outcomes on sound quality.  Given all of the positive reviews that I have read about the Larrivee brand, I am considering the purchase - but the crack still worries me a but.  Should I be concerned?

Thank you, in advance, for helping out a new guy!

John

JohnnyB,

Welcome to the forum!  :gotdonuts:
You can buy a new D-03 for 800 bucks or so, and used they come much more dear....say 600 bucks.  Paying 500 for one with a top crack might not be the best idea when you can spend a little more and get a "perfect" guitar.

If you really want the guitar have a luthier check it out for you and tell you if the crack needs to be cleated to keep it from growing larger or if it is stable as is.  There are plenty of guitars out there with cracks that sound just great.  Good luck!

Justin 
OM-03 MT Custom (Cree Studios "Fish Guitar")

Welcome to the forum John!

A crack is an indication of a severe lack of moisture due to a prolonged lack of humidity.  The crack is probably the out growth of other issues that could also come to the surface.   I would not recommend the purchase unless you do as Justin said...  Have a reputable Luthier do a full examination on the guitar to let you know what you might be headed for.  As was already mentioned a new guitar can be purchased for a bit more and you would not be inheriting the problems that could be costly.

Would recommend you look up the for sale section of the forum, or seek guitaradoptions.com.   They are running a clearance sale right now and you could land a good deal on a new Larrivee.   Once you settle on a new instrument be sure to research the importance of proper maintenance and humidity settings. 

Hope I helped and didn't hinder...

Good luck!

Russ

:welcome:
06' Larrivee LV-03E
89' Fender Strat Custom Shop
85' Zion Electric
Carvin all tube vintage amps
And a lot of other junk!



Thank you Justin & Russ.  The luthier at the shop recommended that the crack (which he indicated was caused by prolonged lack of moisture) be left alone - and of course the guitar humidified appropriately.  He felt that may even close it up entirely.  But then again - he may be a bit biased.   :wink:

That said - I have the same concerns about additional problems.  Is it possible to fully "restore" an instrument once it has been dried too much?

Thanks!

John

I would say yes....  But a crack is a crack....  While it may close a little - it is still a breach in the integrity of the instrument.  It should be repaired....  Having said that, a new one for a little more $$ might provide a little more security for the new owner.
guitar
Also, consider the cost of repair - Sounds like the Luthier is biased.....   He may be a repairman - which is (in my view) different than a qualified Luthier.   

Friend of mine had a guitar that completely dried out - the neck bowed severely so the strings actually touched the frets!  He had to take it to a Luthier who re-humidified the guitar.  It took two weeks in a humidor being saturated with moisture....  My friend promptly sold the guitar.... 

Anyway, I would still recommend a few more $$ on a new one.  You will probably have to spend that much on repairs in the long run.....

Speaking of long run..... I'd better....

Regards,

Russ
06' Larrivee LV-03E
89' Fender Strat Custom Shop
85' Zion Electric
Carvin all tube vintage amps
And a lot of other junk!

Also check with Jason at www.notableguitars.com - get his pricelist by email and check it out.  He gives even better prices to the forumites....Dave at guitaradoptons does too and also Jim from Trinity Guitars....all great fellows and all great prices right now before the 2009 price increase.  By a new one!  You won't be sorry.  I just bought a D-03 from Jason.

Justin
OM-03 MT Custom (Cree Studios "Fish Guitar")

Although the crack may be stable and no effect can heard, or barely seen, it will effect the resale.  I had a beautiful Morgan dread with a repaired top crack....had a tough time getting a decent price for it.  If you plan on keeping it forever, offer $300.

Good luck,
Kevin 

John, as was stated so nicely by others on this post, be careful. Here's a true story:

While he was visiting his brother at Penn State a couple of years ago, my son bought a used 12 String Segull for a couple of hundred dollars plus a brand new case from a supposedly reputable dealer who had been in business for many years. It too had "dried out" and had a bridge that was lifting. Within a couple of days of the purchase, I took it back to the dealer myself to get my son a refund or a store credit and the owner of the shop told me that since he had sold the guitar on consignment, he wouldn't budge on his position. I reminded the shop owner that there was no mention of the fact that while his store had a refund or return policy in place, he made zero effort to help us solve the problem. He said since it was sold on consignment, the rule did not apply but no one told my son that when he bought the guitar.

I was able to take it to a friend who builds guitars and he was able to fix it and it has been properly humidified and sounds and plays pretty well. That being said, if my son had it to do over again, he wouldn't have bought the guitar. In the long run, this was a hard (but fairly inexpensive) lesson in the heartache of buying a used guitar and my son should have known better but this lesson will serve him well in the future.





I think you need the unbiased opinion of a good luthier not attached to the shop that is selling the problem guitar.
Humidifying the guitar will not cure it of its ills even if the crack sort of comes together again. the 2 halves need to be cleated after it is re-humidified. And frankly, I wouldn't want that guy to be the one to do it if he thinks no further action is necessary.
If all the alarms arent going off for you on this yet, they should be.

AND If there is a visible crack chances are there is damage elsewhere - bracing, binding, etc...  Sometimes we need to deal with our emotions while shopping for a guitar.....  Until we find the right one, they need to be seen as "units" and love will come soon after......       :smile:
06' Larrivee LV-03E
89' Fender Strat Custom Shop
85' Zion Electric
Carvin all tube vintage amps
And a lot of other junk!

                    The horse trader in me says give them 300 and humidify it. But I look for these deals. I have never lost yet. I might though and you might but then it may be a sweet deal. Danny


OK -

So I think I have started to notice an overall trend in the responses to my original question.  If I cannot negotiate a much lower price - I should look elsewhere.  I really appreciate everyone's input on this!

John

I've found that people often buy flawed items, or items they really don't want, when they feel rushed.  You didn't say you were shopping for a D-03, just that you want a nice learner guitar.  There are plenty out there, and if you want a Larrivee, you could even get the slightly cheaper OM model.  You have time to take a breather, find a good guitar, and one that isn't cracked.  The first thing someone asks about instruments is "are there any cracks."  If you have one that is, you'll never sell it for top dollar.  I bet a brand new, warrantied, om-03 from Notable or another online shop would be just a tad more than the 500 dollar broken guitar.  You'll have a nice, new one, and if you decide to upgrade for a dread size, it will move easier than a cracked one.  .02 

My best to you on this endeavor.

Just thought I'd throw my 2 cents + tax in here as well.  When I had briefly considered selling my D-03SPE, I was planning on asking not much more than the used one you found - and mine is in perfect condition!  I would stay away from it and continue the search.  Happy hunting!

Powered by EzPortal