Titanium Strings

Started by edgeguy, March 17, 2008, 10:41:26 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

DISCLAIMER: I AM NOT a luthier, string engineer, etc, etc. If you want to talk air flow on a diesel engine, turbo's, fueling characteristics, or the like, I'm your guy! I'm only relating what I have read and trying to apply the stated facts to what is being claimed and trying to make sense of it all.

saffron_boots -
There are many variables when looking at how a sound is made on a stringed instrument. Laying aside wood types, the guitars construction process and materials, and concentrating on string differences only... the relationship betwee string length, mass per unit length, and frequency (also could be defined as pitch) are dependant on tension to reach a desired harmonic. You can somewhat understand it this way...

Given the same mass, the longer the string, the higher the tension to achieve a frequency.
If the strings length is constant, the higher the strings mass, the higher the tension required for the frequency.

There is actually a formula that relates this. The formula looks pretty formidable, but it comes from the fact that the note produced by a string is proportional to the speed that sound travels in the string, and that speed in turn depends on how tense and how heavy the string is.

As you can see, mass and tension affect frequency and are somewhat tied. However, if the construction process of the string affects the mass, you would also affect the tension to reach the desired frequency. So, if you are dealing with a solid core string (like the 1st and 2nd), if the material has the same mass, the thicker the string the higher the tension required for the same note.

When you deal with wound strings, how tightly the winding process and what they use to wind around the strings will affect mass per unit length, therefore affecting required tension for frequency. For instance, a winding around a core string that is tighter will affect mass and tension. Round wound or flat wound will affect mass and therefore tension. Etc, etc, in all the varying configurations. Some tension is created in the winding and therefore adds to the total rate. All very confusing.

So far, we have only spoken to reaching the SAME frequency. We all know that guitars utilize different frequencies on each string. Depending on the tension for the mass of the given length, volume and sustain can be affected by either the mass or the tension, but also by the transmission of the frequency to the guitar (which is wear bone or tusq conversations can start). Also by what they are being transferred to (Spruce or Cedar, Rosewood or Mahogany, etc).

For any particular guitar there will be a harmonic or vibration that can be more resonant. String size is related, mechanically, to the desired root note (frequency) and tension. However, the harmonic vibration of the sting mass for a given length under tension is also related to the string volume and sustain, which can obviously be different for any guitar (dreadnaughts produce more volume than parlors) and for each type of transition material and wood type.

So, for a heavier gauged string set, you should theoretically get a longer sustain at a given volume. As you go lighter, you should experience less sustain at a given volume. As long as the string construction and materials remain the same. Hopefully you're not as confused as I am at this point  :?)

You are correct in assuming that the string material and the interaction with pickups is more problematic with electric guitars. However, there are some pick ups used in accoustics that depend on magnetic properties, such as the LR Baggs M1, which is an ultra modified humbucker style sound hole pick up.

Atlasheating -
I think I figured out why I have been confused a little with some of the statements. You are defining light and medium as tension amounts and I am using the term "light gauge" or "medium gauge" as terms for the diameter of the string sets. In metal, gauge refers to the thickness of the material. I was assuming that gauge, in string terminology, would refer to the thickness of the diameter of the sting.

Obviously, dependant on the string material, core shape, winding type, winding amount, winding tension, etc, you can have varying masses for the same thickness (or gauge), which would require various tensions to reach frequency. Throw in we are now working with different metals, titanium and nickel instead of steel and phosphor bronze, you change everything up again.

One more twist... not every company uses the same gauge thickness per defined set. One company may call 10's light and another may say 10's are ultra-light. Sort of why, even though Newtone classifies the Med-Light that way, I would probably put them in the Light category based on the gauge thickness they used and how it matches, almost exactly, what other companies identify as Light.

I might suggest, for the purpose of this discussion, that we use gauge thickness to identify Light, Medium, etc and not tension amounts. One, because it seems to be more univerasally the industry standard. And, two, because it may be easier to define material or construction differences for the same gauge thickness and how it affects mass and tension and how it will relate to pitch.

If it is easier to end up with the same string mass and reduce tension to keep fretting easier without affecting sustain and tone by using more technologically advanced materials that interact with tension differently, I'm up for it!
"The barrier to knowledge is the belief that you have it"

2006 Larrivee LV-10 MR   1980 Les Paul Custom Natural   2008 Larrivee LV-03-12   1998 Carvin LB75 Koa Bass

Dale you have really thought about this. I really hope these strings work out for you!
I am more of a trial and error guy when it comes to strings and most are cheap enough to experiment with and not break the bank.
Please post when you have used these strings and let us know how you like them.

I tried the Ti strings twice and hated them both times.  In addition to their feeling sticky and sounding slack, the B string broke within one week both times.

AtlasHeating - I'm a trial and error too, but a bit of a technology junky and like to see how new stuff works. Being somewhat of an engineer, I love the "theory to production" process. However, all to often, what works in theory never really materializes in practice. Pertinant to Titanium, since it's properties are different, it is bound to sound different as well. If nothing else, I wasted $25. In the grander scheme of things, not a huge loss and there are things much more detrimental I could be wasting lots more money on.

BobN - Bummer. The one thing I would not have expected was string breakage.  I don't know enough about steel vrs titanium to know the properties of elasticity differences. In the same metal type, if you raise size and lower density your mass is affected and it would not be as "solid", if I can use that term.


NEW THING TO THINK ABOUT: Elasticity
We haven't talked about the properties of elasticity at all. As the sting changes unit length the diameter is also changed. The longer the unit length the small the diameter. As you strum, the string vibrates, and changes unit length. For this reason, new strings lose tension quickly as they "stretch" and need additional tension applied. The string will eventually normalize somewhat (what we call "stay in tune"). However, once in tune, we tend to think of the string as keeping the same diameter and not changing much. This is not true. It is constantly changing diameter as the tension is increase, decreased, increased again, in the playing process.

In the engine world we call a metal piece returning to a normalized position "memory". Such as a spring returning to its tensioned neutral postion. Different metals have different memory properties. You don't want too much density or you don't end up with movement, you end up with breakage. Ex: Grade 8 hardened bolts are actually fragile and have very little give. High in tensile strength, low in shear strength. Grade 5 hardened bolts are less in tensile strength, but higher in shear strength.

A string has to bridge both of these worlds. It has to hold high tension well while subjecting itself to memorized elasticity and still not break. Not a real easy task, and probably why string technology hasn't changed much in the last 100 years. From BobN's comment, I wonder if Titanium won't hold up under these parameters?
"The barrier to knowledge is the belief that you have it"

2006 Larrivee LV-10 MR   1980 Les Paul Custom Natural   2008 Larrivee LV-03-12   1998 Carvin LB75 Koa Bass

OK. Let's look at it this way:

An acoustic guitar is a Helmholz resonator. We hear tones because the soundbox vibrates and moves the air that's both inside and around it. The soundbox vibrates because excited strings are mechanically coupled to it via the bridge. The amount of air moved by the strings themselves, to create sound, is insignificant compared to the soundbox. i.e. Play a solid body electric guitar like a Les Paul unplugged. It's minor.

On an acoustic guitar, play the open 6th string note (E). Detune it to A. Play the 5th fret (E). Same mass, same frequency. Volume goes down. Why? Lower tension results in a less efficient transfer of energy into the soundboard hence it doesn't vibrate as much.

To counter the loss of energy with lower altered tunings we've increased scale length of specialized guitars from 23-26" to 27-30" just to bring the tension back up and have comparable volume to normal guitars.

There is a delicate balance with tension though: too much and you prohibit the soundboard from vibrating efficiently. To the effect of less, muddy bass and lower volume. Classical guitarists have had to deal with this for over 100 years. They get really fussy with their strings; to the point of mixing and matching sets and brands to find the right balance of tone and volume between the strings on their particular guitar.

I think string manufacturers have focused a lot of energy (pardon the pun) on creating a more efficient string (new materials, winding techniques, etc.). One that's easily excitable with minimal input from the player. Hence they ascribe virtues of them being louder, more sustain, etc. But put them on a crappy, inefficient guitar and I think the effect is lost.

"But put them on a crappy, inefficient guitar and I think the effect is lost."
That's why we put them on our Larrivees,

Powered by EzPortal