Colosi bone vs. Larrivee bone

Started by Ronniedee, February 07, 2008, 01:18:28 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

I've decided I'll keep the OM for a while now and I'm ready to bone it up. Is there a difference in quality between Colosi's bone saddles and that sold by Larriveewearables.com?

One more question: for my OM-03 (mahogany b/s), should I try ebony or bone bridge pins?

While I do love the sound it already has, I've heard some say that these changes can improve it. I'd hope to hear more note separaton in chords and fatten up the trebles a bit.

And if anyone has had a significant improvement with another material, I'd be interested to hear about it.

Thanks in advance :donut :donut2 :coffee

Hey Ronniedee,

I asked myself this same question when wanting to work on my D-03.
I decided to get the bone saddle from Larrivee along with some ebony pins from there as well.
I've heard only great things about the Colosi saddles -- lots on this forum.
Reason I bought mine from Larrivee is that I figured I'd go with the actual company behind the guitar.
Also read somewhere that they are the same bone saddles put into the high end Larrivees.
Plus, I wanted the ebony pins (so they would fit perfect, and they do) and it was easiest for me to order them at the same time.

I can say that adding the Larrivee bone saddle and ebony pins greatly improved the overall sound of the guitar.
I'm loving it right now. Better sustain, nice balanced sound and it does fatten up the trebs a bit.
And the ebony seems to keep them from getting too sharp.

I'm sure both Colosi and Larrivee saddles would work fine, just thought I'd share my thoughts.

./devin

PS -- i put in the saddle myself. just sanded it down (on real flat surface with 120 grit paper) so that it was just slightly higher the one that was in there (wanted a little higher action). it dropped in perfectly. no issues. and the ebony pins fit perfect and i dig how they look.

I just put a Larrivee bone saddle in my OM-03 ST and the quality is very good and the price was good, too.

I don't think you'll be dissappointed. All I had to do was adjust the height. The width was just right.

I've used Larrivees and Colosi, both worked out great!
Ruben

Colosi's is higher quality. I've got Larrivee saddles that were porous and a couple that were not even the correct radius. Colosi's are even polished to a shine.


Aren't those Colosi saddles made from rare imported Rhinoceros tail bones?  I think this type of bone is on the list from PAIRRB. (People Against Imports of Rare Rhinoceros Bone)

I'm not going to give my money to that kind of business!  :mad:






:humour:




Steve you bad....no flame fanning please!!!... :humour:

Either one is good...the colosi IS higher quality but I've bben ahhoy with the one I got from OLarrivee too.

Blue
OM-05MT "Mary Helen"
Silvercreek T-170
Harmony Herd (1203, 162, 165, 6362)

Colosi uses Triceratop horn, hence the superior tone :tongue:
"I've suffered for my art; now it's your turn."

My songs:

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/default.cfm?bandID=236287

Quote from: Steve on February 07, 2008, 11:03:39 PM
Aren't those Colosi saddles made from rare imported Rhinoceros tail bones?  I think this type of bone is on the list from PAIRRB. (People Against Imports of Rare Rhinoceros Bone)


Quote from: topographic on February 11, 2008, 11:44:54 AM
Colosi uses Triceratop horn, hence the superior tone :tongue:

I'm assembling an angry mob of animal rights advocates against you as we speak!  I've never heard of such atrocities!  We'll be coming your way just as soon as I find the kerosene for my torch....And where did I leave that pitchfork?   :mad:  :bgrin: :laughin: :humour:
Larrivee D-09
Washburn D-10S
Framus Classical Archback
Fender Jazz and P-Basses

"Snap snap, grin grin, wink wink, nudge nudge, say no more?" (Eric Idle)
Dum spiro, spero. (Cicero)

I think Larrivee fretboards have a flatter radius than all of the Colosi saddles I've ever installed but I like them for that reason.  I just ordered one from Larrivee because they are cheaper.  I did have a Larrivee bone saddle split on me once after I got it installed and was bringing the guitar up to pitch.  They replaced it no questions asked.
More than I deserve.


Quote from: saffron_boots on February 11, 2008, 02:55:45 PM
So Bob's got better cows too?



Actually it's because Bob uses his own femur bone and Jean insists on using his humerus which is not as dense.

And a few more options that are totaly rhino-guilt free;

My luithier loves the "vintage bone" (as does Frank Ford, and many others), i just put it on my 12 fret D, and love it too;
http://www.lmii.com/CartTwo/thirdproducts.asp?CategoryName=Nuts+%26+Saddles&NameProdHeader=Nuts+%26+Saddles
unbleached "vintage" bone - $3.40

Andy Depaule is a great guy - i have bought inlay from him, and would recomend him as well;
http://www.luthiersupply.com/nutsandsaddlespage.htm
Bone saddles - $ 3.00
Buffalo Horn - $ 4.00

I have bought tuners from these guys and again they were great to deal with;
http://www.stewmac.com/shop/Nuts,_saddles/Acoustic_bridge_saddles.html
bone - $4.82
Vintage bone - $ 5.87
As well Stew-mac offers two pre-shaped saddle for under $12.00, in both 20" and 12" radius.. but for a Larrivee you might be better off getting the blank, and shapeing it to the correct radius? 

Maury offers pre-made bone saddles as well;
http://www.maurysmusic.com/guitar_saddles?start=4
pre-made bone sadddle - $15.99

And another choice that's well known (but i have not delt with them first hand);
http://www.internationalluthiers.com/guitarparts.php
Bone - $4.50

I'd bet the PAIRRB. (People Against Imports of Rare Rhinoceros Bone) are Ok with all the folks above  :humour:

d.


Quote from: Ronniedee on February 07, 2008, 01:18:28 PM
Is there a difference in quality between Colosi's bone saddles and that sold by Larriveewearables.com?

The Colosi might be a better quality saddle but I'd bet nobody could tell the difference in sound. I just had a new Larrivee saddle put in my SD-50 and was tempted to get a Colosi, but I figured why bother since the Larrivee is less expensive and sounds just as good.

Also, Larrivee's customer service is fantastic. I had a problem with a saddle I bought from the online Larrivee shop and the good folks there exceeded my expectations. Honestly, I'm proud to own an instrument from such a great company.
Guitars: Larrivee P-05; National Resphonic Style 2 Squareneck;      National Resophonic 12-fret "B"; Dupont MD-50;
Lazy River Weissenborn; Robert Sayers custom flat-top;
Cervantes Crossover; Todd Korup banjo-uke; McSpadden dulcimer;
PRS 22 semi-hollow ltd.; PRS DC3
Amplification: RA-400; Rivera Venus 3

I replaced the uncompensated (unoriginal) bone saddle in my L-60 with a Colossi FWI saddle.  I noticed Zero difference in tone and noticed my wallet was much lighter.   :smile:  The saddle is nice looking and shaped though.
00-05 SH, '73 Hernandez Classical, Taylor 314

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/default.cfm?bandID=770687

Quote from: Novalis on February 11, 2008, 09:20:27 PM
The Colosi might be a better quality saddle but I'd bet nobody could tell the difference in sound.

You might if you got one of the porous Larrivee saddles and compared it to a Colosi saddle.

Quote from: jeremy3220 on February 11, 2008, 10:39:46 PM
You might if you got one of the porous Larrivee saddles and compared it to a Colosi saddle.

I'd be willing to bet $1,000 that nobody here could correctly identify, in a blindfolded test, the difference between a tusq, bone, or Colosi saddle. The human ear just isn't that sensitive. The sound of plastic vs. bone is a noticeable difference but not between two different bone saddles.
Guitars: Larrivee P-05; National Resphonic Style 2 Squareneck;      National Resophonic 12-fret "B"; Dupont MD-50;
Lazy River Weissenborn; Robert Sayers custom flat-top;
Cervantes Crossover; Todd Korup banjo-uke; McSpadden dulcimer;
PRS 22 semi-hollow ltd.; PRS DC3
Amplification: RA-400; Rivera Venus 3

Quote from: Novalis on February 11, 2008, 11:39:06 PM
I'd be willing to bet $1,000 that nobody here could correctly identify, in a blindfolded test, the difference between a tusq, bone, or Colosi saddle. The human ear just isn't that sensitive. The sound of plastic vs. bone is a noticeable difference but not between two different bone saddles.

That's a really great question to which I'd love to know the answer.  I just bought a Colosi saddle and pins--they arrived today.  I haven't installed them yet.  I really wonder if I'll hear the difference or if anyone else could tell either between bone and tusq.  I bought them because until today I thought that everyone here believed that they did make a difference; but honestly, I've wondered if after spending $30 plus, people just want to hear the difference.
Larrivee D-09
Washburn D-10S
Framus Classical Archback
Fender Jazz and P-Basses

"Snap snap, grin grin, wink wink, nudge nudge, say no more?" (Eric Idle)
Dum spiro, spero. (Cicero)

Quote from: Novalis on February 11, 2008, 11:39:06 PM
I'd be willing to bet $1,000 that nobody here could correctly identify, in a blindfolded test, the difference between a tusq, bone, or Colosi saddle. The human ear just isn't that sensitive.

It sounds like you got a gambling addiction.

Quote from: blued03r on February 12, 2008, 12:04:34 AM
That's a really great question to which I'd love to know the answer.  I just bought a Colosi saddle and pins--they arrived today.  I haven't installed them yet.  I really wonder if I'll hear the difference or if anyone else could tell either between bone and tusq. 


I guess you'll find out but I'm sure there are plenty of people who can't tell a difference.

Quote from: blued03r on February 12, 2008, 12:04:34 AM
I've wondered if after spending $30 plus, people just want to hear the difference.

I'm sure that happens but I wouldn't generalize. I've bought a couple things I didn't expect would change the tone then after installing it I was surprised it did. I got some expensive inlayed bone pins laying around somewhere that didn't sound so good in an OM-21 I had.

Really all this tone talk is a waste of time, I don't know or care what others can or can't hear. My experience is that Larrivee's saddles have sometimes been porous and made with the radius being very flat (flatter than the tusq saddles) and that Colosi's are polished, and I haven't seen any that are porous or the wrong radius. I'm not going to argue over the tonal effects with people who haven't made the comparison and I couldn't prove they can hear a difference regardless.

Quote from: jeremy3220 on February 12, 2008, 12:47:27 AM
It sounds like you got a gambling addiction.

:laughin:

Seriously, two different guitar techs, one of whom is pretty well known, told me that there isn't a "just noticeable difference". He also told me that it's his job to make his customers happy and if a client wants to spend more money on a fancy saddle then he's more than happy to oblige. I personally like the Colosi saddles, especially the aged looking ones, and I'm pretty sure that they really are higher quality than most others out there, so I can understand why people like them. It's just that, for me, if the human ear can't hear a difference than I can't see any reason to spend the extra money.

Believe me, I spend most of my expendable cash on my guitars and music. If there was any chance that the more expensive saddles could have a posiive impact on the sound, I'd buy one immediately.
Guitars: Larrivee P-05; National Resphonic Style 2 Squareneck;      National Resophonic 12-fret "B"; Dupont MD-50;
Lazy River Weissenborn; Robert Sayers custom flat-top;
Cervantes Crossover; Todd Korup banjo-uke; McSpadden dulcimer;
PRS 22 semi-hollow ltd.; PRS DC3
Amplification: RA-400; Rivera Venus 3

Powered by EzPortal