Another long winded newbie

Started by Michael T, January 05, 2008, 01:12:44 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

 :coffee  :donut2  Had my own doughnuts for you but it'll take some trial 'n error to figure out how the insert image thing works here, kinda like debit/credit machines, every one you use is different. I have had my DV-09 for a couple years now and couldn't be more pleased with it. I often wonder how guitars can be so different from each other even within the same series and manufacturer. I have owned Martin, several Gibsons, a Tak, as well as a few knock offs. I made it a mission to search out a new six string before I purchased this Larrivee. I thought I was in search of a Collings, Martin, Goodall, Olson, or Taylor when I first stumbled on an "L" at a small used shop in Tampa and they suggested I try one that was traded recently. Great feel and sound, but a hefty ticket for a 4 year old piece with a few character scuffs. I did add it to the list of to be compared though. I put in many miles over a few months finding the different places that had a few upper end pieces to play. Fortunately I do a lot of driving in my profession and could get around a hundred mile radius fairly easily. Withou getting carried away here, I finally found a shop that had a couple Collings, some Martin dreads and oo's, Taylor 8&9 series, and a few Larrivees on hand. I called ahead and made an appointment to compare them side by side, gave 'em a credit card number to put the same strings on all of the 6 I wanted to compare and made a day of it. Honestly I told my wife I was off to buy a Collings, but wanted to be sure I was comfortable with the decision before I dropped the big bucks this time. After a couple hours of me do, you do, you play I'll listen etc. It came down to the DV-09 and the Collings, I had a bad case of GAS for the Collings too. Try as I could, the Larrivee just sounded better, even enticing strangers to close their eyes and listen time after time it kept being chosen out of the mix. I had a little issue with the highe "E" not resonating the way I thought it should but the clever folks at the shop put in a bone saddle and tweaked the truss a bit, voila, riiiing. Needless to say I went home with the Larrivee. I have suffered many GAS attacks in the last couple years, even picked up a Taylor T5C2 Koa 12 string recently, but I have to say my Larrivee is the best antacid for me. I have played several other Larrivees (L-03, SD's, Parlors etc.) and can't say I would trade, I do like to try them though. Every once in a while I get an urge for a different tone or wood combination, probably brought on these forums, but I can usually settle down after a tune or two and a look in the check book. I do have a hard time understanding the purchasing over the net etc., every guitar I have played is different in one way or another, I also appreciate the expertise of the luthiers and shop owners whose advise and knowledge help me so much (I tend to confuse myself). Even this Larrivee had the saddle changed and a rod tweak that cleared up an issue for me. Am I different in this? Or, is it just more common to read about it on the threads because we are net folks?[69][/160]
08 Larrivee L05-12
02 Larrivee DV-09
73 Granada Custom
Kids got the others  :)

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/default.cfm?bandID=797065


     :welcome: Micheal T, great first post! Most players if possible compare guitars, (A-B them). I've never heard of anyone A-B ing them with the same strings. It's brilliant.  Obviously  strings make a huge difference in voice and playability, and a truly fair comparison of the guitars would mandate that they have the same strings. You said you have a hard time understanding an internet guitar purchase. I had the exact feeling before I bought my D05 bearclaw on line. I live in Sweden and it was difficult to find Larrivee's. When I finally located a few they where in the same shop as some Martins so I could A-B them. For my ears & eyes it came down to an L05, and a D05. I decided on the D05. The prices here are about 2  1/2 times what they are in the U.S.... :crying:OUCH, so an on line order was the only way for me. I found my guitar on line at one of the great dealers that are frequently referred to here. Besides the standard D05, he had a D05 bearclaw that I was very attracted to. I've never seen one here in Sweden and not having a chance to A- B it with a standard D05 I went on what the dealer told me about the voice of the bearclaw top and a bit of blind faith. My feeling was that a guitar is such an intimate thing, and as you say even among same makes and models they vary. I wanted to actually play,feel, and even smell  the very guitar I was buying. I felt the on line purchase was a bit detached. Kind of like a mail order bride. I've had my guitar about 8 months  now and I can tell you those feelings belong to the past. The guitar I got was way and above what I expected, and I expected a lot. You mentioned Collings. Just a few weeks ago I was able to get together with a good friend who had bought a Collings D1A. I brought along my D05 and we had a great afternoon of laughs & music. It was interesting to hear my guitar compared to such a highly regarded guitar as the Collings. They sounded just beautiful together, but at the end of the day, I was very happy to be taking my D05 home. But that's just me.  :winkin:

Thanks for the welcome! I can appreciate the situations that drive people to make a leap of faith in their purchases without playing the object of their guitar quests, just not in my comfort zone with guitars, especially not when I am considering putting a comma in the $$'s. I do a lot of purchases on line myself for much of my office equipment, supplys etc., even have bought watches and dinnerware with the help of the net. Then I guess there is the confidence issues as to knowing what you want and a trust factor. A custom build has got to be a trying experience, it sure would be for me! I thought about commissioning one in the past, even when I made up my mind I wanted another "good" guitar in the quest that netted me my Larrivee. There are, as mentioned, very personal nuances and unknowns for me in regards to my guitars. Neck width and shape, overall balance and feel, and of course the many tonal variations and playability issues that (IMHO) would haunt me. Personal justifications aside, many do buy, sell, trade on line and I am sure there are many wonderous surprises that come in the mighty brown gift wagons all the time. I have had a dealer order a guitar that he was willing to stock if I didn't buy it, (and I didn't),  the guilt thing was enough that I had a hard time going back there right up until I moved, even though he sold it fairly quickly. It simply didn't feel the way I expected even though I had played several of the same models in different woods. There are huge volumes of guitars being bought and sold on the auction sites and classifieds everyday, I guess there are a lot of collections out there or maybe I am too descerning for my personal uses. I have 3 kids in their 20's, they got their 1st guitar from me, (in one case his 1st, 2nd and 3rd), and they still have them. I still have the guitar my folks bought me some 35 + years ago, and a '73 Granada I eventually had reworked a couple times. I have had Les Pauls, SG's, Taks etc and really only traded away one (in retrospect, lost my shirt in that deal, but it seemed fair at the time). In every purchase though it was a fairly difficult choice. There is no doubt in my mind that my DV-09 will be with me as a personal treasure for as long as I can play. I may eventually order that custom build someday to compliment this one, naaah won't happen with my attitude. Do many of you who trade a lot, or at least buy alot make money on acoustic guitars? I'm curious, it seems to me there are big hits to take dollar wise in buying a new guitar and reselling it used in a couple years. Or, is it more like anything else in our market place, know what the market will bear and buy below it to sell above?   
08 Larrivee L05-12
02 Larrivee DV-09
73 Granada Custom
Kids got the others  :)

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/default.cfm?bandID=797065


Welcome Michael T!   Well done!  I applaud your selection process.  No matter what it said on the head stock, your ears and hands made the choice. Way to go! 
I'm curious about how your request for new strings on 6  guitars was received?  I can imagine some shops being reluctant to do this.  I like the fact that this place was willing to do this and do a quality set up including a bone saddle. 


Mark

 :welcome:

Welcome Michael T
:cheers
Roger


"Live simply so that others may simply live"


Quote from: Larrivee4me on January 07, 2008, 07:15:54 PM
Welcome Michael T!   Well done!  I applaud your selection process.  No matter what it said on the head stock, your ears and hands made the choice. Way to go! 
I'm curious about how your request for new strings on 6  guitars was received?  I can imagine some shops being reluctant to do this.  I like the fact that this place was willing to do this and do a quality set up including a bone saddle. 


Mark
Mark, I explained the process I was going through in selecting a upper end guitar. They thought I was a bit eccentric (which I am), I think the phrase including "nuts" came up, but hey, when we are comparing in the 3-4-5k range a little courtesy should be expected. Besides I told them I'd pay for the strings and an hour or two labor and gave'em my card #. I had to drive some 60 miles to find a shop that had the brands and several of the models I wanted to compare, and they understood. I guess not too many people call for an appointment and are serious enough to at least offer to pay for their time, too bad to, good shop people are worth their weight in gold (IMHO). I also had spent the better part of 2 months stopping and playing different models at the usual Ashes, GC's etc. as well as smaller shops as I came across them, so I am pretty sure they believed me when I said I was prepared to come in and buy, if I could find the fit and sound I was looking for, oh, BTW, I am past the half century mark too, may have added a little credibility. Then again, I haven't had much resistance when I treat people with respect for their time and acknowledge it's worth some sort of renumeration. I'll have to tell you all about the string adventure I put the guys through when I bought my T5C2Koa 12'er. That was like pulling teeth, of course again I was willing to pay for the service. You know, even when I am just trying out a new interest (while I'm picking up strings or cables and stuff, any excuse really to stop and goof off) I think it is pretty important to acknowledge my intent and show some appreciation for the assistance I'm given, most of the time it's respected. Come to think about it, doesn't everyone insist on having questions and concerns answered when we're paying big bucks for stuff? I ain't shy, I play guitar.  :ohmy:
08 Larrivee L05-12
02 Larrivee DV-09
73 Granada Custom
Kids got the others  :)

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/default.cfm?bandID=797065


Nice story.  There are many other stories of people who sell their guitars shortly after buying.

It makes sense to be deliberate about buying a guitar!

:welcome:

Glad you  found a really good fit!
Naw, I don't think that's at all unreasonable for you to ask them for the 6 string changes...honestly, people who are reputable and run good shops WANT you to spend time comparing, and if you are willing to pay for the strings and the time, you are way ahead of most buyers....no offense, anybody, I just thing this guy was extremely considerate of the shop's time and resources. The owners of Cotten Music in Nashville are very good friends of mine, and they would be most happy to have such a thorough buyer visit them!
:donut
Larrivee LS-10 Custom "Jesse"
Larrivee 000-50 "Emma"
Larrivee 00-50 "Dublin"
Larrivee 00-60 "Rose"
Larrivee L-03 Koa "Hula"
Martin 5-18 ('57) "Tink"
Banjitar  "Plinky"
Baby Taylor "Lichious"
Taylor GC-5 E
Oscar Schmidt OU-5 concert uke "Abalone & Cheese"
Makai MT-70 tenor uke "Kimme"
Martin M3 Soprano Uke "LJ"
A couple non descript cl

Michael,

I never make any money on buying, selling or trading acoustics.  You fall short every time.  Since I can afford to do this, it is more of an entertainment cost.  I look at it as an expensive rental.  However, when the right one comes along, it stays put!  I am fortunate to be able to do this, and realize that others might not be as lucky.  I have a nice variety of instruments to play.  Good therapy for the soul.  It is very rewarding when a nice instrument shows up.  I buy a lot on the net, as it takes me weeks to decide if it is a keeper.

Your method is much better and more scientific.  Great idea to pay for new and similar string sets on everything you want to sample.  In the end, its all good!

Jim D

It's a damn good thing you aren't a lefty.  You would have to fly into Houston to the all-lefty shop there to try everything out!  Welcome to the forum and congratulations on your new Larrivee.
bluesman67
HOGTOP CHARLOTTE

www.reverbnation.com/hogtopcharlotte

Bluesman, I am a lefty! But I was raised when the Nun's frowned on us as such, so I learned trumpet, guitar, golf, baseball, basically anything you have to do in public 'cept eat all with my right hand. But if I had to I would've flown to Houston to the lefty shop :)
08 Larrivee L05-12
02 Larrivee DV-09
73 Granada Custom
Kids got the others  :)

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/default.cfm?bandID=797065


QuoteDo many of you who trade a lot, or at least buy alot make money on acoustic guitars? I'm curious, it seems to me there are big hits to take dollar wise in buying a new guitar and reselling it used in a couple years

You are right.  There are indeed big hits to take on selling used guitars.  Much like cars and other stuff, things depreciate with every mile (scratch, nick, scrape, etc.). 

I've owned some higher end stuff over the years and its the more expensive guitars that take the bigger hits.  It's a rare situation where you break even or make a little money.  My average loss in each transaction might've averaged $150.

And then, there are Larrivee guitars.  Where a Martin, a Taylor, Alvarez-Yairi or Gibson will cost more up front, I've noticed they suffer a greater loss in the resale.  My experience has been that, Larrivees are the best bang for the buck upfront (not cheap, but a good value) and take less of a beating in the resale.

Guitars have never been good instruments of investment.
Larrivee OM-03R-12 string + IMix external
Martin 000-15S + IMix internal
Martin OM-16GTE + Fishman Matrix
Gretch 5120
Fender Squires - Tele & Strat

whiskeyjack:  Perisoreus canadensis.  aka, gray jay, whiskey jay, whiskeyjack or timber jay.   A small, friendly bird of the northern coniferous forest.

Quote from: whiskeyjack on January 10, 2008, 12:50:06 AM

Guitars have never been good instruments of investment.

Unless you are lucky enough to have bought the right guitars 30 years ago or more.
Roger


"Live simply so that others may simply live"

I agree - I've sold a LOT of guitars and I've nearly always taken a hit.  But that's the price of temporary ownership - look at it as rent.

WhiskeyJack's comment about Larrivee resale value is largely true only because Larrivees are so deeply discounted to begin with.  If one were to pay MSRP (why anyone would I have no idea), one would not do very well selling at a later date.  The same is true of Martins, btw.

Ken

Quote from: whiskeyjack on January 10, 2008, 12:50:06 AM
You are right.  There are indeed big hits to take on selling used guitars.  Much like cars and other stuff, things depreciate with every mile (scratch, nick, scrape, etc.). 

I've owned some higher end stuff over the years and its the more expensive guitars that take the bigger hits.  It's a rare situation where you break even or make a little money.  My average loss in each transaction might've averaged $150.

And then, there are Larrivee guitars.  Where a Martin, a Taylor, Alvarez-Yairi or Gibson will cost more up front, I've noticed they suffer a greater loss in the resale.  My experience has been that, Larrivees are the best bang for the buck upfront (not cheap, but a good value) and take less of a beating in the resale.

Guitars have never been good instruments of investment.

It sounds like the nuns treated you right and saved you a lot of money in your adult life.
bluesman67
HOGTOP CHARLOTTE

www.reverbnation.com/hogtopcharlotte

Powered by EzPortal