Strange experience with ebony bridge pins

Started by Parlor Picker, June 26, 2007, 04:04:58 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

I just took delivery of a couple of sets of lovely ebony bridge pins with an abalone dot inlay, so immediately set about replacing the plastic(?) ones on my Larrivée Parlor.  They looked great - but the sound quality deteriorated.  I expected this to be an upgrade in both aesthetic and tonal qualities, but sadly not so.  The ebony pins made the strings all sound slightly dulled and the treble strings had a definite "fuzziness".  At first I thought my ears were deceiving me, but on changing one back to the original, it immediately rang out clearly again. I thnk there was some sort of vibration going on with the ebony pins.

The original bridge pins appear to be plastic, but are they actually "Tusq"?  Perhaps a Larrivée expert can help me here.  The guitar is dated 2003.

It's a great shame, because the ebony pins with the inlay look really classy - unlike the boring originals.  However, sound quality is more important than looks, so I've gone back to the original set.
Larrivée Limited Edition Rosewood Parlor (2003)
plus various other acoustic guitars and one ukulele

I've done some experimenting with various bridge pin materials on my acoustics, too and found that some guitars do sound much more muffled (or sometimes much more twangy) with certain pins.  I think the parlors come with Tusq pins....which are "fancy plastic", but they can be the right choice for a given guitar!   :smile: 

Have you tried bone pins yet?  I got these nice double inlay bone pins from Bob Colosi a while ago for my P-09BZ and they help a great guitar sound even better.
Abalone dots with an ebony ring around them:

(you can click for a bigger view)




 

 :ph34r:

I tried ebony pins as well and don't like them.  They dent easily and don't sound good IMO.  I always put bone pins/saddles on my nice guitars.

I replaced the plastic pins on my new L-03 with some black TUSQ pins with mother-of-pearl inlay I got off eBay. They look really nice, particularly with the Larrivee "ebonoid" tuning buttons. I really didn't expect to hear any difference, but the guitar did sound better. More clarity and string separation, particularly on the high end. Of course, the guitar might have been starting to open up a bit after a month or so. I can't really say it was the TUSQ pins, but I'm ever so slightly less skeptical than I was 2 months ago.

I think the TUSQ pins are probably the best value for the money if you're a believer. they are definately not "plastic". They make a glassy sounding "tink" when you drop them. Bone MIGHT be better, and buffalo horn might be prettier, but I am really skeptical about the utility of anything above that. I suspect anything above that is basically jewelry. (Now saddles could be a different story...)

John A.
Midland, TX

They say only a pawnshop guitar can play the blues. An eBay one does it better. A guitar's bound to feel unloved if her owner plasters pictures of her front and back over the internet for all to see and then sells her off to the highest anonymous bidder.

Quote from: Parlor Picker on June 26, 2007, 04:04:58 AM
I just took delivery of a couple of sets of lovely ebony bridge pins with an abalone dot inlay, so immediately set about replacing the plastic(?) ones on my Larrivée Parlor.  They looked great - but the sound quality deteriorated.  I expected this to be an upgrade in both aesthetic and tonal qualities, but sadly not so.  The ebony pins made the strings all sound slightly dulled and the treble strings had a definite "fuzziness".  At first I thought my ears were deceiving me, but on changing one back to the original, it immediately rang out clearly again. I thnk there was some sort of vibration going on with the ebony pins.
The original bridge pins appear to be plastic, but are they actually "Tusq"?  Perhaps a Larrivée expert can help me here.  The guitar is dated 2003.
It's a great shame, because the ebony pins with the inlay look really classy - unlike the boring originals.  However, sound quality is more important than looks, so I've gone back to the original set.

I don't believe that I'm just reading this post now.

Two days ago, I finally gave in and decided to quietly "personalize" my Larrivée L-03 ... I just ordered the black 'synthetic' ebony tuner buttuns AND the ebony bridge pins (with abalone inlay dots) directly from the Larrivée Online Store.

Parlour Picker, did you get your "ebony bridge pins with an abalone dot inlay" from the Larrivée store?

The original Larrivée bridge pins on my L-03 now are "Tusq" and I DO like the sound ... but I am used to a quieter sound, since I usually don't use a pick.

When I look at the pictures of the more expensive Larrivée models in their catalogue, it looks to me like they are using the black ebony bridge pins that they are selling in their store? ... So I don't know what to expect when the stuff I ordered arrives in the next few days !!!    :?
:guitar

2006 Larrivée L-03
2006 Martin Backpacker

"The best things in life aren't things."

 :ph34r:

Canoe65, don't worry, a lot of folks like the ebony pins and yes thats what they put on the above 03 guitars.  Bridge pins do very little for tone, whats important imo is that they are light and durable. I prefer bone others ebony, others brass, others walrus ivory, so just experiment and see what you like.

I bought the pins on eBay from some workshop in Taiwan that seems to turn out hand-made bridge pins and other accessories.  I've done this before and have a set on my Columbus parlour guitar and they work fine.  In fact my old mahogany Denyer has a set of ebony pins - always has had since it was made in 1976 - and that sounds great as well.

The episode with my Larrivée Parlor is still a bit of a mystery - not to mention a disappointment, because I honestly thought I was upgrading the instrument both visually and in terms of sound quality.  All I can surmise is that the ball-ends of the strings were somehow vibrating.  I've discussed it with two luthiers and both are at a loss.  One suggested the ebony might not have been properly seasoned, but who knows...

Maybe one day when I'm feeling brave I'll get hold of a set of bone pins, as suggested in this thread.  At the moment I'm leaving well alone.

[Edit]:

Since writing the above, I have now spoken to another luther (in another country) who mentioned the pins have to fit really well and the ball ends of the strings must be pulled up tight under the bridge, otherwise they can cause vibrations.  That seems to be sound advice.
Larrivée Limited Edition Rosewood Parlor (2003)
plus various other acoustic guitars and one ukulele

QuoteTwo days ago, I finally gave in and decided to quietly "personalize" my Larrivée L-03 ... I just ordered the black 'synthetic' ebony tuner buttuns AND the ebony bridge pins (with abalone inlay dots) directly from the Larrivée Online Store.

I have these on my Parlor and the pins do sound a "little" bit better than the stock plastic originals.  I think the L-03 comes with plastic pins too.  At worst you'll have prettier L-03.... mine has ebony pins and tuner buttons but not sure from where as they were fitted by previous owner.  Is defintely more payback in a bone saddle over original plastic than ANY set of pins.....but don't get me started on brass pins   :angry: .... guitar makers spend a lifetime getting the top thin and shaving those braces so the whole thing is light as possible ....then some retard comes along and rams a chunk of heavy metal in it...  yup that'll kill those pesky subtle high end overtones every time... :doh

Pete


1992 Larrivée L-09 Koa

I, too found Tusq to be the right material for my parlor. Even tried a bone saddle, but I put the Tusq one back in. My OM has bone bridge/nut and bridgepins. I bought ebony bridge pins for the parlor, but they deadened the sound. YMMV

Deb

Quote from: Parlor Picker on June 26, 2007, 04:04:58 AM
... the sound quality deteriorated.  I expected this to be an upgrade in both aesthetic and tonal qualities, but sadly not so....

There ya go ... at least you didn't spend the $$$ for brass pins, which would have made it sound even worse.

Actually, you could usually put ebony pins in without making it sound noticeably worse, but I wouldn't expect it to improve.  SOme people think fancy pins will do that but it's just the placebo effect.  Especially after spending the money on them.

All those wood or bone or brass replacement pins are heavier than the plastic ones.  The last thing you want to do is to increase the mass of the top.  You're just damping the vibration.  If you think you're hearing more bass it's because the top is being damped in the higher registers.

If you really want to improve the sound try getting the pin holes slotted.  Or, when you fit strings into the holes, hold the string near the ball end windings as possible and pull up a bit as you push the pin in, so as to seat the  ball end well against the bridge plate.  Don't yank hard on it, that's not necessary.  You can feel it when it's making good contact.

This will couple the string to the soundboard better and will give you a real improvement.

Very intersting conversation. Undortunately most of it ignores my question, which concerns bridge pins.  All this talk of stringing methods and alignment of the nut with with peg is useful, of course. Please feel free to carry on.

However anyone who wants to address my question concerning the make, model, size or material of bridge pins can feel free to email me directly at:
raharris
AT
yahoo.com

Quote from: hatofthecat on June 30, 2007, 12:24:47 PM
but don't get me started on brass pins 

Had some of those.  They made the guitar louder, definitely not better.  Changed them to Boxwood which matches the Maple binding.

Another 5 year old thread?   :?
Roger


"Live simply so that others may simply live"

Reviving this ancient thread - I just swapped the plastic bridge pins on my Larrivée Parlor for Tusq ones and I am certain I can hear an improvement, albeit a very subtle one.
Larrivée Limited Edition Rosewood Parlor (2003)
plus various other acoustic guitars and one ukulele

Powered by EzPortal