maple

Started by biggaliath, December 14, 2006, 11:44:57 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Hey
as some of you know I recently got a om-03fm - love the guitar, has a few small issues but overall im very happy. This om is the only one ive ever played - so my question is how does maple compare to rosewood, mahog, koa etc, whats the supposedly best style for flamed maple?

Maple has mid-range punch.  Mahogany a more dynamic tone, rosewood has bass (relatively).  You can play lots of styles on your maple OM.  But not bluegrass.

I personally really like Maple guitars. However I have come to realization that Maple guitars are just not popular or in demand when compared to Mahogany or Rosewood. Perhaps, it's the higher price of Maple.

You asked about the tonal difference fo maple comparing to other wood.  I would say it you do a search with the word"rosewood", you will get pages of post that will answer your question. However generally Maple is going to be very very bright and dry and rosewood is going to be dark and wet. I know these words to describe the tone might not be enough, and thats why I referred you to the other posts.

btw, congrads on OM-03 Maple.

Quote from: Ratishna on December 15, 2006, 09:00:40 AM
...  You can play lots of styles on your maple OM.  But not bluegrass.

Balderdash.

Play whatever style you like.

- Richard (who sorely regrets selling his L-09FM)
oldWithoutMoney.com

Larrivee L-09 (w/ non-cutout iMix)
Larrivee 00-19
Larrivee OM-0312R

plus a few other treasures

To my ear maple seems to be sorta sterile in that there seems to be a lot less harmonic richness in the tone except for the ultra hi end where it's pretty nice. then again it has so much of that it can overpower the body of the tone where the mids are. Rosewood is maybe the richest wood as far as harmonic content. I really like maple a lot for electric necks and an overdrive tone. Works really good for that. for me tho, rosewood is the kiing when it comes to acoustics. I used to be very pro mahogany till i got the om9. Now i don't think i could ever go back.

Maple is very perky kind of sound (in most guitars).  Some call it sterile, which is true up to a point.  It is very transparent (but also very resonant), it has a very honest sound that doesn't favor any particular register or color your sound.  Having  maple larrivee myself, I can tell you that Larrivee maples tend to be much more mellow sounding than other's I've played.  Overall, maple has great note separation.  You dont get the sparkle of the mahogany, nor do you get the bass & zing of the rosewood.  It's a very in-your-face, robust sound.

I particularly like maple on jumbos, great for rock rhythm.
Larrivee LSV-05
Larrivee LV-09FM
Larrivee CS-30
Yamaha Chronos LL-16
Yamaha Pacifica 112J
Martin LX-1
Fender American Stratocaster Delux
Fender Mexican Stratocaster
Fender Mexican Telecaster
Rivera Sedon

Exactly......note seperation. You're quite right there, and i think it's probably the lack of harmonic content in the mids and lows compared to roswood for example that is responsible for that clarity of each note. It makes sense when you think about it because the less the overtones the less there is to get in the way. A 12 string might be a good example of how overtones affect note seperation.
But it's not a good or bad thing, it's simply a different flavor.

For me, maple is the wood for fingerpicking. You can hear what you are playing without worrying about it being muddy.

Andy
Larrivee OM9
Larrivee PO-09 Koa
Breedlove SN20
Webber 000 Cedar/Maple

Quote from: Calvin on December 18, 2006, 04:13:27 AM
Maple is very perky kind of sound (in most guitars).  Some call it sterile, which is true up to a point.  It is very transparent (but also very resonant), it has a very honest sound that doesn't favor any particular register or color your sound.  Having  maple larrivee myself, I can tell you that Larrivee maples tend to be much more mellow sounding than other's I've played.  Overall, maple has great note separation.  You dont get the sparkle of the mahogany, nor do you get the bass & zing of the rosewood.  It's a very in-your-face, robust sound.

An OM body dhape doesn't have a lot of bass to begin with.  Make the back and sides out of maple and the midrange gets really strong while the little bass there is disappears.  Thus you really can't play bluegrass on a maple OM because there is no low end thump. 

Quote from: Fergy07 on December 18, 2006, 01:34:49 PM
For me, maple is the wood for fingerpicking. You can hear what you are playing without worrying about it being muddy.

Andy

I guess it depends on how good the guitar is because my rosewood OM is about as un-muddy as you could ever ask for. I wouldn't be inclined to call it perfect otherwise. (i still can't believe i found a guitar i can use the word to describe, but i honestly cannot hear a single tonal flaw)

Powered by EzPortal