Is this the best way to pack a guitar...or overkill?

Started by drtse, January 28, 2008, 03:42:19 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

I'm getting ready to ship out my old guitar to someone here in Canada and I came across the article in Ebay...

http://reviews.ebay.com/Guitar-Packing-De-Mystified_W0QQugidZ10000000000760588

Any comments on this proposed packaging method?

thx

K

If it makes it where it is going, it was packed ok, else it wasn't.
I have seen guitars way over packaged and get damaged.
A fellow forumite received a guitar with a shipping label on the case.
The guitar was fine, but the case a little scuffed.
The debate always is about string tension, Larrivee for one, says to keep the strings at tension.
I have always just tuned down a step, kind of middle ground.
The big thing is rally pack the headstock, a sharp jolt and it easily snaps off.

Good Luck..
SD-60 SBT
O-50 TSB
OM-03 Koa
D-09 12 string
Gibson-J50
Gibson Blues King
A gaggle of ukes

from Larrivee's webpage...
Packing the Instrument for Shipping

Another event that occurs is damage during shipping due to improper packing. This type of damage is also not covered under warranty because it is a owner-preventable condition. Please follow these steps to ensure your guitar arrives safely

    * Ship the guitar with the guitar at full tension / regular tuning Do not loosen the strings.
    * Remove the battery from the battery clip and put it in the case compartment.
    * Put a lot of packing under the headstock of the guitar. Either use a couple of old t-shirts (Which will be returned) or a lot of newspaper. The headstock should be resting firmly on packing material and not floating. The goal of this is to keep the headstock from snapping back if the box falls over during shipping.
    * Ship the guitar in a box meant for a guitar. Your local music store (Whether or not a Larrivee Dealer) likely receives guitars regularly - ask them for an old guitar box - they will probably just give you one if you ask nicely. Often the packing materials will still be in the box. You want the case to be supported on top, bottom, and side once inside the carton.
    * Please do not use foam chips - they do not protect the instrument.


I will be flying Air Canada from Toronto to Miami on Sunday for the upcoming Songwriters Cruise, and plan on taking my L09.  I am fairly familiar with the process of packing the guitar and headstock before travelling, but wonder if anyone has any words of wisdom about flying with (as opposed to shipping) your guitar.

I understand that all of the major carriers have clamped down on customers who want to take their guitar as carry-on luggage, but I have been told that you can "gate check" your guitar (where they literally pass the guitar from the boarding ramp down to the ramp worker who places it in the plane, and then return it to you at the gate upon arrival - avoiding the dreaded baggage carousel).

I will attempt to pack it properly, and am prepared to have a lengthy conversation about carrying the instrument on to the plane.  Any advise or words of wisdom when travelling by air???

jimmy

Quote from: jimmy buffett on January 28, 2008, 05:40:13 PM
I will be flying Air Canada from Toronto to Miami on Sunday for the upcoming Songwriters Cruise, and plan on taking my L09.  I am fairly familiar with the process of packing the guitar and headstock before travelling, but wonder if anyone has any words of wisdom about flying with (as opposed to shipping) your guitar.

I understand that all of the major carriers have clamped down on customers who want to take their guitar as carry-on luggage, but I have been told that you can "gate check" your guitar (where they literally pass the guitar from the boarding ramp down to the ramp worker who places it in the plane, and then return it to you at the gate upon arrival - avoiding the dreaded baggage carousel).

I will attempt to pack it properly, and am prepared to have a lengthy conversation about carrying the instrument on to the plane.  Any advise or words of wisdom when travelling by air???

jimmy

No real good advice for you, but good luck!  Do let us know how it goes.
Mcilroy A30C, 2005
Yamaha FG-512, 1978
Custom Built Orchestra Model

Previously Owned:
Larrivee L-10 Special Edition, 2002
Larrivee Classical, 1977
Larrivee LV-05E, 2005
Larrivee P-09
Larrivee OM-05 custom
Larrivee OM-03
Larrivee D-03R, 1997

Read this info at the Larrivee website, same thing Queequeg said but with pictures. This information is also in the owners manual

http://www.larrivee.com/5_features/educationEssays/shipping.html
Roger


"Live simply so that others may simply live"

Quote from: jimmy buffett on January 28, 2008, 05:40:13 PM
I will be flying Air Canada from Toronto to Miami on Sunday for the upcoming Songwriters Cruise, and plan on taking my L09.  I am fairly familiar with the process of packing the guitar and headstock before travelling, but wonder if anyone has any words of wisdom about flying with (as opposed to shipping) your guitar.

I understand that all of the major carriers have clamped down on customers who want to take their guitar as carry-on luggage, but I have been told that you can "gate check" your guitar (where they literally pass the guitar from the boarding ramp down to the ramp worker who places it in the plane, and then return it to you at the gate upon arrival - avoiding the dreaded baggage carousel).

I will attempt to pack it properly, and am prepared to have a lengthy conversation about carrying the instrument on to the plane.  Any advise or words of wisdom when travelling by air???

jimmy

pm sent.
2007 L-03RE
2003 Yamaha F-310

Quote from: didymus21 on January 28, 2008, 05:46:37 PM
No real good advice for you, but good luck!  Do let us know how it goes.
well, there's a bit of info on this thread:
==> anyone managed to get their guitar onboard a plane? And lived to tell about it..<==
People complain about life being hard, but what if it was limp?

1967 Gibson b45 12strings
06.2007 OMV 09
1972 Global 6 stringer (lol)
2002 Princess (classical)

ooh, and I totally forgot to share with you this nightmare vision of travelling with a guitar:
http://www.themusicemporium.com/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=1027&products_id=24860
BBrrrr I shiver just looking at it
People complain about life being hard, but what if it was limp?

1967 Gibson b45 12strings
06.2007 OMV 09
1972 Global 6 stringer (lol)
2002 Princess (classical)

Quote from: olchip on January 29, 2008, 02:02:34 PM
ooh, and I totally forgot to share with you this nightmare vision of travelling with a guitar:
http://www.themusicemporium.com/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=1027&products_id=24860
BBrrrr I shiver just looking at it

words fail me  :crying:
This is a nightmare. It made me sick just looking at the case, not to mention the guitar.
2007 L-03RE
2003 Yamaha F-310

OK guys, DannyO had sent me some info and I was just getting comfortable with the idea, but that picture of the broken neck was just plain gruesome.

And no amount of effort that you put into packing would change the fate of that guitar.  It looks like the case had been run over by one of those baggage tractors.  Now I know that my L09 is a nice guitar, and I appreciate it more every day, but if it meets it's fate on this trip, it is replaceable. 

I should point out that when I was in Fort Lauderdale last year, I saw guy walking around with his guitar in a gig bag.  I asked him if he was checking the guitar and was told that it is almost inevitable these days, and that most airlines are pretty restrictive about bring guitars as carry-ons.  He told me that he stuffs "about 50 t-shirts" in the gig bag and has never had a problem.  Now that's good karma!  I will at least be using a hard shell case!

I'll post a report on my return, along with a rundown on the Songwriters Cruise that I'm attending...

jimmy


For flying with my 000, I would always use my Clam case.  I can't imagine anything being safer, including a Calton.  But even using the Clam case, you STILL have to properly pack the guitar as if you were shipping it, especially around the headstock area.


With my parlor, I would try a carry on. 
Mike

Larrivee P-10MQ
Martin 00-18 Retro
Martin 000-16SGT
Martin LX1
Washburn D10SDL
plus lots of Chinese instruments, 2 violins, 2 pianos, etc., etc.

One thing I might add to Larrivee's shipping instructions is that you might want to consider removing the end pin. Especially if it's an older guitar that doesn't have the cutout in the case for it.
Roger


"Live simply so that others may simply live"

Echo the end pin removal.  Drop the guitar on its end and you can easily crack the end block.
Larrivee LS-09
Webber OM - Maple / Cedar
Larrivee P-09 Rosewood Special Edition
Larrivee OM-03 (for sale)
Seagull Parlor
1972 Yamaha Classical
La Patrie Presentation Nylon String (for sale)
La Patrie Motif (nylon parlor )
Fender Telecaster (for sale)
G&L Legacy  (Strat)
G&L ASAT  (Tele)
Weber Mandolin

Quote from: didymus21 on January 28, 2008, 05:46:37 PM
No real good advice for you, but good luck!  Do let us know how it goes.

Well, I'm back, and my L09 is no worse for wear. 

I packed the headstock area with lots of newspaper as was suggested, and left Toronto on an Air Canada flight to Miami.  Try as I might, there was no way the guy at the check-in counter was going to allow me to take the guitar as a carry-on bag.  No gate checks either.  He placed "Priority" tags on my bags and after clearing U.S. Customs in Toronto, I took the guitar in it's original Larrivee case and placed it on the conveyor.  Bye-bye...

A couple of hours later as I stood at the conveyor in Miami, the first item out of the gate was my L09 followed immediately by my bag.  A quick look inside the case confirmed that we had made the trip successfully.  On to my Songwriters Cruise and a week of great musical experiences, and then back to the MIA airport for the return trip to the frozen North.  Used the same packing to get the guitar ready, and sure enough, I was told once again that there was no way I could take the guitar as carry-on.  I was getting more comfortable with the idea by now, but as you might guess, off come the bags in Toronto, and after waiting for what seemed like a very long time I finally saw my bag - but NO GUITAR.  A couple of trips to the over-sized staging area and still no guitar.  Damn...

Stand in line to file a report, while everyone at the counter seems to be moving in slow motion.  After completing the Lost Baggage Form, I make one more trip to the over-sozed area, at 2 AM and two hours late, and low and behold, there sits my Larrivee.  Another quick check to make sure that she is in one piece, and I'm off.

I'm glad I took the guitar and it was a joy to have her with me for the week, playing with other pickers and singers, and I'll probably take her back to FLA when I go in a couple of weeks.  BTW, there were tons of players with their guitars on this cruise, and I saw several Larrivees.  Anyone there from the Forum???

All's well that ends well.

jimmy


QuoteA couple of hours later as I stood at the conveyor in Miami, the first item out of the gate was my L09 followed immediately by my bag.

Holy s__t! The guitar came off the conveyor belt, in its case, along with rest of the luggage?  You are one very lucky guy. That's sort of like shooting craps & you're number just came up on the first try. Well, all's well that ends well, I guess.  For whatever its worth, I've had pretty good luck taking guitars onto Air Canada flights.
Mike

Larrivee P-10MQ
Martin 00-18 Retro
Martin 000-16SGT
Martin LX1
Washburn D10SDL
plus lots of Chinese instruments, 2 violins, 2 pianos, etc., etc.

Powered by EzPortal