Setup

Started by Stylin, May 06, 2007, 02:59:47 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

I recently purchased a brand new L03R and took it into the store where I bought it from for a setup.  When I received my guitar back from them, there was a yellowish resin or epoxy on several of the nut slot holes.  I suspect that they cut the slot holes too deep.  Is it normal for the resin to be so visible?

Also, one of the string's intonation is off.  I used a digital tuner to tune the guitar with an open string and played the note at the 12th fret.  The pitch of the fretted note was sharp by about 20 cent.  All of the other strings were bang on.  When I received my guitar from the setup there was no improvement and they said that this is not much of a difference in intonation and this is normal.  How much of a variance in a string's intonation should be acceptable?

Stylin,   
    In the rare case that I have cut a nut slot to deep I fess up to it and make a new nut. I NEVER fill a slot and re cut it. I see that as a temporay repair that will cause issues down the road. If someone brings in a guitar with the slots to deep there are two actions. a new nut, shim the bottom of the current nut with a bone shim and re cut the top.
  As for the intonation, put away the tuner and listen with your ear. I never use a tuner for intonation set up. The entire concept of a fretted instrument is a huge compromise and what we need to do this the best job a fooling the ear to thinking everthing is OK.  With the fretted note sharp the compensation on the string length needs to be increased. To tell if this can be done with out major work, look at the saddle. The contact point of the string will need to be moved back toward the pins making the vibrating length of the  string a bit longer. This will componsate for the intonation. If the contact point is not already at the back of the saddle that you can make this adjustment by reshaping the top of the saddle to move the contact point back. Make sure you have a frest set of set in strings before you try to set the intonation.
  By the way on the classical guitar the 12th fret test is only one of many I use to test intonation. Playing octaves of the same note on different strings and 5ths intervials really fine tunes the process.
Jim Holler, Luthier
Trinity Guitars
www.TrinityGuitars.com

 :+1: what the man said.Jim I bow to your Knowledge and honour. :bowdown:
A REPAIRPERSON,Barefoot Rob gone to a better place
OM03PA
Favorite saying
 OB LA DE OB LA DA,LIFE GOES ON---BRA,It is what it is,You just gotta deal it,
One By One The Penguins Steal My Sanity, Keith and Barefoot Rob on youtube
Still unclrob
#19
12 people ignoring me,so cool
rpjguitarworks
Call PM me I may be able to help

Thanks Trinity,

For the intonation the sharpness on the 12th fret is noticeable to my ear.  As the contact point of the string is near the back of the saddle this may be a problem.  What are my options?    Who knows what will happen to my guitar if it isn't done properly.  I am wondering if it is even worth the trouble, because if this adjustment isn't done properly more damage than good may be done to my guitar.

Just out of curiosity, what are other peoples experience when they have taken their guitar in for a setup and the nut slots have been cut too deep?


Look at the top of the 12th fret first and make sure it is well crowned and has no flat spot for uncompleted fret work. If the top of the fret is flat and not with a radii that the contact point of the string will be forward on the fret and create a sharpness to the note. If the fret is OK that there are a few ways to fix the intonation.. Cut a wider slot in the bridge and use a wider saddle. Fill and re cut the slot in a new position. And make a saddle that is L shaped in cross section so that the top of the saddle extends over the back side of the slot. I have a vertical milling maching that I can do this on with good results. There needs to be a good amount of saddle projecting past the top of the saddle for this to work.
  All of these solutions require skills and tools past what most music stores will have.
Jim Holler
Jim Holler, Luthier
Trinity Guitars
www.TrinityGuitars.com

It may be a bad string.  I'd suggest changing them before surgery.

Quote from: Hoser Rob on May 09, 2007, 05:40:47 PM
It may be a bad string.  I'd suggest changing them before surgery.
Very good point. It is always my hope that the Buzz and intonation problem will be a string. I am never that lucky however. I spent 4 hours looking for a buzz yesterday to find it in a very slightly loose screw on the tuning machine.
Jim Holler, Luthier
Trinity Guitars
www.TrinityGuitars.com

Quote from: TrinityGuitars on May 09, 2007, 06:36:51 PM
   Very good point. It is always my hope that the Buzz and intonation problem will be a string. I am never that lucky however. I spent 4 hours looking for a buzz yesterday to find it in a very slightly loose screw on the tuning machine.

Glad you mentioned that, Jim. Whenever I'm dealing with a buzz on one of my guitars, the hardware is the first thing to get tightened....tuner screws and nuts, strap pins, electronics doors, knobs, covers, etc. ...THEN I look at the bridge pins, internal wiring and all that fancy electronic stuff. This approach has served me well over the years. Although there have been times....

Dan
"Time flies like an arrow..Fruit flies like a banana"
Townes Van Zandt

When I got back into playing guitar I thought my guitar had a wolf tone on the low G.

It turned out it was my technique ... I wasn't playing that note close enough to the fret when I played that note.

Thing was, it sounded exactly like it was coming from the body.  Buzzes can be tricky to find.  Check out "buzz diagnosis" at www.frets.com ...

Powered by EzPortal