I was poking around inside my Parlor recently, and noticed that the bracing is fairly light (due to the small body).
Typical Larrivee bracing looks like this:
(http://www.larrivee.com/features/images/tour/2f.jpg)
Notice the two flat finger braces on both sides and the two lower horizontal face braces.
The Parlor has no finger braces and only one lower face brace.
How about the 00? Did Larrivee go lighter on the bracing than, say, the OM?
This is what the tops looked like in Oxnard last August, when they were building that special run - I think most of the guitars have very similar bracing, perhaps a little less on the parlors with the lower tension on the bridge.
I also took a picture of my LS with a CF lamp inside the body - this is the LS 12 fret 12 string for reference -
Tad
[attachment deleted by admin]
I'm bumping this thread because I got to play with one of the F-III's recently.
Tad, when I first saw the bracing in your 12-string LS, I was struck by the size of the bridge plate. But it made sense to me for a 12-string because of the added tension.
I discovered that the 6-string F-III has identical bracing, including that large bridge plate.
So now I'm curious if anybody else has examined the bracing of their LS-03. Is it the same as Tad's 12-string?
The bridge plate is that large due to the 12 fret neck joint.Its also the same on on my OM03PA also a 12 fret neck.My two LS's are 14 fret neck joints and the plate is more like the typical bracing shown.Hope this helps.
Thanks, unclrob, that sort of makes sense.
The bridge is lower, but they left the X at the same location, so they reinforced between the X and the bridge with that small brace, eliminated the second lower face brace, and made the bridge plate larger.
That is a huge departure from Martin's approach -- very interesting.
It's also interesting that the 12-string bracing is the same as the 6-string. Most 12-strings I've seen have heavier bracing.
And, FWIW, the 12-fret Parlor bracing is quite different from the 12-fret LS.
Quote from: gitnoob on July 04, 2010, 12:13:27 AM
Tad, when I first saw the bracing in your 12-string LS, I was struck by the size of the bridge plate. But it made sense to me for a 12-string because of the added tension.
It doesn't make sense when you know what a bridge plate is for and what it isn't for. The main function of the bridge plate is to keep the ball ends from tearing through the top.
Does it resist tension? Yes, but it does a very poor job. When you increase bridge plate size beyond the footprint of the bridge you aren't adding much stiffness for the amount of mass you are adding. This is because low flat grafts make poor braces for basically the same reason a 2x8" board is easy to bend when you exert force on the wide surface but not when you exert force on the narrow surface. If your desire is simply to increase the stiffness of the top to resist string pull then you shouldn't use a giant bridge plate to accomplish this.
I'm sorry but I still find it disturbing that despite Larrivee using the largest recorded bridge plate in human history they still managed to miss the bridge.
Eh, it's a brace. Yeah, going tall and narrow would increase the strength and reduce the mass, but Larrivee uses flat braces for the finger braces as well. I assume he's going for a certain voice by doing so. This is obviously a departure from his "standard" bracing pattern, so I assume he gave it some thought.
Quote from: jeremy3220 on July 04, 2010, 11:06:51 AM
It doesn't make sense when you know what a bridge plate is for and what it isn't for. The main function of the bridge plate is to keep the ball ends from tearing through the top.
Does it resist tension? Yes, but it does a very poor job. When you increase bridge plate size beyond the footprint of the bridge you aren't adding much stiffness for the amount of mass you are adding. This is because low flat grafts make poor braces for basically the same reason a 2x8" board is easy to bend when you exert force on the wide surface but not when you exert force on the narrow surface. If your desire is simply to increase the stiffness of the top to resist string pull then you shouldn't use a giant bridge plate to accomplish this.
I'm sorry but I still find it disturbing that despite Larrivee using the largest recorded bridge plate in human history they still managed to miss the bridge.
Well I've owned six Larrivees and have yet to see any pronounced bellying of the top/bridge area similar to some Martins and Gibsons I've owned. With one old Gibson dread I could only use light gauge strings because mediums would raise the bulge/action almost unplayable So perhaps Mr. Larrivee with his vast experience knows what he's doing.
gtrplayer
Quote from: gitnoob on July 04, 2010, 12:00:25 PM
Eh, it's a brace. Yeah, going tall and narrow would increase the strength and reduce the mass, but Larrivee uses flat braces for the finger braces as well. I assume he's going for a certain voice by doing so. This is obviously a departure from his "standard" bracing pattern, so I assume he gave it some thought.
Exactly, for whatever reason it was done, it wasn't due to a need to overcome tension.
Quote from: gtrplayer on July 04, 2010, 12:08:06 PM
Well I've owned six Larrivees and have yet to see any pronounced bellying of the top/bridge area similar to some Martins and Gibsons I've owned. With one old Gibson dread I could only use light gauge strings because mediums would raise the bulge/action almost unplayable
Having no belly is not a good thing.
Quote from: jeremy3220 on July 04, 2010, 01:40:11 PM
Having no belly is not a good thing.
Interesting response to a statement about *pronounced* bellying. :smile:
FWIW, I do have a Martin that was too-lightly built. Pronounced belly. Sinking below the sound hole. Rotated bridge. But it sounds great.
There are also builders, like Charles Fox, who build for both robustness and responsiveness:
(http://frets.com/FRETSPages/FieldTrips/CFox/CFoxViews/14.jpg)
I think Larrivee is in the same camp.
Quote from: jeremy3220 on July 04, 2010, 01:40:11 PM
Having no belly is not a good thing.
Some guitar tops are built with a slight arch,
some...Gibsons come to mind. But "pronounced" belly, a la Santa Claus, is another matter entirely. I've yet to see this with a Larry. With regards to his bracing, Jean's walking the fence between stability/sound and doing it well.
Quote from: gtrplayer on July 04, 2010, 03:02:32 PM
Some guitar tops are built with a slight arch, some...Gibsons come to mind. But "pronounced" belly, a la Santa Claus, is another matter entirely. I've yet to see this with a Larry. With regards to his bracing, Jean's walking the fence between stability/sound and doing it well.
I can assure you that having built arches into guitar tops myself you aren't telling me anything I don't know and when I say belly I mean belly not top arch or radius.
Ya'll can keep talking about which guitars have a belly and which ones you like the sound of but I'm not interested. My initial post was about the structural significance of the bridge plate.
Thats what so cool everyone builds differently.I more then happy with the way Larrivee builds theres guitars.Never had a problem with the bellying on theres have had that problem others.
Quote from: unclrob on July 04, 2010, 04:24:57 PM
Thats what so cool everyone builds differently.I more then happy with the way Larrivee builds theres guitars.Never had a problem with the bellying on theres have had that problem others.
I'm with you unclrob, same observations I've seen also. The lack of a Larrivee bulge might be due to that large bridge plate somebody mentioned.
Larrivee's got it down right.
gtrplayer
Slight bellying around the bridge is desirable. No belly at all is an almost absolute sign of overbuilt guitars. Larrivee guitars are heavily built instruments. There is no getting around that. That being said, lots of folks like the Larrivee voice and make great music with them. To each their own. I can't understand why so many of the folks that claim they love the way Larrivee guitars sound still get their panties all in a bunch about them being heavier guitars overall when compared to lots of other factory built guitars. If you like the sounds coming out of the box, you like the sound. The fact that they are heavily built doesn't matter if the voice is pleasing to you. Mama Cass was, er, uh, shall we say, a low utilities girl, but it didn't change the fact that she sure had a pleasing voice to many folks.
Quote from: GA-ME on July 05, 2010, 09:57:58 AM
Slight bellying around the bridge is desirable. No belly at all is an almost absolute sign of overbuilt guitars. Larrivee guitars are heavily built instruments. There is no getting around that. That being said, lots of folks like the Larrivee voice and make great music with them. To each their own. I can't understand why so many of the folks that claim they love the way Larrivee guitars sound still get their panties all in a bunch about them being heavier guitars overall when compared to lots of other factory built guitars. If you like the sounds coming out of the box, you like the sound. The fact that they are heavily built doesn't matter if the voice is pleasing to you. Mama Cass was, er, uh, shall we say, a low utilities girl, but it didn't change the fact that she sure had a pleasing voice to many folks.
I like that I can use any weight strings on my Larrivee's and they will likely last 150 years (academic I know.)
It is speculated Martin likely went to rear-shifted braces and large bridge plates because they were getting too many problems with the lighter built gits. I see what GA_ME is saying about a little bellying. But I love the Larrivee sound, especially as the gits mature - usually without problems.
When my '74 LoPrinzi got a neck reset a few years back, the tech said that the slight bellying on the top was actually a good thing. I wasn't sure about it then, but it makes sense now.
I wish I had just a slight bellying!
Quote from: cke on July 06, 2010, 05:24:21 PM
It is speculated Martin likely went to rear-shifted braces and large bridge plates because they were getting too many problems with the lighter built gits. I see what GA_ME is saying about a little bellying. But I love the Larrivee sound, especially as the gits mature - usually without problems.
You have to realize what context that took place in. It's not as though Daddario EJ-16s were around back then. I believe they commonly used heavier gauge strings like 14-60 and wrappings were made of a different material. Also note how quick the changes took place. Martin within just a few years of starting to sell steel string guitars moved the braces back; this means if they were having issues then they were almost immediate issues due to string gauge not longevity issues. This makes sense because many of those 20's and 30's Martins are still around 70+ years later and in great shape - most likely due to not having someone put heavy strings on. In other words as long as you put the appropriate gauge strings on it doesn't matter how lightly built the guitar is.
And since Martin knew what they were doing back then they didn't use a large bridge plate to beef up their guitars. They started putting large rosewood bridge plates on in 1969 and kicked off the worst era in Martin's history.
I don't think the Martin stigma applies here. It seems like Larrivee increased the area of the bridge plate in conjunction with taking out one of the lower face braces.
Kevin Ryan uses a giant bridge plate as well....
(http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g231/cpabolting/RyanInsides.jpg)
Quote from: jeremy3220 on July 07, 2010, 09:45:52 AM
You have to realize what context that took place in. It's not as though Daddario EJ-16s were around back then. I believe they commonly used heavier gauge strings like 14-60 and wrappings were made of a different material. Also note how quick the changes took place. Martin within just a few years of starting to sell steel string guitars moved the braces back; this means if they were having issues then they were almost immediate issues due to string gauge not longevity issues. This makes sense because many of those 20's and 30's Martins are still around 70+ years later and in great shape - most likely due to not having someone put heavy strings on. In other words as long as you put the appropriate gauge strings on it doesn't matter how lightly built the guitar is.
And since Martin knew what they were doing back then they didn't use a large bridge plate to beef up their guitars. They started putting large rosewood bridge plates on in 1969 and kicked off the worst era in Martin's history.
Thanks for the info. So why DID Martin use a bigger plate?
Martin change the bridge plate in 67 not 69.The 70's made stuff didn't suffer from the the change of bridge plates,like so many companies of the time period but from the advance's that the off shore companies were making into the market and also from very poor quality control.Why they changed the size of the bridge plate i can't really tell you as I don't know.Maybe it had something to do with all those life time warrenty repairs they were doing.
gitknoob thats a really cool bridge plate design.
I played my F-IV , OM-21 and F-III in that order earlier today and I did check the Martin for bellying (as is my habit). It is there but in no way affects the sound or playability in a negative way. I just have to say here that I don't know why Larrivee did these plates the way they did, but I really like how both of my forum guitars play and sound. :nice guitar:'S
Good thread, lots of great pics and input.
Need to add that in 67 Martin switched from a maple bridge plate to rosewood.
Quote from: gitnoob on July 07, 2010, 01:46:30 PM
I don't think the Martin stigma applies here. It seems like Larrivee increased the area of the bridge plate in conjunction with taking out one of the lower face braces.
Kevin Ryan uses a giant bridge plate as well....
Well, I think it's apparent that isn't a bridge plate in the traditional sense. I did a search and found this thread. http://www.acousticguitarforum.com/forums/showthread.php?t=161544
(http://i27.photobucket.com/albums/c177/jenehoward/2009%20Healdsburg%20Guitar%20Festival/DSC_0352_314.jpg)
This should act more like the nomex double tops rather than a flat wide solid graft. That brace would probably add a lot of stiffness but may not weigh much. In Larrivee's case by simply increasing the width they are adding as much weight as stiffness and by removing tall braces they are lowering the stiffness to weight ratio. It's a fact of life, I'm just telling it how it is, if you like the end result that's fine.
Quote from: unclrob on July 07, 2010, 02:07:29 PM
Martin change the bridge plate in 67 not 69.
Yeah but they started using the
large rosewood bridge plates in 69 (serial #242454). Nothing wrong with rosewood bridge plates.
Quote from: cke on July 07, 2010, 01:50:35 PM
Thanks for the info. So why DID Martin use a bigger plate?
Probably as a cheap way to beef up the guitars and decrease warranty work like unclrob said. However that doesn't mean it was a good idea and that's why they don't use giant bridge plates today on their high end guitars. There's no doubt a wider bridgeplate helps prevent the bridge from rolling forward but that doesn't mean it's the most effective way(unless you need the extra mass there). Martin and other companies have made a few changes to their guitars that were either bad ideas or improved some aspect while injuring another. For instance the upper transverse graft (aka popsicle brace) was added to stop the top from cracking around the fretboard and this practice has been adopted by almost all the major manufactures but quite a few luthiers today feel this graft is basically worthless; I believe Mario Proulx said something along the lines of 'the popsicle brace has never prevented a single crack in history.'
And since the title of the thread is "What does the 00 and LS bracing look like?" here are some good pics of the LS bracing.
(http://www.larriveeforum.com/smf/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=25417.0;attach=4179;image)
(http://www.larriveeforum.com/smf/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=25417.0;attach=4181;image)
Quote from: jeremy3220 on July 07, 2010, 11:55:46 PM
Probably as a cheap way to beef up the guitars and decrease warranty work like unclrob said. However that doesn't mean it was a good idea and that's why they don't use giant bridge plates today on their high end guitars.
So if I do manage to buy that D-18GE I am GAS-ing for, will it hold up in the long run?
Quote from: cke on July 08, 2010, 12:40:39 AM
So if I do manage to buy that D-18GE I am GAS-ing for, will it hold up in the long run?
I don't see why not.
Newsflash -- I finally have an answer for the original question posed in this thread. :smile:
I got to peak inside an F-IV 00-03MT today, and the answer is ... the bracing is different!
Pretty similar to the F-III with the single lower face brace, but the bridge plate is much smaller.
It would be interesting to catalog all the different bracing patterns used by Larrivee. I used to think all models were braced like an L-body. But the Parlor, LS, and 00 all appear to have unique bracing.
I've been lightening things up in my Lv-03r (yes I like stock Larrivees; I've owned 4 -- I'm just experimenting) and I thought there was an awful lot of bridgeplate. I don't know what to do with it other than really thin out the sections not directly under the bridge shape -- being flat it is hard to judge see changes the way I could with the tall bracing, when modding. Off topic a little-- sorry. Please do not flame me for sacrilege.
Quote from: hadden on July 24, 2010, 11:12:13 AM
... I thought there was an awful lot of bridgeplate. I don't know what to do with it other than really thin out the sections not directly under the bridge shape -- being flat it is hard to judge see changes the way I could with the tall bracing, when modding. Off topic a little-- sorry. Please do not flame me for sacrilege.
Sacrilege! :bgrin:
I would never mod a Larrivee -- too expensive, but I do experiment with a cheap Chinese guitar.
Simonoff has a book on tap tuning and voicing. He asserts that the bridge rocks back and forth along the long axis when excited by string energy, and he feels that most bridge plates are poorly designed.
On his guitars, he tapers the edges of the bridge plate to reduce that steep transition at the edge.
Quote from: hadden on July 24, 2010, 11:12:13 AM
I've been lightening things up in my Lv-03r (yes I like stock Larrivees; I've owned 4 -- I'm just experimenting) and I thought there was an awful lot of bridgeplate. I don't know what to do with it other than really thin out the sections not directly under the bridge shape -- being flat it is hard to judge see changes the way I could with the tall bracing, when modding. Off topic a little-- sorry. Please do not flame me for sacrilege.
I wouldn't bother thinning down the bridge plate much because you are going to be removing more stiffness than mass(not an effective way to lighten things up).
Quote from: gitnoob on July 24, 2010, 04:00:54 PM
Simonoff has a book on tap tuning and voicing. He asserts that the bridge rocks back and forth along the long axis when excited by string energy
It's called the long dipole. The bridge actually vibrates along many different axises: The greatest volume producer being the monopole axis which produces the main top mode.
Quote from: jeremy3220 on July 25, 2010, 01:31:25 AM
It's called the long dipole. The bridge actually vibrates along many different axises: The greatest volume producer being the monopole axis which produces the main top mode.
We may be talking about two different things. It sounds like you're talking about vibrational modes of the top. I'm talking about energy transfer from strings to bridge to top.
When the strings vibrate, they're actually compressing and expanding, which rocks the bridge back and forth along its long axis. Simonoff believes one should maximize the energy transfer by giving the bridge more freedom of movement. This is a different concept than controlling the resonant frequencies of various vibrational modes of the top.
Quote from: gitnoob on July 25, 2010, 05:21:49 AM
We may be talking about two different things. It sounds like you're talking about vibrational modes of the top. I'm talking about energy transfer from strings to bridge to top.
When the strings vibrate, they're actually compressing and expanding, which rocks the bridge back and forth along its long axis. Simonoff believes one should maximize the energy transfer by giving the bridge more freedom of movement. This is a different concept than controlling the resonant frequencies of various vibrational modes of the top.
It's the same thing. The bridge rocking in that manner is what forms the long dipole mode(as opposed to the cross dipole mode). Think about what dipole means and imagine what happens when the bridge rocks back and forth; the area in front of the bridge will dip and at the same time the area behind will rise and as the bridge keeps rocking this goes back and forth therefore producing a dipole type movement.
"Dipole" is an interesting word to use in describing the top/bridge movement.
Does this mean "equal" movement in each direction, as far as force. Or is there a simpler way to explain this to all of us who are trying to understand what y'all are referring to here?
I believe the "poles" he's referring to are relative to various vibrational nodes. A different concept than a rotational axis, but I wouldn't be surprised if the axis is one of the nodes.
Regarding vibrational modes, there are some good pictures and videos in this thread:
http://acousticguitarforum.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2284132&postcount=25
BTW, one of the interesting results of studies like these is that there's no bass side or treble side to a guitar top. So Martin lefties can be converted to righties as easily as Larrivees.
The effect of symmetrical vs asymmetrical bracing is different than what we all assumed. Rather than "balancing" bass and treble response, it really just changes the symmetry of some of the vibrating modes -- I have no idea what effect, if any, that has on tone.
The link gitnoob posted is a good find and illustrates the poles. Mode just refers to the type of movement not necessarily a specific vibrational frequency. However what you are seeing in those pics is the natural resonant frequencies of the top occurring in different modes. You can see from the pics that the bridge does act as an axis.
In the first picture you are seeing the main resonant mode of the top, this is the monopole mode where the bridge moves up and down as a unit. This type of movement is the greatest contributer to volume because it acts like an air pump and usually couples with the resonant frequency of the air chamber because it tends to be an octave above it.
The 2nd pic is the cross dipole mode, this is the result of the bridge rocking(vibrating) from side to side. In this mode the bass side will rise will the treble side falls and this goes back and forth.
The 3rd pic is the long dipole mode, this is the result of the bridge rocking/rotating/vibrating from front to back. This is where the area in front of the bridge will dip and at the same time the area behind will rise and as the bridge keeps rocking this goes back and forth therefore producing a dipole type movement.
Then you start to get into tripole modes and others I don't know the names of.
Here's a thread where Alan Carruth explains some of the significance of each mode: http://www.luthiersforum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10101&t=25759&start=0&st=0&sk=t&sd=a
"I think the location for the peaks on scalloped bracing have to do with controlling the frequencies of the modes above the 'main top' mode. Basically, you're working with the stiffness of the top/bracing system in different areas, and the effect on the mode frequencies will depend on whether the brace is bending or not in that location for that mode.
The lowest four modes of the top do most of the work in producing sound, and particularly the 'main top' mode, which is thought by some to be the most important sound producer all the way up to 1000 Hz. That's the mode that works like a loudspeaker, with the whole lower bout moving in and out.
On loudspeakers they make the edges really loose, and try to get the center to move like a piston, with no bending. We can't do that: you need a certain amount of stiffness at the edges, and anyway, we're not trying for the sort of 'flat' frequency response the loudspeaker people are. One researcher, Richardson in Wales, has shown via computer models that a top that is loose in the center will actually move more air in the 'main top' mode than one that is loose around the edges, assuming both tops are stiff enough to take the loads. Scalloping reduces that central area stiffness, and thus accentuates the power of the 'main top' mode, as well as the 'main air' mode that it drives.
The next three modes up also contribute to the tone, even if they are not as effective at producing power as the main top mode.
From what I can see, the 'cross dipole', which is usually the next higher one in pitch, tends to be a 'loser': it's so much less effective than the 'main top' mode that you'd rather not have it stealing energy. You do this by making the areas of the top on either side of the centerline, about halfway to the edge, stiffer, to move the cross dipole pitch up away from that of the 'main top' mode. Meyers (iirc) showed that guitars that had a narrow 'main top' peak in the spectrum tended to sound 'harsh', and too low a cross dipole pitch contributes to that by stealing energy and cutting off the main top mode. So, having the X braces peaked outside of the bridge wings can raise the cross dipole pitch, and make the 'main top' spectral peak broader. I've noticed on the guitars that I've measured that this seems to contribute to a 'full' or 'solid' sound.
The 'long dipole' could be a 'waster' like the cross dipole, but it often couples strongly with one of the inside air resonant modes, and ends up producing a significant amount of sound; often around A on the high E string, where nothing much else is going on. Loosening the area in the center of the top behind the bridge with scalloped tone bars will drop the pitch of the top 'long dipole' mode.
The fourth mode, the 'cross tripole' may or may not show up on any given steel string guitar. It's a power producer, though; generally up around 500 Hz (C on the high E). The peaks on the lower end of the X ,and the tone bars, are in places that probably help to move that one upward in pitch.
The important thing to think about is that each system of shaping the bars tends to establish a certain relatinoship between the mode pitches, and thus to form the spectrum of the guitar's output. That's why scalloped, tapered and flat bracing tend to sound different.
Also, of course, there's no free lunch. Loosening up the top in the center is structurally risky, and also can, if not done right, give too much bass and less sustain. All of this is pretty complicated, and good, stable, balanced, and 'clear' sounding instruments can be built with all sorts of bracing. Still, knowing the strengths and weaknesses of each pattern, and how they tend to sound, can help you build what the customer wants, even if that's just you."
And to explain why the term "pole" is used when discussing modes...
Imagine you drill a hole through a thin sheet of something like a piece of table cloth or guitar top. Then slide a small pole though and glue it in position. If we were to use just one pole in the center of the sheet and someone held the edges while we moved the pole up and down(perpendicular to the sheet) we'd have a monopole type movement. If we inserted two poles, one on each half of the sheet, and moved them back and forth in opposing directions we'd have a dipole type movement.
If you look at the pics you can imagine a pole running perpendicular to the top through the dark spots. So in this one you've got two dark spots therefore two poles(dipole).
(http://i103.photobucket.com/albums/m133/johnjaypl/fea/hcpy_15.jpg)
Jeremy, the bracing on my new Crafter TV 200/NV (solid wood, Engelman top, HOG back & sides, "modified scalloped "T" bracing) looks virtually like your pic, as far as the main bracing. When I tap the top in the upper bout, not much response. Move to the lower, get a response that would compare to your diagram. Very responsive. Is this diagram representative of a "T" bracing, as it looks, or generic for an "X" bracing.
Didn't look inside with my indicator mirror, but my luthier drew a quick pic of what "T" bracing looked like & how effective it was. The bracing on different guitars has always been an interesting subject to me. This description you provide really clarifies alot & one I'll save on my PC. My custom Martin OOO-15s has an "A" bracing, which is common on this type of guitar(?).
Learned alot from all here & has some very interesting posts. J, think this is the longest & one of the best I've seen from you. Thanks for posting it. Explains alot.
Quote from: gitnoob on July 25, 2010, 01:55:10 PM
I believe the "poles" he's referring to are relative to various vibrational nodes. A different concept than a rotational axis, but I wouldn't be surprised if the axis is one of the nodes.
Regarding vibrational modes, there are some good pictures and videos in this thread:
http://acousticguitarforum.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2284132&postcount=25
BTW, one of the interesting results of studies like these is that there's no bass side or treble side to a guitar top. So Martin lefties can be converted to righties as easily as Larrivees.
The effect of symmetrical vs asymmetrical bracing is different than what we all assumed. Rather than "balancing" bass and treble response, it really just changes the symmetry of some of the vibrating modes -- I have no idea what effect, if any, that has on tone.
Obviously it's a good effect :wink:
Quote from: BluesMan1 on July 26, 2010, 12:15:08 PM
Jeremy, the bracing on my new Crafter TV 200/NV (solid wood, Engelman top, HOG back & sides, "modified scalloped "T" bracing) looks virtually like your pic, as far as the main bracing. When I tap the top in the upper bout, not much response. Move to the lower, get a response that would compare to your diagram. Very responsive. Is this diagram representative of a "T" bracing, as it looks, or generic for an "X" bracing.
Didn't look inside with my indicator mirror, but my luthier drew a quick pic of what "T" bracing looked like & how effective it was. The bracing on different guitars has always been an interesting subject to me. This description you provide really clarifies alot & one I'll save on my PC. My custom Martin OOO-15s has an "A" bracing, which is common on this type of guitar(?).
Learned alot from all here & has some very interesting posts. J, think this is the longest & one of the best I've seen from you. Thanks for posting it. Explains alot.
Well the link gitnoob posted isn't really related to how responsive a top is. All guitars vibrate and the diagrams are more about how they vibrate(modes). It's true though the upper bout is always less responsive and more or less so depending on the guitar. Some guitars use a massive upper transverse brace and a graft(aka popsicle brace) where the 1927 0-18 I owned had a UTB that was about 1/4" wide and no popsicle brace; there's no surprise the 0-18 was very responsive.
When you refer to T bracing you're talking about the cross sectional profile right? Whether or not this bracing in the diagram uses that type of profile isn't that important. All guitars tend to vibrate in roughly the same pattern though the frequency at which the modes occur will be different.
Great thread. Roger Simonoff book on tap tuning is an excellent source for those interested in techno dynamic's of acoustic stringed instruments .
Thanks Jeremy, as usual all this information is more than my mind can hold. But the diagrams really help.
I was wondering what you think the luthiers understood about all the science behind the bracing. Martin came up with this basic X bracing pattern only a short time ago in relation to how long man has been making fine stringed instruments.
I guess my simple question is "Did Martin know these things when he designed the X pattern?" Or where they all just working by experience and the "master-apprentice"passing on of design and build techniques?
Until the modern age with computers and the internet not much was shared among luthiers. Yet they managed to build the best instruments we have ever seen, or I should say "heard". Of course Stradivari is implied here as well. His guitars were not so great, but in the early 1700's is when he produced the violins.
I know this deviated a bit from bracing alone but the question is relevant I believe.
Jeremy, I think what was explained to me was more reflective on how the braces are scalloped. The bracing pattern is similar to the one shown in your colored diagram, after I looked in the guitar with a mirror. The "T" bracing is a type used on these guitars, which was explained further when I dug into the internet & found a description of this, developed by Crafter. The bracing pattern is different than the normal scalloped, "A", or square type.
Here is what I found & sorry if it deviates from the your explanation a little.
"For the past 100 years, the most commonly used types of braces were square or A-shaped. Both of these brace types are sufficiently rigid to retain the shape of the top, but then to top loses resonance due this stiffness. Another alternative is the use of "scalloped bracing", which does allow greater sound top resonance. But, because the braces are less rigid, the string tension sometimes allows the top to bow upwards. This can raise the action & cause playing difficulties.
The T-brace is similar to the shape of an A-brace, except with narrower sides pared down to a square bottom, looking like an inverted capital "T". This reduces the overall weight of the guitar, as wood is removed from BOTH sides of the brace. The lighter T-brace makes the sound louder & better balanced, while still allowing rigidity to maintain the shape of the top. The T-brace is installed @ a right angle to the top for strength, but offers more resonance than the traditional A-brace."
Makes sense, esp. in the weight to rigidity sense. Lighter top, but still rigid & responsive.
Also, I can see from your diagram how the bridge acts as another axis. On a 12 fret guitar, how does the new placement (lower) of the bridge explain, in terms of your diagram, why it seems to be more responsive & louder? Is what I've found, & many, to be the norm for guitars of this type? Can you explain this further?
Quote from: dependan on July 27, 2010, 11:07:52 AM
Thanks Jeremy, as usual all this information is more than my mind can hold. But the diagrams really help.
I was wondering what you think the luthiers understood about all the science behind the bracing. Martin came up with this basic X bracing pattern only a short time ago in relation to how long man has been making fine stringed instruments.
I guess my simple question is "Did Martin know these things when he designed the X pattern?" Or where they all just working by experience and the "master-apprentice"passing on of design and build techniques?
It's hard to say what they did and didn't know. I'd guess the X brace was designed not arbitrarily but from recognizing an issue with ladder braced guitar tops rolling forward. Other aspects like scalloping I'm not sure. I wouldn't be surprised if they knew things like how the guitar acts as an air pump and how certain changes to the design would effect that. They did some really smart things back then.
Quote from: BluesMan1 on July 27, 2010, 02:58:45 PM
"For the past 100 years, the most commonly used types of braces were square or A-shaped. Both of these brace types are sufficiently rigid to retain the shape of the top, but then to top loses resonance due this stiffness. Another alternative is the use of "scalloped bracing", which does allow greater sound top resonance. But, because the braces are less rigid, the string tension sometimes allows the top to bow upwards. This can raise the action & cause playing difficulties.
The T-brace is similar to the shape of an A-brace, except with narrower sides pared down to a square bottom, looking like an inverted capital "T". This reduces the overall weight of the guitar, as wood is removed from BOTH sides of the brace. The lighter T-brace makes the sound louder & better balanced, while still allowing rigidity to maintain the shape of the top. The T-brace is installed @ a right angle to the top for strength, but offers more resonance than the traditional A-brace."
Makes sense, esp. in the weight to rigidity sense. Lighter top, but still rigid & responsive.
Also, I can see from your diagram how the bridge acts as another axis. On a 12 fret guitar, how does the new placement (lower) of the bridge explain, in terms of your diagram, why it seems to be more responsive & louder? Is what I've found, & many, to be the norm for guitars of this type? Can you explain this further?
Well I'm pretty sure the A shape profile still has a slightly higher stiffness to weight ratio than the T shape. The tops with A shaped braces don't really inherently lose resonance due to stiffness because one can always just make the brace shorter. Also, the A profiled brace once glued to the top forms a T anyway. However my guess is that there isn't a great deal of difference between the two in practicality.
As for 12 fret guitars: Most 12 fret guitars have bodies designed for 12 frets (unlike the Norman Blake Martin's and the Larrivee forum guitars) and the placement isn't significantly lower. The forum guitars if they're louder(I've never played one) is probably in part due to the bridge being more toward the center of the lower bout. This means it's further away from the sides (which act as a very stiff brace) and more movement can take place. Think about pressing down on a slat of wood with the two ends across a saw horse, the more toward the center you press the easier it is to deflect.
Quote from: jeremy3220 on July 27, 2010, 11:31:03 PM
I'd guess the X brace was designed not arbitrarily but from recognizing an issue with ladder braced guitar tops rolling forward.
On second thought... although the X brace does address the issues prone to ladder braced steel strings, Martin came out with the X brace about 80 years before steel strings. So I'm not sure what system it replaced. I still imagine it was done with a structural purpose in mind. One doesn't need computer generated models of chladni patterns to realize the structural effects of the X bracing.
Thanks, Mr.J. It's like having a book of guitar knowledge & history when asking you something. Makes some of my questions seem too simple. I'll have to think of some hard ones before my head bursts from all of this! :bowdown: :humour:
JP (so there's no confusion, like there would be?)
Quote from: BluesMan1 on July 28, 2010, 02:19:40 PM
Thanks, Mr.J. It's like having a book of guitar knowledge & history when asking you something. Makes some of my questions seem too simple. I'll have to think of some hard ones before my head bursts from all of this! :bowdown: :humour:
JP (so there's no confusion, like there would be?)
Thanks. The questions are good, they make me think.