"In general, I would lean toward the Gibson simply because of the construction quality and consistency. The Larrivee in its present form - a youthful factory built guitar - suffers from the limitations of a focus on production. I have played some L-05s that had almost no D string for hammer ons, as an example, and others that had a really dead G. It was almost like nobody was tapping the tops or doing quality control, just shaving braces and getting it done before break etc.
I loved the Larrivee guitars when they were made in Victoria, B.C. Canada - my home town - and if you can find a seasoned one from there you have the real tater in your hands - but today's Larrivee is made with Jean doing the paperwork while the apprentices toil away at production and I would venture to guess that if you aren't plugging in, you will get tired of the Larrivee within six months.
If you are looking for a solid stage guitar, the Larrivee has to stay in the running. Its overall diminished resonance but excellent string separation are a sound man's delight. Feedback is very easy to manage, for example."
I ran across this from 2008 in the Gibson Forum while searching for some Larrivee info...
Say What? :wink: I guess I lucked out with a 2002 (which took a year off the line) and a 2008 built in 12-2007 whew, ooops I do have a couple of dogs, both were built in California, dang I really liked them too only to find out they are firewood. Good thing nobody has to know where they came from :bgrin:
And what exactly were you doing in the Gibson Forum looking for Larrivee info? :humour:
To be square, I have run into a few Larrivee duds as well. But I have also tried many Gibsons off the wall in some shop, and several of them have sounded dead to me.
At the same time, there is a great little CJ-165 in a shop nearby here. And the P-09 I played at Sam Ash was outstanding. Play it before you buy. As always.
Quote from: frankhond on May 30, 2010, 09:33:02 AM
And what exactly were you doing in the Gibson Forum looking for Larrivee info? :humour:
What were you doing in the Gibson Forum looking for any info?
I put "Larrivee Forum" in my Google search engine and a "Gibson J-45 vs Larrivee L-05" discussion comes up on the first page. Couldn't help myself--needed a laugh...
I tend not to really bother with Gibsons but on the odd occasion when I have looked at new J45's there always seems to be cosmetic issues particularly around the end of the fretboard near the sound hole and the line between the nut and headstock - I dont see anything like that with Larrivee's in general. The Forum IV issue is the first I have come across.
:wacko:Gibson simply because of the construction quality and consistency.Having owned 3 Gibson acoustic's in the 40 years I've been playing and having gone thru a few hundred just to find them I would like to ask you to please share the meds with the rest of us.Comparing one brand of guitar to the other is so useless its funny.There not built the same so the only thing that can be compared is tone[subjective]quility of build[OK]volumn[OK]feel[subjective]price[subjective].Again please share the meds.
:coffee :coffee :humour: :coffee :coffee :wave
I've heard more than a few people compare Larrivees -- especially Ls -- to Gibson. It doesn't make sense to me. If you want the J-45 sound (and to me it's a great sound), get a J-45. Larrivees sound like Larrivees.
I just have such respect for people who know what they're talking about. Kind of gives me goosebumps.
Quote from: unclrob on May 30, 2010, 11:30:29 AM
Having owned 3 Gibson acoustic's in the 40 years I've been playing and having gone thru a few hundred just to find them
I don't think this was emphasized enough in the post. A great J-45 is an amazing guitar. The problem is finding one!!!! I can pick up 5 random L-03s, not saying they fill the same role, but I can pick up 5 of them and 3 will be no brainers, 1 might be great for someone else, but I'd pass on it, and 1 would need some TLC before I'd even demo it again. But J-45s? Man... You've got to wade through gore to find one with no fit and finish issues. Then it still might not tickle your fancy. Fanboys are all the same though. Doesn't matter what make or model. Some folks are going to build their entire identity on an object they bought...