I noticed it last night, but it got really bad today. While tuning the A string, the tuner would rotate slightly without changing string tension, then stick and kind of pop forward when I applied enough pressure. Something felt really wrong, and when tuning, a little piece of the ebony (is it ebony on the black tuners?) near the small shaft area (not the large you grab) just cracked and flew on the floor (luckily I found it).
I examined the tuner and realized the metal rod that goes inside the tuning-peg thing was loose and that the ebony casing and the rod were not spinning as one piece. I guess when I applied pressure, the metal inside spun and the tuning button didn't resulting in the break. I tightened up the screws on the tuning button things and it seems a little better.
Is this a problem? I'll try and glue that piece back on, but is there something wrong with the tuner?
I'ver read bad things about the Larrivee Ping Tuners, but don't know what those are. Am I dealing with Ping Tuners?
Thanks!
:donut2 :donut :coffee
Sounds like you have the Larrivee branded Pings. Yes the black ebonoid buttons are/were a problem. Now they come with metal buttons that alleviate that problem. E-mail the factory and see if they have a replacement, or maybe supply the metal ones.
Alternatively, you can do what many do and upgrade your tuners to Schaller, Gotoh 510's, Grovers, etc.
Is the tuner button screw still there?You might want to tighten up.Not too tight just snug.
I tried tightening it up, but the problem has persisted. The ebonoid button now has a big crack in it, a bit of it fragmented off, the button just spins on the post-thing, and I can't tune the A string up anymore.
I like the ebonoid buttons. But if they're cheap, they're cheap, and I don't want to deal with it happening 5 more times. Would I have to replace the tuning machine or just the knob? Which brands are best?
You bought this new right?If so its a warranty issue that you need to contact the dealer you got it from.If not I'm sure that someone on this forum could help you with finfing a new set that are drop in's,remove the old and put in the new without any drilling or anything.
Check that the string is not binding in the nut, and causing too much tension to be put on the knob. Also make sure the screw is not too tight, since that affects the amount of pressure necessary to rotate the knob. You can pretty easily come up with chrome knobs which will not break to replace the ebonoid, but finding replacement ebonoid is a bit difficult.
I would double check the knob screws though - they don't need to be very tight, just gently snug. You should be able to rotate the knobs with the strings off very easily. If they get tightened down too much, you can easily crack a knob since you'd be trying to rotate a locked tuner -
Tad
PS - don't remove the screws and knobs, or even loosen them up too much while the strings are under tension - you can shoot the knob shaft right out of the tuner body. No need to ask how I found this out -
sorry to hear about the button ngerty...
it seems like a fine opportunity to switch to some really good looking buttons, or to get new tuners :)
good luck :thumb
Quote from: Choay823 on May 12, 2010, 02:19:45 AM
sorry to hear about the button ngerty...
it seems like a fine opportunity to switch to some really good looking buttons, or to get new tuners :)
good luck :thumb
+1 both my Larris have Gotoh's now, they really should offer them as an option on such fine guitars, but it is what it is, in comparison to the price of the guitar tuners are a cheap investment that produce a tangible and noticable result. Well worth the dollars in my case.
Quote from: tadol on May 12, 2010, 01:02:45 AM
Tad
PS - don't remove the screws and knobs, or even loosen them up too much while the strings are under tension - you can shoot the knob shaft right out of the tuner body. No need to ask how I found this out -
This is a good point. The screw tension should be adjusted while the strings are off during a string change, I adjust mine so there is no slop and they are firm to turn without string tension on them. They are not any harder to turn once the string is brought up to pitch, just nice and smooth.
I've got the black ebonoid buttons on two of my Larrivees and have never had a problem (knock on tonewood).
In a conversation with Mathew @ Larrivee about another tuner matter he told me that the Schaller ebony buttons available at StewMac are a drop in replacement for the ping tuners. These are they I believe. http://www.stewmac.com/shop/Tuners/Tuner_parts/Schaller_Tuner_Buttons.html
That be the case, I know Larrivee will mail you a new replacement tuner under warranty if you contact them ... I am just in the process of receiving one.
Dave