howdy everyone
i know, there are a lot of threads about gotoh 510's and i understand they are great (obviously im thinking about it :bgrin:) and are drop in replacements but i had two questions....
1- i understand they are miles better than the pings but what about the newer schallers? i have the schallers and when i tune it isnt very smooth. just wanted some opinions to see what its worth to others
2- my schallers have ebony tuning buttons on them, can i replace the gotoh 510 oval buttons with the schaller ones i use now?
thanks!
i cant answer the buttom question but getting buttons to fit difference tuners does seem to be a problem,I just got some 510s and couldn't believe the difference,to be honest I didn't think the pings were that bad but the 510s are so solid,the buttons that were on the 510s I didnt like much untill they were on the guitar and now I prefer the look of them,if your tuners dont feel that soild the 510s will.
I made the switch, but I don't know if I'd do it again. I'd bought the Gotohs to put on my D-03R or my L-03RE, replacing Pings. I didn't find the Pings all that stable, although there's a set on my Seagull that works fine.
So I had them when I traded my D-03R for a 90s D-50 with decent Schaller tuners. But I figured I'd put my best tuners on my best guitar. Later I sold my L-03RE and bought a Larrivee Parlor. Had I kept the Schallers on the D-50, I could have dropped the 510s right into the holes on the Parlor. Instead I had my tech install both. Not too expensive, but not very practical. So I've got the Gotohs on the D-50--still my best guitar--and the Schallers that were OEP on the D-50 are not on my Parlor.
I changed the tuners on my L-09 a week after I bought it. "everybody" said Pings were bad, and Gotoh 510's Delta's the best. I got brushed gold/ebonoid tuners and they look and work great. But it was a cosmetic change, and a desire to customize a special instrument. I honestly was surprised that they weren't that different in feel and function.
Now I have a 00-03 with Scallers/metal buttons and a P-09 with Pings/metal buttons. I am leaving them stock b/c a: they work well so far and b. they look really good, and c. I want to see how they work over time. So far, they all are silky smooth and stay in tune, so...
BTW the biggest concern with they Larrivee Pings turns out be problems with the ebanoid buttons which they no longer use. so...
I honestly don't think the full-size Pings are that bad. The Mini Pings on my Parlor and 12-string on the other hand I really hate. The mini-Grovers on my Guild are much more precise and solid.
Unless I had read here on the forum about negative comments re: Pings, I would never thought about it. I have Pings on my D10 and Schallers on my JCL 40th Anniversary. Both work fine in my opinion. Sometimes we suffer from a "follow the herd" mentality. If someone says Pings are bad, then they must be bad. Same thing with strings, capos, etc. Maybe I am just not that picky.
I had my DV09 probably 3 years before I noticed a bit of wobble on the posts with the stock Pings, and they were getting harder to tune in so I changed them out for the Gotoh due to wear. My 12 string with the minis on the other hand had springs in the tuners that felt really unstable so I swapped them out too, I couldn't handle the way those spring mounts felt at all.
Quote from: leftync on May 03, 2010, 11:06:12 PM
I made the switch, but I don't know if I'd do it again. I'd bought the Gotohs to put on my D-03R or my L-03RE, replacing Pings. I didn't find the Pings all that stable, although there's a set on my Seagull that works fine.
So I had them when I traded my D-03R for a 90s D-50 with decent Schaller tuners. But I figured I'd put my best tuners on my best guitar. Later I sold my L-03RE and bought a Larrivee Parlor. Had I kept the Schallers on the D-50, I could have dropped the 510s right into the holes on the Parlor. Instead I had my tech install both. Not too expensive, but not very practical. So I've got the Gotohs on the D-50--still my best guitar--and the Schallers that were OEP on the D-50 are not on my Parlor.
Actually...the Gotoh minis are a direct drop in for the parlor.
Quote from: itscowfun on May 03, 2010, 08:51:36 PM
i have the schallers and when i tune it isnt very smooth. just wanted some opinions to see what its worth to others
I'm new to all this changing tuner stuff, but I have the original Schallers on my '95 Larrivee OM-09K. I've had no problem with them. Am I supposed too? :wink:
Carol :donut2 :coffee
The pings and schallers have been fine - but the Gotoh 510s I put on my F3 are just alot better - no backlash, higher ratio so a little easier to tweak tuning, and I think more attractive. I also like the plastic knobs for the weight they save on the headstock. Unfotunately, they are a bit expensive so I haven't replaced any others, but if I had any problems with the stock tuners I'd have no problems ordering another set -
Quote from: Carol on May 06, 2010, 09:39:41 AM
I'm new to all this changing tuner stuff, but I have the original Schallers on my '95 Larrivee OM-09K. I've had no problem with them. Am I supposed too? :wink:
Carol :donut2 :coffee
:wave :coffee
Quote from: Walkerman on May 06, 2010, 09:25:37 AM
Actually...the Gotoh minis are a direct drop in for the parlor.
I'm sure you're right. They probably look better on a small guitar like the Parlor, too. But I had the Schallers and didn't want to buy another set. I don't expect to be buying another guitar so I should be good on tuners. I never had a big problem with the Pings, but they do feel flimsy compared with the Gotohs. Pings hold a tune well on my Seagull, as I said. Feel tighter, more substantial
I replaced the ping tuners on a Taylor I recently owned with the Gotoh 510 deltas. They were superb tuners, and well worth the cost--I picked them up for around $75.00.
Bad thing is that when I sold the Taylor a few months later I couldn't switch back to the stock tuners and keep my Gotohs...had to drill a small hole in the headstock for the retrofit. :mad:
I highly recommend them for your Larrivee!
Quote from: KYPicker on May 08, 2010, 12:31:19 AM
I replaced the ping tuners on a Taylor I recently owned with the Gotoh 510 deltas. They were superb tuners, and well worth the cost--I picked them up for around $75.00.
Bad thing is that when I sold the Taylor a few months later I couldn't switch back to the stock tuners and keep my Gotohs...had to drill a small hole in the headstock for the retrofit. :mad:
I highly recommend them for your Larrivee!
Bummer Dude!
I love the Gotoh Deltas I put on my L, superb quality and the brushed gold is not common (thought Taylor and others used them.) Pretty expensive, though (more than KYPicker's). I am thinking of putting torty buttons on it for its birthday. Knowing what I do now? My newer Larri's have chrome buttons, and they look very nice, plus the tuners function nicely. I may do the upgrades some day just to customize, freshen thiongs up, re[place poorly functioning parts(?) pins, saddles, tuners. But later.