I was inspired to ask this separately by Zohn's thread. I always read that every old guitar with a dovetail joint will eventually need a neck reset, particularly old Martins, and I even understand why (the guitar's inexorable need, over time, to fold in on itself). My question is: how would you know? What are the obvious physical signs that tell you you're headed in that direction? I'm guessing this will probably never be an issue in my lifetime for any of my acoustics, since they were all built after 2000, but I'm still curious.
When there isn't enough saddle left from lowering the action(the guitar folding in on itself raises the action).
As you might of guessed there can be a grey area of determining if there is enough saddle sticking out above the bridge. First the break angle over the saddle will be compromised and eventually if the neck isn't reset there won't be any saddle above the bridge.
Tyco here is a link to the Frank Ford page on neck angle. It's a good read. Flathead
http://www.frets.com/FRETSPages/Musician/Guitar/Setup/NeckAngle/neckangle.html
Take a straight edge thats at least 18 inches long,place it in the middle of the finger board and slide it up to the bridge.If the bottom of the straight edge is sitting below the top of the bridge more then likely you need to have the neck reset.