Hey Guys and Gals,
Haven't posted for a while, but have been lurking.
I love the phrase in the title, but, like many such phrases, the actual meaning is somewhat subjective. Many here have said that certain Larris, F-III's coming to mind here, need to be played alot before they really start to shine and come into their own.
Therefore, a question. When you say the above phrase, or see it written somewhere, what is your interpretation of (ballpark) how many hours the poster/person is talking about.
I'm not seeing any mucus coming out of my guits, but then maybe I haven't played them enough yet. :smile: When can I expect to see it?
Take care, Jared
Mine sat here about a month before i started to enjoy it...and there was only a couple hours of play in that month..I think it just need time for all the glue joints to harden....
LJ, like that phrase. Makes sense, but if it's the right one, do you owe it money? I kinda feel that way about my F-III now. Didn't @ first, but after all's been ironed out & "I've played it like it owed me money" (snotty money!), I'm starting to wonder the opposiite. Like, the "I should have paid more?" thing? :?
Jeff :guitar
I know some grind heavier than others, still, I judge from the amount of fret wear with mine and older guitars I'm looking at. I've added some good divots to my L since I got it almost a year ago. It's sounding robust.
Maybe "Play the frets off It" is better.
I wish I had pictures of my guitar with blood sprayed across the top from right hand when I played rythm in an otherwise electric band. It made quite the design.
Ted Nugent supposedly said:
"Play until your fingers bleed...then play more".
I don't have a pickguard on my FIII so I don't really wail on it. I also have a new Guild D-50...THAT one I seriously beat the snot out of it (as if it threatened my 1.5 year old son).
"They" say that Richie Havens played so hard that he ate through the soundboard of a guitar almost every year.
"They" say that Neil Young plays so hard that he puts on new strings every day.
Like you said, it's all relative.
Over the last three years, I've played my 000-60 slightly North of 3000 hours. I'd say that qualifies as playing the snot out of her.
Would definely hate to get blood on my L-10, though I've had blisters burst when I first got it. Have a clear pg also, so I luckily didn't get anything on the top. Would be clear anyway, but don't know what it would do to the finish. GA-ME, 3000+? I think it definetly falls into the description you've given! Like some of these phrases popping up. And the stuff on R. Havens & N. Young. I think it's Neil's electrics they're probably talking about, as he beats the crap out of those! Havens has always played Guilds & had a heavy hand. Makes sense about him, still cool info. I have played my L-10 pretty hard before, it being able to handle it. Don't do it any more or have to. Have that responsive touch down now! :bgrin:
Jeff :guitar
Ride 'em hard like rented mules but don't put 'em away wet. Well, that's my theory anyway. They need to know who's boss. Like a dog, happier that way. :guitar
Quote from: BluesMan1 on July 30, 2009, 01:22:47 PM
GA-ME, 3000+? I think it definetly falls into the description you've given! Like some of these phrases popping up.
Jeff, you know something about chronic pain and dealing with it. Like I've said before, I use playing music/guitar as a form of focused attention to help manage my pain. The more I hurt, the more I play. I'm fully disabled and don't have a job. Between university classes and study time, I only use up between 25-35 hours a week. My fiance's Doctoral program eats up about eighty hours a week of her time, so I have lots of time to pick. Usually 3-5 hours a day. It adds up quick. Given no job, no kids, largely empty apartment most of the time, and a distaste for the dribble called television programming, playing guitar, or working on guitars, eats up about all of my awake time. I generally can't sleep longer than 3-5 hours a night so I play in the morning, afternoon and evenings.
As an aside, according to Malcolm Gladwell, it takes about 10,000 hours to reach expert at about anything. I figure between the 3000, or so hours, in the last three years and the probably 3000 +/- hours on guitar over the previous 15 years, prior to the last three years, I'm on my way! I will say, since I've been playing so much over the last three years, I have gotten at least 300-400 percent better. I am starting to belive if I keep it up, at this rate, I'll actually be able to think of myself as a "REAL" picker before I leave this world!
GA-ME, I tell my wife that my playing, Forum interest, & just basic guitar interest helps me take my mind off my ills. Since the pills won't, my hobbies will! :bgrin: She just doesn't get it & no one can, I hate to say, until they go throught it. It alters your life completely, depression, worthlessness, etc. all set in & you have to fight everyday to get on. Day to day! And I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy! And that I mean!
Hang in there, I keep saying it must get better? I know of one day when my pain will be gone, but I try not to think about that one! :?
Jeff :guitar
Jeff, that's real honest stuff. Thanks for opening up. I know exactly what you mean cos I'm there too. And making music has a transcendent quality, don't you agree? There's times you play and play and time stops and nothing else seems to exist. God made music and I feel that at times like that the veil gets very transparent - it's like a conversation happening. So now I see why you call yourself Bluesman. If it's from the heart, it's the real thing, buddy. Regards, Lee.
Lee, GA-ME & I have had discussions about our trouble with chronic pain issues. If I recall, he has a severe form of fibromyalgia, which I can't begin to understand how it must feel when plating. Might not affect his fingers, but I know it can be one of the most debilitating diseases. Every nerve just screams out in some sort of way, resulting in the brain registering it as pain. Real bad pain. GA-ME, do you take Lyrica for your pain? My shrink gave me some to help with my pain, but I had too many BAD dreams as a result, besides other side effects. Had to stop it, but it's supposed to work well (subjective!) with your condition.
I've had 3 back surgeries since '91, working for Sikorsky Aircraft for 13 years, being 6'6" & about 250lbs. of muscle (back then), & always being the one to help with lifting things. Things that a crane should have been used for, not a couple of guys. Plus, being tall didn't help. I had hurt my back twice around when I was 18, doing stupid, manly stuff. Probably hurt my back about 10-15 times @ Sikorsky, going for therapy 3 times a week. But kept working & doing lifting, if that makes sense. Finally one day, my legs went numb while walking in the shop, with severe back spasms also.
After 2 surgeries (them terminating me 1 week before my second one), I jumped on the chance to go back to school & ended up in Nuclear Medicine, specializing in Cardiology @ Yale. Had found my niche in life, loved my work, then moved a 425 lb. patient on a stretcher with bad wheels into my imaging room. Twisted the wrong way blew another disc, went through the whole therapy route, ended up having surgery again by La Butch, as I've nicknamed this Ortho M.D.. He tore my spinal cord during the surgery, put a "patch" on it, dripped spinal fluid for about 2 weeks, having to change the dressing every 4 hrs. & drinking lots of water to hydrate my body. Was going to go in & fix it, but it stopped leaking.
Then in '02, I had a pt. grab me from the side, pulling me in a way that totally screwed up my back. Haven't worked since, can't take classes like GA-ME, though I'd love to. Just can't sit, stand, walk, or do anything w/o getting spasms & always being in pain, just something you learn to deal with. My pain management M.D. gives me just enough to take the edge off, which is fine with me because I like to be able to use my brain. He says that's why it's called "Pain Management".
Now, both of my knees are @ the point where I need them replaced, buying time right now with some series of injections that lubricate the bone. Just puts it off & have had some recent severe flareups with them. Wasn't able to walk w/o shuffling in pain, with my cane & not able to leave the house for weeks. You get used to pain after a point & find ways to grasp it or embrace it, & ways of taking your mind off of it. Not totally, but helps when I play my guitars, go on the Forum, & things that just manage to occupy my ming, other than the pain that's always there. Sucks, but what are you going to do? Think bad thought sometimes, but that's just an east solution & wouldn't want to hurt my kids & family as a result.
Some have heard this before & I apologize, but sharing one's woes helps also with being able to deal with things. GA-ME, you ever want to PM me or email me ( on my profile), feel free if you want to talk to someone. I try to play as much as I can bear to, even that resulting in pain, but I just can't fathom you doing 3000+ hrs. in 3 years! You're a work in progress & might have found a nonnarcotic way to battle your disease, that somehow can be used in the medical journals! I just find solice in my playing, helping me to relax & express myself, as I said, my wife just not getting it. She asks me to leave the room when I play, not wanting to listen to me instead of the TV. Then, when I play in another room, she complains how loud it is, me trying to play softly, but since I got my F-III, it's hard to play w/o responding in higher volume levels. Just is so damn responsive, but it's my choice of my guitars right now & what is, is!
Again, sorry about the dissertation. Just telling my story, & as usual, in a way that's too long! :yawn
Jeff
Jeff, I have spine problems like you. My spinal cord was crushed in 2005 at the L4/L5 vertebral level. I had a massive hernation, posteriorly into the spinal canal. The net result was I have been left with what is known as Cauda Equina Syndrome. I have severe nerve death/damage from the injury. Essentially, my brain was sending pain signals because of the compression. By the time the doctors removed the compression, the nerves had died leaving me in a quandary. Because the nerves died before the compression was alleviated, I'm stuck in a negative feedback loop where my brain just keeps sending the pain signals. I tried narcotics, combined with anti-epileptics, such as Topomax and Neurontin (Morontin, if you ask me), along with antidepressants, and I just couldn't stand the side effects. I felt like a drug addled fool all the time. No concentration and no quality of life at all when I was drugged up. I manage now with medical marijuana, meditation, and playing guitar, which for me is a form of focused attention/mindfullness.
Usually, I keep the spirits up, but the last couple of weeks the worthlessness has started creeping in. I have worked and supported myself since I was sixteen and this disability stuff doesn't sit well with me. I have Spanish I and II left to complete my undergraduate degree and then its on to a Masters in Social Work. The thing thats been getting me is I just don't believe I'll get hired when I get my Graduate Degree, because of the issues caused as a result of the injury. I never realized I'd miss my old trade, and working so much, until I couldn't work. Right now, its just about keeping the hope up and believing that there is a reason that this happened. I hope, eventually, to be able to help other spinal cord injury patients to see there is a life after the injury. A different life for sure, but one that can have meaning and purpose.
Hmmmm. And I thought this thread was about a guitar's development with time played? One thing for sure, as far as guitar's go, all my solid wood ones noticeably improve every month, even those several years old. As far as me, I am not so sure.
d.
GA-ME, the "horse's tail" as it's known. As your spinal cord hits your sacrum, it splinters out, like a horses tail. Thus, the Latin "cauda equina". My state hasn't legalized pot for medicinal use YET, but it helps alot, as I've found out. All of my M.D.'s just say "whatever works" & leave it @ that. Sorry to hear you had so much damage. I live on narcotics, Soma, & Valium, a nice cocktail when I go to bed, wondering if I'll wake? That's the scary thing about this stuff. I have scar tissue wrapped around my nerves @ different levels, constantly pulling whenever I move. I guess enough about this here on this thread. Email me for more.
webberlink, you're right. But until you've been there, it's just something you can't begin to relate to. As I said before, my wife just doesn't get it still. Argue alot about my pain, which I keep to myself, but doesn't allow us to do things like before. Not my fault & doesn't get it.
So, just to annoy her, I'm going to grab one of my babies & play the snot out of it! The only one that hasn't been broken in yet is my Baden, which I'm selling, so I'll lightly play the snot out of it! It can handle it, & then some! :wacko:
Jeff :guitar
It's interesting (at least to me) the direction this thread has evolved. The phrase "play the snot out of it" conjurs images of Peter Townsend thrashing his electric. Whereas, some of you have indicated that playing your instrument has become a way of coping with your own personal burdens, and discovering the child like wonder and appreciation for your own improvement as you put in the time. This is very encouraging and inspiring. Music can be such a wonderful outlet for all of us. Aspiring to improve by putting the time in has huge payoffs. Maybe a better image is one Leo Kottke often relates during his performances. He talks about getting so engrossed in his own music and then suddenly realises that yes, he is connected in a very personal way to his guitar, by a long strand of drool, and he is at that point in time the focus of everyone's attention. Man, that's got to make you humble. Music is such great therapy regardless of the enormity of each person's troubled condition.
DAVE
Quote from: ducktrapper on July 30, 2009, 01:34:31 PM
Ride 'em hard like rented mules but don't put 'em away wet. Well, that's my theory anyway. They need to know who's boss. Like a dog, happier that way. :guitar
[attachment deleted by admin]
Danny, couldn't agree more. Just don't beat them "like a dead horse"! :humour: I play my guitars hard sometimes, my L-10 having seen it's days of having to be treated a little rougher, due to playing with more than a few people. Or if playing outside, where the sound just seems to drop off sometimes. I beat my Epi AJ-500M really hard, but never hurt it. Jumbos are made to be played that way & respond well to it. My F-III, as you have found with yours, doesn't need to be beat, just lightly caressed to get a big response. Might be a gender thing, you think (guitars=females)? They're always referred to as "she" or "her", even by woman. Always wondered about that one? :?
Dave, you're right about how the term can be interpreted. Play it alot or play it hard? It seems to me that the thread started out just about wear from playing alot, others then comparing to playing hard, then GA-ME & myself doing our expanding (or expounding) of how we relate to it. My guitar playing, as with most, has always been an outlet for something, picking me up when I'm feeling down, or just helping me maintain happiness. Now it's evolved into this. I just wish I could handle things the way GA-ME (wish I knew his first name?) does, w/o narcotics or drugs. I do visualization alot, a form of meditation I guess. Your story about Kotke was cool & shows how we all relate to our playing in different ways. What else can you do than focus on him when he plays, being such a great player. Since "My Feet Are Smiling", I've fallen in love with his playing. It's kinda funny that he wouldn't think he was the focus of everyone that paid to see him play. Is humbling. Have always got that impression of him. There is alot in life that is humbling, many not realizing it. GA-ME & myself find ourselves in such a place & have found our own ways to get by for now.
You know, I've always used the line that you can't play the blues until you've lived them, even before my injuries. Have had much happen in my life, esp. losses in my family. Makes you really appreciate what you have now more. And when I play my blues, I can really feel them & express myself in such a way. I know from your PM's that you do think of me, & I really do appreciate it. Nice to know there are people even here on the Forum that make me feel better, just by that. Thanks!
Jeff
Hi Bluesman what a great post. I have to agree with you. On a smaller scale I notice songs that I enjoy sound good, but songs that I can relate to are played with emotion. Some evoke different emotions. I'm sure it affects how I play the song (guitar) :guitar
Quote from: jshowyin on July 29, 2009, 05:30:13 PM
I'm not seeing any mucus coming out of my guits, but then maybe I haven't played them enough yet. :smile: When can I expect to see it?
Depends on you and your beliefs. We see threads all the time about how someone bought a new guitar and wished it was brighter, darker, punchier, etc. Of course the guitar will open up in months, weeks, days or even hours, depending on who's doing the wishing, and sound however they hoped it would. I'm sure if you believe in it enough you'll see a little snot seeping out of that soundhole.
Quote from: Lawn Jockey on July 29, 2009, 05:32:56 PM
If "playing the snot out of it" isn't cutting it.....perhaps you should "beat it like it owes you money".
:cheers
Where would this sayin' comes from "playin' the snort out of the guitar" I didn't know guitars have snort :? :whistling:
cheers
fongie
Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 06, 2009, 10:29:19 PM
Depends on you and your beliefs. We see threads all the time about how someone bought a new guitar and wished it was brighter, darker, punchier, etc. Of course the guitar will open up in months, weeks, days or even hours, depending on who's doing the wishing, and sound however they hoped it would. I'm sure if you believe in it enough you'll see a little snot seeping out of that soundhole.
:yawn
Quote from: flatlander on August 08, 2009, 12:18:11 AM
:yawn
Wow, thanks for the emotional feedback. I'm always interested in how my readers feel about my posts. It's ok if you can't comment on the actual subject matter, it means a lot just to share your feelings.
Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 08, 2009, 10:21:45 AM
Wow, thanks for the emotional feedback. I'm always interested in how my readers feel about my posts. It's ok if you can't comment on the actual subject matter, it means a lot just to share your feelings.
I thought you would catch on that I was just letting you know that your little jabs don't go unnoticed. If you want full response I can certainly give it to you. Gotta go to son's soccer game now though.
fongie, the expression refers to "snot", as in "bugers", the mucous, sometimes hard things that work well as projectiles that come out of your nose! :humour: What you're thinking of is the word "snort", which is a sound or a noun, such as a pig makes, or some disgrunted & doesn't agree with you would make. What was that? Thought I heard one coming from around Tennessee? Snort can also be a sound that comes out, through the nostrils, as a part of a laugh. Or referring to drugs through the nose. Or, even, doing a shot of alcohol. Snot is something your brother, when sharing a room, throws on you when the lights go out! Yes, from experience!
You can always say "playing the heck out of your guitar", or something meaning the same. We'll get the idea! But then, is it meant as "beating your guitar so hard" or " playing it for a long time"? Is a subjective phrase, meaning something different to many. Most just think of the length of playing, not try to put words in people's mouths.
One thing to always remember is to keep the snot OFF your guitar, or yourself! :humour:
Cheers, mate!
Jeff :guitar
Quote from: flatlander on August 08, 2009, 11:00:26 AM
I thought you would catch on that I was just letting you know that your little jabs don't go unnoticed. If you want full response I can certainly give it to you. Gotta go to son's soccer game now though.
They weren't jabs but rather crucial points in my statement. Are you really going to tell me it doesn't matter what someone believes in regards to how they perceive their guitar opening up?
I don't think Matt was focused on perception or belief regarding guitars, but rather the "perception" that could result from such statements. ie. ''condescending'' for one thing could be construed by a gentle person,who lacks the boldness for a retort.
Jeremy, I think you said it right, as Dan seconded. It seems to be a subjective thing & all don't get the concept of "opening up" or perceive it the same. Now I'll get some backlash from flatlander, but we also all have a way of replying to posts sometimes, some in your face & others tiptoeing. I don't think either of you tiptoe around here & are always ready to defend what you say, as I've found out in the past. I'm not trying to start something here, FL, just seeing things as I do.
FL, I hope you had a good time @ your son's soccer game. And I'm not being sarcastic. I'm just kicking back more on the Forum, tyring not to get into arguments & just enjoying it a little more. No harm meant. This appears to be between you & Jeremy. As I said, I think alot of things people say are subjective. Yes, I get the sarcasm from Jeremy sometimes, but it's just part of him & I still like him for who he is & respect what he says, as he's expressing his opinion. As you are. It's like a medieval jousting match. Who's will break first? :cheers
Jeff :guitar
Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 06, 2009, 10:29:19 PM
Depends on you and your beliefs. We see threads all the time about how someone bought a new guitar and wished it was brighter, darker, punchier, etc. Of course the guitar will open up in months, weeks, days or even hours, depending on who's doing the wishing, and sound however they hoped it would. I'm sure if you believe in it enough you'll see a little snot seeping out of that soundhole.
"How come I keep wishing I didn't hear the sound of you saying quick break in periods are in peoples heads but I'm still hearing it?" That's how I was going to start last night but decided it really just made me tired. Hence the yawn
1st Bluesman I don't think you get the point of mine or Danny's post, so let me spell it out since inquiring minds want to know. (I am having jousting fun BTW)
Jeremy, 1st if you don't see above quote as a jab, call me crazy and drop off now. Over the years you have made it quite clear that you believe people's perceived breakin are in thier head. You've always been a "fact" guy, which is good, and the fact is that often you have outright said, or over the last year insinuated, that these changes in tone are in peoples head. There is/was a clear deliniation between perceived change in tone and real. People presented it as real change, you dismissed it as in thier head, just as you did above.
Of course I'm sure you remember your replies concerning me reporting changes happening with my 000-60
within 6 weeks of "playing the snot" out of it. And how my L-10 didn't change much even as I was activly looking for it and leaving it in front of speakers ect.
No one has presented facts on breaking in guitars. In this day and age with spectrum analyzers very accessable and reasonable, I'm not sure why. But anyway there are many bonified builders and musicians who have a different opinion on this than you do. Are some peoples break ins, in thier head or in how they adjust to guitar? Certainly. I really don't think mine was. I'm not gonna go thru the individual, obvious to me changes that happened. But even if it was in MY head, it doesn't matter. I'll readily admit I don't have the best ears.
Physically or mentally. My right ears highs are fried and volume about half of lefts.
Most really good musicians have good ears. I have a friend who I would call great. Plays everything electric and acoustic great. He never says anything about it but he has perfect pitch. I've seen him restring instruments with out a tuner or reference and tune them right into 440 with the tweaks that make his tuning sound better than yours. Everyone loves playing with him because he makes everyone sound better. He just instinctively and sublimely fillls in the sonic spaces. I trust his ears. He believes some instruments break in much quicker that others. In fact he said he's heard a big and very quick change in Banjo's when you pick them up after not having played them for a while. He mentioned in particular his early 30's RB and how he had to "wake it up" after being in for maintenence for a long time. Where was it? It was at Snuffy Smiths who also has similar belief. Snuffy works on some of the very top musicians instruments. J.D. Crowes man. Remember when someone posted about Clarences D-28 and there was a reference to Tony Rice saying he had just gotten it back out, literally from a vault? That was at Snuffy's. He let my friend look at it, but not touch!
There could be more, like violin makers applying high frequency sine waves to instruments to straighten out fibers in wood................. but the point is that you dismiiss reports of quick break-in times as in someones head, on instruments you haven't even heard? To me dismissing someones opinion outright because it differs from your own limited experience with breaking in new guitars,and your understanding of wood and glue is closed minded even for your own sake. More importantly I think it comes off dismissive of other forum members opinions. Lastly, when you act like you are so sure about a subject that it is impossile to be sure of.
(especially when you've never heard the guitar in question) it cast doubt for me on other things you may present in full confidence. That's a shame because I know that you contain a wealth of info. Much more than me. Well there's the rest of the story. Always appreciate the things I learn from your posts. Matt
Matt, I think I get the point of both of your points, Jeremy & I not agreeing on things constantly, & I can see how you feel the way you do about the "jabs". Sometimes Jeremy just comes off as "in your face" sometimes, seems like he's always right, & I kid him, which he understands, sometimes. I don't see you as someone that "lacks the boldness of a retort", as Danny said. I've done this dance with Jeremy before &, in the end, it's almost like butting heads! As far as he's concerned, I've learned to ask questions, if I don't agree say so, then let it be. He's helped me alot on tech questions & seems to know alot of what he's talking about. Not saying you don't. Alot of these posts are subjective, not factual. I, as you, have placed my L-10 in front of my massive speakers (years ago) & played the snot out of my speakers. Heard it made the break-in period less time, esp. with the bass turned up & really getting the top vibrating! Might have worked, as my L-10 is just an incredible guitar. To say that I, or others, don't learn from what you've had to say isn't true.. You always have good input. I try to have good input & share my years of knowledge, but always still learning.
If I got the answer you got, I'd have to give a full answer also, as you did. I get it. Maybe didn't phrase it as such, but I get Jeremy & his personality. Have emailed each other, me mainly asking for advice, & his tone is totally different in that world. I haven't been around as long as you & heard all of his quotes, but the break-in comment was kinda sarcastic, or I perceived it as such. As I said, I'm trying not to react to things like that, knowing that he's half kidding? I think? :?
Know what the funny thing is, my F-III has taken half the time to break in as sounding as good as my L-10. Something I realized the other day!
Jeff
Quote from: flatlander on August 08, 2009, 06:39:49 PM
Are some peoples break ins, in thier head or in how they adjust to guitar? Certainly.
:ohmy: Oh come on, you are basically saying the same thing I did in the post you have a problem with. You don't even disagree with what I actually said.
Quotebut the point is that you dismiiss reports of quick break-in times as in someones head, on instruments you haven't even heard? To me dismissing someones opinion outright because it differs from your own limited experience with breaking in new guitars,and your understanding of wood and glue is closed minded even for your own sake. More importantly I think it comes off dismissive of other forum members opinions. Lastly, when you act like you are so sure about a subject that it is impossile to be sure of.
(especially when you've never heard the guitar in question) it cast doubt for me on other things you may present in full confidence.
I wasn't dismissive of anyone in this thread, the person I quoted didn't even claim their guitar opened up. There is no 'guitar in question'. Nor were any opinions dismissed simply because they differ from my own 'limited experience'. My beliefs are based on some small part to
your experience with your 000-60. If you have an issue with something specific I said then you are welcome to bring that up but don't try to pin me for a crime with no victim. The conversations will be much more fruitful if you stick to the words on the page rather than pretend you know what I believe and why.
Also, If I believe that guitars breaking in is only in one's head, it wouldn't make any difference if I heard the guitar or not would it? Unless you are claiming I have would be immune from the effect you claim I believe in.
Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 08, 2009, 07:52:36 PM
but the break-in comment was kinda sarcastic, or I perceived it as such.
Well yes to some degree. However it does depend on who is perceiving this changing(breaking in/opening up) and that includes what they believe. That idea doesn't exclude the possibility that the change could be real.
Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 06, 2009, 10:29:19 PM
Depends on you and your beliefs. We see threads all the time about how someone bought a new guitar and wished it was brighter, darker, punchier, etc. Of course the guitar will open up in months, weeks, days or even hours, depending on who's doing the wishing, and sound however they hoped it would. I'm sure if you believe in it enough you'll see a little snot seeping out of that soundhole.
Jeremy, I kinda wish the :yawn would have been the end. But I appreciate deserving a more specific post. So this is last of this. Like I said in last post, if you don't think that was a jab, call me crazy and move on. I don't need to go any further than this post to be specific and make point.
I realize that it was just kidding but I also know that it something you have brought up a lot and slipped into threads. The overall theme of the above post seems to me to be
that break in time is determined by "you and your beliefs" and what the individual is expecting or wishing for. "depends on who's doing the wishing" I don't know how that can be interpreted any differently. I'll try to address the points you made in counter.
"I wasn't dismissive of anyone in this thread"
Perhaps not but I wasn't speaking of only this thread. I don't need to look up old threads because you said it right here. "We see threads all the time about how someone bought a new guitar and wished it was brighter, darker, punchier, etc. Of course the guitar will open up in months, weeks, days or even hours, depending on who's doing the wishing, and sound however they hoped it would."
This is your own comment about past threads. Lets break it down to be sure. We see threads all time. (commenting on real, threads) about how someone (a forum member) or even hours, depending on who's doing the wishing, and sound however they hoped it would." (dismissive) The guitars in question would be the one's spoken of in these past threads you refer to.
"Also, If I believe that guitars breaking in is only in one's head, it wouldn't make any difference if I heard the guitar or not would it?" I know you have acknowledged changes over time. It's the dismissing of someone's opinion outright because you don't think the time frame is plausable. I don't think it's fair or logical, to do that without hearing the guitar over that time frame yourself.
"Oh come on, you are basically saying the same thing I did in the post you have a problem with. You don't even disagree with what I actually said." Your right. I don't disagree that it is probably sometimes, maybe a lot of the times, the case. But I'd still want to hear guitars myself before deciding. I hate explaining something like this, it's like having to explain a joke, but the main purpose of that statement was to acknowledge common ground. It tends to make discussion more civil in cases like this.
That idea doesn't exclude the possibility that the change could be real." Just say that a little more often or throw it in if you want, when inferring that changes in a guitars sound are in owners head.
That's really all it would take to fit my idea of a less dismissive attitude. Otherwise carry on.
Bluesman, yes, yes I get or think I get Jeremy. I like in your face straight talking people. I'll take that to fluffy B.S. anyday. Of course with that comes some blow back, which I don't think he gets bent out of shape about from past experiences. I also know how much he brings to forum on the wood and strings side and I've commented on that several times before. I certainly look forward to
the many things we'll agree on in future post and don't think I'll stay on his shix list longer than today, Ok well may tommorrow. :beer
QuoteThe overall theme of the above post seems to me to be
that break in time is determined by "you and your beliefs" and what the individual is expecting or wishing for.
That isn't the theme. I didn't address 'break in time' at all. Go back and read the question I responded to initially. The OP didn't ask when the guitar would break in, he asked when he would perceive it. It was a theoretical question. I think I was right on the money, that how and when one perceives a guitar opening up depends on who they(the perceiver) are and what they believe. I think that's true and that concerns me more than if the idea is dismissive or not. If you have issue with an old post then you've already had your chance to address it, certainly don't get it confused with this one.
I had the snot knocked outta me once.
This plain clothes detective got out of his car in my suburban Detroit neighborhood and asked me a bunch of dumb questions and I must have done something "perceived" by him to be a threatening gesture caused he popped me a good one upside the head. I was about 145 lbs, pimpled faced and 16 years old.
I also had a cold. I think he had to lend me his handkerchief.
My "perception" of cops changed right then and there. (my house was just across the street)
My mom was pretty angry with that "tough cop"
Let's see... what were we talking about? Snot, perception, guitars? Not really. :blush:
The actual time period when one "perceives" that a guitar's tone has changed will vary hugely. There are just so many factors involved, not the least of which is that when you own a guitar and play it every day, the change on a day by day basis is imperceptible. It's like living with your kids and not noticing that they are getting taller and taller whereas someone who has not seen them for a year will say "Wow, how they've grown!". But the fact that tonal changes do occur is surely undisputed. However the latter part of this thread is a bit confusing to me. Jeremy states that the opening up time depends on "who they (the perceiver) are and what they believe". But what do those two concepts mean, Jeremy? Who I am and what I believe has nothing to do with whether I perceive a change in sonic properties (unless I were hearing impaired). How I judge those changes will be due to subjective factors (my own tastes) but the fact that I do perceive changes is an objective fact, assuming that I am speaking with honesty. In just such a way, I perceived changes in the colour of the top of my year old L03 R as UV darkened the spruce - indisputable and in this case, verifiable by photograph - but whether I liked the changes (I did) is a subjective response based on who I am ie my personal tastes and thus, "in the head". Is this what you are saying? Because if you are saying that any PERCEPTION of change is subjective, then I disagree strongly. And I would really like you to explain how you see it that who they...are and what they believe influences the time it takes to perceive tonal change in a guitar. Regards, Lee.
Oh heck - why not throw some more fuel on the fire -
The "perceived" change in a new guitar has 2 other parts in my estimation. One is the "honeymoon" period that I think everyone goes through with a new (or used) guitar. When you finally get that guitar into your living room, and sit in your favorite chair, and play some of the songs you really know the sound of from other guitars, you start to hear things that are different. How long the honeymoon lasts varies from guitar to guitar - reading some of the For Sale ads, you would think its over within days for some people. I have found I need to play a guitar for months before I start to feel like I understand my feelings about it.
The other part is the change and adaptation of playing style on a new instrument. This is especially true if there are some physical differences between the new guitar and the ones you are used to - neck size/shape, body size/shape, etc. - the physical differences I think you actually adapt to, and change the way you hold the instrument and play it. And some of that may even be subconcious.
And the "structural" changes to a new guitar must be real - there is a company that makes a vibrator kinda device that you attach to the instrument and turn on, and it claims to stimulate the changes in the instrument that take much longer to happen just by playing - http://www.tonerite.com/
SO there you go - a bunch of stuff happens when you "play the snot out of your guit". Some are physical changes to the guitar, some are possible physical changes from the player, and some are purely perception based on the expectations the owner has from the purchase. Plus you usually end up with your first scratch or ding, getting that change out of the way too -
Asbestos suit on - Fire away!
Tad
The prices of those Tonerites seem to have fallen. I might get one. I remember them being much more. Still a lot for a vibrator. If Wallmart were selling them they'd be $19.99
Tone is much more complex than simply observing a soundboard getting darker in color. We also don't have photographs to compare. 'Who they are' involves factors such as how sensitive their hearing is. That doesn't just mean their physical hearing. When I was in the recording program at MTSU there was a class called 'Critical Listening', because understanding what you are hearing is very much a skill.
I already addressed the beliefs part. Like I said in past threads we have people who complain their guitar is lacking something and sometime later the guitar 'opens up' and is no longer lacking. That would be fine if these guitars weren't all opening up in different ways that happen to coincide with how the owner wished they sound. Someone reports their guitar getting brighter while another reports theirs getting more bass.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deutsch's_scale_illusion
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_fundamental
http://www.cog.brown.edu/~slomanlab/Fernbach/Assets/op264-fernbach.pdf
Frank Ford made a couple posts on the UMGF about this subject:
QuoteI must start by saying I wish I'd had the foresight/opportunity to do this kind of test with a larger sample and under more controlled circumstances. But this is what I have:
In 1983 I bought a new Martin "Custom - 15." In case you don't know that model, suffice it to say it's another brother of the HD-28.
David, a local bluegrass picker, bought one just like mine that same year. In fact, they were VERY similar guitars: grain spacing on face, bridge height, setup. Most of all, they sounded as nearly identical as any two guitars I've heard.
David built himself a box for his guitar. It was big enough to hold the instrument, was made of 3/4" ply with foam insulation inside. Also inside was a speaker, through which he played his stereo LOUD for many months. During and after this break-in period, David played the guitar in the classic hard-driving bluegrass style. He formed a band, and drove it with his Custom 15. This guitar got years of really hard mileage.
I, on the other hand, am a mandolin player, and was suffering with the beginnings of arthritis. My Custom 15 has hung on the wall or sat in the case, and has been played so little it's embarrassing.
In 1993, around the tenth anniversary of their manufacture, David and I got the two instruments together for a trial:
I had just installed some new strings on my guitar when he arrived at the house. He walked in and hit a G-chord on it and said, "Well, so much for all that breaking-in - your guitar sounds better than mine!" I insisted that he break out his guitar and restring it, too. After some serious comparison, we agreed that his had an EXTREMELY slight edge over mine in the clarity of trebles. It was such a small difference that we agreed it might well have gone unnoticed ten years earlier.
Now, what do I think I learned from this experience? First, I got a quick lesson in David's ability to recognize his own guitar. (No big surprise, because some days I don't think I could identify the mandolin I've played for 30 years.) Second, I think I'm satisfied that the break-in of a guitar is a subtle thing I have no business even trying to hear. I'd say it is very likely that the two guitars aged some by just being instruments, and probably less from the vibes they experienced. Neither instrument had any peculiarity of tone or volume that would compel one to describe it as better than any new Martin dreadnought. They're both good, but not outstanding.
Of course, like any other study, the results are easily skewed to suit a predicted outcome, but this is the most objectivity I've been able to manage.
I spoke to David recently and we agreed it was time for a second "summit meeting," sometime soon. . .
Update, 2009:
David brought his guitar into the shop for another "summit." He's continued to play his every day, fronted numerous bands and generally worked that guitar hard. I, on the other hand (or should I say both hands) have bad enough arthritis I have difficulty holding a pick, and I simply haven't played any music for a decade. My guitar has had no use at all in that time. It has been stored tuned up to pitch, and it needed to have its neck reset at the same time David's did - both were done a couple of years ago.
This time we invited the entire assembly of Gryphon employees and customers who were in the shop to compare the guitars, without telling them what was up.
There was a clear consensus that both instruments sounded so similar as to be considered nearly identical. Some voiced a slight preference for one or the other, but there was no agreement on which one.
Most agreed that both guitars had begun to develop that "vintage" tone and were stronger sounding than equivalent new ones. Indeed, they are both excellent sounding guitars.
QuoteA few more random thoughts -
One thing is measurable - our poor memory for fine discriminations of sound. Kasha, in his peculiar quest to explain and establish the ideal classical guitar, wrote about that decades ago. What we don't remember is specifics of tone. What we DO remember is our emotional state at the time. Over the years I've met any number of players searching for that illusive instrument that sounded just like one they heard but can't seem to find again. And, I've run into lots of players who bought what they thought was a guitar better than the one at home only to find it decidedly inferior because they didn't bring it along as a standard of reference when they tried out the new one.
When I went looking for stereo speakers some years ago i stopped into the local audiophile shop. The sales guy told me I could look but not to bother to try to listen. He said the board was being rewired so he couldn't A-B demo the speakers. He'd have to plug and unplug sets of them, and that would take too long (seconds) for me to hear the differences between two similar candidates.
By that bit of info, to suggest that we can hear our instruments "mature" is patently absurd - we change far more than they do in an equivalent period, whether it's a matter of moments or years.
I can't tell you how many players have brought in instruments proclaiming that we'd be stunned by how much they've "opened up" and how great they sound. So far, not one of them has struck anybody in our shop as remarkable. Wishful thinking abounds.
Have you been to a jam session where instruments are traded around and most of the tone stayed with the player? Well, that's one situation I've witnessed lots of times. I also hear it in our shop over and over - the player's technique means more to tone than most people are willing to admit.
So Jeremy, you're saying my perception of my L-10 "opening up" & sounding better, after 15+ years of playing is just a perception of what I wanted it to, or expected it to? My brother, who as I've said before, is a professional guitarist, has perfect pitch, notices some things I don't, but commented on how much better it sounds over the years. We all know that alot of older instruments get better over time, such as prewar Martins. Long break-in period! Funny, i can ask any luthier or builder & they will tell me "it will only sound better with time". Not my perception, but theirs. And my F-III opening up in OVERALL sound is just my own emotional expectations of what I desired it to sound like? Frank Fords story is interesting, but it's his story. His perception, his partner's, & the Gryphon employees agreeing with what was said. I agree with you that visual changes are something noticed by fact, & sound being a totally different matter. It is PERCIEVED, not seen, as you said, subjective, & I disagree about the emotional expectations thing. Some might fall under that category, as you've given examples of.
The second quote is just another's perception of what he feels about the subject. An emotional explanation, as it is something he perceives. Yes, walk in one day & speakers suck, go in another & they sound great. Could be one of many factors, including your emotional state. If I haven't played my L-10 for a week or so, pick it up, am feeling kinda down, but when I start playing it I think what's coming out is just fantastic. Could be emotional. Could be my perception of the sound. No, it didn't change from last time I played it, but it HAS changed over the years, me noticing a long time ago the change. Isn't it always said, & when you built your dread I think you said it also (I'll look for that one, as I have your build thread saved on my favorites), that before you tweaked the bracings you'd give it time for the bass to open up & the "woofing" to maybe go away?
These are just my thoughts & I do believe that guitars open-up or break-in within a few months of some good playing. This isn't meant to start a "you said, I said" thing, just how I "see" things, or hear them. My opinion only. Just as yours, the others you quoted, & the others that posted. Sound is the most subjective thing with guitars, all of us not hearing things the same. Just the way it is?
Jeff
Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 10, 2009, 12:44:24 PM
So Jeremy, you're saying my perception of my L-10 "opening up" & sounding better, after 15+ years of playing is just a perception of what I wanted it to, or expected it to?
No. I still haven't shared my opinion about guitars opening up in this thread, only people's perception of it.
Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 10, 2009, 12:44:24 PM
when you built your dread I think you said it also (I'll look for that one, as I have your build thread saved on my favorites), that before you tweaked the bracings you'd give it time for the bass to open up & the "woofing" to maybe go away?
You're probably thinking of the wolf tone and it is still there.
Yes, the wolf tone. You are right again! Will you share your opinion, or do you want to start a whole new thread? :humour: I really an curious. I get the perception thing & how some phrase the terms in such a way that it does almost seem like a physical thing to them. If they notice something, God bless 'em. As you are, W/O putting words in your mouth, I'm a more cautious guy about this topic. I have heard some that opened up, others I never heard a difference. Can't explain that. Guitars are a creature all to themselves, almost like an enigma. Some things are easy to explain, others not that easy! I give up, until you give up your opinions & then I can actually read them, becoming a physical thing, from a perceived one! :?
Jeff :guitar
Let me squeeze a note in edgewise into this passionate thread. I haven't played the snot out of my LS-03R but it does sound different than when it first came here. Besides developing a deeper and richer sound, in particular the big E string fretted up 3 to G is now resonant and FAR better than the thud it was when new. It is not my imagination.
But it is interesting to read stories of brother guitars traveling different roads and coming together somewhere down the hallow to sound very similar. That's an age factor, of course.
Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 10, 2009, 03:15:29 PM
Will you share your opinion, or do you want to start a whole new thread? :humour: I really an curious.
My opinion on guitars opening up is that it doesn't really matter. If you buy a guitar that sounds like you want it to and it doesn't have any shortcomings in the first place then you shouldn't care if it opens up. With that said, I think wood deformation,settling and aging are the main factors in a guitar opening up. I don't see how vibrations from playing causes any permanent physical changes in the guitar.
Jeremy, ever wonder if an MRI causes any damage? It makes your molecules "vibrate" with magnetism, enabling the imaging. Does it cause permanent damage? I don't know, but they scare the hell out of me because of that. I would love to take a guitar, minus any metal, & put it in an MRI for a while, & see what happens. But try getting in to use one, as they operate 24/7.
Anyway, I agree with you about the changes in the wood, the ones you describe, playing a major factor in the guitar "opening up". I've been reading what I can find, & a majority of those that believe in the "opening up" concept refer to the physics of the molecules in the top, along with resin & whatever the hell else is in there, vibrate & loosen up, causing a tonal difference. Adi tops were referred to alot, probably due to the density? This is one of the grey areas i was referring to about a guitar. The basic physics is that the strings vibrate, transferring this to the top, which then projects the sound off & around the inner body. This you know.
As was mentioned before, take Clarence White's/Tony Rice's prized guitar. I really don't think the sound of it was all due to the wood changes, etc.. They played the snot out of that guitar. Now, do you want to call it "settling in"? Is that a more acceptable term? The physics of the top vibrating is a big factor, IMO, to the break-in, opening-up period. One big discussion was from owners of Adi topped mandolin players. If they sat, they had to have the snot played out of them to get the tone back. Their words. If you find a '38 D-18 that's been sitting in a closet since it was bought, will it sound like one that was played constantly? I doubt it, but these are some of the things that can't be explained to all's satisfaction & won't convince someone that doesn't believe it to begin with. Especially real headstrong people, with beliefs that just won't change. Maybe when the aliens come, many will believe they exist! :humour: I'm not done researching this idea, but I do agree that alot of the changes are from the guitar just settling in.
Jeff :guitar
The idea that vibrations change the way the wood vibrates is a popular one. However I don't recall seeing anything remotely scientific in explaining this. Also there is nothing special about a top simply 'loosening up', there's a reason builders use wood with a high stiffness to weight ratio for the top.
Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 10, 2009, 06:10:14 PM
Jeremy, ever wonder if an MRI causes any damage?
No
Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 10, 2009, 06:10:14 PM
I really don't think the sound of it was all due to the wood changes, etc.. They played the snot out of that guitar. Now, do you want to call it "settling in"?
No. By settling in I mean wood has a plastic response, in other words if you bend wood into a certain shape after a while it will retain that shape. That involves the sides being bent or maybe an arch sound plate glued to a flat rim or deformation due to string tension.
Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 10, 2009, 06:10:14 PM
If you find a '38 D-18 that's been sitting in a closet since it was bought, will it sound like one that was played constantly?
I don't know, I've never found one. Either way I wouldn't know if it would sound different had it been played. I probably wouldn't care at that point.
Didn't expect much more than what you said. No, No, etc.. Ever have an MRI, Jeremy? If you have, you might have more interest in than just answering no. Tops vibrate. Fact. Tops open-up with more vibration. Theory. How do you change the theory to fact? Check out this link with a review of master builder Tim McKnight talking about his guitars opening up & trying the "Tonerite" device. Some science stuff, so try not to fall asleep! :humour:
Jeff :guitar
http://www.mcknightguitars.com/tonerite%202.html (http://www.mcknightguitars.com/tonerite%202.html)
Can be found @ http://www.tonerite.com (http://www.tonerite.com)
Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 10, 2009, 07:52:20 PM
Ever have an MRI, Jeremy?
Yes.
Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 10, 2009, 07:52:20 PM
Check out this link with a review of master builder Tim McKnight talking about his guitars opening up & trying the "Tonerite" device. Some science stuff, so try not to fall asleep! :humour:
I still didn't see anything to explain why/how the vibrations physically alters the wood.
Also, like mentioned before I don't think trying to remember the complex tonal nuances and comparing that to after the guitar was vibrated is very accurate.
Wow it doesn't pay to sleep round here! A whole page has filled up while I was asleep and during my day. So if I could just back up a bit and clarify something I said about aural and visual changes. I'm sorry, but I don't know how to operate the quote function so I'll use italics. Jeremy, this is for you. Tone is more complex than simply observing a soundboard getting darker. Your words. Well of course it is. But you missed the point of my analogy. I merely meant that both aural and visual changes can be PERCEIVED in a measureable fashion ie they are objective. Whereas the same changes can and will be PERCEIVED and internalised in a unique manner by each individual ie they become subjective. Hence the "in the head"stuff. And not to divert the current direction of the thread further, you state that I already addressed the beliefs part. Trouble is, I didn't read your posting on the relevant thread, so your seemingly dismissive comment leaves me still wondering what you are talking about. But frankly, it doesn't matter. I just wonder, though, how much more effective as a teaching tool, such extensive knowledge would be if it were augmented by consistent patience and tolerance. Lee.
:smile: :smile:
Lee. Yes. No. 'bout says it all! There is scientific proof of the top being altered by playing more, the reason being vibrations changing the physical character of the wood, thus affecting the sound. Known fact, by all but those that refuse to accept it. If someone doesn't want to accept things on a scientific approach, that's fine. Can't move a 1 ton rock with one hand. Or change someone's mind once it's been set in stone. This going back & forth crap is going nowhere, so maybe just agree to disagree, which won't happen & will bring a retort from SOMEONE?
The MRI thing was half in jest, but got me thinking that it could prove a point. Then I saw the "Tonerite". Vibrates on only one frequency, but seemed to be a noticeable difference. Paying $150 to get something done faster that's only going to happen anyway is a choice, maybe one for a store to use. I don't need it. No.
If it's a matter of all settling, most builders use wood that's been aging for 20 yrs.+, reaching a point of stability. That's the body wood I'm referring to, the top being the real "meat" of this vibration, breaking-in topic. Things change over time, & not always for the reasons some choose to accept! :?
Jeff :guitar
Totally right, Jeff. Violinist and violin luthiers have never had a problem acknowledging this "opening up"process. Dunno if I'd go so far as use a machine or blast my Larri with high volume stereo sound. I'm happy just let it happen naturally and be delighted when I suddenly hear something new coming out of her or see the visual character of her soundboard develop as it darkens. Like life, it unfolds as you go along (for better and for worse) and you arrive at peace of mind faster when/if you can accept the process. All the best, Lee.
:thumbsup :thumbsup
The topic of breaking in time or effects of vibration on wood will not be settled any time soon. You can read all kinds of varying opinions AND scientific results. If you're really intersted, to where you'd want to take the time to read book, this might be a good one.
http://books.google.com/books?id=z4bIWmwoxQkC&pg=PA199&lpg=PA199&dq=effect+of+vibration+on+wood&source=bl&ots=QBNlnrnwJL&sig=-B1MVCTTELxf2-w3pLG-iC3T0pI&hl=en&ei=kBKCSuPCGZaltgeOifTEDw&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=5#v=onepage&q=&f=false
As I skimmed quickly over it, it does seem to point to a change in wood due to vibrations but acknowledges that not a lot of test have been done and some have caveats to them.
There do seem to be a couple of well conducted tests that indicate change due to vibration. One speaks of getting louder then settling back down to a level higher than original level. Another
shows resonent frequencies changing after applied vibrations. So one freq may increase in sound, resonance, whatever you want to call it, but another may drop off. So on and on it will go.
There's no studies or opinions that can't be bucked by another study or opinion. That's what makes it fun. I'd suggest no one, including myself, close thier minds to either side of argument.
And keep some Kleenex handy :guitar
"While my guitar gently sneezes" :whistling:
Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 10, 2009, 07:52:20 PM
Tops vibrate. Fact. Tops open-up with more vibration. Theory.
Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 11, 2009, 11:43:40 AM
There is scientific proof of the top being altered by playing more, the reason being vibrations changing the physical character of the wood, thus affecting the sound. Known fact, by all but those that refuse to accept it.
LOL, I must have missed a huge scientific discovery between 6:52:20 PM last night and 10:43:40 AM this morning.
You asked for my opinion and I gave it. I didn't say vibrations don't change the tonal properties of a guitar.
It seems I really pissed you off from reading some of your recent posts.
Flatlander, you're absolutely right. The discussion goes on and will go on about this, both on this forum and out-there-and-everywhere. But sometimes life has mysteries and personally, I like it that way. That my Larri has broadened her palette sonically is a fact. How it happened, I have no idea but I like it. The original question of when it will be perceptible is also unanswerable, I think, but THAT it happens - no - IS HAPPENING (ongoing process), I truely believe. And I like that too.
:bgrin: :bgrin:
Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 11, 2009, 11:03:15 PM
You asked for my opinion and I gave it. I didn't say vibrations don't change the tonal properties of a guitar.
It seems I really pissed you off from reading some of your recent posts.
Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 10, 2009, 04:14:52 PM
I don't see how vibrations from playing causes any permanent physical changes in the guitar.
Then there's the Frank Ford post which gave a very 1 sided view of effects of playing guitar. I can't afford a Philadelphia lawyer tp split hairs and nail down what the definition of "is" is. I can however say confidently that most people on here take the response and the quote as indicating that you don't believe that vibrations have an effect on physical/tonal properties of wood.
I couple things strike me as ironic in this thread.(and others) One thing is that you "come off" as having a very strong opinion yet you always leave wiggle room to technically leave your "percieved" opinion a way out from being firmly attached to what you really think.
Another is that this thread is in large part about "perception" and it certainly comes off to me and others I'm sure, as you are explaining that perception is the biggest factor in hearing the difference
in a guitar over varying amounts of time. This indicates an understanding of human nature. Yet some statements like "It seems I really pissed you off from reading some of your recent posts" seem to indicated you're surprised or don't understand why your statements caused that reaction. I doubt that though. You're smarter than that. I think it's more likely that this explains the effect.
Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 09, 2009, 11:50:24 AM
I think that's true and that concerns me more than if the idea is dismissive or not.
There's a way to bump "not being dismissive" up in the priority chain without losing the point of what you're saying.
Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 08, 2009, 08:10:04 PM
The conversations will be much more fruitful if you stick to the words on the page rather than pretend you know what I believe and why.
2 things. This indicates that you want conversations to be more fruitful yet you say something like this.
Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 11, 2009, 11:03:15 PM
LOL, I must have missed a huge scientific discovery between 6:52:20 PM last night and 10:43:40 AM this morning.
In conflict with previous statement and again ironic, as much of this is about human nature and perception. Most times that someone is sarcastic it throws up the others defenses and that becomes as much of a concern as actual topic. Thus the conversation is not as fruitful as far as original topic goes.
The other is that all I have to go on as far as understanding what you believe and why, is what you type. I'd suggest that a better understanding of human nature would lead you to have a better idea of how your statements are going to be percieved. That apparent lack of understanding undermines your argument of how peoples perceptions effect what they think they hear. It also leads
to your "suggested idea's" or innuendos as being taken as what you actually think. Since this subject is unprovable, and due to human nature leading many to believe that your stand is that vibrations have little or no effect on tone, it can easily be taken as you are claiming that someones opinion is not true, even though it's not provable and you've never heard the instrument.
Along the lines of what Lee said. I think if you either had a better understanding of human nature, or cared, your many valid points would be imparted to the masses more productively.
The question is, what is your goal. To actually share your knowledge or to always be right, or not being able to be proved wrong by the "outs" you leave.
I'm sure many will think this is silly and some will think it's off topic. But honestly we know that this is the real subject underlying the 2nd half of this thread.
What I spoke of has to do what how posts are actually percieved, not how they were technically written. So back to what the goals are to decide if that's a matter to think about or not.
Quote from: flatlander on August 12, 2009, 09:18:48 AM
Then there's the Frank Ford post which gave a very 1 sided view of effects of playing guitar. I can't afford a Philadelphia lawyer tp split hairs and nail down what the definition of "is" is. I can however say confidently that most people on here take the response and the quote as indicating that you don't believe that vibrations have an effect on physical/tonal properties of wood.
I couple things strike me as ironic in this thread.(and others) One thing is that you "come off" as having a very strong opinion yet you always leave wiggle room to technically leave your "percieved" opinion a way out from being firmly attached to what you really think.
The original statement was "I don't see how vibrations from playing causes any permanent physical changes in the guitar.", this of course after stating opening up doesn't matter much to me. That's not a very strong opinion. I was simply saying I don't see enough evidence to believe in the vibration theory. I don't have anything to wiggle out of.
QuoteIn conflict with previous statement and again ironic, as much of this is about human nature and perception. Most times that someone is sarcastic it throws up the others defenses and that becomes as much of a concern as actual topic. Thus the conversation is not as fruitful as far as original topic goes.
The other is that all I have to go on as far as understanding what you believe and why, is what you type. I'd suggest that a better understanding of human nature would lead you to have a better idea of how your statements are going to be percieved. That apparent lack of understanding undermines your argument of how peoples perceptions effect what they think they hear. It also leads
to your "suggested idea's" or innuendos as being taken as what you actually think. Since this subject is unprovable, and due to human nature leading many to believe that your stand is that vibrations have little or no effect on tone, it can easily be taken as you are claiming that someones opinion is not true, even though it's not provable and you've never heard the instrument.
Along the lines of what Lee said. I think if you either had a better understanding of human nature, or cared, your many valid points would be imparted to the masses more productively.
My post was effective. You agreed with the point I made that breaking in can be in some people's heads. It was the points I didn't make that you disagreed with. A better understanding of how that post would be perceived would not have led me to clarify that opening up can be real. It's not relevant to the point I made. If someone wishes for me to clarify something I probably will.
Jeremy, firstly I can't see how Flatlander can disagree with points you "didn't make" unless ESP is one of his attributes. And then, vibrations DO effect the molecular structure of all substances - metal fatigue is the easiest example to understand. Vibrations can shatter glass and at certain frequencies and intensities affect the integrity of concrete. So how can we be so sure that the guitar string vibes don't effect the molecular structures of the wood? And the glue? And we know it causes molecular changes in the strings. You might not choose to acknowledge this. And finally, I really do think this thread has degenerated into a matter of incensed pride and has ceased to be of much use. A young friend of mine has on her business card "The mind is like a parachute - it only works when it is open". Lee.
:cop: It is time to close this thread. :cop:
and then go play the snot out of your guit :bgrin:
Quote from: jeremy3220 on August 12, 2009, 11:21:58 AM
The original statement was "I don't see how vibrations from playing causes any permanent physical changes in the guitar.", this of course after stating opening up doesn't matter much to me. That's not a very strong opinion. I was simply saying I don't see enough evidence to believe in the vibration theory. I don't have anything to wiggle out of.
My post was effective. You agreed with the point I made that breaking in can be in some people's heads. It was the points I didn't make that you disagreed with. A better understanding of how that post would be perceived would not have led me to clarify that opening up can be real. It's not relevant to the point I made. If someone wishes for me to clarify something I probably will.
Jeremy, you have beyond a shadow of a doubt defended your position with fortitude and scientific facts. You are obviously a very deep thinker and would make a great lawyer.
And for my part at attempting to turn this from a heavy mental engagement I admit failure. I also apologize for anything perceived as a snipe. At times that is what I was doing.
You are a real asset to us here. Have a donut and let's just move on. At this point I know I don't care anymore about the issue of vibrations opening up a guitar. I do care about the folks on the forum, which certainly includes you. :donut
Jeremy, I'm not pissed, just frustrated. Like I said, feel like I'm just butting heads with you, thus the agree to disagree comment. Should suffice? All of these builders, players, etc., talking about their guitars opening up. Hell, the woods been stable for a long time, like I said also, so what needs to settle. The glue joints? The bracing? You have your opinion, many of us disagree & have ours. That's just the way the world turns. Some won't ever change their minds about ANYTHING, so like I said & others, you have your opinion, I mine, others their's. It won't get farther than that unless the brickwall falls down, and that I doubt.
flatlander, I agree about the sarcasm. But, he wasn't sarcastic until after my post & if it was the other way around, I'd get my balls ripped off (sorry, but true). What you say is true, as one says, "the dude resides", & I'll dig & dig until I can throw something on here that will be definitive! It does seem like it just comes to "I'm right, you're not, so what's your problem"? I thought I saw you @ a town meeting betweens those times you listed,Jeremy. Was that you? :humour: But, it is an issue that many disagree on, but more the way that it is true. The top vibrates, the molecular structure of the top changes over time due to this, & things happen that improve the sound. Let's try & stop arguing with Jeremy, he has his opinion,& we should respect that. Even if he's wrong! :humour: Jeremy, only kidding, so let's let the arguing rest?
Jeff :guitar
"I'll be back"!!!! And like Dan said, have a doughnut, but I say not too much coffee! :donut :donut2
Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 12, 2009, 08:23:05 PM
Hell, the woods been stable for a long time, like I said also, so what needs to settle. The glue joints? The bracing?
What I'm talking about is unrelated to the wood's age. I'm talking about the wood settling into a certain shape. The longer the wood is in that shape the less tension there will be. So if you have a radiused top matched to a flat rim, there will be a lot of tension from trying to force the wood into that shape.
Quote from: BluesMan1 on August 12, 2009, 08:23:05 PM
Jeremy, only kidding, so let's let the arguing rest?
Sounds good.
Here's just a statement, which isn't meant to provoke a response, that I got from my grand luthier, George Youngblood. He said:
"The first year is a period of settling in, breaking in, opening up, whatever you want to call it. Next three the guitar is still in it's infancy, so things are still happening to ALL of the woods, not just the top. As the guitar starts to age, the molecules of the resin, to break it down simply, start to "crystallize", changing in structure & affecting the tone. The shape of the braces (he had an open top with bracing sitting there to show me) direct the sound to all parts of the inside of the guitar, the result being the sound coming out. He said that this was why new Gibsons, for example, though made the same as a vintage one, don't sound the same & don't draw the money of an older one (ex.:new J-45-$2200, '30 or '40 something, (can't remember the exact year) he just had, $7500). Compared the tone to a new violin that someone played in the front row of a philharmonic to that of an older one, the point being you would want the older one for tonal improvement (and volume)". Agreed that it was a point that all had their own view on, this being his.
Puts things into perspective, as his point being that there were changes, but how they are perceived, are a subjective one. So, I guess we're all right in some way?
And Rob, should I quote the great philosopher, Rodney King again? Nah, been there, done that, all's cool? And Jeremy, I never have not respected your opinions or views, just don't agree all of the time. As you with me & others. Let's just leave it at things happen over the years, & I think we can all agree to that? :thumb
Jeff :guitar
And, I'm not trying to get the last word in. Went to get some bone pins & a Buffalo horn pick for my electrics (WOW, you should hear the difference!), stopped him mid-repair to ask about this.
I haven't read this entire thread, and something tells me that may be a good thing. :bgrin:
I'd like to attempt to answer the Original Poster's question:
QuoteWhen you say the above phrase (playing the snot out of your guitar), or see it written somewhere, what is your interpretation of (ballpark) how many hours the poster/person is talking about.
I believe I played the snot out of my guitar last week. I played four 3-hour shows in three days.
What's more, durnig show #2 of the above mentioned four shows, I sneezed in the middle of a song. It caught me completely by surprise and I had no time to turn my head. A respectible amount of snot landed right on my guitar top. I inwardly rolled my eyes, and played on. Here's the interesting part: By the end of the song, there was no trace of snot left!
So, not only have I played the snot
out of my guitar, I have also played the snot
off of my guitar. :guitar
Cheers,
David
Hi Dave, that was a great story. :bgrin: :bgrin: :bgrin: :roll
Quote from: Big E on August 14, 2009, 08:56:37 PM
Hi Dave, that was a great story. :bgrin: :bgrin: :bgrin: :roll
Oh, Come on! That's snot funny. :roll
DAVE
Quote from: dberch on August 14, 2009, 11:34:23 AM
I haven't read this entire thread, and something tells me that may be a good thing. :bgrin:
I'd like to attempt to answer the Original Poster's question: I believe I played the snot out of my guitar last week. I played four 3-hour shows in three days.
What's more, durnig show #2 of the above mentioned four shows, I sneezed in the middle of a song. It caught me completely by surprise and I had no time to turn my head. A respectible amount of snot landed right on my guitar top. I inwardly rolled my eyes, and played on. Here's the interesting part: By the end of the song, there was no trace of snot left!
So, not only have I played the snot out of my guitar, I have also played the snot off of my guitar. :guitar
Cheers,
David
Do you have scientific evidence to support this empirical evidence which is after all only one man's experience and has not been analyzed by the experts. :tongue:
Definitions:
expert= an old drip under pressure :blush:
play the snot out of your guitar= see the :roll post above by dberch
dberch, hats off to you for the comic relief.