Main Forums => Larrivée Guitars => Topic started by: count savage on November 28, 2008, 12:53:08 PM

Title: The Difference in Sound Between The D and L series?
Post by: count savage on November 28, 2008, 12:53:08 PM
Alright, I'll admit it. The vets here have got me thinkin'.  I'm wondering what those of you who have played many Larrivees would say about the aural difference between a D series and an L series.  They feel differently, obviously, due to the different shapes and size.  I realize a lot depends on wood, strings, set-up, etc., but what do you think the essential sonic differences are between the two guitars? For example, is the L style guitar warmer sounding or less so, as a rule? More jangly, resonant or less? Or about the same? I have picked up that the L series is the definitive Larrivee 'sound.' Doe that mean the D series is not?  Or is it less about aural differences than playing differences?  A wider neck, nut, etc.? 
Title: Re: The Difference in Sound Between The D and L series?
Post by: cc407 on November 28, 2008, 01:51:47 PM
Real simple in my experience: The D sounds like a dreadnaught. The L does not.
Title: Re: The Difference in Sound Between The D and L series?
Post by: bluesman67 on November 28, 2008, 02:05:26 PM
The differences can definitely be heard and felt between the 2.  As mentioned, the nut width is immediately noticeable for most, as is the size difference when sitting and playing.  As for tone, given that both would be the same tonewoods, there are notable differences.  There's slightly more low end boom that comes from the dread and a touch more volume...but probably not noticeable like the boom factor is.  These differences certainly aren't dramatic, just differences.  Aside from these differences, the overall tone between the 2 is very similar.
Title: Re: The Difference in Sound Between The D and L series?
Post by: magictwanger on November 28, 2008, 04:52:28 PM
This is interesting,because about two months ago I bought a "gorgeous sounding" D-03R.....I had been playing/trying out quite a few different guitars at two different guitar stores,but was unsure where I'd actually "go" in a choice.

  I've come back to guitar,after a long layoff,and this time around I really am committed,and have the time to do it right.Whew!!

  Ok,so after following this "superb" forum,and really appreciating the good naturedness, and helpfulness of SO many of "you" I began to migrate to "wanting to go" for a Larrivee.

  I took a LONG lunch break(luckily I'm the boss-:)and played around with about six different Larry's....But,my original intention was to go for either a D-05,or an L-03R.Until I started to play them all,along with a few others....Obviously I was most impressed with the D-03R,which happened to be absolutely fabulous sounding/feeling.It really had a wonderfully dynamic and punchy sound,coupled with a gorgeous tonal balance.It was also absolutely pristine,and I knew the price was right.

  The Hogs were also very nice,in a different way,and I loved them.I'll go for one very soon,but I was a little disappointed by the L-03R.This was really the guitar I wanted to love,but it had almost no bass,and sounded almost dead in comparison to the D-03R.Even the higher registers seemed a bit constricted in comparison.It was the weakest of the lot,in what I was looking for,and I MUST assume it will get alot better with some play,because I've just heard too many good things about the "L".....I believe all of the folks who feel it is great,and state it needs time to open up.

  In my case I've tried to verify my luck with "this particular" D-03R that I've bought, and have played quite a few instruments lately,from other sources.Some from different manufacturers,and alot more money.I was even going to splurge on a particular "high roller" Dred,but after playing "it" my Larry just was not bettered.

   It really holds up well,and I think I was just lucky!....Who knew?

  Best to all

  I hope the lucky trend continues for me,because I'm about to finalize my small collection with a couple of new additions,which will all be a bit different in wood choice and body size.
Title: Re: The Difference in Sound Between The D and L series?
Post by: Daysailer on November 28, 2008, 09:40:46 PM
There are some very well done sound clips listed as the second topic in this section of the forum.
I went crosseyed listening to them to answer the same question you pose.
It has fingerpicking and struming sections that you can easily A_B test via this forum.
Of course there is no real substitute for actually playing them and haviing them played live for you.

My $.02........ the D is Boomier or more full sounding than the L, depending how YOU hear it.
....................The L is more balanced and focused. and less muddy than the D, generally how  I hear it.

Try the link above and also the search function of this forum.  You will find enough to read to fill the rest of this long weekend    :nana_guitar

After you figure out which body type you like,  THEN you get  to decide on wood choices...... :?
Again there are almost endless threads to research through....

In the end it  will  be what your ears, fingers, and musical soul love, not what the rest of us try to convice you to like.

have fun ...
ds    :beer
Title: Re: The Difference in Sound Between The D and L series?
Post by: Danny on November 28, 2008, 10:24:42 PM
   You will get answers from every angle if the members respond.
I've said a lot already, so I will just tell you my experience. I bought my 1st Larrivee used, a LV-03R. 6 years old and barley even strummed. My ear was "tuned" to the Larrivee build/tone; with that satin, rosewood, bearclaw sitka, easy playin git.
   As with all my gits I leave them out for friends and family to play, unless humidity is a problem. I believe guitars are to be played, not just stared at and never touched. Without human hands making it reveal what it was designed for it is firewood. BUT, a friend bumped the LV-03R putting it back on it's stand and it left a dimple on the top. I knew I could not leave a satin git out for folks to play at that moment.
    So enter the D-09E, gloss top, thicker finish, less issues from small bumps etc. Also less sustain and less overall something special that I know only to describe as the Larrivee sound. That was a 2000 model and had been played a lot. The nut and saddle were cut down to the point the strings were a paper width above the top. So let's just say it should have been "open". I replaced the saddle and nut (and had to refinish the headstock :angry:) Then I started playing it a lot. Honeymoon did not last long. My shoulder gave me more trouble with the dread than the L, but also the tone was nothing close to my other dreds, just my experience. So I tried other Larri dreds at music stores, same  deal for me. I have never tried the SD though and would like to.
     I asked my friend to sell the LV-03R back to me, several times, no way. So to some up I sold him the D-09E also and I eventually found THE Larrivee for me (after two parlours) The "L"SV-11. If you are really wired from too much coffee some night I wrote a book on my first one, just do a search here in the forum under Larrivee guitars and you will find my old threads. I guess that L was my favorite guitar ever, except for my very fond memories of my Gibson square shoulder dread that I had in the early 70's. It was my first really good guitar. But actually it was no where near the LSV in quality and tonewoods.
      Let's see...what are we talking about....oh yea. L vs. D ? I vote for the "L"       Danny
Title: Re: The Difference in Sound Between The D and L series?
Post by: leftync on November 29, 2008, 12:45:49 AM
Don't bail on the L. For months, I've owned an L and a D. I've got a thread I started tonight about a Eureka moment I had today about my L.
Here's the shorter version: I love my D-03R. I love dreads and the D-03R is among the best I've heard, certainly it's far and away the best deal. I bought an L-03RE because I'm getting old and decrepit and favor the L ergonomics. But I was disappointed when comparing it to my dread. My intention in buying the L was to sell the D, and I couldn't.
Today I replaced the stock pins and saddle with bone from Bob Colosi, and changed the original coated strings for a set of Martin Bluegrass. Nothing special, but nice strings. Mediums. I use mediums on both my Larrivees.
Count, Twanger--listen to me. The L sounds so much better with these improvements. I didn't make the change earlier because I was lazy and didn't get around to sending Colosi the saddle to copy, etc. And I had my D-03R, which I love to play.
I still love it. But now I also love the L and I see what everyone's talking about. What a terrific-sounding, comfortable guitar, when it's right. It's not a dread, but it's a pretty big sound. And I understand now what they mean by balance.
Again, you can't go wrong with the Larrivee D-03R. I think Jean's original design, the L, gets so much attention that people don't credit Larrivee with making a dread that compares favorably with dreads costing two and three times as much. I can't think of a Martin dread short of a D-28 Marquis that equals my D-03R. That's not a rap on Martin, a company I greatly admire. I think my D-03R sounds as good as Collings or Santa Cruz or Bourgeois.  If I were younger, it would be my main guitar, probably my only one.I may start to favor the L, and I may sell the D, primarily for the ergonomics, but I wouldn't do it if I weren't happy with the sound of the L. These improvements made me happy with it. Maybe the string, nut and saddle differences are more pronounced on a smaller guitar. But don't judge an L with coated strings and plastic. It really can sound so much better.
Title: Re: The Difference in Sound Between The D and L series?
Post by: magictwanger on November 29, 2008, 01:49:12 AM
Leftync,I have NO doubt as to the credibility of your comments!!....In my case,at the time,I was going for "one" git so basicall made my choice from what was presented to me from about six different stock Larrivees,of varying types.
   Let's face it,one does not go wrong often with Larrivee products.Even the little Parlor Hog floored me that day.I've been scoping other potential guitars to complete the total of 4,which seems right for "me".Two small body types(Madi and Hog) and one more Dred(Braz)....Then,that's it!!'Cause I'll be in the poor house-:)

  Yet, in total honesty(remember this is only my opinion)I really think that the vast majority of pricier instruments are only marginally better than a good Larri.

  Warmest regards
Title: Re: The Difference in Sound Between The D and L series?
Post by: R Mellow on November 30, 2008, 05:46:28 AM
In the store i was initially struck by the sheer warm, toneful, meaty chug of the D-03R. But after a couple of hours back and forth with the L-03R, the incredible sweetness and balance of the L did it for me. I wanted a guitar that could help me expand my style, to become good at fingerpicking not just strumming and flatpicking, so although i knew i could belt it out to my heart's content on the D, I just knew that the L contained a whole hidden garden of delights waiting to be explored. And I haven't had a dull moment or moment of regret since. Of course, when i am able, I'll be looking for a dread too, but maybe I'll go hog for the extra contrast, but who knows?
I would say do like me. Go for the perfect all rounder, the L, get a bit good, save up and become a good enough player to justify to yourself your growing collection and go for the D. After that you can even get another one or take up the Bulgarian nose flute.
Title: Re: The Difference in Sound Between The D and L series?
Post by: teh on November 30, 2008, 10:29:07 AM
Ditto on the L Body Size because it has proven to be completely versatile for my 12 string needs.

P.S. I left my Parlor with my son last week and he is holding it hostage. (of all my guitars, it's his favorite). He likes it even better than my Martin D or OM.
Title: Re: The Difference in Sound Between The D and L series?
Post by: limnephilidae on November 30, 2008, 11:39:41 AM
Quote from: Lawn Jockey on November 28, 2008, 06:23:28 PM
To be totally safe you should have both.

It's better to have it and not need it than it is to need it and not have it.

(http://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/smilies/knitting.gif)

I like that logic. There are times that no guitar in the herd but my D-60 MR would satisfy my need aural needs. Yet it's nice to have the warmth of a cedar close by too when the urge arises. :)
Title: Re: The Difference in Sound Between The D and L series?
Post by: willguitar on November 30, 2008, 11:42:42 AM
I own several Larrivee l L's (various tone and soundboard woods) and a D-05. I play them and appreciate them equally. The D-05 holds it's own. See what "nut size" fits you best. If you can, try them first (make sure the strings are reasonably fresh and in-tune). If you can't, pick one (or more) and enjoy it (them). There's nothing to fear. ;-)