Main Forums => Larrivée Guitars => Topic started by: jwb on June 25, 2008, 02:03:19 PM

Title: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: jwb on June 25, 2008, 02:03:19 PM
I was thinking about a recent post that led to the discussion of Larrivee's use of thick braces.  I've often wondered why the braces are so "robust" on their guitars, and it occurred to me that there may be some added benefit to this....

I have owned and played many Larrivees, some over 20 years old and well used and I have never seen one with a bulging top under the bridge, or a collapsing top approaching the neck join.  This is a frequent problem with Gibsons and Martins and other well-known names we grew up with.  How about a fresh neck set?  I haven't seen a Larrivee need it from age.  Those braces make the top very sturdy....it does give up some on the sound, but it may be a worth while trade off in another 10-20 years when the guitar is still going strong.  I am no expert on this (I feel fortunate I can change my own strings, folks) but it makes sense given the present condition of Jean's guitars made back in the 70s and 80s.

I seem to recall from his "I Make Guitars" video that he said his instruments are made to last a century or more.  Those clunky braces may have something to do with that claim.  What does everybody think?

Cheers,

Justin
Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: JasonA on June 25, 2008, 02:20:31 PM
I had a conversation with a high end luthier about bracing once. He mentioned that a lot of less experienced builders will brace too lightly because it gives them an immediate gratification, but he questioned the longevity of a guitar like that.

On the other side, I remember the big flap years ago on another forum by an opinionated store owner who called Collings heavy living-room furniture guitars. Perhaps not surprisingly that dealer was a big pusher of Santa Cruz.

If the guitar lasts forever and you don't like the sound you are getting, that's one thing. But given that I like the tone of a lot of Larrivee guitars, and Collings guitars even moreso, longevity is only a plus in my book.
Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: jeremy3220 on June 25, 2008, 07:09:32 PM
QuoteThis is a frequent problem with Gibsons and Martins and other well-known names we grew up with.

:? It is? how frequent? I never here about this on the Martin forum. A neck reset every 20 years is an insignificant price to pay for a better sounding guitar. It would be a benefit if there actually was a problem with these other makers but I haven't seen any collapsing Martins lately. I did however play a 74 year old Gibson recently that was the lightest guitar I've ever held and it had buldging behind the bridge, which made for an awful guitar if you hate easy playability and amazing tone. Personally I don't think the problem Larrivee has fixed actually exist.

"The importance of longitudinal bracing is central to the success of the guitar because the guitar is basically an air pump, and in lutherie we need to concern ourselves with how efficiently the guitar can pump air. All other considerations, such as choice of woods and how pretty they are, must be subordinated to this if you want to make a successful guitar...

...A second way of getting a reading as to how freely the guitar is able to pump air is in the sound of the tap tone you just delivered, if you did this exercise. Again, this is very subjective, but still a very useful comparative way to get some sense, some keying in as to what is going on. If the guitar top is tight, stiff, overbuilt, heavy past certain limits (which most commercial guitars are), it'll sound somewhat like a table top — high, tight, and solid. If the guitar top is free to move, the pitch of the tap tone will go down and the sound emitted will be markedly more open. Obviously there are limits in making soundboards light past which you shouldn't go because you'll destroy the integrity of the guitar, but most guitars are so overbuilt that I don't think you have to be afraid of going in this direction." ~ Ervin Somogyi

Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: jeremy3220 on June 25, 2008, 07:24:42 PM
Quote from: JasonA on June 25, 2008, 02:20:31 PM
I had a conversation with a high end luthier about bracing once. He mentioned that a lot of less experienced builders will brace too lightly because it gives them an immediate gratification, but he questioned the longevity of a guitar like that.


The consensus on the OLF it seems to me is that new builders tend to overbuild.
Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: JasonA on June 25, 2008, 09:01:19 PM
It could be that I haven't noticed overbuilt guitars from new luthiers because their guitars sounded so dead I didn't take time to look at the bracing.  :tongue:

But, in the end I want both tone and a stable guitar. If it sounds good and its solid, I'm not going to criticize the builder's choice of bracing techniques because it apparently worked for them.
Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: dermot on June 25, 2008, 09:17:47 PM
Where's Scott Van Linge  when you need him?

d.
Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: Mikeymac on June 25, 2008, 11:01:55 PM
I hope my comment won't head this thread in the wrong direction (like a previously demised thread..), but really, this is like the arguments over rosewood vs. maple for fingerboards or humbuckers versus single coils - or to stay in the acoustic realm, cutaway versus non-cutaway...it's getting silly.  If the guitar sounds good, is expressive, is built with quality materials, is easy to play, and intonates properly - IT IS GOOD - so what's the problem?

I've never felt that Larrivee's had any flaws in their design (except for the change in cosmetics a few years back when they dropped the classical style rosette and started looking more like everyone else's, but that's personal preference from an "old Larrivee fart"!).  They sound great and play great; they compete incredibly well all across the acoustic guitar market against other brands!  If they didn't, Jean would not have opened a new factory in CA a few years ago.  I happened to exchange a few personal e-mails with someone in the Larrivee family a few weeks ago, and it sounds like they're still so busy, they'll never run out of things to do. 

Sounds like the sign of a successful company to me...  :thumbsup
Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: ducktrapper on June 26, 2008, 07:11:48 AM
Quote from: Mikeymac on June 25, 2008, 11:01:55 PM
I hope my comment won't head this thread in the wrong direction (like a previously demised thread..), but really, this is like the arguments over rosewood vs. maple for fingerboards or humbuckers versus single coils - or to stay in the acoustic realm, cutaway versus non-cutaway...it's getting silly.  If the guitar sounds good, is expressive, is built with quality materials, is easy to play, and intonates properly - IT IS GOOD - so what's the problem?

I've never felt that Larrivee's had any flaws in their design (except for the change in cosmetics a few years back when they dropped the classical style rosette and started looking more like everyone else's, but that's personal preference from an "old Larrivee fart"!).  They sound great and play great; they compete incredibly well all across the acoustic guitar market against other brands!  If they didn't, Jean would not have opened a new factory in CA a few years ago.  I happened to exchange a few personal e-mails with someone in the Larrivee family a few weeks ago, and it sounds like they're still so busy, they'll never run out of things to do. 

Sounds like the sign of a successful company to me...  :thumbsup

Jeremy really likes Larrivées but must continually remind us that they are overbuilt and really not "all that". Other than the fact that almost every other guitar is better, they're okay though. Right Jeremy?  :wink:   
Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: jeremy3220 on June 26, 2008, 11:11:36 AM
Quote from: ducktrapper on June 26, 2008, 07:11:48 AM
Jeremy really likes Larrivées but must continually remind us that they are overbuilt and really not "all that". Other than the fact that almost every other guitar is better, they're okay though. Right Jeremy?  :wink:   

yeah sure
Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: John R on June 26, 2008, 06:34:33 PM
Mikeymac  :+1: to your comments. John
Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: jwb on June 26, 2008, 07:33:51 PM
Just for a heads up, I was by no means trying to throw my Larrivees "under the bus".  I love the sound, love the product and I can't complain.  I have only 4 guitars, all Larrivees....I sold my Bourgeois, my Gibson Dove, my Guild...and on and on.  I do have a new custom coming, but otherwise I guess I like 'em overbuilt  :arrow....

Mickeymac,

I'm with you buddy.  It sounds good, so who cares what's going on under the hood?  Larrivee is run well like a good corporation should be.  If they were publicly traded, I would  own some of it!  :thumbsup

Justin
Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: Danny on June 26, 2008, 11:57:24 PM
 :yawn  Sometimes I wonder if we are even talking about guitars. :wacko:  I don't give a rat's ...whatever about the logo on the headstock, the braces under neath or the opinions of others anymore. I know what I like and It happens to be made by Larrivee
         I'm thinking of buying a OM-21 (Martin) next week. I own a Gibson and others that I like. I like ALL the different bracing. Ladder, Fan, X, Forward X or whatever it's called.
         I may even like a wash tub with a string tied to it, But I don't care much for fighting about it all. Danny
Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: PastorChuck on June 27, 2008, 12:50:55 AM
Do these count?

(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v717/pastorchuck/braces2.jpg)
Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: prof_stack on June 27, 2008, 01:52:02 AM
OMG, PastorChuck

You certainly gummed   up this thread!   :roll
Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: tuffythepug on June 27, 2008, 11:31:25 AM
Quote from: PastorChuck on June 27, 2008, 12:50:55 AM
Do these count?

(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v717/pastorchuck/braces2.jpg)

Thanks PastorChuck,  That's just what I wanted to see with my morning coffee. :yak:
Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: limnephilidae on June 27, 2008, 06:26:08 PM
Quote from: jeremy3220 on June 25, 2008, 07:09:32 PM
"The importance of longitudinal bracing is central to the success of the guitar because the guitar is basically an air pump, and in lutherie we need to concern ourselves with how efficiently the guitar can pump air. All other considerations, such as choice of woods and how pretty they are, must be subordinated to this if you want to make a successful guitar...

...A second way of getting a reading as to how freely the guitar is able to pump air is in the sound of the tap tone you just delivered, if you did this exercise. Again, this is very subjective, but still a very useful comparative way to get some sense, some keying in as to what is going on. If the guitar top is tight, stiff, overbuilt, heavy past certain limits (which most commercial guitars are), it'll sound somewhat like a table top — high, tight, and solid. If the guitar top is free to move, the pitch of the tap tone will go down and the sound emitted will be markedly more open. Obviously there are limits in making soundboards light past which you shouldn't go because you'll destroy the integrity of the guitar, but most guitars are so overbuilt that I don't think you have to be afraid of going in this direction." ~ Ervin Somogyi

Jeremy, as an engineer I find the side discussion very interesting. While I'm totally happy with the sound of my Larrivees, over-braced or otherwise. I would like to read more on the subject of guitar building. You seem to have strong opinions on this subject. Do you have a source/link for the quote above? Any other sources that you would like to share?

:cop:  !Thread tangent alert!  :cop:

Most engineering knowledge has converted skilled building that people colloquially refer to as "an art" into a structured discourse. The best part is that once an "art form" is turned into a series of well-understood designs, the implementation is almost always complex enough to make it an "art form" on its own. The net result is that complex problems with subjective outcomes offer the most interesting and innovative solutions that humans can provide.

In the case of guitars, the knowledge is frequently learned through apprenticeship rather than centralized teaching (like mechanical engineering for example). This method of tackling complex problems usually results in small improvements in one design/solution over a period of time. In these situations, you almost get a set of solution species, each with a definite history and separate set of advantages and disadvantages. In a way, you have a changing landscape of musical instrument requirements mixed with a diverse set of luthiers solving problems in their own way. Sometimes things don't change because certain aspects of that design are successful but not optimal (ie economical design but sub-optimal sound quality), so certain designs stagnate until the environment changes. It's really interesting to chart out how the design evolves over a period of time.

:coffee :donut :donut2
Title: Re: So you got thick braces, eh?
Post by: jeremy3220 on June 27, 2008, 09:34:41 PM
Quote from: limnephilidae on June 27, 2008, 06:26:08 PM
Jeremy, as an engineer I find the side discussion very interesting. While I'm totally happy with the sound of my Larrivees, over-braced or otherwise. I would like to read more on the subject of guitar building. You seem to have strong opinions on this subject. Do you have a source/link for the quote above? Any other sources that you would like to share?


http://www.esomogyi.com/articles.html
It's the third article down. If you don't know who Somogyi is, his guitars sell for about $25K.

"Ideally, I would test a lot of wood and throw away all but the stiffest tops and all but the stiffest braces. This way I would have the lightest possible top at a given point of flexibility, which would give me the most responsive possible guitar."  ~ Dana Bourgeois
http://www.pantheonguitars.com/voicing.htm
He has a few other articles on that site as well.