Main Forums => Larrivée Guitars => Topic started by: MJG on June 24, 2008, 08:41:05 PM

Title: L-05 vs Gibson J-45
Post by: MJG on June 24, 2008, 08:41:05 PM
Has anyone ever compared these models?  If so, what are the differences in tone and voice?

I see a lot of similarities, i.e., Mahogany/Sitka, round shoulders, close size and depth.

I will probably see what the Gibson forum has to say as well - should be interesting.

Thanks,
Mike
Title: Re: L-05 vs Gibson J-45
Post by: es-335 on June 24, 2008, 08:49:22 PM
I'd say they are totally different..

I recently compared them at Long and Mcquade..

and bought a J45.. and Love it....

L-05 was good but not the right sound for me..

I guess i was looking for more of gibson sound.... lol

L-05 is indeed a good guitar..

But J45 has that sound no guitar can produce...


Title: Re: L-05 vs Gibson J-45
Post by: russski1 on June 24, 2008, 08:55:01 PM
Mike -

Did a lot of comparison shopping before buying my Larrivee....  Most of the Gibsons I played sounded kinda dead..  There was a time - pre-70's when either Gibson or Martin were the ones to own... But then came challengers...  They brought new sound, newer features, and sometimes less price....  Some of the early non-standard acoustics were not too good.  But the new generation guitars are often better since they are paying attention to details and building features while the standards had let some quality go.

So I am thrilled with my Larri...  Sounds powerful, open, deep and clear....  

I am sure the Gibson forum would have a different view - Which I understand!

Title: Re: L-05 vs Gibson J-45
Post by: Dotneck on June 24, 2008, 11:57:29 PM
They just sound different....I like L-05s and may still get one if the right deal comes along...but when I was looking for slope dread I preferred J-45s. Good Gibsons just have some kinda honk.....so I was leaning towards a J-45....then came across an Advanced Jumbo that made me take her home after banging out a few cowboy chords...

I guess you just have to listen to them and see what you like.

A while ago I was playing with a guy who has an older J-45 and I had my forum OM....playing in open G and we were working on slide. My OM almost sounded too pretty for blues compared to his 45...of course he had the mad skilz...

But I still think fondly about the L-05 with the joker headstock that I passed up about five years ago...and wish I hadn't let it get away.

Also remember the L-05 will have 1.75 nut...the Gibson nut is narrower...
Title: Re: L-05 vs Gibson J-45
Post by: markyboy on June 25, 2008, 04:01:19 PM
I just posted a thread how much I like the sound, feel of the Gibson sj200 I played recently. Especially the neck I thought felt very comfy.
But I have an l-05 that I bought almost a year ago. At the time I wasn't considering Gibson, only Taylor & Martin. If I was looking at Gibson, maybe the choice would have been harder. I still think the L-05 would have won out as it was slightly more affordable.

Good luck.
Title: Re: L-05 vs Gibson J-45
Post by: bamacrazy on June 25, 2008, 04:40:21 PM
I found that the sound/tone/projection of J45s vary greatly from guitar to guitar. A good one is beyond compare. Guitar for guitar Larrivee would win 6 out of every 10, but those 4 Gibson wins would be blowouts!
Title: Re: L-05 vs Gibson J-45
Post by: Danny on June 26, 2008, 12:19:18 AM
                 J-45s are fine but they are not all the same. L-05s will have a higher rate of consistency from one guitar to the next. As far as a competition between them I don't see any. JCL is not trying to make J-45s and from what he said a few days ago he's not interested in doing it in the future.
                 If you want a J-45 be sure you play it...a lot before you buy it, to be sure you aren't just buying a "LABEL".