Main Forums => Larrivée Guitars => Topic started by: Johnny Canso on June 16, 2008, 08:37:27 PM

Title: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: Johnny Canso on June 16, 2008, 08:37:27 PM
I picked up a satin version of the Larrivee D-60 a couple of months ago & i must say i really dig this guitar!!!  I had a satin finish Martin D-16RGT that i polished to a gloss finish & regretted it...it looked beautiful, but to me, there's somethin about the satin finish that i missed, maybe the ruggedness of it. I have since sold the Martin after the D-40 showed up & have never looked back!!!!    Here's a  :cheers to satin finish Larrivee's.
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: Mr_LV19E on June 16, 2008, 09:01:27 PM
I like them both. I go back and forth as to whether I would have preferred leaving my OM-MT satin, I like the looks of it gloss but miss the feel of the satin finish.

:coffee :donut2 :donut
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: jeremy3220 on June 16, 2008, 10:45:26 PM
I think I prefer satin on the mahogany top guitars. I think of both the satin finish and mahogany top as what you said 'rugged', so they go together in a way.
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: teh on June 16, 2008, 11:55:03 PM
Both of my Larrivee's have a satin finish and I like the simple clean look workmanship and the llines that both of them have. I had the opportunity to pick up an 05 series guitar in both instances but opted for the 03 instead. The 3 series are easy to wipe down but I suspect that they will start to show wear a little more quickly over time. Maybe someone with an older 03 can offer an opinion based on experience.

Both of my Martins are high gloss and I have a supply of cotton diapers that I use for polishing clothes. Over the years, my arm has done a number on the top of the D-35 and it has clouded up a little.

FWIW, Jim @ Trinity Guitars has a used OM-05MT scheduled to appear on his site for a really good price so I guess it won't last long. If I didn't already have an OM, this would have caught my interest.
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: ducktrapper on June 17, 2008, 07:38:53 AM
Yes but I also prefer gloss to satin, as well. Confusing? Not actually, I have both. 
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: lw216316 on June 17, 2008, 08:40:15 AM
My L-03R is satin and the SD-50 is gloss. I prefer the satin. I like the natural look better.
George Harrison and John Lennon scraped the gloss off guitars - see my post with pictures
http://www.larriveeforum.com/smf/index.php?topic=21895.msg192299#msg192299

George said,
"John and I scraped the varnish off our Epiphone Casinos, and they became much better guitars.
I think that works on a lot of guitars. If you take the paint and varnish off, and get the bare wood it seems to sort of breathe"

- Larry




Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: joethedestroyer on June 17, 2008, 08:50:04 AM
generally, I've preferred the satin finishes...  no fingerprints under stagelights.... not that I'm under them very often.

That said, I still want an L-05MT.  I just want both.
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: PaulR on June 17, 2008, 08:55:20 AM
Quote from: teh on June 16, 2008, 11:55:03 PM
FWIW, Jim @ Trinity Guitars has a used OM-05MT scheduled to appear on his site for a really good price so I guess it won't last long. If I didn't already have an OM, this would have caught my interest.

I think LGF member Denis has already bought this. I probably also would have jumped at it if I didn't already have the OM-03MT

Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: willguitar on June 17, 2008, 10:18:28 AM
I have and like them both. Smudges definitely do show up on the top of my L-05MT, but hey that means I'm using it (smudges less visible on my spruce tops). And I prefer a satin neck to a glossed one (feels better to me).
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: axeman on June 17, 2008, 10:27:11 AM
I prefer gloss.  Just looks and feels better to me.  Biggest downside is that gloss finishes can crack, but then satin finishes seem more easily marred.  I have only one satin finish acoustic, one satin finish strat, and two Warwick basses (which pass for satin finish) out of approximately 40 instruments.  I really don't even especially care for satin necks, but they are getting harder to avoid.  Somehow satin just seems unifinished, if you'll pardon the pun. 
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: mrrinse on June 17, 2008, 10:55:16 AM

Finish wise, I'm not too fussy. And like both. My McIlroy is satin and it's beautiful - compliments the guitar nicely. That said, I really like what gloss does for the spruce and especially the rosewood on my LV-09 (and 19 CA); it somehow makes the guitar look classy. I went for 05 and 09s because I thought the gloss would add to the level of protection and I didn't want to risk swooshing noises on recording (though it's never been a problem with the McIlroy).
But I also love the minimalism and satin finish of the 03 series...

The only areas where I have a preference is in the neck area: I love satin necks - to the extent of disliking gloss ones.
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: Jeff on June 17, 2008, 11:07:56 AM
I prefer satin.  I like the feel of it and its understated look.  I've heard that there is really no difference in the thickness of the finish between gloss and satin--don't know if that's true, but somehow a satin feels like you are closer to the wood, if that makes sense.  Gloss is too, well, glossy.
Jeff
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: Ponte on June 17, 2008, 01:32:36 PM
I prefer gloss to satin
I prefer gloss necks and headstoks in gloss bodied guitars and matt necks on matt bodied guitars
I do not like matt necks in gloss bodies.
In fact I have glossed the headstok of both my L05 and P09
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: bhika on June 17, 2008, 02:23:20 PM
Quote from: Ponte on June 17, 2008, 01:32:36 PM
I prefer gloss to satin
I prefer gloss necks and headstoks in gloss bodied guitars and matt necks on matt bodied guitars
I do not like matt necks in gloss bodies.
In fact I have glossed the headstok of both my L05 and P09

:+1:

That's why I got my L-05MT with a gloss neck and headstock.
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: Denis on June 17, 2008, 03:24:46 PM
Quote from: PaulR on June 17, 2008, 08:55:20 AM
I think LGF member Denis has already bought this. I probably also would have jumped at it if I didn't already have the OM-03MT



Yup, Jim shipped it out to me last Friday.  Probably be another week before it gets to me but hey...for that price, I'd wait a lot longer!!!  Well..not that much longer.

I love both satin and gloss but I love gloss with a satin neck.  Eventually, the satin will start to shine on it's own...love that on the neck.  I no longer own a satin finish guitar.  The 00-50 is glossy as is the Yamaha CG131S and of course, the OM-05MT when it gets here...Oh, I can't wait to get my hands on that one!!!  Looks like I'll have to make some more YouTube videos...
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: Danny on June 17, 2008, 04:44:59 PM
                I do like them both, But here is a short list of considerations

                     Satin is a finish, not a bare wood guitar, but it dents much easier than Gloss
                     satin will break through to the bare wood faster and thus be stained by oil, water, :beer Etc.
                     Gloss can have several small dings that are seldom seen at all and do not "break through"
                     satin is better for stage performance...Lights glare and dirt shows on gloss
                     satin is cheaper to start with
                     Gloss is cheaper in the long run
                     satin necks on gloss guitars look cheesey, but play easier


           I'd like to see satin Larrivees with the tops glossed,(for protection and cost)    Danny
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: joethedestroyer on June 17, 2008, 05:00:40 PM
I would like it if Larrivee had a few more burst finishes.  Jean's is a little dark for my taste, and I wish they were more common on the lower series.  But according the the website...

"People often ask why we charge such a premium for the sunburst - Well the answer is simple: They are an enormous amount of work to do properly. The binding has to be taped off, then painted, tape removed, edges scraped, steel wooled, touched up, etc. Jean hand paints every sunburst we do - If you have one - Jean painted it."

my question is this:  why not just hire a few more people and make a streamlined process?

sorry if that derails the topic too much...
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: johnny37 on June 17, 2008, 06:42:26 PM
Quote from: joethedestroyer on June 17, 2008, 05:00:40 PM
I would like it if Larrivee had a few more burst finishes.  Jean's is a little dark for my taste, and I wish they were more common on the lower series.  But according the the website...

"People often ask why we charge such a premium for the sunburst - Well the answer is simple: They are an enormous amount of work to do properly. The binding has to be taped off, then painted, tape removed, edges scraped, steel wooled, touched up, etc. Jean hand paints every sunburst we do - If you have one - Jean painted it."

my question is this:  why not just hire a few more people and make a streamlined process?


Two thing here.  One, I think if someone other than Jean did the 'bursts, it would lose a little of the mystique.  You know, the "hannd of the master on your guitar" thing.  Bragging rights, if nothing else.  I would think also that they are much more consistent with only one person doing them.

Second, my C-19 is all gloss, and I'd have it no other way.  To me, gloss is a "rich" finish, for lack of a better word.  To use a car analogy, what looks better - primer or paint??  That's my preference, anyway. :cheers
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: jeremy3220 on June 17, 2008, 09:32:42 PM
Quote from: dependan on June 17, 2008, 04:44:59 PM
                I do like them both, But here is a short list of considerations

                     Satin is a finish, not a bare wood guitar, but it dents much easier than Gloss
                     satin will break through to the bare wood faster and thus be stained by oil, water, :beer Etc.
                     Gloss can have several small dings that are seldom seen at all and do not "break through"
                     satin is better for stage performance...Lights glare and dirt shows on gloss
                     satin is cheaper to start with
                     Gloss is cheaper in the long run
                     satin necks on gloss guitars look cheesey, but play easier


           I'd like to see satin Larrivees with the tops glossed,(for protection and cost)    Danny

The satin and gloss finish that comes on Larrivee's are the same exact thing except for a flattening additive to the satin. Same amount of protection and durability. Satin does seem to show scratches and stuff easier just because of the texture.
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: Danny on June 17, 2008, 10:37:42 PM
Quote from: jeremy3220 on June 17, 2008, 09:32:42 PM
The satin and gloss finish that comes on Larrivee's are the same exact thing except for a flattening additive to the satin. Same amount of protection and durability. Satin does seem to show scratches and stuff easier just because of the texture.
Whatever the difference is I do know what I see happening. The gloss can take a punch like a drunken Irishman. The satin has a glass jaw, so to speak. :ohmy: my name is "Danny" :beer  that's ROOTBEER btw
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: lw216316 on June 18, 2008, 08:27:59 AM
Quoteanalogy, what looks better - primer or paint??   

Johnny,  does primer have a beautiful grain to be seen if no paint is applied ?

- Larry
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: canoe65 on June 18, 2008, 03:59:34 PM
Before buying my Larrivée L-03, I owned a Seagull S6+ Cedar and a La Patrie Etude.  They both had satin finishes and I really liked their look.

I traded them in to get my Larrivée and I wanted an L-03 (mahogany back and sides, not sapele) for the satin finish, rather than buy a L-05 with the gloss finish.

And, I have never liked the look of a gloss body and a satin neck.    :tongue:
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: Johnny Canso on June 18, 2008, 07:14:42 PM
Quotewhat looks better - primer or paint
What are we talking about...finish on a 56 Chevy or guitars.... :?
Guys what happened since i've been gone???  The question was "who prefers satin finish to gloss"...i see there are a few glossy guys chimeing in on the topic who want to tell us why gloss is the better of the two....read the subject again guys...just a thread for us satin lovers here. :wink:



Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: lw216316 on June 18, 2008, 08:01:23 PM
Quoteguys...just a thread for us satin lovers here

:thumb

yea, wha da ya think this is...an open mike ?    :humour:
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: Danny on June 18, 2008, 10:19:11 PM
 :doh
Quote from: Johnny Canso on June 18, 2008, 07:14:42 PM
What are we talking about...finish on a 56 Chevy or guitars.... :?
Guys what happened since i've been gone???  The question was "who prefers satin finish to gloss"...i see there are a few glossy guys chimeing in on the topic who want to tell us why gloss is the better of the two....read the subject again guys...just a thread for us satin lovers here. :wink:




Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: joethedestroyer on June 19, 2008, 01:01:19 AM
Quote from: Johnny Canso on June 18, 2008, 07:14:42 PM
just a thread for us satin lovers here. :wink:





Proof positive I've stayed up too late reading this forum:  I thought that said "Satan lovers" the first time I read it. 
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: Caleb on June 19, 2008, 10:56:07 AM
In my experience, satin-finished guitars are louder and sound more open from the get-go.  I have always liked them for that reason.  But... I also really like the combination of a gloss top and satin back and sides.  Best of both worlds. 
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: el guitana on June 19, 2008, 03:31:01 PM
I like satin finish - for the sound I perceive. Gloss usually looks nicer, but I hear something I like in satin.
No problem with me for the "swooshing" some people have trouble with - I think it's a matter of adjusting playing style.
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: gary0319 on June 19, 2008, 08:48:35 PM
For me, it depends on the guitar.

My OM-03MT Forum is satin and I think it's just the right finish.....it kind of matches the tone. On the other hand I think my LSV-11 would look terrible with a satin finish..........too much bling for satin. I would have preferred my OMV-03 to be gloss, (then it would have been an OMV-05, I know), but couldn't find an OMV of any sort when I was looking.

I guess, over all, I like gloss on rosewood, but go either way on mahogany.

Gary
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: Danny on June 19, 2008, 10:29:36 PM
Quote from: the creature on June 19, 2008, 10:56:07 AM
In my experience, satin-finished guitars are louder and sound more open from the get-go.  I have always liked them for that reason.  But... I also really like the combination of a gloss top and satin back and sides.  Best of both worlds. 
YEP...
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: leftync on June 20, 2008, 12:26:19 PM
My Seagull M6, which I really enjoy, has a nice, thin gloss finish. I bought the equivalent Simon & Patrick for my son with a satin finish, and damn if it didn't sound better (it doesn't hurt that he's a better player) and it's not easy to improve on a good Seagull. I'd been saving for a better guitar, and once I realized how much I liked satin, it didn't make sense to go higher than a Larrivee 03, so I bought the D-03R.
Of course, it helps if the satin finish has a well-made guitar underneath.
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: Johnny Canso on June 21, 2008, 02:11:48 PM
Lefty...i have Seagulls also & they were my first real guitar & i've always said that bang for the buck, Seagulls are the tops but the Larrivee 03 series is right there with them  :bowdown:, & now that the all solid wood Seagulls are selling well over $1000 these days!!!!
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: leftync on June 21, 2008, 03:21:11 PM
I agree that the Seagull quality stands out among guitars in the $500 or so and under range. So does S&P, btw, another Godin company. But my Larrivee sounds as good as anything I've heard, and better than just about all of them.
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: Danny on June 22, 2008, 07:02:53 PM
       I just bought a used Grand S parlor, and after a major clean up, sanding and shaping the saddle properly and putting on new strings. I got to say it is a keeper. Very loud and clear. About as bright as maple.
       The satin finish must be the thinnest I've ever seen. I got a high quality OHSC also. pretty sweet deal.
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: hudson on June 25, 2008, 04:45:44 PM
I definitely prefer gloss asthetically, but I will admit that the 03 models that I have played do have an edge in raw, open tones & sustain, IMO.  :drool:  But I also tend to get the "swooshing" effect on the satin finish that I dislike.  :mad:
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: joethedestroyer on June 25, 2008, 05:05:46 PM
Quote from: dependan on June 17, 2008, 10:37:42 PM
The gloss can take a punch like a drunken Irishman. The satin has a glass jaw, so to speak.

Well said.  :+1:
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: SNP on June 25, 2008, 05:10:03 PM
I really enjoy the look and feel of the satin finish.
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: joethedestroyer on June 25, 2008, 05:11:23 PM
I've always liked mine too, but I've always been curious to ask..  there are two small "rougher" spots on the back of my D-03R.. is the finish just thin there or is it just worn?
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: Danny on June 26, 2008, 12:07:04 AM
      JCL responded to the question of gloss and satin finish on the "musicrowshow". He said the satin is 1/2 the finish of the gloss. I also believe the gloss gets a finer preparation on the wood before and during finishing. The satin is thus rougher by comparison. Danny
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: lw216316 on June 26, 2008, 09:14:59 AM
QuoteJCL responded to the question of gloss and satin finish on the "musicrowshow". He said the satin is 1/2 the finish of the gloss 

Danny, tks so much for this quote. I missed the show.   :donut :coffee

This shines a lot of light on my previous posts about satin vs gloss.
I maintained that satin sounded better and showed pictures and quoted George Harrison who told of how he and John Lennon removed the finish on some of their guitars to get a better sound.

I remember at least one person saying in my post, that the amount of finish on satin and gloss were the same and the only difference being that the gloss was buffed. I found that hard to believe but had no facts to refute it.

When I bought my L-03R the smell of the rosewood was so strong (and wonderful). I mentioned this to the store owner and she said,
"It's because of the satin finish. The gloss finish on other guitars covers up a lot of the fragrance of the wood"
She is around guitars all the time and certainly can tell the difference.

JCL's statement confirms what the store owner said and what I from the beginning suspected to be true.
The scientist in me is restless until a mystery is solved.   :thumb

....just wish my SD-50 had a satin finish.

- Larry
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: Danny on June 26, 2008, 01:32:08 PM
            JCL also added that after 6 months or so the gloss models would open up more. The satin is more "open" to start with. So if you got a satin with a cedar top it would boom from the get go.
Title: Re: who here prefers satin finish to gloss & why?
Post by: dleahy on June 27, 2008, 11:22:33 AM
Quote from: dependan on June 26, 2008, 01:32:08 PM
            JCL also added that after 6 months or so the gloss models would open up more. The satin is more "open" to start with. So if you got a satin with a cedar top it would boom from the get go.

I have both as well. I opted for my D-03R over others because I loved the natural, toned-down look. As an owner of Seagulls I can say that they do seem much more "open" right from the box. I want to add that my choice would be a satin back and sides and a buffed satin or thin "semi-gloss top. As far as the satin top showing wear,
I think one only needs to look as far as Willie Nelsons "Trigger" Any guitar that is played enough to truly open the wood is bound to show some wear. I think it adds character and dignity.