I said in earlier posts that I prefer the satin finish of my L-03R to the glossy finish of my SD-50.
If I had a choice I would prefer an SD-50 with a satin finish.
My reasons were for appearance and sound. I said I thought the glossy finish diminishes the sound.
Now I find out George Harrison agreed with me. I have a box of old guitar magazines from 70s and 80s that have been in storage since the 80s. The November 1987 issue of ' Guitar Player ' has George Harrison on the cover.
It has an interview with him and lots of pictures of Beatle guitars and information about them.
George said he and John would scrape the finish off their guitars to get a better sound.
I've attached pictures from the magazine.
I may put this magazine and others up for sale. Anyone interested ?
- Larry
[attachment deleted by admin]
Quote from: lw216316 on June 15, 2008, 02:36:57 PM
I said in earlier posts that I prefer the satin finish of my L-03R to the glossy finish of my SD-50.
If I had a choice I would prefer an SD-50 with a satin finish.
My reasons were for appearance and sound. I said I thought the glossy finish diminishes the sound.
Now I find out George Harrison agreed with me.
George said he and John would scrape the finish off their guitars to get a better sound.
I don't mean to be rude but what Harrison said has nothing to do with satin finishes. The satin finish on your Larrivee is much thicker than a FP or Varnish finish and probably even most nitro finishes from luthiers. The only difference between finishes on your SD-50 and L-03R is a flattening agent; the gloss could be thinner.
It's hard to believe that either the glossy or satin finish choice would have a dramatic difference in sound. My LV-03E sounds better that I thought possible...
Can one measure the difference in sound? I think maybe not so much....
Regards
Perhaps I have misunderstood the satin version. I thought it was LESS finish and polishing and was one of the reasons the L-03R satin is less expensive.
I still prefer the looks of the satin finish.....and I would still prefer to have a minimum amount of nitro, varnish or whatever....maybe I should call it a ' natural ' or unfinished or minimum finished guitar.
Does it make a difference ? George Harrison and John Lennon thought so.
I do too....but I'm not going to scrape my SD-50 :bgrin:
- Larry
Larry the Epiphone was finishised with nitrocelulous (pre 70 Gibson) Your Larri's are finished with the same U V cured durable finish.(hard to repair) Like Jeremy said it just has a little something added to the gloss and they also have to take a little longer and buff it out too.
A natural wood guitar may sound better, (but I doubt it) and then it would deteriorate so fast it wouldn't be nice for long.
As far as I know on a flat top if you take off the finish it will subdue the sound. I did this on a few guitars. It made them kinda mellow sounding. I liked it. But I don't think most would say that was improvement. Most players want resonance with deep bass, clear trebles, and ringing high notes with a lot of sustain.Part of achieving that is the finish.
FWIW, Danny
Quote from: lw216316 on June 15, 2008, 06:15:25 PM
Perhaps I have misunderstood the satin version. I thought it was LESS finish and polishing and was one of the reasons the L-03R satin is less expensive.
The reason the satin cost less is because they don't have to buff it or do as much prep work and sanding between coats. They aren't charging you for more finish when you buy a guitar with a gloss finish but rather the extra labor. It is true though you want a finish that is very thin and hard but in this case there's not likely a difference. I think since satin finishes tend to look more like bare wood, people think it's thinner.
I don't know what kind of guitars they scraped the finish off of but if they had thick finishes it probably would make a difference in sound. I'd much rather have a guitar with a properly applied thin durable finish. I would suspect that having no finish on a guitar would lead to the wood absorbing a lot of oils and whatever else that would end up dampening the sound more than a .003" thick finish would.
Regardless of any effect it has on the sound, I find the post interesting since George is easily my favorite Rock artist. Scraping the finish off their Casinos? That's pretty interesting to me.
One little thing.. when you take off the finish on your guitar...
the wood will observe a lot more moisture in the air...
because it doesn't have the protection(finish)...
Many believe that a French Polish finish (hand rubbing very small amount of mineral spirits and varnish, one layer at a time) provides the best compromise between protection and unimpeded sound production. Since it takes between 40~80 hours of work, not to mention the special skill involved, it adds considerable expense ($1200 on a Simon Fay).
QuoteMany believe that a French Polish finish (hand rubbing very small amount of mineral spirits and varnish, one layer at a time) provides the best compromise between protection and unimpeded sound production. Since it takes between 40~80 hours of work, not to mention the special skill involved, it adds considerable expense
Yes, I've heard this from a luthier I know. :thumb
As a scientist / artist I wish I had the time / money to research this.
It would not be for everyone. Those who gig need something ' heavy duty ' that can survive the road.
Those held captive by tradition and custom would scorn.
My guitars live a sheltered life and a french polish guitar would find a happy home with me.
The truth is out there.
- Larry the artistic scientist
(being an artist and a scientist is a hard life but somebody has to do it :bgrin: )
I have layered Tung oil in this way. It does take a lot of time but it makes a beautiful finish and really brings out the grain in the wood. It has to be reapplied though every year or so. It also is so much thinner it drastically changes the tone of the guitar.
Interesting thread, thanks.
Question: is the INSIDE wood of most guitars finished or is it bare wood? If it is bare then what's the problem with the outside being bare? Other than looks, perhaps.
Quote from: prof_stack on June 16, 2008, 07:03:17 PM
Interesting thread, thanks.
Question: is the INSIDE wood of most guitars finished or is it bare wood? If it is bare then what's the problem with the outside being bare? Other than looks, perhaps.
The inside is usually bare, sometimes luthiers will coat it with shellac. The finish maintains the look. Spruce is very easy to dent and scratch. You can't just wipe dirt, oil, or whatever absorbs into the wood off like you can a finish. Other than looks, substances like oil absorbing into the wood can dampen the tone.