The only guitar I had for the past 20 years was a nylon string.
I'm learning about steel string guitars. I've heard and read that steel strings can be washed and reused.
Please tell me your experience with doing this, how you do it, and results.
Also, is there a good way to clean the strings after each playing session that will help keep them clean ?
:donut :coffee
- Larry
You can boil them to get skin and dirt out. Just wiping them after playing helps. I tried Brasso once and didn't care for the resulting smell (never again) My neighbor plays for a top country band and gives me strings, so usually I don't run out of new sets.
Quite recently, I have been "washing" the strings with Isopropyl Alchohol (IPA) whilst still on the guitar. I soak a small area of a lint free cloth and carefully wipe them all over. This results in a lot of what appears to be dirt and oxidation coming off. I then use lemon oil to finish off with as this will leave a thin layer to protect the string. The lemon oil will also clean more "gunk" off. I find this appears to bring back the brightness of the wound strings, and so far I am not changing to new strings so often. I have also found that although I give them a thorough clean, and the cloth comes away with no more dirt showing, if i repeat the next day before playing i can get more "gunk" off. Can someone explain this? It seems like the strings are oxidising over night, and maybe its this oxidisation that is killing the brightness of the wound strings.
Mel
My bass playing friend has been doing this with his bass strings for years. It extends the life and bass strings are expensive. He boils them and dries them by whipping them around over his head while stripped naked, doing a Celtic sabre dance. No, I made that last part up. I'd just buy coated strings and avoid the whole issue.
so.......that brings up another question...
My new SD-50 came with CLEARTONE strings - those are coated strings, right ?
When they wear out, can they be washed ? ...or is washing - only for NON-coated strings ?
patience please, I'm new at this steel stringee thingee :bgrin:
- Larry
Quote from: melanie on June 12, 2008, 01:52:45 PM
... I then use lemon oil to finish off with as this will leave a thin layer to protect the string. The lemon oil will also clean more "gunk" off....strings, and so far I am not changing to new strings so often. I have also found that although I give them a thorough clean, and the cloth comes
I had pretty much forgotten how "back in the day" when I used to clean my first guitar with lemon oil, I'd wipe down the fret board and there was no doubt in my mind that the strings sounded brighter. Pretty much like new strings. I no longer use polishes and oils on my guitars (except the rare application of a touch of tongue oil on the fret board) and wouldn't dream of putting any oil on my strings, but maybe there's something to it...
jimmy
You might be able to get more brightness out of the strings by using the above cleaning methods but I don't think your going to solve the intonation problems that I experience when my strings have had it and need to be replaced. I wipe my strings off everytime I finish playing, even if its only for a few minutes. I also wash my hands before picking my guitar up. Find a good place to order strings from like StringsandBeyond.com, get at least 6 sets at a time and the per set price is not bad. Heck you can get a new set of strings for the price of a gallon of gas, and just try to get 2 or three months out of a gallon of gas.
:coffee :donut2 :donut :wave
Oh the po boy tricks. They work to some degree. Just remember It can't go on too long especially if you play hard
cause the strings gonna wear down and get uneven where you play and that throws the intonation off. In fact for general purpose, not recording or gigging, thats when I change strings. When the tuning get a little whacky.
that fast fret stuff gets your strings pretty clean... but it can make them slippery if you don't whipe them down after.
Quote from: jimmy buffett on June 12, 2008, 04:03:17 PM
I had pretty much forgotten how "back in the day" when I used to clean my first guitar with lemon oil, I'd wipe down the fret board and there was no doubt in my mind that the strings sounded brighter. Pretty much like new strings. I no longer use polishes and oils on my guitars (except the rare application of a touch of tongue oil on the fret board) and wouldn't dream of putting any oil on my strings, but maybe there's something to it...
jimmy
Why use TUNG oil on the fretboard, I could understand boiled linseed or lemon oil (no silicone). I've used tung oil a lot but never on a fretboard. So I'm curious about this.
Larry when coated strings lose their coating they are done for. Danny
Quote from: dependan on June 12, 2008, 10:18:47 PM
Larry when coated strings lose their coating they are done for. Danny
Some would say they are done for before they lose thier coating! :bgrin:
Yea, a good set of EJ's does the deed nicely.
A soft dry cloth does the trick for me, I have never boiled strings, but had a cowriter one time who (twenty years ago) didn't want to spend four or five bucks for new strings, so he boiled his strings. He didn't know WHY he was boiling them, he had just heard that if he boiled them they would be like new.
If they are trimmed properly, they may be a bit tough to get restrung.
I also use Elixirs, but I still wipe them down, especially on tour, because finding the time to get them changed is sometimes a challenge.
Try Dr. Duck's Ax Wax and String Lube.
I used Dr. Stringfellow years ago.
I am a jeweler by trade and, before I started using coated strings, I would take them into work and throw them in the ultrasonic (used for cleaning jewelry) with a solution of detergent and ammonia and then steam cleaned them. They sounded like knew! :thumb
Not every one has access to these items but maybe you know a jeweler?
The scientist in me can't stand it any longer.
The burning question is
Why do strings lose their tone ?
Sound is made from the vibration of the string.
Why would a ' little dirt or oil from hand ' in a relatively small area of the string affect the vibration of the string ?
Perhaps the main problem is tension rather than ' dirt '. Perhaps the string just looses its tone because of prolonged tension being exerted on it.
- Larry the scientific artist
As has been said they stretch,thin out at various spots and the wound ones fill with skin,dirt, oil etc. So the "clean,crisp, clear sound and proper intonation are forfeited. Some guitars do better with slightly tarnished strings, it will "dull" the bright ringing ( of say a Taylor :tongue:)
But usually a new set, no matter what brand will sound better than stretched out, worn, thinned and plugged windings on older strings. I think some coated strings take a back seat to regular 80/20 bronze on say a SD-50 because the "thick" coating can act just like grime build up. Try some EJ-17's sometime and see if you notice a higher and lower tone range than with the coated Cleartones. (which most of us don't care much for btw) Danny
Quote from: dependan on June 12, 2008, 10:18:47 PM
Why use TUNG oil on the fretboard, I could understand boiled linseed or lemon oil (no silicone). I've used tung oil a lot but never on a fretboard. So I'm curious about this.
Well, when I bought my first "good guitar", an OM 05 from Dave Wren at The Twelfth Fret, I asked him what I should use to treat the fret board. He told me that he uses tung oil, and figuring that Dave was pretty well informed about these matters, I went with it.
I seldom put any waxes or polishes on my guiatrs, but once in a while I clean the fret board and polish the frets with 0000 steel wool, and put a light application of tung oil. It makes the wood look great, and dries very hard so I know that no oils or contaminents will transfer to the strings.
jimmy
QuoteTry some EJ-17's sometime
Tks, I'll try 'em.
I plan to experiment with strings after my original cleartones don't ' tone ' anymore :bgrin:
What about different guages on the SD-50 ?
How would light to med-lights respond on my honey Maggie ?
If I understand correctly, a change to lights or med-lights would require a rod adjustment ??
- Larry
Quote from: jimmy buffett on June 16, 2008, 08:43:30 AM
Well, when I bought my first "good guitar", an OM 05 from Dave Wren at The Twelfth Fret, I asked him what I should use to treat the fret board. He told me that he uses tung oil, and figuring that Dave was pretty well informed about these matters, I went with it.
I seldom put any waxes or polishes on my guiatrs, but once in a while I clean the fret board and polish the frets with 0000 steel wool, and put a light application of tung oil. It makes the wood look great, and dries very hard so I know that no oils or contaminents will transfer to the strings.
jimmy
Thanks for the reply Jimmy, Tung oil is easy to work with and when I have time I like to refinish scratched up old guitars using Tung oil. It is very time consuming but when I have the time (Fall and Winter) I enjoy doing it. Old darkly stained guitars once stripped can reveal some very nice wood grain with some great natural colors that were totally hidden by the dark finish. And since tung oil can be used as a wiping varnish it doesn't require a spray booth set up. which I don't have (YET).
Quote from: lw216316 on June 16, 2008, 08:54:24 AM
Tks, I'll try 'em.
I plan to experiment with strings after my original cleartones don't ' tone ' anymore :bgrin:
What about different guages on the SD-50 ?
How would light to med-lights respond on my honey Maggie ?
If I understand correctly, a change to lights or med-lights would require a rod adjustment ??
- Larry
I changed my LSV to a lighter set and enjoy the ease of finger pressure. I used the EXP version of EJ's
they were EXP11 LIGHT12-53. I like them fine. My next set to try will be Dean Markley Alchemy Gold Bronze 12-54. The EJ 16's would be a little lighter than the EJ 17 13-56 and these EJ strings sound great and are not too pricey. I wouldn't adjust the neck until you have had the strings on a couple of days. And I'm sure your "being good" and keeping your SD in proper humidity range, Right? :donut :donut2 :coffee
Quote from: lw216316 on June 12, 2008, 01:15:37 PM
The only guitar I had for the past 20 years was a nylon string.
I'm learning about steel string guitars. I've heard and read that steel strings can be washed and reused.
Please tell me your experience with doing this, how you do it, and results.
Also, is there a good way to clean the strings after each playing session that will help keep them clean ?
:donut :coffee
- Larry
After I play I wipe down the guitar and strings with a polishing cloth or other soft cloth. That works just fine for me and my strings last until I get bored. :bgrin:
I wouldn't attempt to boil strings to get another use out them. It's not really worth the time when you can usually find strings for around $6.